← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/706/2021dismissed

Sumit Kumar v. Punjab And Haryana High Court And Another

2022-05-16Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih,Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil7 pages



       

  !

"#$%& 



 

  

    $#  '$ ( )  ) $)  '$ ( )) $ 



  !""

#$%!&%!'( & )'

  ,!

%&%!'( & )' $*'

%

  ) $)&( $"

-' **+ %+.')



( &'%') $+ %"

#+%#% %/0 1/ 2121%"3""

$4"

* *)%5 

-* $5 ($++ #%'

#' $'%')%"* "

#4"

%"

"3*+"("

'%"

(('% (4"

+5 45%'

$)' $3"('

*' %5  %"("+#"  &/  +&" %& $)'& $"%'%(

 %%! '5 "%

$'+%$!5 #"!

'**'  '%) %$"3+)



")+ &  $  )(   ')  $  (    $  **++

 4 **'"

% '

"'

"!""'

&"'

20 21/7 (('%"

3 ')**'"

&$4'

*'5 )' *"'%') 4' 4$"($('+%5"

(%5 '

3'  "

*"'%')*'5 & $3($*"' '('3*+ 4' &*'

453"

%4"

$#% $4'8') $*  ")( ' 5

$"!"+%#9 "'"!""'

:&" "

+'

)"%

"+ *'

)' $ 21/7-/;4('%%<5+'4!#= "!"(4 %"* $'

20 21/;%"

*+>') $**'"

+

&$4*+(%'

)'*"'%') 4'  %*('

'

2') $"% **'"

+

& $3*+' ('+%5%"* $&"

( $4'8 4)' '5 ")( ' $+ ##')

'%4"3*+"("

"

 $4 #4$"($ 4'+%  "

%"(    "

 4   "(  '  ( #  *"'

  4$"($  3 %!+  ))( $  )   *'*(   ')  $  **++

  "

( 

 ')  $  !"(  ')  $  **++

 4    *  $  3  ') **'"

%"

$*'5 *"'%& #3'4?"% '5

"#"

$"

'% **+4*)% 5)'  $  %3"

"  "!  %#  ')  $  "'

  "!""'

&  4$"($  4 %("%%  '

 10 21/>  9

@  -7:  ,( #  $  3    "

 4 ('

(+%% $'%4 * "!5 43+ 5%*'

3

')$""

5"+"

)' $*' &'

4$"($$4**'"

('

 $'

 4)' $'!++3

$4'8

 ")( ' %"

$*"'%')

*

(('%"

#+ &$"!"(4%"*

" $'%')

+' -((*

(')

$**+&4$"($4($++ #%5)' $+ %"

#+%#5 4 ') 4"

* 5 

4$"($4"

* $+'5 %"3"% $'+%"

$"

$'%')

4"

*"'%')*'5 '

$5"') %"

(('% (4"

3') **'"

5"

#5%*'

 ")( ' 4'8 &(

5 $+% '5"

$* "!' "( $4 '++# #"

4$"($4'+%(++)'  ?" '$'4( "( '5 !%*'

$"3*"' '*'(%"

'* '%')

 %(' +)'

('

% $# ")'

"#3 )'3 $)(

%"* "

#4"

" 3+ 5%'

4'8

5 ""

)+ (%5  %'

$5"')

$'*"

$"!"+%#9 "'"!""'

:&" $"

%* %

3"

%  $   5  **+"%  5  $  " "(  %#  %&  $)'&  "3*# %'%(



;

$ * &"

$5  %5  $+ %(' +)' **++

$#5') $'%')%"* "

#4"

**++

&* +( $5 8 #"

%& $)'&

$"3*# %'%5"

# "((

5 $'

$'+%+") $!"+ %)"

%'  $5$"

%"

 $& $&5

3%)'

#"% $"3*# %'%')

*%5  " "( %#+' $**++  $'"

$+ %"

#+%#

B  $!  ('

"%%  $  53""'

  3%  5  $  + (' +)' $* "5 %' )"

%'+! '5*%% '((*

+

$('

') $+ %(' +)' $**++

>

$

'%% %20 21/;9

@ -6:% )'++'4 - < 

!"(')$"3"

3& '

$' ')

 & "!"+ %# 9 "' "!""'

:& "& $5 %"* $&4"

$"33%"

))( &%"

$*"'%')

++('

( %5"

)'3%(('%"

#+ =

'

#$('3'

('%4$"($4'+%"

%"(  '%')

&('%%5'!&" '%"3*+"("

') %"* "

# 4"

$  $!"( ')

 %"

#  $ *"'%  ') $"

 "  "("

 ++ '%'"

)+( ($ *(

  D $&  "

 "   %3"

%  *'"

$  **++

 4  '

)'*"'%') 4' 4$"($4@ %5+5 '

  "

( $4**'"

%'

/C 21/7 '

"'

"!""'

&"& '%')

% %20 21/;$5 *%%"

$*"'%')

/1

$ 3 ')**'"

48 '4 **++

('

! %(++ 5  $**'"

+

% %/C 21/7 9

@ -/:

&4$'&"

* ( $ '&$%,'"

!"('

20 21/7 $+!

3 )' $**' ') $*

(4'+%59/:&92: %9>:&4$"($%)'++'4 - </

$ $"**'"

"*+ '

3*' 5" '!"(( 5

"34"

$' "#

'

4$ '!&4"

$' *"' "(

, $  '**'"

%'

$('

')!"( 4"++  5  #+ %  5  $     5'%"

  '

5+"$3

9 ("

E +'

')!"(:

+&  /CCA&  %     "!"+  !"(  +  #+ &3 %%)'3 "3 "3

@@@ @@@ @@@ @@@ @@@ > $  '**'"

$++5'

*'5 )'*"'% ') 4' &4$"($( 5"

(% = *+') $5'!4'+%38"

3*+ (+ **'"

4*+ '

3*' 5" %$"!"( ('+%5

"34"

$' "# '

4$ '!& 4"

$' *"' "( "*"'%')*'5 4' 4$"($('+%5 (% %**'"

%'

$('

')!"(4#+ 5  $ 5'%"

'  5+"$3

9 ("

E + '

')!"(: +&/CCA9$"

) )% 'F/CCA +F:&

% "!"+!"( + % #+ &3 %%)'3 "3

"3 //

+>') $/CCA +%+4"

$*'5 ')*'

**'"

$!"(4$"($%)'++'4 - <

'5 ')*'

**'"

'!"( 9/:

'

**'"

*' $!"($++3"

*'5 )'*"'%') 4' ')("

%5 %"(

**'"

%'

 "

$(')*'3'

&*'!"%%

- 9:

"'%  *

 '

 %*

 '

   ('*'

#  '  $"#$*' $++('

'4%

 95:

$(') **'"

5   ) *"'%') 4'8'

?"!+

'$"#$ 8*"'% '**'"

$!"(3 "

$%"( $**'"

# $'"

5 ++'4% '('

'4%

9(:

  *"'%  ') '))"("

# **'"

'  $!"( $++5(8'

%*"'%*

'

*'5

92:

)&"

$'*"

$**'"

# $'"

& $4'8

% ('

') 335')!"(%"

#  $*"'% ') "  ")( ' "

3 - )($*'

"("

%5 %"( **'"

%"* 4"

$"!"(&'! $"3 '*' '

4$"($$$+%+" *"'

'$"**'"

= *+') $5'!4'+%) $+! '3

')%'5

4'

*'5 ++ $'#$%"

$*"'%')$" !"( %& $)'&$"!"(('+%5%"* $%"

$"% *"'% /2

$  

+  '

)"%

"+  *'  ') $ **++

$  5

)' '5<5+'4!#=)' $  #21/7  $"33%"

'))"(&4"

$4$'3

($%&$)' $4'8 ('

'5  ")( '  %& $)'& $%(""'

')

$**'"

# $'"

'%"* 4"

(('% (4"

3   ')**'"

&4$"($ ""

('

'

(4"

$

 '  +&(

5"% '5"++#+'

(('% (4"

$+4

/6

D $& #$('3'

('%4$"($4'+%)+(

$'%$5 *%)'+ "'3'

"!'('

"% '

$

 4$ $5 3

%5'!  $" #4$"($4'+%"

%"(

4  "(&*!'"

3

&( *"'

4$"($4'+%%!+ ))( $) **'"

*'*(  ')

/0

"

+%*'*'"

')+4 %"

$*"'%') & ' ?" "?"% '5$+% + $"3"('

"5 $3*+'   (&"

$*

(& $" '($

(4$"($4'+%"

%"(  $3 $5 #%5  (' +)'

/7

$+"#$ $5'!&)"

'3"

$*

**+&

$3

%%"3"%

 -  ) $).

    -) $ .

   $%& *, B$ $*8"

#G'

G'

B$ $ *' 5+ G'