Surjit Singh & ORS. v. State Of Punjab





    
      



 ! "#$%&&$'

!!!""##

$  

%& !!! "



  

$%( #

!!!%  $  

%&



!!! "



 )#  *+) & ,
& &,&)  *+) & ,
&,&) % 

'

(!$ ) *  + ,

(!."

 * + ,

""##

 & !"

 # !)!* %&!

(!/!!)##*  + ,

(!!0!

 .* + ,

1, ."#

!

&,&)-& $

 .

 "

   #

"#

&

* -

 +,

#   4 56

,  ,   1  7%
+  .

 8!!

+



.



,

## - '

.

/!

0,

"

10

 7%


." .

#

"3

 !*1 ,

#





." .

"

3 ,

"#

&

 1 7%


." .

#

"3

 !*1 ,

#





." .

"

3 ,

"#

&

 7%


." .

"

3 , ##

&  + ,



 , #3!

,, , +,

 ""##

      "3

""# ,,"

*

."   .

+,



,

 

,:



. 

.!

;

 ."#

#

&



 $%( ,+

,.

,

"3.

.



<

,  ."  !  #3  *

,

3

. 

#

-

.

+# / " #* 4

% #,  4 

&

4 -



4

6  

+##

.  



" #!

= ,"

. * #, " # 71/=  

,
+# / " #* 4 *

,.

,

."#

#

6 .

4

6  

+##

.*

 3 *

.

>?!%/ , 

7+

=

, 

3 !!

!@!

*

4 .# 0 (

<#

4  

+##



#

,

.6 5.

,6A

+

,

4 .# 0

.   (



. 

,

A



,

 ""

# ##

+##

.

.

8' "!.!*

4 -



4  

+##

.* # ,#

."#

+

,

 6.

,

A

4 -

# +

, "###

/&

%

##



-3#

.

*

.

 ?*

.

 ?* "#

.


,#&* ##

) &

4  

+##

. -##

 &

.



"

-"

!



4 -

"6

*

+ &#



4 -

## -A

+ &#

 ?

4 -

A

."#

,

  B

6##

6##BA

).#

3-

 

#.*

-+*

"#

&

,  

4 -

* 6#*

& .

 ", + -"

 A

#.

&

  ."#

"  *



*

 #

#

 ", + -"

, 

 

4 -

, ."#   +3,

"

+##

&

4 -

+# / " #* 4 A

,

+# / " #* 4 * 4 -

 ?.

*

  *



"

< A

# &

6

"

<  .&#, 4 -

&

#

+

,

 " 

#

."#

+##

.!

=

-3*

,#+

# 

#

,, *

 . #

 3 "

,  ,

&, 

,#

# !

 3 "



,

&  , - 4 -



:

 . #

,#+

+

&& #3

,

!

=



+,

,

..

 .

4 -

.

>?!%/ 

."#

%&!

/ 

71/=  

""

  .

>?!%/1 &#

.

& +

, " &#  ,    7%
 ,# *

:

#,

&# )

& 

.# 57 >?!%/1 ,  7 6 +

71/=  

<
)

%=

"

"#,

,,,

+##

.

 

6"

, / ,

:

,



 3

4 -

""

"

>?!%)!

 3  

.

#

4 6

.

,   , 8
!%!
!

7+

=

,

 3

)!)!!

(,#
## 56

""

.

?. +

""#, >?!%5

!

7

.- #*
&# )



"3

57*

,

:

"

7+

=

, , 

.

  !

&# )

.

,, * .#3*

.

+# / "

6"*

*

#, " ,

+# / " #*

6"* (<

##,

% #, 
 3*

6"!

7+

=

,



, ,



, 

.

.

% #, 

&# )

7+

=

, ,

@ +##

. ""

"#

"#,

,,, >?!%D

" ,

4 .# 0 ).#

7+

=

, 

 ", #

&#

 , &* "

.

* ""

",#

#

+

BB

",#

6

+ ..

>?!%E!

7+

=

, #

&#

   ",

,#



"#,

,,, +

.

",#* #

+

."  BB!

/ 7=

#

)F) 7

"#,

,,,

 ,#

+ ..

>?!%G!

/

H

&

 I !
/ 

+ ..

>?!%!

#, "  -

+# / " #*

6"!

7

.- #*

&  , 

*

*

 !

#, "  -

+##

.

,, !

)+

%;

" 

7+

=

,

,, * .#3*

7+

=

, 

+ ..

>?!% , 3 ,.





" # ,

""!

#, " 

% #,  4 * 7 I.#

,

7+

=

, "3

.

"

&  &#

, *

6

+ ..

>?!%!

, " "

(/
"

,6"!

= !@!



,

7##: ( 

.

#, ,

3!

= !@!





!





*

  ,#

.

>?!%(

6"

,#
 

,







 6- ,, 

.

#

.

, +

., !

.##3*

&



  ,#

.

>?!%I

6"

,#
 ?

&.&

,6 

,



,

6 -#

#3

#

.

, +!

,, 





.

.

 ,

>+, ,

6"

,#
 

 &

?

  #

 *

,

6 -#

#

.

, +!

5

##*





&#

, +!

7+

=

, ""

>?!%J!

+

",# #

7+

=

,

+

 ,"

BB

6

+ ..

>?!%!

,.



# #, ,

3 #

#, "

"#,

,#.

. #

, +




&#

!

+

",# #

7+

=

,

+

 ,"

BB

6

+ ..

>?!%9!

 

*

# #, ,

3 #

#, "

"#,

,#.

, +




&#

!

7+

=

, ""

>?!%F!

+

",# #

7+

=

,

+

 ,"

BB

6

+ ..

>?!%$!

= !@!

* "#

&

,

7+

=

,  

.##3 

, 

!





* "#

, +

&

, + 

  *  ", +#3!

&#


. 
+

# ",#

6

#, !

= 

#,

*

7+

=

,

#, ,6"

"

, "

(/
!



+ *

7+

=

,

"" ,# "#

"#,

, / H 

+ ..

>?!%<<!

-"

&

, +

""

 ? >?!%*
 >?!%*

>?!%*
 >?!%* .

>?!%@* 
>?!%8*

- >?!%*  >?!%* , & >?!% 

""

"!



."#

+

.#  * ## 

""

#

4,# ( 

# * 56

= " 

##

4,#

 ( 

# * 56

""# "

,.

# "

##

+  ,

8
!%!
!



,  ,  7%
?,# +#3

&#

   * # 4,# ( 

# * 56

+

  !8!

 ..

,

#   4 56

= ,"

, * #   4 56

& +



,  ,  7%


 ,  

,  7%


"#

&



,  ,  7%
 ,# 

##

,, *

 

,,  #3*

"#

# ,#.

#!

,

?

+,

, !



+,*

, ?. .3

-#+ " # &# -'

%; !/6.

)  (,# =

,*
+# / " #* 4 "

!@!



' "!.!*

: -

.  >?!%

% #,  4 

+#

 4 -



 3 *  

+##

.

+# / " #* 4  

.,

 !

,, 

 *

+





  ?"#

# +

*

.

.. #3

< !

/

. 3

#, !

/ +

" ,"

#"

>?!% !

 %;

&# #6

!@!

*

% #,  4 !

,

""

.#  *

 +,

+

>?!%

:

 "

+,!

%; !4!!

##* (!!

%

/

 , (, * 

(,

< + * ) +.

%&* )!)!!

(,#
## 56

 !@!



' !.!*

,

.

?.

 3

4 -



4

6  3 .#*  

+##

.*

&

7 I.#

%/) % "

% #,  4 !

 3   #

4 6

+##

.!

#

 3 @

 ,

 3

-## &#

-##  .# -

"3.

- 6,

!

##

,#

&#

!



" 

3

.



" 

&,6!

(

#

#3

"

,# !

## -

 " 

 3'

!  ,   8! ,.

?

,.

" 







+ .# 

3&

"- * #3

,#"

& .

, ,#

&#

" 

!

!  ,    ,.

?

! ,.*

H ##3 "#, " 





!

 ,. !

+ 

  ,.

  



 #*

#3

,

,#

&#

" 

!

! 

&#: ,    ,.

?

! ,.

" 







.#

&,6- # ##3!

 ,. !

  

 # "!

! 

 + ,    ,.

?

! ,.

" 

.#

*  ,. !

  

 #* #3

& .

, ,#

&#

"  ! 

  ,.

?

! ,.

" 

.#

6!

"

 ,. !

# #

#* ,#

&#

" 

!

@! 

  ,.

?

! ,.

" 

 ,. !

&# 

" #!

"* ,#

&#

" 

  "



" 

"3.!

8! 

H

 ! ,.

?

! ,.

" 



+

# # .## # * #3

,  ,#

&#

" 

!

!  ,    ,.

?

! ,.

" 

# # "

"

 ,. !

 

3 I=!8* ,#

&#

" 

!

!  ,    ,. !

?

! ,. !

" 

 .#



  #3!

 ,. !

&# 



" #*  "



" 

"3. #3

&

,

#

&#

" 

!

!

 ! ,. !

?

 ,.

" 

#*  "



" 

. ,# "

 ,.

+   ?##3 "?* ,#

&#

" 

!

!

##

&

&#,6  ! 

  ,. !

?

! ,.

" 

   ",



 ,. !

+

"" 



" #!

! 

   ,.

?

 ,.

" 

  # #  ",

#

.#!

! 

   ,. !

?

 ,.

" 

"

"" "

& .

!

 ,. !

&#

""#

H ##3 "#,!

!

&#: 

  @ ,. !

?

,. !

" 



# ##3!

,. !

3 I !!

@!

  ,.

?

! ,.

?

. ,# "

" 



# !

 ,. !

   " #, "!

#

&#

 " 

  "



" 

"3. - 6,

!



.,

."

3!

.##

##

3.

#

##

,# .

  !

F3 &# ."

3!

/ 

" *

,





 ##

  .



,

, 

3

 !

+ &&#

.

#"  -

 

-



.



 !

/ + "3

.

"

>?!%>* ",

#  .

-

 >?!%>1 #, :

 ?. >?!%5!

/

&#

, 

.

"3. >?!%*

>?!%  - >?!%

&#

   "



+

.

",#

.



+

#,

,# !

%; /
4



% #,  4

 !@!



!@!

*

.#

 +,

+

>?!%4!

%; /
I.#

!@!



% #,  4

7 6 +



+

",# "

,

 ' !.!



6

4(7
17##: (  56



 !@!



' !.!*  ",# "



+

#,

,

.

#

!

 %;@

"

% -

!@!

 #

,

+ 

"" ,#  "# >?!%0

,

).#

4 .# 0 %;

 

,#  ,

K  6. !

%;8 7  

, +

, " #3 "

!

%; #

."#

%; (

+

3- ,, 

""

,

3

. #  ",

%; 7 I.#

.#

 +,

+

>?!%< "3

.

 "

. %;  !)+

)

@ 3 * ,#   

+##

.

>? (.& %,33

+##

.* &  &

% 

< ,# )- %& 6
..

 L 3 &,6

.

, 

!!

 

,.

.A

##

 ,#

"#

&

..

.

4 -

#, ,

,

#,A

.##3

.

"#

&

..

.

4 -

>?",

,

#,!

,, 

 *

# ,

# :

 .

#,

. " 

 *



  :

#,

,

7  

 !

"



&



" ,



 ,#

.

, +
*
* 


,  ", +#3*

&

6

!

%;

7  

,

+

,

. ?

"

 +

+ ,. #  # %&#, % ,

 +, 5< "

>?!%(( >?!%II ,#

, +,!

 .

,   , 
!%!
!*

##

,.

,,.

, ""



,

"

&



## 

 ,

&

# #3 + #+

, !

5

* 

"#

."#, *

"

"#

&



,

-

/&

).#

&

#"" ,  4 -

3 #* :#

,#+

6 "#, -

.A

4 -

#

+ ,.

,6

, 

.

@  A



"+

,

, 

.

&#

#

4 -

##

-3!

,, 

"#

6

5

*

"

"#

&

# #3 ."#,

,

.3

" 

,



"+

,

&

.# ..&

.#3

,,  "#

&

"#

6



,* ?.

  !

; !(

4- "

!@!

*

>. ,3 
+# / " #*

6"A

3*

., # ##3 ?.

) &

 

+##

.

' "!.!

, 

## -



" '

! <,  ,#"

! ,.

?

! ,.

" 

 ,. !

#

 #3 .# ,.

!

5

&#

"  D3

,#"

+ !

! -##

 ,. !

?

 ,.

" 

 .



# 

+



,"# !

+  ?3



!

! -##

 ,. !

?

 ,.

" 

# #  ",



 ,. !

+ # # .## # !

+ 

8 ?3!

7 I !

 6"



& +

-"

  ,# &#

##

 !



+

"

' "!.!

&

&

"#

) &

&&# 



?

 !

)

*

"

?3 ?.

 ,



,"

"

,#  I !

."# 3 I !

+  !

/

?3 "

?3

#.

/= ,!

/ + ?3

#.

>?!

* ? 3 "

>?! * (<

 >?! ",

#  .

-

 >?!1!

;

#"

, +* 

. "

+  +##

. "" ,# "# >?!

0#-

0  

,#

 ,

K  6. !

; 4

7 ",

) 7* =

""# * 4

&

..

 ,  " 

+##

.

 #

.

 ,

 ,

 ,

) &

 

3 I !*  ,

&

"#



3 I ! 

"#

) &



I ! *

) &



# I=!!

/ +

"

.

>?!

>?!

"

 #  ,  

>?!

>?!!

 ; 4 

% * 7 ",

*

" + " . ,# % .* # 4

&

..

 ,  "

.

"#



# I ! !!

,, 

.&*  ,, 

.&

* )+



 !

/

&

 # &

"

>?!

>?! +

" &

>?!

>?!8!

;

, +,

,#!





 . #

#

+, ,

.  "*

+

+

#

" 

""#!

;

+

 #  #

""## ,,  +, #  #

."#

""## #  # + ,

)#



%& -## #  # " 

1, ."#

& 

, !



 + #+.

"#

,

,*



# #3

&

.

 .,

,

#

+,

+,



.

?.

%; #

%; (

" ,

 # &&# ,, 

+

: ,

""##

#,!

;

 3 .

 .

  #  #

""##

,   * #

, 

" ,

&

#







+

&#

 ,#

,

#,!

;

 #

,

 !

#

%; (

%; &#

+##

.*

,

6 "#,!

""

,# +

 !

.

,

4 .# 0*

."#

#

#

!@!



8' "!.!

,



 #!

"

3- ,

 #&#

,   !

 

+

.3 "

 -"

 #

4 -

."#

&

,, ."

4 .# 0 .

+

.6

 

  * #

4 .# 0 (

,

" + .

.

+

6

 6

+

:# 

 6

&

.  #

, 

. #+ ,3

3 -"

 !

 

,

&#

 ,#

7+

=

,* ,

,#

&#

*

,, 

6

, ,

,#

7+

=

,!

5

.

*

&

# +

, *

#

+ &



+

 

"  "

 &#



 

&

"  &#3 



."

#

, # ,#"

+ #+

 ,

"

"#,

3 3.

  !

*

: .6

+

,&#

"



+  -

=  .

+, #  #

""##

."#

"

!

+

,

."#

"  .,

3 #

&  , - , 

+

,6 4 -

 *



 .

+

3

,!

+

#



.

,.#

+3 

,#



 .

+3

,.

 ..

3 ""

 &#

+!

/



, ## +

, *

+

"

,6 4 -

 

&,

+  . #

,#+

&3

,

" 

, 

#

+

, 

",6 "

:#

,, !

>+

- *

,

+,

,

+#&#*

+ "#

   ,,*

*

 .

#  #

""##

,

3 ,!

"

"#

 ,

"

 + 



,

 *

-

/&

).#

#"" ,  4 -

3 #* :#

"#, -

.!

4 -

+* ,.

,6

, 

.

 *



 "+

,

, 

.

&#

#

4 -

##

-3!

 + 



&&# "# &#!

7

+ 

+

3



&

.

3 -"

!

" 3*

#

+

.!

5

-"

&#



7+

=

,!

*

:

.

&

6

!

  



"

 " ,#  !

#

"

; !(

4-*

,"

?3 "

,#  I !

."# 3 I !

+  * ,

3 &



+ "

3!

7

, ?. *

3 I ! #  #

##

 ,  I  

+ "

3!

/

.6

+ #, + &#

 I  &# #

#

 I 

"

#  

!

*

,







, !

6

"#

 ,*

.

,

" ,"

!

  ,  +*

+

#

.6

,

?,



 ,*

?

, 



, !



,

6 "#,

.

,

""

3

."

""



 

,

#

#

, 

3 

"+

, +#&#

.*

+ & &#

&#

 +  !



+ *

"#

 +

+

  ,#

.

#

, +3

*
 

,!

,

?. %; )+

%; 7  

!

-"





. &#

" "

5< >?!%(( >?!%II*

&  

, 

",

,.

+, 

.

.

%; )+

>?(.& %, 3

% 

< ,# )- %& 6
..

+##

.

&# !

/

+

@ 3 *

.

##3  ", &# "

+##

# "

,

+

. #+

#,

 . ,, 

.

.

+

..

.

4 -

;

3 

 &#+

.

!

 * ?

 ,#

,

, !

=



.

?. .3 @ 

& +

3

,  "

.

%; !4!!

##!

,

.&

 ,#

,   *

 *  



"

&#

-"

 

 #

.&

 #

:

&  #!

+

, ""

+ & ,

 ." # .!



##

7+

=

,

+ &#3 ,#

-

."#

" 

,, !

"#,

,

? ,

&#

 , & ##,

7+

=

,

5< " "

.  " , &





. &#

!

*



&

,

6 "#,

" ,

,

3

"#,!

57

,

& :

."

#3!

7

-3*



,

, 

"#

+ ,# +#3

. +#3* 

 + #+.

&

,



&#

##3

, !

 " #

57

.

3-

", 3

&

&

.!

 "

,

3

57 &

.



, +3

-

.


!


  ,#

#3 



3"!

&

-

+

 3

.

 ,

>+, ,

-"

, +

!

 .

,



+ , +

&

"

, +3 ..

>?!%//*

& ,

#, "#

&



&

-

+ & , +

"#

&

*  , +3

3 -"

&

,

&

. 

" ,"

, ;



  +-

,

& &#

&#





&

&3 

 &# &

+, , ,

!

 .

#

?

&#!

* +-

#  ,  +* "

#

+, ,

,  , 

7%
*  +, ,

##

+,

,  ,  7%
*

 

"#

 ,  

,  7%

 * 

 +,

,  ,  

,  7%
,

..

..

.

4 -

,##3

&#

, !

,

"#

 ,  

,  7%
#

.

 ,  

,  7%
!!





." .

#

"3

 !*1 ,

#

"3.





." .

3!

+, ,

&

##

,

 

,:



. 

.!

7

-3 ""#

# ""##

+,

&

## - 

""##

+,



"#

 . 

 ,

+!

""##

+,

&

&#!





.

  ,  !

""##

+,

"#



&#



#  "

,!

&#  ,,##!

4,# (  56

,

  

-



.6



.

,!




 I !

#

."#  

##

,

,,.

, +,

#*

 3 

,

,

." .

  3 ,

"3 .



<

,  ."  !

+   .  ,,  #3!

  2& &,&)3 2&,&)3 $%&&$'

    0 4 ;

"6 1  '

E 1I

;

"

&# '

E 1I