High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/9201/2023allowed

Shiv Kumar Sharma v. Ut Chandigarh And ANR.

2023-07-11Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil11 pages

!"#"

$ % "&"

' ()*"

+ *+ ** ) ****

!"

# +, -$ ./01 " (1).

$ % # &' ( )*+* ), ++ *)*) " -.* '

! " " ,+!

/0 +1 # *2 +) *)*+/0 *1 3 34 " 3%

"

# &' (2).

3 % 5 &'#" 3 #

"# &'5 "# ( *64 75 3 # ( * ( +)-,!' ! 8*!

/

1")+ +* *)+9 # " # # 3 ! 5 0" 35

( *55 35 # 3

5 0"34 ( *3 ##6 : & 7 5 5# '# 4 # #

5 5 5 $ V VISHAL 2023.07.12 11:08

- 2 - # 4 #

"

## # 5 5"

:

( * (3).

' 5 +9 )* *)*)! 5 (;

*

!# 4"" # # #

!

&' 3 #

(4).

; *2 +) *)*+! # "

"! #

" +2,

/0 *1! 5 3 " 5 3 # # ( *

"

4"!"

3

"-.*'

(5).

<

" # 3 # # ! ( * 4 # #

5"5 "

4

" 5 #

" 35

;+, )* *)*)/0 .1! "5"

"

3 & " 5 ## # = ##"! $5 ( * ! 34 5#

34 " " 4

5 ' 4 ( * " *9 )* *)*) /0 -1! 5 4 ># 3 # 5" # " ( *55

3# 5 " (6).

?# 3 # "

# #

#

4 *)*)! ( * 5

# #

- 3 -

# ## # @ #

( *!+, )2 *)*) "5"5 4

34 )A )9 *)*)! % ( *

"% "$5

4 *)*)! 5 ! %! ( * 4

"% # #

4 *)*) 3

"%# #B B 4!5" # "# " "

! 5!

4

(7).

'# "#

" # 3

34 ( *> 3"

5 5 #

&'

""5 ! 35 ( *

4# "

##"

&' 3 34 ( *># # (8).

<

" # 3 " #

"-.*'

"

"

4 # 3 4 " ##"

#

5# " 5 " )+ +* *)+9 ( *

45$

4

4 5

*9 )* *)*) ;" " 3 "# ##"+, )* *)*)!5

34 (;

*5 $ " "*)+- '

- 4 - " # ! ( * ## 4

"$34# 5 # "! 345 4# # &' ( *# " "

"4 # 5 # 4 # >

C ! 3

3 5 #

! 5 5 " 5

4 # "

:"

"

' #

3 # !# # #

#

#

5 "

3

4# # " 4

(9).

& 4" (;

*34 # " "! &'

D 5! " 5

5 #

# # # "

3

# "

5 5 5 3 5

# # # #"-.*'

; 5 ! #" -.*'

4 &' "

343 $ "$ 3 #

"#

5

# # " ' ;##" ' 3 3# " 5 # # ! # ! &'5 5 # " +2,

! 3 &'5 # $ #==

- 5 - (10).

?

" # #

(11).

C# !'

"# !5 3

"

#"-.*#'

!5"

8 2

(12).

;

# #

!

#

# $ " -.* # '

! 5 %

% 3" 4 # ##" " -.* # '

! 3 3 / 1 "" "

/31 5 " # $

# ! # # 5 # 4

! ! # #

# ! # ! # 5 #

'# #5 % #!"-.*5 3

" (13).

?

#! 3# " --* #'

8

- 6 -

(14).

?5 !#

" >"0 # 5 ##" "-.*'

$ # "

"--+

# "--+#'

8

(15).

# ! "

5 3 " #!

4 # 5 "

!

4 #"

4

5 $# ! 5# 4 "

4!3 5# 4 !5 #

4! 5"

3

5# ! 3 5" 3 5" 4 $ 5

# #

(16).

'"

# ! "

#$%&'()*+ "),*!

3 4

45 5 4! !"

4 # 3 # "

" 4 "! 5 # 4E ##"#

- 7 - 5 4

"%" # 4 5 $ 4 3

4 "! ! $ 4 "%" 5 $5 E "5 # 4 "

#" 4 "! ! " " " ""

"#$5

"%"5 3" 4 "!

"

3 3 4# "

#" ! 4 "! 3 5"

(17).

' - ! .

&'( )++ & ,* 0 3 "35

5

5$5 E 3

34

" "" ! 45 4!

" $" # 4 3"

! 4 " $5

$ 4 "

4 " 45"--+#'

(18).

B "

/"!0/ 1& ),+ "2+3!# " " 5 !# "

5"" 4

34 ##! 5 ""

#

# " 5

! "

"" 4

5 ' "

%

3# 3 #

# #

"

3 #

- 8 - # ! "

34 "

# 4

# # !

43 #

3 4

"

5 #"--+#' '5 # #4"#"--+! 3 3

5" ##" '5

43# 4$ "" 4

# # # # "# ! 3 "

>#4

! # ! 4 5" " 3

4

>"

34 " ! "

"" " "

3 4 3#

" #

(19).

3 "$"

&'! ! "

=" 3 ! *)+9! # 3 # # "

# (

"

# 3 4#""3!

( * 3 :

# #4

,) ++ *)*,

( *

" 5 +*+. $

C 4 # !

4 # #

5 # # #3 5 # ?5 ! #"!

- 9 - (;

* 5 4 #

4 # (20).

"" # 3

" 3 " " " 40 53# " "

" " D 4

4#

4"

4 "5 #3

#

5"

4 "5 4 "" 3 43 5 3

#

"

# 4 " # #5

" 3"# 5 #

# 4 " 43 "

#

"# 5 3"

" 4 ""

#5

#

(21).

!# #

"--+

##"#"

$

" 3 # # " " " "#"

& "!

4#3 5 # # " "

! " ##"#"

' 5 ! 0 "#

#"!

4 # ! 5 ! 5 3 3 ##" #

(22).

'5#"--+!--*-.*#'

5 5

5 4 "

/

1 /"4 "

/

1!"

# 43 4

6"

7

- 10 - #4"#"--+#'

! 3 3

5# 4

5 34 ! 4! 5 " ##" ##"5 4

"%"# 4 4:

! 5 $ 43

4 "! ! $ 4 "%" 5 $5 8 4:

!3 3 5 "

" 4 "! 5 # 4 4:

(23).

$"#&' 5 # " +2,

! "

3 !

5# 4 5:

34 ! 4! 5 " ##" 3 4 3# " 4 ##" ! ! 4 4

#"

4 (24).

'

'%

! "

-

255)3,"6!?@3

!

"

#

!

$

%

- 11 -

(25).

' 5 # 3 "

# 5!

#

3! 3 &' 3 5

#

85 "

F

" !" #"

##" (26).

"" 4!

5 &' ( )*+* ), ++ *)*) " -.* '

! " " ,+!

/0 +1 5 # *2 +) *)*+/0 *13 34 " 3%

"

# &'! % ++ )2 *)*, &&

3+, -$ ./04

$ .

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No