High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4884/2019allowed

Anita Devi v. Union Of India And ORS

2025-04-07Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj9 pages

!"#$!%&'&"()*++,

) -.

+ /0 /+

! Ms. Puneeta Sethi, "#$ "

% &&&&& 0 /+ 1+ 23 ' # ""

( )*)+,)', '-)*,)', % )-),,))) ),).,))/ 0 12 ( " ,/'),)''

,.'),)'' '')',)', 1

3( $ 3 2 4 "2 12 (% )-),,))) % ),).,))/ , $ " (1 " " $ 6$ $1 1 ( 7//*),,-*' 8#9: #2# 1"

0 " 8 # 1"

8 0 -,; "', ; " :;

" 0 $2 :

<" # % '-).,)'' ,))) :

<" # ; " =$ " "

( $ " : >"

(

:""0 +-) "

(,?6

$ 3

"$ 0 1 ((

0 $ %32( < < ; " 8 "

0 0 " : $ 0 # $" 2 " 98 <! #" ( 1 3( "

00 " 12

- : 0 "

()?)*,),-0 ""0( 0

! "#$ %&' ( ( )! * +

(!!! ' % ", !! !! - ' ",

!./ ! # (

.! ( 0! 1# ( ! .$ /

! 2! 3! .$/

4 #! / #$ (##/ "(#2$ 52#4 ! (, 14($

! ! 3 1( ! ! (4 * 6$ 3 $ !#$!!! ( ,!!.(( #2

2 (2$/ ( !# ! 2$/ .( (2 ( #2

2 ((!# !2$/

($! ! /#$2

. !.((, $ 2

2#2 $$ ,!/ (2$/ ! / 0#! #$2 ( + ,!/ (2$/ $$ , $ 2

2 #2

.! (

! / ## (#!# # #(!! ! #!# .

.$ 1#4

4 $!.((,!/(2$/ $$ , $ 2

2#2 - 7! # $ ( $ #!

# ( . #$

(! /8"9(2!

2!! - # (($$ /869( !2!

.! ( !

((! #!# 4

4# (($$ !( (8##!9 !(! !:

$-($1$;1#

<,!/ :

- :

(( ! :

$ !

#! != -

>##!>2 ?

!!! 1!.$2 @

2 !

#(!1!

/ 2 #/ ./ 1$# (!# ( 1#@A

7!# $((

( 2!

2 !!

", B !$ , $ 2

2 #2 ! # ( ($$ ! #$

( ( !

#! !=

) 2 ( C2 (

DB&BB& ' !!

4 , $ 2

2 #2 1$.$ (2$ #$ E12 1$ 2$/ 4 ! (2# ( . (! ((#$ !

! 1

## # 2 ( , $ 2

2#2 $$.1 ! !=

C ## !

$* ##! # ( (2#(!

. C ## :

$* # ( (2# ( !

.$ # ( 1$# ./ 4 #$$2 4#

# C## 2/ :

B $* #$ .! *2 !

.# 2$ 4 4,2 #

! C ## $ :

B $*

/ #(! $ !4 ##

.$ .! 4 # ## ( $ !

4 ,2 #! C2 ( DB&BB& ' !!

$$ ! 2!(! ,A )

( #4$! !

2!!' B B

!./C$3 :2 C1 F

C# E$4 6;G ! @ -B'& - C$ 3 ! , $ 2

2 #2 ( :

7# ! ( 2$/ ! !! ## ( #!# $1,# ( !0 !

2! != ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ! %' 6 6;G4 7 ;H! ; ! ! # !

)!*7($5 #"; ( E 0 .#

%' 6 !$/!

!$#6!

%%I 2$ .$$!.//(6$ ( #7H!; 22.( ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

.! ( !! ;2. %4 B 2 ( #2$ 2.

# 2$$ !

/ 6!

I 2$ 7 ( $ # 3 2/ 1 ! $1 .$2 # 2/ 1 #.

! #*

((! ./2.

# $!.#.

(

## ! $ (2 2.

# 2 $$ !

.!(

#1 !

/ ! ## ( ##! 1

! ./ ((# 2!

!! ;2.

!;2. 4 . 1 $.$ * 1 ((# 2!

2.!/ .(#$ ,# 1 $#/ $.$ (##! $!. .1

$! $! . $! , $ 2

2 #2 /.$ ! ((# 2!

2 !! ;2.

2!(! ./ ((# 2!

2 !! ;2. 4 #2 /.$ $! . :

4 4 &

7# $/ # !#.! * (2!/($

#2 $$.! 2$ JK 2#*! * (2! ( !# A 7! # $ ( ! * ##22!!!

!./ "!0 ! ' -A ? $ " $(

< $ #$ 0 $ @ % $ ( $ " 1 " 21

3 $ 1 (

3( " $ 0 "

( "1 $1 $ $ "

3( !8$1 "00 8( "$

("2 " < 1

" # (2 2

$1" A

A% )-),,))): $$"1 ( 3 % 2

% ! "" " 1 0 A " 4$ A $2 5

A$ $ " 21

( 1

8 # 1"

),)*,)', ($ :

(

.(!$ ( " 21

8 # 1"

($ $ 1 1

3 + $ " (1 " 0

" ;

"8(#$ $( $ !$ 4++ + + "+ ,* "# "

B/5 + 0&67 8&9!$& 0'+ (&"( "# ($& ($ " :!2'C 0 00 8 # 1"

; "6 0

+; " ; $24 ;4! $( " " $ $1 D$ !$ 8 $1 " < "

$( $ 2 3( " $0 1 1$ :

$( $ B) $ ( ( !4 1 $! !9 0#(9 #$2 (, #2

.$!( '

.! $!#$$/+ $(/ ! 2.(,

>C ## !

##! # ((2#(!

>( #

2(:

B$* /.$2 ( !! %

% 4(4$$ ./ ! ! ‟!!!- B 0# '

/ ( ( , #2 ! !# ! /

2(:

B$*

!( * )(2 ! * 4 2 $$. J K 2A *

$ " ( 1 "

( $( $ 0 0 "" $( ;

"8( #$0 1"

$ " $ 1

;

"8(#$0 " 1 3( 1

3 3 . : 0 ("233"8!$ 0 $(

$ +: $( '! '&$!: 3 " "

( 3( ') 1 $ < 0 ),

2 1"

1 1 "

0 $ /

< "( 0 "" 1 "

E+F $

0 /+ *++, $; > <(9 97 > 1"