High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1274/2003allowed

Narender Singh v. State Of Punjab

2015-01-06Ms. Justice Navita Singh9 pages

!"#

#$%&% (

!')!*+ ,- .

!*#'/#* 3!4!

55555 66#44!'"

7&5 "!"#

)'8!9 55555 #&6 '/#'"

5 :1#"1#* #6 *"#*&

$!4 6!6#*& ;!+ !44 <#/

&## 8)/0;#'"= 5

*# #**#/

#6 *"#*&

"= 5 :1#"1#* 8)/0;#'"

&1 *#6 *"#/ %0#&"= *5 !)*!91 * *!- >#0!4 %/

!66#44!'"5 &5 %'!?&1% +!4- -

)'8!95

1%& !66#!4 /%*#$"#/ 8)/0;#'"

'@%$"% /!"#/ A55

&#'"#'$#

#@#'

/!"#- *#'/#*#/ 15 5351%*- "1#'

//%"% '!4 #&&%

)/0#-

!"%!4!- @%/# !66#44!'"!*#'/#* 3!4!

1#4/ 0)%4"+ .

*;& $"

&1 *"

B"1# $"B

?##6%'0 1%& &&#&&% 5 *# )'"*+ ;!/# !'+ 6#*;%"

4%$#'&#5 # &#'"#'$#/

)'/#*0

*%0 )& %;6*%& ';#'"

'# +#!*

6!+

%'#

C.D /# !)4"

$4!)&#

)*"1#* )'/#*0

*%0 )&

%;6*%& ';#'"

/!+&5 9*%# &

!$"&

!*# 4%?# "1%&(

E55-

!0*)6 !4 '0

%$%!4& 6*#&#'"

!*#!

@%44!0# !<!&

*!1;!'!

''#$"% %'@#&"%0!"%

AAD 6#*"!%'%'0

"!"% !/!*-

!"%!4!

!*#'/#* #"$5 !%/%'0 6!*"%#& <#*#

*;#/5 '# *!%/%'0 6!*"+ 1#!/#/

!0*)6 %'01- <1#*#!&

"1#* !"6!4 %'015 !%/ '/)$"#/ !"

)'%'1!9%"#/ 9*%$?

?%4'

!*#!

31#*!

!""!'5 1#*#-

%@# 6#*& "<

;!?#

"1#%* #&$!6#

<1#*#!& "1*## <#*# '!99#/5 1#%* '!;#& <#*# !*%'/#* !66#44!'"- !8) ')5

%*&"

!44- &#!*$1

'/)$"#/

!0*)6 6#* *)4#&5 '

&#!*$1- )'"*+ ;!/# 5 *# @#*#/

*%01"

/)9

6!'"

!$$)&#/5 "

)'4 !/#/ 4%@# $!*"*%/0#

"!?#'

"1#* 4%@# $!*"*%/0# @#*#/

*%01"

$?#"

6!'"

!$$)&#/5

"1 @#*#/ 4%@# $!*"*%/0#& <#*# ;!/# %'"

6!*$#4 &#!4#/ &#!4

B <1#*#!& @#*#/ &#6!*!"#4+ &#!4#/ &#!4

B5 1#*#!

"#*- 4- 4%@# $!*"*%/0#& <#*# "!?#'

%'"

&&#&&% @%/# ;#;

)01 &?#"$1

6*#6!*#/ F5 &%0'#/ 553!*!;$1!'/ )9#0 <%"'#&&#&5 #!4 "#* )&# 1!'/#/

@#*

)9#0 %'/#6#'/#'"

<%"'#&&5 66#44!'"

!**#&"#/5 )G!

&"!"%

*#0%&"*!"%

<1#*#)6 '-

*;!4

D */#/5

)01 &%"# 64!'

F5 6*#6!*#/5 "#*

9"!%'%'0 &!'$"%

F5 5

%&"*%$"

!0%&"*!"#

4!)'$1%'0 .

!66#44!'"- $1!44!'

6*#&#'"#/ )*"5

%'/%'0 6*%;!

!$%#

;;%""%'0 !'

#'$# 6)'%&1!94# .

$"- 15 6!4 * *!-

"1#'

)/%$%!4 !0%&"*!"#

%*&"

4!&&-

!"%!4!- @%/#

/!"#/ 55 $1!*0# &1##"#/

;;%""%'0 !'

#'$# 6)'%&1!94# .D. D.A

*;& $"-

64#!/ 0)%4"+ $4!%;#/ "*%!45

#'$# !'

AE, /!"#/ E55- AAD 6#*"!%'%'0

"!"% !/!*-

!"%!4!-

*#-

%&"*%$"

)/0#-

!"%!4!

*# #**%'0 ;!""#*

'$#*'#/ )*"- <1#*#)6 ;!""#*

15 5351%*- "1#'

//%"% '!4 #&&%

)/0#-

!"%!4!

<1 &# ''#$"#/ ;!""#* 6#'/%'05 "#* "!?%'0 #@%/#'$#- &"!"#;#'"

*/#/ *5 55 <1#*#%'

/#'%#/ #!$1 !44#0!"% 64#!/#/ 1%& %''

$#'$#5 /# #'$# "!?#'

!$$)&#/!66#44!'"

#$"#/

1%;5 #

!4&#4+ %;64%$!"#/ $!&#5 $")!44+- !66*#1#'/#/ 6*#&#'$#

!'8%"

%'01- *#&%/#'"

*9!'

&"!"#-

!"%!4!

"1%'0 @#*#/

1%;5 !44#0#/ 64!'"#/ )6 1%;5 "#* 1#!*%'0 "1 &%/#&- "*%!4 @%/# 8)/0;#'"

/!"#/ A55

&#'"#'$#

#@#'

/!"# 1#4/ 0)%4"+

;;%""%'0 !'

#'$# 6)'%&1!94# .D. D.A

*;& $"

&#'"#'$#/ 1%;

;#'"% '#/ #!*4%#* 6!*"

8)/0;#'"5 1!@# 1#!*/

"!"# )'&#4-9#&%/#& !66*!%&%'0 #'"%*# ;!"#*%!4 ;%'0

*/5

!*0)#/

!4&# "1%'0 @#*#/

&&#&&%

!66#44!'"5 1%&

!$"

9#$ ;#& $4#!*

;!"#*%!4 !@!%4!94#

%4#5

& 6#* $!&#- )'"*+ ;!/#

5 *# !4 '0 "<

4%@# $!*"*%/0#& <#*# @#*#/

&&#&&%

$!*"*%/0#& <#*#

)*5 '4+ /)$#/

*# 1%;5

3!;!4 3);!* :- $!"#0 *%$!44+ &"!"#/ $!*"*%/0#& <#*# *#$#%@#/ 1%;

!4 '0<%"1 6!*$#4

#$ '/4+- /)$#/ )*"H %"

9#!*%'0 &#!4

B33B5 "#* "#&"- *;

)* 1!/ 6)"

1%& &#!4 %'&$*%6"% B33B

&!;# /)$#/ %"

9#!*%'0 &#!45 1%&

!$"

!%4#/

''#$"

/)$#/ #@#'

!*%&#& &#*% )&

/)$#/ &!;# "#&"#/ *;

)*5

'4+ "1%&- #@#'

)* :

%*# &1

*?%'0 '/%"%

"5 1)& #@%/#'$#

%4#- $!''

&!%/

*##

)9"5 '

"1#* 1!'/- %"

!*0)#/ "!"# &%'$#

3!;!4 3);!* : 1!@%'0 &)

%$%#'"

#F6#*%#'$#

"#&"%'0

!*;&-

*#- #@#'

%*# &1

4- <#44 0%@# *#6 *"

!9 *?%'0 '/%"%

'# $!&#5 "

!4&

!*0)#/ &%'$# &#!4

%'"!$"

&!;# /)$#/

*# *;

"#&"5 1#*#

*#- #@#'

&#!4

. %;6*#&&% B33B

6!*$#4

%;;!"#*%!45 #!4 %;6*#&&% B ;)$1

6!*$#4 &!;# /)$#/ )*"5 "

!4&

!*0)#/

/#4!+ &#'/%'0

"#&"

)*5 G)#&"% &#%I#/

E55 <1#*#!& &!;#

#F!;%'!"%

.555 /#4!+ &#'/%'0

#F!;%'!"%

!"!4

$!&#5 "

)*"1#* !*0)#/

%'/#6#'/#'"

<%"'#&& )9#0 %'#/ %'@#&"%0!"% #F!;%'#/ <%"'#&&5 # 0%@#'

)6 1!@%'0

@#* !$$)&#/5 !/ #F!;%'#/ '- 0#')%'#'#&&

1!@# 9#$ ;# ?'

<'5 >#!*'#/

)*"1#* %'"#/

!*# /%&$*#6!'$%#& &"!"#;#'"&

: 5

: /#6 &#/

*;#* /%&$4 &#/ $!"%

9*%$?

?%4'

&%0'

!*/

9*%$?

?%4'- <1#*#!&-

: /#6 &#/

*;#* !$$ ;6!'%#/ "1#;

%5#5 )6"

9*%$?

?%4'5 # *#;!%'#/ "1#;

"1* )01 /)*%'0 %'@#&"%0!"% '5 & 6#*

!66#44!'"- '"*!/%$"% ;!"#*%!4 '"*!/%$"% #&

$!&#5 6!*"

!9 @#-

: /#6 &#/

'&"*)$"%

9*%$?

?%4'

<1#*#!&

: /#6 &#/

/#6%4!"#/ '/%"%

9*%$?

?%4'5

4%01"

!9 @#-

'"#'/#/

!%4#/

@# %"& 9#+ '/ *#!& '!94# &)$1 #'"%"4#/

9#'# %"

)9"5 "

)"&#"- 4%?#

;!?# ;#'"% AAD -

AE,

E55 /#$%/#/

15 5351%*- "1#'

//%"% '!4 #&&%

)/0#-

!"%!4!

@%/# 8)/0;#'"

/!"#/ 555'

!$"- 6*#&#'"

*;& $"

/#$%/#/ !4 '0

*#;#'"% '#/ &

'# "*%!4 )*"5 *;& $"

/#$%/#/

%*&"

%'&"!'$# 4/%'0 0)%4"+

#'$# 6)'%&1!94# .D. D.A

B"1# $"B <1#*#!& ;!%'

AAD /#$%/#/ "*%!4 4!""#*- !$G)%""%'0 0%@%'0 9#'# %"

"1#;5

%$# *#6 *"

64!$%'0

*/ 6+

8)/0;#'"

*#'/#*#/

AE,

E55

1!@# !$G)%""#/ 0%@%'0 9#'# %"

)9"5 &#$"%

!4&

*#6 *"#/

)'/ *#0%&"#*#/

AE,

E55- %&"*%$"

!"%!4!5

!$"- *%01"

9#0%''%'0-

#& %'&6%*# %/#'$# ;%'/

*#0!*/%'0 0#')%'#'#&&

$!&#5

&"!*"#/ %"& ;!?%'0 ;#'"% 6!*"+ !4&

6*#&#'"

''#$"% %'@#&"%0!"%

*#0%&"#*#/ AAD !*#'/#* #"$5 "1#+ !66*#1#'/#/ !*#'/#*

<#44 ') !8)5 '

!$"- 6!*"+ 6*#&#'"

)& "!'/

!<!&

*!1;!'!

''#$"% %'@#&"%0!"%

AAD 6!*"+

6*#&#'"

''#$"% $1#$?%'0 &#!*$1

&)&6#$"#/ 6#*& <1#*# "1#+ *#$#%@#/ &#$*#"

*;!"% %'$4)/%'0 6*#&#'"

#$"

"1#+ <#*# ;!?%'0 64!'&

;;%""%'0 /!$ %"+

)*"1#* "1#+ <#*# !*;#/ /#!/4+ <#!6 '&5

1!'/- "!4?

!9 &)$1

*;!"% &"*!%01"<!+ &!%/ 6!*"+ 6*#&#'"

''#$"% %'@#&"%0!"%

AAD *#0%&"#*#/ !"

"!"% !/!*-

!"%!4!

)'/#/ )6 1%;- <1#*#!&

: /#6 &#/ %'#/ 6!*"+ 1#!/#/

!0*)6 "1#+ <#*# 6*#&#'"

)& "!'/

!<!&

*!1;!'!

''#$"%

AE,

E55- )9#0 %'#/ 6!*"+ 1#!/#/

!0*)6 "1#'

"1#+ 1!/ '#

!9!'/ '#/ 9*%$?

?%%'

!*#!

31#*!

!""!'5 1)&

: "!4?

!9 *#$#%6"

&#$*#"

*;!"%

!0*

%'$4)/%'0 "1#+ <#*# ;!?%'0 6*#6!*!"%

;;%""%'0 /!$ %"+ !"

)" &?%*"& !*#!

!"%!4!

%"+5

: -

!0*)6 %'01- '@#&"%0!"%'0

%$#*- /#6 &#/

6#*& $1#$?#/ /)*%'0 "1#%* &"!+ !"

)& "!'/

*!1;'!5 @#'

/#6 &# !'+"1%'0 !9 *#$#%6"

&#$*#"

*;!"% %'$4)/%'0 "1#+ <#*# ;!?%'0 6*#6!*!"%

;;%"

/!$ %"+ !"

*#&!%/ !9!'/ '#/ 9*%$?

?%4'5 #

)*"1#* /#6 &#/ )G!

!9 (

55 '

#'/

1%& $* &&#F!;%'!"% /#6 &#/ )G!

55 1)&- &"!"#;#'"

'@#&"%0!"%'0

%$#* 1%;&#4

'"*!/%$"

%'"

)G!

&"!"%

*#0%&"*!"%

!9 @# !4464!$# <1#*#

E "%;#

%'/& ;#'"% )G!-

@#*<*%"%'05 "%;#

&#'/ )G!

&"!"% '- 0!%'& %;6 *"!'$# 553!*!;

1!'/ :

!0*)6 : - '@#&"%0!"%'0

%$#* /#6 &#/

#4#$"*%$ 9)49

")9# !"

&%"#

9*%$?

?%4'5

'/#* "1#&# $%*$);&"!'$#-

& )*$#

4%01"

9*%$?

?%4'- %"

9#4%#@!94#

6!*"+ ?#6"

*/%'0 $##/%'0&

)6"%44 5

: /#6 &#/ "1#+ *#;!%'#/ !"

&6 "%44 5

: !4&

/#6 &#/ 3#&#* '&"!94#- <1

1!/ "!?#'

*)G!

$!;# 9!$?

(

&6 "5 "!"#;#'"

'@#&"%0!"%'0

%$#* &)'

1!/ &#"

6!*"%!4 /!*?'#&&5 "

9#4%#@!94# 6!*"%!4 /!*?'#&& !"

- (

55 >%@# $!*"*%/0#& <#*#

)* :

#F!;%'!"% '5 @#'

%*# &1

#F!;%'!"%

)*5

: $!"#0 *%$!44+ &"!"#/

%*# &1

'/#* "1#&# $%*$);&"!'$#- '"#'"%

!%4#/

@# *?%'0

*/#*- $!**%#& <#%01"5

%'/%'0

&#!4 %'&$*%6"% B33B

!4&

!%4&

''#$"

/)$#/ $*%;#5 '&#'/%'0

4%@# $!*"*%/0#&

#F!;%'!"% !4&

;!?#& )45 "

)*&# "*)# "#&"%;

'%#&

%$%!4& !*# !"

6!* "#&"%;

'%#&

%$%!4& <%"'#&&#& %"

%'/#6#'/#'"

<%"'#&& %'#/ 4!"#*

0%@#'

A 1!@%'0

@#* #F!;%'%'0 1%;

)*"5 !/ #F!;%'#/ )9#0 <%"'#&& )*"- 1!@# /%&$4 &#/5

*##

*%01"

%'$#6"% '5 &"!"#;#'"

'@#&"%0!"%'0

%$#* 1%;&#4

'"*!/%$"

*+5 #$ */%'0

$##/%'0&

/!*?'#&& )'9#4%#@!94#5

;!%'

1!@# !4*#!/+ !$G)%""#/5 >%@#

$!*"*%/0#& 1!@#

"#&"

)* '/)$"

"#&"

%*#

G)#&"% #@#'

!%4&

''#$"

/)$#/

$*%;#5 & &)$1 "#&"%;

'%#&

%'&6%*# %/#'$# ;%'/

*#0!*/%'0 0)%4"

!$$)&#/5

!9 @# &!%/ *#!& '&- 4/%'0

!%4#/

9*%'0 ;# 0)%4"

9#+ '/ *#!& '!94# )9"- 8)/0;#'"

'@%$"% /!"#/ A55

&#'"#'$#

#@#'

/!"# !*# &#"

!&%/#5 !66#!4 !$$#6"#/5 $$)&#/

*/#*#/

!$G)%""#/

$1!*0#

!$%'0 "*%!45 %& 9!%4 '/& &)*#"+ '/& !*# /%&$1!*0#/5

%'#- %

!'+ 6!%/-

*/#*#/

*#")*'#/

!66#44!'"5

#$%& &;*%"%