High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/9886/2023disposed of

Kush Prashar v. State Of Punjab And Others

2023-04-13Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja3 pages

!"#$"%&'&#()* * +,'-. '- . /"!&!&#(". 0".',' 1! !"#$,(2 3 (4#!-".' *** "'5#(4"(!'

) 67 * 1 +1 ."'"(!) '*7#89""( (4 :48#% !":$#.!-"5"!&!&#(".* .*0*+*,5! ::,(2 3* .**1*1 9 ( :48#% !":$#.."'5#(4"(!'#*;* <<<< +1 :*

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

, '-&(@#$ '>"99 ' #!-".',3'"?,"(!5.#%""4&(@' .&'&(@#,!#$!-"' B" @ &('!!-"5"!&!&#(".:!-" 4&'5,!" 3"&(@ 5,."9= 5".'#( 9 &( ( !,.": !-"." 4#"' (#! 55" . !# 3" (= &B5"4&B"(! ' ."@ .4' ?, '-&(@ #$ 5."'"(! * " $,.!-". ',3B&!' !- ! &( #.4".!#B &(! &(5" %" (4- .B#(=3"!>""(!-"5 .!&"':5 .!&%,9 .9=,(4". !-" %&.%,B'! (%"' >-"."&( !-" 99"@"4 #$$"(%"' - 8" (# '#%&"! 9 &(!""'! &(8#98"4: &! >#,94 3" 55.#5.& !" !# ."(4". %#B59"!" ?,&"!,' !# !-" $#."B"(!&#("4 4&'5,!" 3= ?, '-&(@ !-" #( !-" 3 '&' #$ %#B5.#B&'" "(!""4&(!#3"!>""(!-"5 .!

( !-" #!-". - (4 9" .("4 1! !" %#,('"9 ',3B&!' !- ! 4," !# ("@9&@"(! 5 .C&(@ #$ !-" !.,%C #$ !-" 5"!&!&#(".: %#B59 &( (! ."%"&8"4 (4 ',$$"."4@.&"8#,'&(2,.&"'*

8&(@-" .49" .("4%#,('"9$#.!-"5 .!&"':!-"=- 8&(@'"!!9"4 !-"&.4&'5,!" '# '!# 9&8"5" %"$,99= &($,!,.":(#,'"$,95,.5#'" >#,943" '".8"43=5.#%""4&(@$,.!-".>&!-!-"%.&B&( 95.#%""4&(@'*(!-"9&@-!#$ 3#8"4"8"9#5B"(!':(#% ,'"."B &('$#.!-"!.& 9 #,.!!#&(8"'!$,.!-".!&B" (4"$$#.!&( 42,4&% !&(@!-&' *-"%#B5.#B&'"&(?,"'!&#(&'$#,(4!#3"

$,99=&(%#('#( (%">&!-!-"4&."%!&#(&'',"43=!-" #,.!&(

! " #$ %

& '

# ( !

! $( * -,'&(8&">#$!-" $#."' &4."5#.!: %%#B5 (&"43='! !"B"(!' #$ 3#!- !-" 5 .!&"' ' >"99 ' C""5&(@ &( B&(4 !-" 9 > 9 &4 4#>( &( !-" $#."B"(!&#("4 2,4@B"(!: !-" &('! (%" 5"!&!&#( &' 99#>"4 (4 #* 4 !"4 ** : ."@&'!"."4 ,(4". 1"%!&#(' : : 44"4 9 !".#( !#9&%"1! !&#( (,.:&'!.&%! !& 9 (("A,." '>"99 ' 99!-"',3'"?,"(!5.#%""4&(@' .&'&(@!-"."$.#B ."-"."3=?, '-"4*

-" $#."' &4#.4".'- 99-#>"8".:3"',32"%!!#5 =B"(!%#'!'#$

'*E:

D !# 3" 4"5#'&!"4 >&!- !-" ,(2 3 (4 .= ( &@- #,.! ''#%& !&#(7 >=".F' B&9=G"9$ ." ,(4- 8&(@%%#,(!#*E

>&!-1! !" (C#$(4& :&@- #,.!. (%-: - (4&@ .-:>&!-&( 5".&#4#$ !>#>""C'$.#B!#4 =* +1 * * (&9 G-"!-".'5" C&(@D." '#("4 ) "'D# G-"!-".."5#.! 39" ) "'D#