← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/423/2004disposed of

Satish Chander Chopra v. State Of Haryana & ANR.

2022-05-07Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj13 pages



      



 !

"#$#%&'()( ** 

  

+ ,$-$ *   (  

&  ./ ( *+ *( 0 11111         

       ! "# $% &  11111 + *( 0(( / '        ((  !"# 

)& "( *

+(

 

( + # (+ #( , -.- /001 /-1

  

 ##

 "

   2 3   (+ /1      

   43+5     /21 )&  

   "

    "

#

# 

   /&        .6' !"#  

   

   ")!# (( )

 ( 

"



( + # ((, -7.  !"# 02 (  

)&    #

 ,#  "

$&  '   #(     #(             #     ((    "

   //008  )&  &  8.6 

 # &

 "

) , 6-8 "  

 9: $ + ; 

(.-  

 (

   .6 ' #     #; (( 

 & <"  



  



&  "

'"

(  



 ## "

/5=/5   "

    "

' #(      #  ; 



 )   #(   (  (   #( ' #(  ( "

 (  )   "

  ((&9"   #      ; "

 =" ("

   ="  (  =   >   #(  # ;

"

 ( &(  "

 "

!), (9 ;    ) (  

  "

'  #(  ( (

) ;  )  ( "

 

 "

 (" (     #)&#  )   "

'  #(    

#"

) " )   )&) ;



#)""



 ;(& ( "

"  ) 

 "

 =  .-    "  ) 



#'"

    

)(& /(((&) ;  ( ; 

# 



 #(     )  

&((  (  (      #  )&     #(    '   #(    #

      "  )"   )   

 "

 "

  

(" (

 - '   

      #(  (

  ()&

   &?

  ()&        3    )&   + "

                

 #   (( #(  )&#; (    &

 



# &( #    # "((&#  "

!), (9 ;' "# #  "(&;

( )&    # "

   -/-+ +   

 #   # "

!), (9 ; "(&

#  #(  ,     "(  )( 

  ; )&#  # "

   -/-+ +   & ( =(    &  # 6(   (#  

 (       &) # ) ;  #   (( %"

"  " #(         #   &  

 # &   "

'

 "

   23+  (&         !"#     /-1       

   "

    "

#

#  /& '(  

 

!"#   #

%       ,2-3 % $  5

# #% ,& 2 >

 "

(

    & "  ")#       ((  !"# 

)&+ "

)( 

#    "(

    & (&     #    &

"       ( &"

  #   /1&  8 >

 "

(    " " 

   

  "

 (( #   ((=" //008

    #(  <"  

" & /0073

# (& "   ( &      # ( 

    (&8&

% "

    " 

 /-1   8&

  "

 (&

 #  7&

% "

  (#    (   ;     (     & #       

    3 "

    " #   "

   ( "  ( &"

  &  # (

"

"( # ( ;   

  "("

 &  #   /1&   (&@ "(    )& + "

)(  ##&) "   "

  7      ! "# $% &     ")#   )     "(  ##



    () (&  (   "

 # "

!), (9 ;    (    ")#

(  "# )

+ "

 

#   ;(  # ( &   (( # "

;  

 # &

"

'"

 

   ##)&    6 ##

   #) (( " " =" #      

 

# + "

3   

 )&#   )#  7&

  &

,

,$ %! ,#%"#56 $ * %

%"#%2& 1 '  % 5)(  " #  + "

    (        (   

+ "

 #           # !"#  % 5)( " #+ "

 # 

   

 (  =   !"# 

 "  )( 6

)  

   





 





  



 



 

 





      

 





 

    



 

 

  

    

  



 !

 "#

$    

%

&







 



  

 





 $

$  '



 

 

 

         

 

# !





 %



 



 

 %    

     

'    







( ) *+,

( +-  ( ) *+,

( +". ( -+



( -&/ -&0

$

$  '

    

 



    

   

     



1

  











. !    

  





 

  

2

   %  

 

 



        !

 

 

3 



  4  

   

 

(

$ 



   



7

  

  

   4 









  



2        

   (



  

 

 

  



0/ % 5 $   ! 5  (  

6 7*033", + ($$ ++/8  $

9

:0 %  



   

 

 

  

 ;  

   

 





 



:

00 <  =   >

!

 (  

!' 7*033&, & ($$ +"08   5 $   * ,    

 



 





  



 (

  





0+ %

  ( ;  !

 (  

<  ?  7*+//&, + ($$ - 38  $

9

@#



 

    

 



  (  





     

(   %



    

  A 

)   



     





4 

 





 

  





 '

   



  

 



  

 

 

 

' 

:

:

 





 

 

  B $ (

      9 :(  

 

 

)) 

)) 







 :



       

  

 





  2 6    



   

    

 

 



  

  

 

 

  







  

  

 

 

  



    >  

 $

( '   (  

C 7*0330, - ($$ "#08  $

    



 





 

 

 

 2  

 

0. D <   

:(  <:

:(  9 E <

 !   E :

9

:%



    

   )  

)

  :  :



 :  :





 



:    :

  

  



 





    

 

    

       

     





  

  :

    :





1

    

 

8 

 

   D

 

    

 

 F

 

 

 5      

    

  

       

 



 

   

 

 

     4 

  

    



   



     

             )    

  

     

 %

      







  





    :

7G 8

   



9

:%      

     

 

   1





   2 







  

 

:

03 H > >  G  

$  ;  (

   :(  :

  9

:!      

 

     

 

   



   



   





 ?  

      

    

 

 2 



 



  *:



9

:,

 

  



   







 



 *:



:,

!

  

)

  

  

  

  



 

 

   

  

29 %       

  I %    



 

 

  I E  





 

 



      

I   





2  

  2 

    

 

 I    

          



  

 







 





   (     

    

2

 



  



     



 

 *E   

   

    

 

  

:  :

  *  033#,,:

+/ !   E C ;

 



  

 

  

      9

0      

 

  



)          

  

     

:   + G

       

   

   )  )  4  )     

- $  



" > 

 

   

0 ' 

" ( =# )&% 5)( " #+ "



#      ! ! (  = 

 !"#   "  )( 6 0 < 





    

   

  

  

 

     





 

 





  

  

 % (  

' 

 '

 (

*+//., # ($$

/  $

  

  

J

@+ %

     

 

  

  



2  

    

 



    

  

   ? 

 

     !

 4   



 2  

 ( 

 

2 D D $   D  $    

 



K

0&   



 

 $

 

 $





 

 

 2

 

  

   



    *(9 >  $   (  

D '

 *03#&, ($$ +.0 5 $    5  (  

::

 

6 *033", + ($$ ++/ (  

D '

  < ( *+//-, .

($$ 0- (  

H    '    *+//", ($$ "#  A

%  H ( *+//", + ($$

3/ ( ;  

 (  

< 

*+//&, + ($$ - 3 ( 

 (  

H   *+//&, 0/ ($$ &#- (  

D '

  6  *+//., ($$ +-" (  H

(   6 

 (  

D  *+//3, & ($$ "3.,

0" %

    

  





  

   



 



  

 

   

4   

4





 

     I %    4  

 





4





      *

 

  ,

  



  



4





(     

  29 *0,  



4   

 1 *+,  

    







 

+& '      

     

+#



 

  9

+#0 $



 

   

   J

  

   



+#+

4 

4







   

    

:   +#- %

 

 

      

 



+#" ?



  



4

 

 

+# A 

4 F   

   



  

     %



 

 

4 



2  



   



  

   



 E   





       

      



    





   4 %"6-$#%& / * #   "

(        (  #   "#    

)   "

 )=      '   ( &"

   (&@  ")     # " #

#   &  # (

"

    (&8&

% ( &  :  #  7&

% ( "(  &  #(

  

)

"#   # ( )  # '       ) ((&)( )&;   

     ") <"    "     

         



# )  "

 )  ()&  "

  

   # (     (  

)()& + "

' "        #   ) ") <" 

( #      &  #(

 3  "()

 "



)(      "



:    #          8&

   

(&  (  // ' <"  #)&(

 "

(

    (&((         "    ( &"

 %         .6 # )& (+ "

     /.6 ) 3((< 



(    #  3    ("

            #  (()()( "

     # )& (+ "

 /           (&   (&  ((   '  !"#  

 

)&+ "

)(  "(          #    #  

  + *( 0     ;'< (( * ,  

F  

LFC  

 

LFC