High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/11125/2016dismissed

Schreiber Dynamix Dairies Pvt Ltd v. State Of Haryana And ANR

2023-11-14Mr. Justice Pankaj Jain18 pages

!"!#

$% &' !"!# ( !(

#$ )0 12) ( 3 4 % #

& '

( % #) *&'

& %

* !++,&'

" $-.

% # / '&''0&

4 ( $ + )! " !!

2 +34! 3" $,5 678

"9!&, :

!3 0;

<$ %!+ *: !4!$ 3 ,!

"9!& "%

& ( $ ! $= $ "9!

,%3&# + "$(! '" ";

!,'

&>6 - " " : >6 '

$, ( ;

<$ & # + -$ 5 .,,33," " '

,3 $ ,," $, "" :?, :5 9! * :, 3

!!,"#!, " ";

!,#!,&>66- "" :>66#!,:.

',3( $,$"!, ',(",

$!3 "9!&& "9!

,%3& # + $, ( "%

& -'!=.$ !

3 $= $

!,$3 $! $,$" 3 $ $,,,(

""" #!, ">66#!, !, ",, 3 3 "

$ +3 3 4!, ! ,!, $, "3" "

1 "3" ,,3 $,

:?, :5 9! * : "

$ +3 4!, !,!, $, "3" "

! (!, ! "" " ! #!, " >66#!, <"! 3

, , !,$3 $ $

" ,3,"";''

#!, ! ,( !,,!" "

""$ ! "( $ 35 9! * & "

$ +3 $ " , ", 1 " $ 1$ 5 $ +3 @ )! (,

" , $, !, " ! A!<,$, '!= <"! " !,,!$ ,(, ( ":

556 27&7(35 5 5 55 1 -!""8/%3 +8% 15947 5 5:5() $7:59:57 9 -;<;/!3%+; 13&(3 57-5/'=2 5 ( 57 3 565 5 1 -;<;/ ! 3 %,# 1) 7$7:59 :57 9 7(5947 5 5:1 7&759 77 (+8 ;<# 7 "'!3!&> &135(>7 '5$ 5 1& 7&759::59(8%8 ;<< > "

$& > 2& :

( 555?5 5 5 ( :$ =56 95& ) 7$7:597= 7 77$1& !"";-#/ )@-(/8+& 145975: &59A &59(4( 5& 5

% 1 !"";-#/)@-(/8< 1397 7592(5 5 (35 556 51 !"%3 27 %<

155 &7$592(

7 7B :57( 35 ( (

3$5= )77= 59 5

5&79= @9 5 3$575 2 $6C 5 1 !"< 3 2799#<< & !,! $#!,

( #!, $$ +3 "

!, ,,(

, 3 $,+, !$ 3 3

:% :" $!$" '

" ! ,!-." >6 '

' ,""

$ " ! ! ,, " ,, $ +3 $ < 3

$ +3 "

4! "! 3 "!)! & !+3 ,,& B?, :5 9! * C"" $ ! $ "!3 "!)! (

(!, ",,( ""

< , !," $ 3 !3 "

! " " !

+ ! !!

!! " !# $ $ %&' (

#,$">6 '

" )!

" $ ! D!-7E/D&7'5FD ,""

-. ""&!!"&, ,+, & ,""

! "(

, & $,,

$ !!,,,, !

E -. "",, $ "$,

!E - . ", (

,3 ,"

E - . " ,! &",! &$( $, " , 3

, " , $$"

3,! ,,E -. "", , "!$ ,, (E -". "&( , $ +3(

, $$ " !" ! $ (

$ +3 $ !!,

, ! "( ,"

,$ ! '

E -3. " $ +3 3& ,, $ +3 & 3 3 3 3 ! &(

, ",, 3,$ !,E" $ +3 ( $ ( $

E - . " $ +3 3 ,, $ +3 "" ! !, $ !" !$ " ,E -. "$!$&$ 3&"$ ,

!&!,,,!

" $ 3&,& $$ !"" ," $!

,!"!

!E -). " " ,",!3&" , ,!3

, $& ( ! , ,, 3 " & " 4! " '

!, ! E -+. ",,,

( 4!"

!, ! E <(

7'77 &5

5$ 59 $( $57 57$9 (D5$ ,, ,"$

,"!" !",&&,, !D -. !, "

E -. "

E -. ,""

" ,"(

, $ & $

(

" , E -. ,""

,"(

" 3$ ;

-, .'! F "$!, , EGHHHG -. ,""

" $ " '

" !, ! EFG F-. !, G F) D; $!$" &$ ,, !, "

< "

,""

" ,!-. ,!-.

,!-." !

" !" ! "" ,""

", G !"( 7B5$ 5 759

$(G-/ F5 $ !""" ! '

3"" ! 'G ,,! $& ( ( "&F ,0 0 6FHHHG$! ,"& 3,$ , & ,0 06FHHHG $ !""" ! '

! $!

7F 3 ! G" & F" $ G

! $" $" $!, ,,3(

$, 2F-. 5 ! " " %$, %39!

,%3" " , ,, "" ! '

-.5( 3 3 "

, !&> -"> .&"" $! , ! != -''." 7 ,, 3I,

=,,.

G H!"( C $ 7&:95&5

5$ $(D ?

!3 ,""" ! '

,,3 $&3 !" !& ! ," ,""

!" &

"& !

!" !& ! ,, ( "" & & !&( 3 3

F!= -." > " ", !&> -"> .G $ 3

!3 $ ! ! 3 ! G

#,$">66#!, ! D#<( 25'9 $57 59 &7957 5& =',, ,, & ,&

3& &" (

", , 3$ !, 3 "

$ +3& 3 4! !,! , $, "3" "

F !, ,,$$,$ ", " " " & ! ( !

!3&*!,,A& +&$ " ( !

03*0, $ , $ #!(= ::5$65 $5= 595'9( =-.

0,= -. $ +3 "

,, $ ,, ,,,3 ",& , 3 $,+, ! $3 3

,$$ +3 "

,,$$, !

(,, $ "

-. ,, ,, ,&$& ,, , ,3, ! ! ,

"$!

- . ?

($$& ($$ ,, " ,,

,, , ,3, !3 ! ($$ !

-. ,,3"$$ +3 "

= A$ +3""

,, ",,(3" ,,

-. " "

=1 " "

,, ,!

$""

;

$ +3

"3 =A $"3,3 "

& ,"3 ,, , ,, ",,(3== -. ,"3 ,, $$$ ,&!

J3 JE -. "3 ! $ ,, , 3 " $ (3 ,!& & "!" !E -. ( 3 ," $ "( 3 & !

$! 3 ,, , ,"3 &

$ ,& +&" 3 3 " (3 ,!& C

>6 '

$,$ "!" !&3& , ! " !, "

< $ !$ !, ,$ ",3

$ 3$" ) , ,""

1 $) " '

$ !$$," !, "

=!"" "

, " ! % "

$ !

" '

* 3 ,3,! "

$ ",

( " "

>66 #!," ! >6 '

, ,( $ +33

,,,3""

#!,$ ,,"$$ +3

!, $3 3

+( #!, $ ,, !, & ,& 3& &" (

",, 3$ !,3 3 "

$ +3 3 4! !,!, $, "3" "

1 $ ",,"

" !! >

'$! " 556 27&7(35 5 5 55 -!$. , ! : /$3 $ $, & ( J!

J ! #!, ,3( !) (

1 ! ,!" !,

,3 " $ $& , ( $ , $ (

33" 4!," $ < $ &! $$,, !

$ ! " 3, ,, " $ (

" ,&(

3 $$,,

$ $!$ " (

, ! & I & $$ " 3, $ K, $ ! $ ,," ,, "33 4!," $ &(!, ",,(

#!, < $ & 3, ( ,, ", ( 4!,"

, :!$=" :& :=" :& : =" :& :

!,=" :& :!,=" :& :=

,,:& :

,, "3 :&: 3 :&:

,," ,:&:! " ":

& 33( 4!,"

$ (

""#!, " ;'

#!, <!$ 3 ! !

3" 3 ,""

- ,.( $ ! ,, 3 ( ,""

4!& $,, 33 " ,""

! " +3 3, ( $ !(

333 4!," "

4! :

, 3 ! ") 7$7:59:57 9 7(5947 5 5:-7&759 77(+8

;<#/-!$. , ! B> < , "! ( $ $!$ ,,(

" (

! !"0,!

1 4!"

($,(3,3, 1 ,, $ +3!33 ,""

$ 4!,& ,!

3 "

(&"

1 ,, ! ,, $, !!"

,, !, , $!

,""

!!"

#!, " !," ! '

$ ,, ,, & ,

3& " (

", , 3$ !, 3 "

$ +3& 3 4! !,! , $, "3" "

<%! $, $", 1 !#&<

# -> ., 7 2

93) 3 9 ," , J ,""

,, $! ",,+,

,""

! "(

$,, $ !!,,,, !

53,!, 8, (( ( ,!, ',,

( !

!3 ! J<("! ,

J , $ :":($$

"::&!3 :/ :( ,,",&

",,4!",+"&",,&(,

,!, $!

;! 3 !"%

:7$7597 (2(. (35 )5 =5

:$1)((((,8%8I!"&

2 "9!&> , ! B 1 3 3," 6& , $ " !, "

,"", 6" '

! = "$" ,""

=5$ ,,$< = -. !, "

E -. "

E -. ,""

" $"(

, $ & $

( " , E -. ,""

" $ " '

"!, ! $ $" !, ',& $, " "

( "! "3

,& $ L!+M$ $ +

< 1 !& , ,(, " 3"=$ +3& ,&( $ +3(!3 < "=$ +33 (,",, , A (& $, ( ,#!, #!,> $, " $$" !, ',&

# 4!"," 6" ;

!,'

& '$!=>" "3954 &5 (35$ !""3 97)5%!8" , ! = > '$!," $!, ,:$(!, , !,

', $, $,( ,,,

( 4!"#!, "

;

#!,>66&! ( ( $, (

1 ! $ "

! 3 ,

! "

3 "!

6 <= 2" "97527&7( 35 )5 55 5H-!"!/38,#J '$!

, ! =

1 $, 3" $& + $" ( ,, " "

$ &,& J%33 5 ,J J%33 1+ %, !

J& < "

, !"

!,% & , !, " $ 1 4! !33 $"!,> ( ,$"!

( $,3!333 "

& $ $$ ,$ ,( ($ ,"

$ (

(!, $

"$!

$ , $" ,$ &" ," ,

1 ) ,,!

, $ 3,$!, " , 3 ," !" ! ,,""

M !

" ,, ( ) &(!, " ( ! ,, " " < " $ & , J%33 ,J& ( ", ! $ , ! $ J%331+ %, !

J$ + ( $

, !,"" 1 ,,( !33 $ ,$" ,$ 4!! #!,>

<" !,! $ &

% $, ", ,, < ( " " &

,! ! $3

> ;

<$ 3 '!

, ! 1 , !"" "

, $$

! $8 $$, ! ! $ , ! "" ! $, 3 ,, ,( !

( $,( $ &$ $$ ,$ $$ " ,$!$ 1 $$,,! !! (,! ( ,,( ! $$,,: ! " "$ , ! 5( (

3,,, 3 $8 $ ' ( 3 $ $ ;

<$ 3'! & $

$$! !!

3 $$,,! 1 !"! " $$,, ! $ " 0 # 77 -A.

1 $$,,! $ (0 #77 -A.& $ !$$ " 1 $$,, ! "! $ J%335 ,J& 3 ( "",! $8 $ ,,! ,!"$

, ! !$$3 " 3 " $ J5 ,J ( " ",! (

$$ "

1 ,

3,,, 3 $8 $ 1 ! $,3 ( $"!, '," !, , " ,, $ !,,! $ , ! < ( " " & $$,, ! : ! $ 3! 3 ! !$$3 " ,:3 ( " ",!! 1 $$,,! : $ " $ J%331+ %, !

J,! ?

3 $" !, ', ) " ;

<$ &?

$ " "#!,>& " ( &J13 ! "

, $ = (

(!, 3 ! : !, "J ," 0 #77

"! $$,, ! 3 $ ,"!$ "

+ 3, !,+,, ( $$3 ,, & J1 3 ! " , $ = (

(!, 3 ! :!, "J !

#!,> # 3 ( $$3 ,, & , ", 3, J13 ! ", $= (

(!, 3 ! :!, "J 1 ,,( !33 $ J%331+ %, !

J ,$ " , $!$ ,$ < "" & " $$,,! $8 $ !3 ,, +3 "$ (3 $

,3 ,", $E( , $$$ , $ !

!3 3!

1 " $$,,! "= "

2 1+3,,(" &<"

$ , !"

!, % & , !, " $

3 ,,, 3 $8 $ $ "

"#!,>";'#!,!!, 7 = " " ( '&&5 9. (( 35$ !"";-!/)@-/%+%,,(

! = 1 $ $, ,, !,

', $ " 3 " ,, ' , 3",, 4!!, ',$

;

<$ &( ($,

3! ,,"3, <$ 3 !,

< (& $,,$ ! $ ;

<$ (

3, 3! 3 4! $" !, ',

< ,3 " " )!

3& $ ,,! , ,,(

1 $!3

88 (,, $ 3

, $,! 7" ";

!,'

&>6 & 4!

!& ,3,$ 3" "

$ $3#!, $" >6 '

<" $ +3 3 ,""

,, $ +3& 3 3 3 3 !

(

",, 3, $ !," $ +3 ( $ ( & (!, : 3:E -.

:% :"

$ E -. #!, " #!, " ! >6 '

$ ,," 3& ,&

3& &" (

",, 3$ !, 3 -. "

$ +3E -.

4!E - .

!,!E - .

,$, 3"

< $ , $ 1 $ , ,,3 $

, $ +3& ! : ,,3 : :

,(3 3 " , ! +$ !" "

1 A3, ,3!3(

%" !< +( 3":)! :! ( ( : :

:& $$, "3, !!" !(, !" $ "" $ '

, !"$" ,, ,,"" 1 ! $!," $" 3 ! +4!( "

,3 $ "" 3 $ 1 ,+,

" "!

$,3!( ! ;

,)! ',,3 !3, ,"

,)! 1 " " "

,3$

"" $,)! !, ! < ", " 1 ! 3 ,

:1 ?, :5 9! * 1 ! $

(!, ! !: 3:(!, $"

<("& !" 3

8 " 3 ,, ! 3" $

#!,,& $ $

A copy of this order be kept on the file of other connected case. November 14, 2023 (PANKAJ JAIN) Dpr JUDGE ?

$+38 N ?

$, N