← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1881/2002dismissed

State Of Haryana v. Krishan

2026-04-01Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja5 pages









  

  

  

                        

            

B#

  

22($ 

22($ 

22($ 

22($;

;

;

; ;86;6 6;6 6;6 6;6: 

 

 

 

     ! ! ! ! "  "  "  "               ++ () ++ () ++ () ++ ()  ()  ()  ()  () #$ #$ #$ #$    '

()$ #'

( %&#

"  %&#

"  %&#

"  %&#

"  # # # # 4*2( * 2(// '@ ()- ) ')* () CCCC /'

/'

/'

/'

" # " # " # " # 0 1  !2.

)*2 33('.

'/)*

,4

'2(5

/

6/

7/

8/

9/

:/

/

/

/ ;/  / 6/ 7/

8/

9/ :/  /669 (.76;; 6;;6B B# 4 2(5.

2.

,,)*

, * '2 ( =)  33(

>=22)2 ( (. 2(<,<  2.

()2

)

>= )2( ?')* 4'

<2)@/

)

4 2(5) '3

6;;6 061  @ @

,/ (5 * 4

(, 2.) (?

'..

6:;66;;6 + . 4@ )*

. .., 2)'2 ) =.5 / 2 ' *

' )  4

=')E

''

)* A 071  '

,@) )2(5/2()*

/8;7

(./?*2 (

)2( ?

 , =(. 78

/ 2)=

. ?2)*2( )*  '

(=

<2,,  &* '2 5*/

*2,  =(./ 2 2)'2 ) 2 '/ ?

. < <2.

)2

)2(.

.7; 6 : (. ;

  2= .=(.

)2(8B: & (. >=22)2 ( )/ 8 '*'))* A  8 )E'

+

)2< ,@/ ')* +=4 4,2 +='+ /( ,@ @K ()'= )2( 322(5,2 ,2(D' .4 )?

( )) &* '2

2 2&* '2'

.F?

'.=(.

)2(  8 )?

+ .4@ & (. >=22)2 (,,

)' '*')A)* & E(6 ;8 /?* 4@3 'D ,=

> ., (.?

.G  /69/;;;-I+

,(5?2)* ,, )* ') )=)'@4

2) (.2() )+'<2.

.=( (.

')* 8 ) 081  2 )2 ?2)* ?

'. 4@ &/

'2(<D .

)2( 8  )/ ?*2

) + '),@ ,,?

.

=')<2.

2) '. . 6:;66;;

;6/ ?*2,  5'

()2(5 )* 3 (*

3+ ( )2( G 6/;

/;;

;;-I

4 2.

'.2(5 ,,)* ') )=)'@4

2)-2() )2()* 2'

<='=( (.

8 ) 55'2 .)*

,?

''

))*

- )  () 091

3+ +=5(2(5 )*

2. ?

'./ ,

. ) =( , =432) )

. 

 =') ?

() ?'(5 ?* *2,  .2

'.2(5 )*  2()

+'.=

()- ) '3

HI )HI7&

. )

=( =')* =432))* ))*

.

=') ''

.* <2(5'

.=+ +(

. ;;9 :HI <2.

?*2 *;

"

, (.?

 ,.

'6/ /;;;- -I&

. ) =( ,

() (.)* )2(

3+ )2< ,

)2( '32(5+ ')

()2( .

HI < <2JI

I<2J )*

. , (. ?

 () 4,2* . ( ( '

'./ )* =,. () *

() (2()

=() ')* +='+ '32( )2( 'D )< ,= 2(

+'

 

/+'

@ )* ))*  23 3+=5( . L=.53 () 4@ )*

=') ))4 2.

(.)* ?

'.+ &4 )'

. 0:1   (  *  +=) 2(

 ( ( 4  )*  '

()  *

'.,

. ) =( (.5( )*'=5*)* + '4D ?

,, '

'.

 3=( ) 2(.=4)

=4322(3 (4

()- )

01 ) 2') 2()

/ 2) 3 @ 4 () ) )  ()  )* 2()

+'.=

(.+'< .('

'.4@4 4)*)* + ')2 2(=++') 2'

23

2,)* H)'

.* '$I

.+'

.+'

.+'

.+' H*242) H*242) H*242) H*242)     .=

(.

.=

(.

.=

(.

.=

(.

.?( ' .?( ' .?( ' .?( '

'

,.

'

,.

'

,.

'

,.

(5

(5

(5

(5     9 : "

)69

9 

"

) ;

5, -"2,, 5, -"2,, 5, -"2,, 5, -"2,,

(2.

)2(

(2.

)2(

(2.

)2(

(2.

)2( HI  ;;9 ;/"2,, 7-7 6/ /;;;-I HI6 ;9 /"2,, 9 6/97/;;;-I

.+'

.+'

.+'

.+' HI ;:;

.=

()- )

.=

()- )

.=

()- )

.=

()- )

 9

"

)67 :  6;"

)69 32( B  

"

) 7/"2,, 68  ;/;;;-I HI6 :;:

7/"2,, 7 B6 6/7 /;;;-I HI7 ; ; 6/"2,,  8  /;;/;;;-I 1 ' 3 )* 4< ')/ 2)

( 4 .2

. )* ) )*  2()

+'.=

. 4@ ()- )  2( )* '3  HI6 (. HI7 (. )* 2()

+'.=

' HI6+ ') .)+ '2. +)()2

)2( (=(.

)2(8 8

)/)*=/(

.())4 .=+ +( =')* '3'

/

HI +'.=

.4@ @)* ()- ) ,(

. )

 .2

'.

 <2.

 )*

2./ ;

 D (. ?

 ,. '  ;/;;

;;-I ?*

 )*  &  2) . )*  3 'D

) < ,=  )*

. , G  /69/;;;-I+

(

+ ')* ?2.3 3 ,,

)'/?*2 *?

4

()*

.2)

.3 '2 ,3 2, 4@)* (= =)*'2)2 /)* < ,=

. , (. ?

 *25* ' )* ( )* ) '

. 2( )*  .

. HI  ?

?2)* 3)6-7'. +'2

.2

,3 &/)*

(() ) 4  )'

 4(

2.

 )'

(

)2( ' )*  +='+  .

'32( )2( (  'D )< ,=

2(* (.)*=/

(()4 .=+( 01  '.)*

. ;;9 :HI +'.=

4@ () -, '/<2.

?*2 *;

"

,; 

'3 32(5 ') < '@ @ (= <2,,

&* '2 5*/

*2, = =(./ 2)'2 )2 '?

,. '6/ /;;;-I/4 (5+'2'))* )2

)2(

)2( 8   )* 8  ) ?2)* ,

 +'H232)@ 2( )23 M )*

=') )'25*),@'

.=+()* 3 () 'D )< ,= 2( +'

 =4 >= (),@/)*

.

=') ++,2 =2)

.= )2(     ;/;;;-I +

 )* =+ (/ (

=()   ,

)2(

5'

+*2

,.2

(.+

,)* 2(<2I I<2)*

., (.M M = * 2( )*  5 52<

) 2'

=3)

/ )*

. 

  =')

++'+'2 ,@

'.

 =3   6/;

/;;

;;-I +

 2(

<=' 

'4 2(5L=)

2'3 'D )< ,= 0 ;1 

(< <2 ? 4< I 3

()3 4@)*

.

=')?*2, ,@ @2(5=+( 3+, '.

;;9 :HI 

(()4 2. )4 =(L=)2 .'=(

2'

.

=')/)*=* <2(5+

'. 4 . ( ( +'+ ++'

)2(   3 '2 <2.

2,  ( '

'./

/

,,

'(2()

()

,/ = ,,)*

=(.)4 < 2. '2) (.)*=/.232 .232 .232 .232 . 0 1   (.2(5 ++,2

)2(/2 (@/* ,) (..2+ .  0 61  + +*) +@ )*2'.

'4 +,

.()* 2, ,,)*

 " # " # " # " #     +'2, +'2, +'2, +'2,; ////6;

6;

6;

6;6:

6:

6:

6: )2D     N* N* '+

D2(5-'

( .  ''

+')   - -