← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4045/2003dismissed

P.G.I.M.E.R. v. M/S Kalsi Construction

2019-05-10Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri8 pages





        



  







!"#$ %%&& '() * +& () -%

/(

$% .    

 

( ( ' .

0/(.12

.3 

%%&&

(

(/ (4.

5 .3 

 64/ 5/

.3 

 +3 (4.

.3 

(%

77777777  



 %%& &.

4:

/&&:

..

; %.

.. &

,/.:(/ 1/(9

&.

/(

(9( &

=  ( >/ > :

. ..

 -9(

.-.

 (



(

( ()

.3.

.( ,( .

(%

 (

/ (:(.

( :(- .(1 ?).

%( (4 -%&.

1/ -

)/

& 9&& )&.

1

:(.

 -)(-

$%

 ( .%) (9( 5/ 55  : %% .

& (

/ %( /( &- )(&- 9 (

1/ -

% ..

/ -9(

::(3.

:

/( /&&:.

-

9 (

,/.:(/

1/

-

.-.



..

;

1//

/&&: / %%&

( ' .

0/(.12

&(.

)& %%(:

9/&

(:)@ %( ..

.

:(-

:(:



& &-

)

%(

-(.

3.@ (:(.:

&-

1(..

- ( % - / :(.

91 %(@ &-

9 ) (

.& -

9)

( :3 1:

(

BC

)/

.:

)9&@ (:(.

&-

&

)9-.

 -(4 ( %.

( &.

& %( &)

(@ -&(&

.:

(9(

&-

;

 ).

9) ( 1( %%( 3.

5)%(.:

%& #:( - 1( %.

(1(..

%& #:(

)/

/ ( .-.

/3 %.

%(.

%& #:(@ (:(.

&-

B

)9-.

(4.

) /

1 (

)

( :

- ..

(49& (-)&@ -&(&

%%( /

  &(.

(:(.

&-

& 0&&  ).

9) & 0&&  )9-.

(  -)(-

(4

" &

..

 /: :(.

(-

(

$:(.:

&-

(:).

/( %( () .

* ?1&& -

1 &/ % - .)

-%

 %.

( (*(%

1(..

-% : (.

:(.

(-

( $,, % - 1&& &-

B

 ( (

(

(/ (4.

&(.

5 )& & :

 64/ 5/

.3   +3 (4.

.3  %%(:

9/&

(%

(:) (:)-

&(.

)& /3 .& .&

&(.

- ( )9& " ..

9( %()&

():



;

%: 1 (9( 4 

.( -(&*3.*.

)- 3&9&

( (.

.:

(9( ( 1&& ( .

" &

(:).

  ()&

&1 &(.

(:/&

.-.

% &.

.&.

(.(

)%% (

/ (:)-

/ (&.

)% 2).:- (.(.

    

      

        !"""#$%&'() *+,  -   

 !""&#$%.$!  "

/3 /(.

&(.

)& %( /3 :



 /( ):/ &

=

1/& .-:

% &.

9(3.

).(@   

       

          

     

  

          

    

 

            



    

    

 

   

 



 

  

  !  !    

  "#$      % 



    

 

    &'#

  ( !       

%         

    

     







 

     ))))))))) $* !

+* "

 & ",,(  





           

   

 

    

   

                     

      

 



   "

   +$,,    -

       



. 

  





           

   "

  /%    

$-0,0

'1 &     

   

     ! !!2 &  / 

3

4''#5 67 

  "

    

  

 

8

   



 

"

   

 %  "

  

           

%   "

 

)

           %         

9    

    

%  

& 

 "#8 



!  "#8$   :    

     %    5

! ;  #8



%



   

%  

       "

     

         

 $ '

   





 

     

  

           "

        



      %    

 ! 5

! ; #8

  %   '1 %

.

     

      "

         !

* "

 &",,(  

    9  34

%                    

 34

.



   

      

  

       



             8

      

  

%          



  

 % 

%      "





   

 % 3< '

=  %   <9  ;  =   7 

  $>>$3+4  !

& &

'

-$4    %          

          

=





  "

  % !

 * "    3'1    %     ))))))))) * %    



 % 

 %       

 

%  



    0?         

     )

   9

   



   0?

 

  

          

 

@



  

   

  

 

%  



"          % 

 ; 2).:- (.(.

)9& 0/

5)%(- )( ,/

0     1/2  !"'&#& %$(3

9(3.

).(@ 0    



 

&  %

  &    

    



     %    "

  % #







   

  

"

        

      



    

 "

  *    

   2      

    )  

   ) )  

2 )    2,       ) 

  3!

6  &9 &=D =;" 3$>>*4!&&

; >,E% 7"



D F3$>>4 !&&0>E2& &

'

%

=  D F7:

3$>>4!&&*,E "

   &   D   '   G 

=  3$>>04(!&&$0E!! 7=

&

=D F7" 3$>>04* !&&A 31

9 3 (

&1 ( :

:

/( ):/

/ )(

.(.

31  (9(& 8(9)& /.

:

 /( ):/ (&3 -(& %&.

9 ( ( :

:

/( ):/ -

%.

1(.  /.

%%&.

/ -.

:( ).

-.

)

(( 1(.    .

  ((

).-& % &

". &1@ 9 ((

(

".@  ((

2)

- (& @

. %&

&&:& % &&:&

)&.

:

3(

-( (3& &&:& 13(

)&.

 . 

)( )( 9& 4 

)( B 

.&.

%.

():



;

%:

 %()&

-%):.

..

; %.

:



 

9 ( / )(

1( &

9 ( /-

.&.

- / 3(



.&

( .):

3. &.

9 ( /-

-%):.

.).

)--(

&

.&

B



).

&:& 3&.

6(.

)& &

3/-&

(:) ((.

1:

&-

1// %(

% -



 * ):/ )%%&

 &.:

* ?1&& - (4 .

 0& 4#

" (:).

% -



 * (:/&

9:

1//&.

(4 .



.

-

* ?1&& - (%

&-

13(

%()&

)&.

(& 4 

 ) &( ..(.

& 4:

(%

)%%&

 &.:

* ?1&& - /(9

/ &.:

(%

)&.

&.

&-



 *

 )

)%%&

 &.:

8/(

(-

( :

1:

.

&-



-(9&

&.

% 

)

&&:&

(-

-%):.

%.

)/

:( ).

-.

)

(( -

31

9 3 .)

%%& /(9

.-.

9:

.3 .

-(

 

 !"! #   %  E//( %4:*( .

F*

E//( (% (9& F*