Assistant Director Directorate Of Enforcement v. Prakash Gurbaxani




        
 

            !"#"$%& 





























  



























!
'       






























"#




































 
 $$$$$
 % &'(
) 
"
*
"


 + 

 #
"#


#

,  
-


) 
 +
) %#
"

 #
+

, 
-


) 
" 
 # 
) 
 
" %




) 
 
/  
 + 





) 
"

"


 +  
-


) 
  

) 
0  +
  
" %




)
 
 + 



.

)()
12!34

!2!


) 
) +
 
 +  
-



) 
  +


) 
1 
5 *  
 + 



.

)()
12!36

!2!



 






/&
- &

 


(



 

 
7 8
 
%
 #%


.




















9  %:  %




2!2;!2!



(4



 
  &
#

"

 
5 % (("

 #
5 % )<
 % 

 
7 8
 
.  ,  

%
12:=,>:!2?


( ( 




7
., 8

#


 &


( 


 

+ %


"

@6
.

.

%
 

%



*  







# 

  #
 
#
9  

# -

 

+#+



!

"

 



 &
 #


 

##

 

 : 

 #
+ #

 
-
 + #
# %

 

 
 

 #  
+  
A-
#


 % 

  #
  - 

%

%  
. #
, 
 + 
< 
" 

#

<
B.

#&
. &
< 

#
" 
/ *%

 
 % 
+
C,
12!?

;!!23



(;





D!2
,.

2


= &

#

%# 

>



?64

 
7


?648
-

## %  
 
# 
1?2

!223
43

!2;

6?

!2D
-

%


#

.# &

E,

#
.&F
  
2@
23

2?

 % 




  



!4G



  #
#

!D?
#


  #
#





 ( 
.# &
-



E1
 
1
<F

 
7
11<8
  % &


















 
=-


 #&
3D
#


 
  % &
-



 +

##
44
#





%+
<<
.

&
" 

#

%

. 

 
#
-

 


 
. &
" 

#



+# 



 + 

 




  




## % #


&
## %: ##

 

%





(



:



#

( 
  



"$      


) % %



B.

#&
.
< 

( 

"#
"$  ' 





. #
, 
+
< 


 #

 % 

  &

# #
# 
 . ##


%  




2




?64
 #&
-# 



D!2
,.


 
 %#&

#
&
  
. 
;

=-




- (-#




 
 9 #&

%

., 




( 
C, 
A

( 

"#



()" ""$ *)"+"$ ,- &'& 


#
=%
. 



9  %

 (



.,
+


2623!2!2



(?
 


- 


-



#



 
., 
-#
%

 %
#

&






++


# &
 (


- 
#


- 
 9






(

(  




















" #
H 
A





 %




+ : 

 #
 %



%  

# &
. ("

:. ## - 



6;3
.

.
-#




"

D!2
,.

 
-
#

++ #

 (



.,




( 






" #
H 





)

&
< 

%

!22!

 
7
)<
8

 



;

D


 

-

+



D



 


# &
. ##

-

% 
62!!2!

+ #  

. 



 %

 &

+




32!!2!



(
 
 

 #

( 

9 
C

# %
%% &


(






#  $.'  

 #

 
+


 

22;!2!



(D
 

.(
/ 
( 
 








(


 


 
-






,
#


 





 
+



2!2;!2!



(4
 

% 

#

:

*  &





%

 &





C

# %
( 
-
 (



 
+



% 

4

/

+

 %



# % #&

+ # &


%







(4



























 
 


#

#  



(@

(6
 




# 


%# #

 

+



!D2!!2!



(
 
A



&



+

%
  #& $. / &   


. 


 %

 

# 

 
-

##- &

.( / 
+



2!2@!2!
@

,

#

 &

 




 
  
  #
<

 #
.

#

%
1
6@@@(6@@6

!2!
+

# &
 ##
 



2!2@!2!
 +






!22!2!
-

##- %

+  '(


 
    


               !   "   #        $ %&  
   '      $ %! ($ %   #!  '     ' "  
  )  #    )          !
  * '!'   
+


















 










C 


 #




(

+  




#
 


# 


%# #



 



 ##

 
.(
/ 
 


 

 # 

6

,
 +


#

  #
"#


#

, 
"

 #


( 
#

"

 #


(    

#

 #


(  '  

 +
#


# 


##&


3

<

"


(
 


 
 #  

  ##&
+



 &





*  

32!!2!

+

&


&




+







(


   #&
 

. 

 #

 


&
#

%
.

)()
133!4

33!6

!2!

+



22;!2!




(D

 

 



 
-


  




+
%







(4
  
% 
## % ##&
#



(

9 


-

 
% +&


 
 +#+
 
#
  




-# #  #&
%





(D


 

 

%
 
 %

 
4
&
 









+ 

"

@6
.

.
-#



&


















!



8
 &




 % 
A





 

 
# 

#

"#$%&#'
(&#$
)*
+,$-(-
*,
.#.,

/,-.
,01#'


0'%0,
#'


*,,'
*#0)
#%0
+,$-(-
.#.,

"
#0)
.*,$-


"
 
?



 
#

"


. #



      

#

 #



 ' 
 + %
 


 +

&

 %#&


% 





* #

. ## :. ("


 
#

#


  &

. 

2!2@!2!

# 


%# #




 

( #


+ (9


!22!2!



 
4
&
 











 # 


@6
.

.
 
# 
# %
%

 #
,
 


 
 &
 +
#
# 

#

#.2#3%.
#''(4*#%
5,-#%
#0)
.*,$-
+-
.#.,

6(3#$#.

78
(9$,&,
($.
#-,-
I
3%.
%01*
:
%.
%01*
+-
.#.,

"(03#4
!

0'%0,
";
 <I
,0.$#'
($,#(

0=,-.%1#.%0
9,>%#'
0=,-.%1#.%0
,''
,?
5,'*%
+-
0(9#&

('@#$0%
7<<8

(9$,&,
($.
#-,-


#.#01
%0*
+-
*,
,0.$#'
($,#(

0=,-.%1#.%0


0'%0,
#'
 
2

,

% 
- (-#




 
%



-


2;2;!2!
-

%










# 


%# #




.(



















/ 
+


2!2@!2!

-



 #


 

#
 

 



&


 



 
#




 + 

%






=
"







  %




(  


!22!2!


,
 
  %  ##&



 1!!

* %

#.2#3%.
#''(4*#%
5,-#%
7-(9$#8 '(
        

,          #  # #!   '   #           # # #!   '     &   !      #   #!    !                #      #    ###  !

+




C 


+  


 
9

#
 

+ -

(


!22!2!

 
=
"

. 

. 
 

 
 &



 

*  
 &





,

%


 

+#+ -
 ++


.
 


 
 #&

 




 






  #
-##
 +

 
  

&

 &






# -






















<

 #


%

 +  

!





# % #&

+ # &


%






(4


- 

2!2;!2!
  +

 
 


##- %




-

%+

.(
/ 
-#


 

 
. 
+



(D'(


E-         '     $& *./% /0
12
212/        

  3. .

 3' * 4'          ,   '      #!      #!     #!       5
/  12
16
212/  /1
11 

  !'        &

#!
  ! # 12
16
212/'  !       # 
 '

# #,#&

    
+ ;

=-



%


%








(4

#
 

  #
. 
 




##

&


(9




. 
-#
 





 

#&
 #
-
##

 

 "

 #
 #
  




 
 %  

  


 




 



 



















-

* % 

 &

  #
 #
   
  


 


 

 







 &

 
# -

 :%



D

A

+  




,0.$#'
($,#(

0=,-.%1#.%0
9,>%#'
0=,-.%1#.%0
,''
,?
5,'*%
7-(9$#8
&

.(
/ 

3%.
%01*
:
%.
%01*
7-(9$#8

- ##

. #
=%
. 

#.#01
%0*
7-(9$#8



+ #



 
,0.$#'
($,#(

0=,-.%1#.%0
9,>%#'
0=,-.%1#.%0
,''
,?
5,'*%
7-(9$#8


( 


2D2??

- 
 

. 
) # ) %
242??

9 

 ## 

- 


*  #
 &
##
2??

 
&

#  &
- 
%

, %  %
H


-#

- &


##

- 
 
 #

- 
 




!2??

- 


*  #
 &
##
!?2??



, %  %
H

% 
#


#
 &
-
- 
#

-





 

9 









 &


*  

+

&
 

 #

 


- 
 ##


.


 

- 


+



(D
 

 
 
4
&
  
%  #

 
&



+
%


A 

3%.
%01*
:
%.
%01*
7-(9$#8

# 


 #





  ##&

##-
























- 
#

- 


*  #
 &






#   #
#


@6!
.

.

-





#



 


 




#&
 % 
,
#.#01
%0*
7-(9$#8
#


- 

;2!24




 

 #





 

 #



#
 &

 %
 

 

- 
% 
 #



&




#
 &
- 

* 
-








  

4
A

+  
 &
. #
=%
. 

"#$%&#'
(&#$
)*
7-(9$#8

) &



=%
. 

*,,'
*#0)
#%0
7-(9$#8



 #


+ -

 (



+  




#.2#3%.
#''(4*#%
5,-#%
7-(9$#8


@



 9 #




(% %
 

##-
 
%

%



2!2;!2!
  &

  #
.


% ##&
 


-



. 




 

9 :





  &

. 

2!2@!2!
%

 %

# 


%# #




 




-
 


 #



# #&

  



 %#&


      *01

- 2 +3 )&4     
J %

   ,7 89   #8 9