Kumari Neelam And ANR. v. State Of Haryana
!"#
#$%&% '(
)*) +
( , - )
. / . -- , - )
. ).).01
!
""
#
$$$ ).).012
)
3!4 % &
'
'
'
"'("' )*)+,))-.
/ "
0"' 1 3 . .
" -),4/
" ' 5 )))67 '
" " , 349:!
'
'
.
9:/.; <0
#/ & '
.=- # >'
# 8 9:/ . ; <0 '
'9:/6%9:/6,
. " . 7
!"#$ %&
'
!
( ! ( !& !)* +
!& !) ! !$!(! ,( - ../
'$0 (,!* +
'
$ ("(&!0! * +
1 !& 2!2 #!% !
2!2 # +! "!% 3(!& ! +,&& 4(5 !(4 4 !,,
"! ! !,2 !,5 6","(6 ,( ! &"2
6 4!5 (4 (65
( " "2!2 ( 4!!+(
'
( ( " ( ! " 3( ! (* +
7 ( "!
!4!( "
3( !
'
( (!5 !&*
+
&!0! (, ,!( ,
0
896# % , ! !!& :
:::
:;
$ &!
!,5444!,!
4
$ ;
& 2!<&!
2!<&!
7= =! 7 = =! !
:
:
:::
:
:
:::
9 !&+6 ;
>!!&!
&!0!!!4!, !
$
!" !
! ! >& $ 4!!"(,!!9 +6 & ! ; ! ? , >& $ 4! ! ( +6 !&;
>!!&! ;7 7= =!!44 4(, +6 ! 7 "
&!& !>( 78 ;
- :::.
:::&!& ! !, !
, @A "( ,!! + 4 78!!
+ ( !, B ?./+:@?6; 6 ! (55!
"!& ;!,! !" (& ; !8 ? &!
! ,
6+6!
"!&"(
!0 !&! 4,!4!
"!& ,, !, (& 4,! " &!
! , ! (" "!!
# >&$ 4!!% 2+6 ;
!" C :
::: -;
7C
- &
&. "
"'
& '
#/ 8
' ; <0 >
#/ )?)5%@@* " '
."
("
; <0 (' # '
" %+-/ / .
/ "
'
A
: "
..
/ "
/ "
0"'
3 . ' %-)?,)))
/ "
0"' 3 . "4!2 ,! "
-),4/'
. ' " ."
-),4/&
" '"
'
5 8 ".
' '
"
" %, 8 "
:=% (B .
; <0 "
"
)?)5%@@* ; <0
# / " % 5) )))67
'
'
"" ; <08 "
5) )))67 8 " * )))67
" . "
C ,*%%%@@@
D
. D
" "
".
C)@)%,)))
" ; <0
' " D
."
("
' " '
77 77 E"
'
D &.
D; <0"
" .
"
4 7:
' '
" 8 D
" 7
(' # )+-)=
8
3 .
. 8
('
#
' ' (' #
3 . %))%,)))
)@-) %))%,))) ? "
"
: =, / . # '
"
# >'
# :=-
; <0 %))%,)))
".
9:/ 9:/6%
F'
( B %-)%,))) "
E"
9: 4 7:
.
:
%,CG D1 2
' %,%5 D
' ' ; <0 D
.
.
/ 4 ' 'C 8 4 ' 'C .
. D
' '
*
; < 0 D
"'
"
"
"
"
'
"
-56A) "
D
' .
" "
8 ' "
' ; <0 + # / D (' #
: =A "
:
. ; <0 %-)%,)))
D
. *)H"
."
'
.
D
.
'
."
.
. * "
"
: =5 4
( '
34 9:! D 9:!6%4 / : =?
)@)%,)))1 '
)@)%,))%2
4
(' B E"
5 ("
; <0
'
8 %))%,)))
C
'
9:B6%
' 8
=- # >'
#
; <09:/
)@)%,)))1 '
)@)%,))%2 '
."
# .
; <0 " . @ "
"
:! # =+
.
,,%%%@@@ =*4#"
" %+-/ / =@ D!"
#
4# & "8 "
"
: =%)4# & " )@)%,))) C3 .
'
' (' #
; <0
."
"
" "
C %))%,))) (' #
/ . B =- # >'
# 4 / ('
9:/'
34
' ; < 0 : %-)%,))) "
'
4
7:
. "
)%-)
. "
%,-) %))%,)))
%))) ' . ." %) "
"
: =%% # ( "
' ':; <0 (' # 8 .
"'
.#/
'
."
("
"
!'
' C:
' " %,)
"
.
" +?H."
'B9: 9:B
' '
; < 0 9:B6% . # "(0
' "
# "(0
D '
4 7:
D
: "
9:/6% %% "
"
: '
F#/ (' # =%, .
"'
" (' #
9:B6, %))%,))) ' '
; < 0 D 8 ' "
"
# D0 '
%))5,))) . "
D
G '''
'' "
C
# D0 "
4/F
7:
D "
"
. D'
8
.
' %, '
"
' "
.
" -%-/ / .
/ "
%
; <0 "'
D'
&. ,
.
8
"
%- 8
: #=% # D " :; <0"
C 3 . )@)%,))) .
"'
. ".#/ . "
?)H."
. .
"'
. )@))%)))
'
(' # "
:#=,#/ ". ; < 0
; < 0 )?)5%@@*
'
D' " )@)%,))) '
= "
D
:
'"
D
"
' 8 "
D )@-) '
8 9:#& %A "
:"D #=- '
. "
"
; <0 # / '
D' " " ("
"
"
; <0 .' D
.#/
'
&.
8 ""
:#=A( '
"
#=-"D 8 "
:#=5(!"
.
"'
' 6 3 3 .&. "
)*-) )@)%,)))
. "
%),5
' 9:#/ ' 9:##
9:#9 %5 B "
'"
.
"'"
"'
& '
.
8 "
''
.
" 5) )))67 3"
'
#/ ". ; < 0
"
' . "
' "
D . "
)@-) )@)%,))); <0 "
C 3 . :.# D " #=%8
(' # B "".
)@-) )@)%,))) %,)) %))%,)))
.
3 . #
; < 0 "
; <0 " *)H."
("
.
'
4
=-
# >'
#
; < 0. %,%5 %,-) %))%,)))=
D.=?4 / %,-)
%))%,)))
; <0 ' .
; < 0
"'
"
'
; <0
"B ""
".
# D 0 '
9:B6,
:.
"
9 =%,
'
D
# D0
'' "
# D 0 B ""
".
"
4
..
"
'
"
. " .
"
"
.
. E"
.
/ "
%? C
"
". . "
".
; <0 .=-=- #
>'
#
' '4
'
.
'
; <0 "
"'
"
+
' "
=?
4 / .
'
("
D D'
.=- #
>'
# "
" :#=,#/
.
"
#=- "D #=A( '
'
. "
. .. .
/ "
#=5(!"
. '
. .
/ "
%+ = "
"
/ "
" %* G." / "
! ""#$%&''$
&%()* ""# + '$, ,& %)%!
"
'
. ' " 7 .
+ !&2,! "!& 4 !! ! (!!4 , ,,( "
,
2E!!!
!
!"!0!, E,4!& ( &! !
!"!!
9 !
!"!! !
(4!,!4 ,
!
9
54! !&,! 04(( ! &( ! !&! !"!! !4
( "!&! , ,(!!
0,!,( ,
-.
/ 0 ,1 2! #34#$#& 5 )4#6 !4 !"!! !&,! !
!!&!0"
( !
,! , ! ! !,4" 5!& 4! ! !& ,! 4(4 0 " , 9 ""! &!
6!
& "( ! ! 0!,! , ,,(, !,
0, 6 ( ! ,4,! 5 , !4! ( ! &0 (" , ! !4
!, 5 ( ! "
, ,"0!,!&
(,,
,! ( ,! 67 8 9 / 0'
!+ '#3(4, ,()3
! (& ( !! !
!4""! 5 !&,!
"5 5 9!
( ! (4!& !!&
! (& !&2,!"
! ! ( !,! ( !!& ,0!,!,& ( 6:
;
, / 0<!+ '#3) , , #"
# !& ,! ( " ,(4 4,! !, "
,, "!&"( , ,!(
,( 0 , 6 9 / 0,1 2!+ '#3)%, ,((=
!
( (, ,(4
!"
0"!4 !!5 5! !!&!"
! !&,! ,("! 4(4 " E,( , !! 6 <
/ 0,1 2!+ '#3)#, , #(4# !& ,! , "
60 !&!& !, 9!
(E,( , !! !( !0 !&!& !, & !&,! "
,
&"4 ! 4! 4
:
+ !& ,! 4!, !, !
!
!"!0!, 04,!, !& ,!"!&,"
!0 !&!& !,
" !
,(& !
( (& !0 !&!& !, 0!!& 0!, 7&!
,!& !&,!! ! 4
!"
E,4!!
, !
(,4,!( ,!! !0 E,4 "!&,"
!0 !&!& !,4!, !, ! !&,!
6 <,,'
/. 0< > !+ '#34?
, , #33! !
( "
0 2 F!0 !&!& !, ( ! !
(,,
!0 !&! 4,!, !0 !&!& !, ! ,!& !& ,!(!&,( !0 !&!(& ",(&F 9 !&,!, "
!0 !&!& !,!4 , ,
* ! ! ,
E,( , !! !(3(!
!! 0!, 7&!
,!& !& ,! E4! 69
/ ,1 2!+ '#343, ,##4%!
(
4! !&,!,"
!0 !&!& !,"!&!!0!,, ! 4 G"!" ,!& !&,! !>(4 G !"
! ,!! 0!" 6 !& ,! ! ( , (& ,( " >,&(! ,"
4!, !, , !,!!,,!! 4 ,("0!"!0!&, !&,! !&,! ( , !! !,! !,
"!(" (C %@ "
I." / "
> 0:
>
:
! "
#$%&''$
&(" "
#+ '$, ,&
%33 7 D?
0,(!
!"!! ,!"!! !&,!#<E ;-%! !" " !,!",( 0 , 0!! 0( !& ,!
( , ,0!,! " (4
!!
(& , !,!">(!
4(!,!"(!"
!
(
5 !
(">, , ,!( !& ,!
! !,, , , ! "! !, >(&
+ 6 '
/ 0:
!$ ""%& ?==%!!
(, ! !( 3( !
4,& "( ( !
!!0 , ,,!"!! !& ,!4""!! ! ,!& 6
!
( (!0 44!,!!!
&(, (4(4 ( "(4 " ,!4, "( ,(! !5 0 ,
6 / 0:
!$ ""%&### !!
(,!,,44 ,(!, " !&,! , "(@:
( /:4,"(
6 ! ("! !,(,,4!>(,( 5! !&,! 4 "( /.( "(!&&!0!&!(! !0! !, ( !>(!
9 ,( , ,! !,! "
, &!& 4
!, ,!! , 5 !& ,! 0
!
( 4! ! !,!,! ,! !& ,!,&0(" &(!
,( 9( 4!0 (& , ! , F4! , ,!( 5!&F! (,! !, ,"
! ( (, 4 ,(!
,!! 4! 5!& !& ,! (0!, , !0 !&!& !," ,( ! !! !404 ,(!, 6 :
/ 0<
!
$ ""?& #% #?(! ! !& ,!!
4!, ( 0!,( !5 0!, !
( !
! !
( ( ! !
"
( ,(4! ( !&(4 ,!
!! 2/ 0@,1 !$#33 & =4= ! !
( ( (4 0 40!(
>(& &0!& !& ,! ( ! 5H5!#(4%!II F#!%9!
!( 4(, !& ,! , " , (4 !( ,"! $ <,, '
/ 0 < -$#34?&%#"=6&* #!!%6 (!
!
! !&,!!
(0( !," ,0!,!! !( ,"! $ 0A/'
B / -$#3)(&#(( '
9/ / 07
-$#3)%&# ##6&* #!!!%9( ,(!!
!&,! , ( ( (,!!
( (!& 44!& !&!! 9 , 44(! "
0!!
! ! ! 5,!
$ : '
'> / ,2
, -$#34?&%?#)6&* #!0% !&,!!
( 4!,!( ! (
" , (4 !( ,"!0 0!, $ '
7/ 0<-$#34=&= ?=6&* #0% , (, ,!( ,( 0 5 !& ,! 0!, ! &!!
">, $:
/ <-#3)#, (6&* #0!% + !&,! !, ( ! !!
, " !
,0!,! $'
< / 0A-$#3)#& ?(=6&* #0!!% 7 ",( !& ,! ,!! ,,(,!!
" >, $ 0<
/: , C
,-#3)",=((6&* #0!!!%<3( ",( !!
"! !!
"!
, ,
! &( ( $, 1 / 07
-#3)",4?36&* #!E% ,(! !
, ! !,!!5 !& ,!5(4!,4!! ( !
!, ! ! , ,!( 5 !& ,! !,4!!,40! $C ,'
/ 0<-#3)),#( 6&* #E% 4 ,(! 0 ! ! 0 ! &!0 ! !& ,! ! ,!,",(4 $ 0A/ < <
-$#3)3&%%3"6&* #E!% ! ( !&,! ! !4! ! ( "4 ,( ! 4(! !&
,!,(""( !" ! ",,4 $<
@ @ / 0<
-$#3) ""6&D ,) . " .
/ "
'
' 9:/.; <0 "
".
'
.
4
"
D . "
)@-) )@)%,)))
. "
)@-)
"
C3 . ' : . #=% # D "
('
#
9:#
(' # )@)%,))) ': )@)%,))) .=%%# ( 4
B
'
."
="
". . " ' .
)@-) )@)%,))) %,)) %))%,)))
.
3 . # '
; <0 9 =% (B
. "
)+-)
)@)%,))) =? 4 / '
'
"
)@)%,))) =%)4# & " '
'
)@)%,)))
'
"
4
'
; <0 9 " *)H."
("
'
'
' "
"
"
".
" "
,% "
"
"
. "
' 9:/ ; <0 .=- # >'
#
. "
%,)) %))%,))) D
' '
; <0
D
'
%,%5 "
.
'. / 4 ' 'C .
. D
' '
; <0 D
"'
"
.'
-56A)"
D
' ' "
; <0
D
'
"
.
=?4 / 9:BD'
; < 0 ("
'
'
9:B6%
'
=- # >'
#
9:/3 "
9:B6%
9:B6, ' .
%,-) %))%,)))8 "
' " %,-)
D
%,-)
'
9:/ '.
=- # >'
#
"
'
'
"
:"
=%%# (
; < 0
D
6: "
9:/6%
=%, '
' '
9:B6, ' . # D0 "
4/F
"
+
9:B6-4 7: =%, '
D "
"
# D0 . D'
"
' 9:/ .
' "
# D0 8 "
.. " ".
'
.
'
,, "
' ; < 0 ". .3 '
'
'
77
77 / 4 .'
" 5) )))67 '. =%4
"
77 .. "
"
' 9:/
; <0
% "
D &. ,
D
. ; < 0 "
. =A # / D
D
. "
."
! ; <0 3B
3B
9:J D " " .
."
! .; <0
"
,- "
=% (B
.
; <0
)@)%,)))
" . "
5-)
' " D
."
("
' (' # )+-) )@)%,)))=
' ; <0
. "
%,-) %))%,)))
.
"
. .
.
(' #
'
)@)%,)))
D '
."
("
'
D
=%% # (
" : +?H."
. .
'
.'
'
.
.' " " 4"
. D
"
4
' %,-) %))%,)))
.
# D0
9:B6,
:.
"
"
:=%, '
' "
D
=- #
>'
#
"
'
'
."
"
:.
"
."
' .#=,#/ #=%# D
" "
C3 .
"
" ."
" :#=,#/
.
". ; <0
'
. '
8
.
"'
'
9:#& "
; < 0 '
)@)%,))) D'
" ,A ".
# / .
.'
.
. " .
/ "
"
7:
#=-"D
'
. "
; <0
* "'
D' "#/
'
D
&.
/ '
/
"
&
,5 #=A( '
%
/
"
"
#=5( !" "
' 6
3
3 . &. ,
D'
"
)*-) )@)%,)))
%),5
' 9:#/ ' 9:##
9:#9 8 "
.. " ".
'
"
,? 4
.
"
. ; <0
'" '
"
. " "
"
. = "
"
' .
/ "
"
"'("' .
/ "
,+ E"
"
. E"
'8 .. "
.
. '8
5 " E"
.
. ' 3 "
.
".
"
."
,* '
' ,@
.
" : '
-)
/ "
. . . D -% . 1 / . --
).).01 ,?)+,),A
=
D'6 ;6 =
. ;6