High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5306/2021allowed

M/S Silverline Chemicals v. Union Of India And ORS

2023-02-14Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri,Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra8 pages

!"#$#%&'&() * +',&-.#/-&(#0#1&%!-' #"&"&(#/ 3'

(&(($&!!($"0#/' #'4($#("'

/#'#(") /,56#'07&($!-8$.%!"#8 /"0#4#"&"&(#/ /##4#'07!66!/8$.%!"#8

//('051!(04/!8,#(&/,"!($&(95('#-8 /"0#/#'4($#("' ::::

&"5!0/&8 /!- +' ,&-.#/-&(# 0#1&%!-';4#"&"&(#/ &' '##6&(9 ! </&" &( "0# (!"5/# 1!($!15' $&/#%"&(9 "0# /#'4($#("' " '!(%"&( /#5($ "0# ,4!&$<&"0/#9!/$""0#9$'#=4/"#$&#>?#//!"#$'544-&#'@81!$# .&$# '0&44&(9 A&-- 'BC* !($ B* D $!"#$ DB B !($

CB B/#'4#%"&.#-E 0#4#"&"&(#/&'/#9&'"#/#$<&"0"0#&(&'"/E11#/%#!($ &("0&'/#9!/$8%#/"&&%!"#14/"#/;=4/"#/$# $!"#$CD

0!'A##(&''5#$AE"0#''&'"!("&/#%"/#(#/!- /#&9( /!$#0#4#"&"&(#/0!'!-'4-!%#$(/#%/$%4E"0#, #9&'"/!"&( #/"&&%!"# ; "'0<"0!""0#%14!(E&'/#9&'"#/#$<&"0"0# $'!($,#/.&%#!=5"0/&"&#'4&#'"0#'0&44&(9A&--'!($!&/<!E A&--'0!.#A##(!""!%0#$!'((#=5/# ;'4#/4#"&"&(#/8"0#9$'<#/# #=4/"#$"/!(!($,<&"0/#9!/$""0'#9$'<!'4!&$"#/"0# 9$'<#/##=4/"#$8!'4#/,#%"&(*"0#,%"8 B8/#!$<&"0 ,#%"&( "0#,%"8"0#4#"&"&(#/1!$#!(!44-&%!"&(//#5($

,4!&$<&"0/#9!/$""0##=4/"9$' 5/"0#/8("0#/#F5#'"+%14-!&(" 1!$#AE"0#4#"&"&(#/8!%//#%"&(<!'1!$#&("0#A&--'!($"0#!15(" ,4!&$AE&" 4#"&"&(#/ <!'%//#%"#$!' '8 8* +;/'0&44&(9 A&-- BC* $!"#$ DB B !($ '8*B8*D+; / '0&44&(9 A&-- B* D $!"#$ CB B <#.#/8 "0# /#5($ , 4!&$ <!' /#G#%"#$$5#"$/!<A!%6&( !/">@"!6#(AE"0#4#"&"&(#/ H#!/(#$%5('#-/"0#4#"&"&(#/0!'!/95#$"0!"!'4#/ 5-# C * "0#, 5-#'8 B8%-!&1"0#/#5($%!((-EA#<&"00#-$( "<#.#("5!-&"&#'8<0&%0!/#!'5($#/);

!"#$ %&'

$"!

"& ) &''"

"& &% ) *+ * & "& "

&, * & -"

&)$

.,' &%% $$ &

. & !)"'" /% $" !!&$ !-"

.&#"

"& &% 0 !

"& 12& 0 !

"& 11 &%!

"& 345&

.&.&%%"!&%

$ '"

/&&$ - *.& $" #"&) "& &%

.&#"

"& &%

+1678I H#!/(#$ %5('#- /"0#4#"&"&(#/ 5/"0#/ !/95#$ "0!" %!'# "0# 4#"&"&(#/ $#' (" !-- 5($#/ !(E "0# !/#'!&$ #.#("5!-&"&#' -!&1&(9$/!<A!%6&'(9/5($/<&"00-$&(9"0#/#5($,!15(" 4!&$&(/#'4#%"9$'#=4/"#$

4(("&%#8/#4-E(A#0!-/#'4($#("' "0!'A##( &-#$8 <0#/#&( "0#E 0!.# G5'"&&#$ "0# /#G#%"&( "0# /#5($ , AE /##//&(9""0##("/!-!/$($&/#%"!=#' 5'"1' +!/$ &/%5-!/+ B;5'"1'$!"#$ B 8<0#/#&(&" 0!' A##( %-!/&&#$ "0!" $5/&(9 "0# "/!('&"&( 4#/&$ /1 B " C B8"0##=4/"#/1!E8/#=4/"'1!$#$5/&(9"0&'4#/&$8%("&(5# "%-!&1"0#%14'&"#/!"#'&#/!"#'!($%!4'9&.#(5($#/%-51(' * !($

/#'4#%"&.#-E"0#,%0#$5-# '$5"E$/!<A!%68'5AG#%""%#/"!&( !$$&"&(!-%($&"&('(/#'4#%"'5%0%!'#'8<0#/#,/#5($'0!.#

("A##(9/!("#$$5#"%-!&1&(90&90#//!"#$/!<A!%6/<0#/#0&90#/ /!"# !($ -<#/ /!"# <#/# &$#("&%!-8 !("0#/ &/%5-!/ A#!/&(9 B+ D;

5'"1' $!"#$ C D ; 0!' A##( &''5#$ "#/ %('&$#/&(9 .!/&5' /#4/#'#("!"&(' /1 "0# #=4/"#/+#=4/" !''%&!"&(' !($#="#('&.#-E#=!1&(&(9"0#1!""#/8"0#!/$0!'A'#/.#$!'--<') J22"0#-#9!-4/.&'&('/#-!"#$"/!<A!%6%-!&1'!/#!'5($#/) "#' !($ %($&"&(

+ ;5'

$!"#$ !' !1#($#$AE"C+ B;5' $!"#$C B 85($#/<0&%0 -- ($5'"/E !"#' /!<A!%6 0!$ A##( ("&&#$ !($ <0&%0 <#/# !44-&%!A-# / !.!&-&(9 %14'&"# /!"#' $5/&(9 4#/&$ &( F5#'"&( &# B " C B 8 4/#'%/&A#$ "0!" >0# /!"#' !($ %!4' $/!<A!%6'4#%&&#$&(%-51(' * !($ "0#'!&$,%0#$5-#'0!--(" A#!44-&%!A-#"#=4/"!%11$&"E/4/$5%"&8'5%0%11$&"E/ 4/$5%"&'K 22

$ #=4/"#$%-!&1&(9/#5($"0#&("#9/!"#$9$'!($'#/.&%#'"!= 4!&$('5%0#=4/"'L "#' !($ ($&"&(

+ ;5' $!"#$ !' !1#($#$ AE "( C+ B;5' $!"#$ C B!($B+ B;5' $!"#$B B 4/#'%/&A#$"0!"J0# /!"#'!($%!4'$/!<A!%6'4#%&&#$&(%-51(' * !($ "0#'!&$ ,%0#$5-#'0!--A#!44-&%!A-#"#=4/"!%11$&"E/4/$5%"8&"0# #=4/"#/'!"&'&#'"0#--<&(9%($&"&('8(!1#-E);

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

B B"B B8!1!(5!-$#%-!/!"&(<!'!-'/#F5&/#$"A#9&.#( !' "0# %0!(9#' 1!$# ( B B <#/# 1!$# !44-&%!A-# / #=4/"' 1!$#/1 B(<!/$'

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

($ D B8/#'4#%"&.

4(("&%#&("0!"4#"&"&(8/#4-E(A#0!-/#'4($#("0!$A##( &-#$8!$1&""&(9"0!""0#4#"&"&(#/0!$#=4/"#$"0#9$'5"($&!/1 "0#5($/! /"!($"0#'!1#<#/#"A#"#/1#$!'>?#//!"#'544-E@!' 4#/,#%"&( "0#,%"8 B0#4#"&"&(#/0!$4"#$"4!E1#(" &("#9/!"#$"!=!($%-!&1#$/#5($'5%0"!=!'4#/"0#4/.&'&('

,#%"&(*"0##("/!-$'!($,#/.&%#'!=%"/"0#/5-#'1!$# "0#/#5($#/#"!&-'"0#'0&44&(9A&--'0!.#A##(9&.#(!'5($#/); ,/ ,0&44&(9 &-- ,0&44&(9 &-- $!"# , !15(" $#%-!/#$&('0&44&(9 A&--

DCBB *

DD B

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

- /#5($ !5"1!"&%!--E ( C D "#/ 4/%#''&(9 "0# '!&$ '0&44&(9 A&--'8 "0# 4#"&"&(#/ 0!$ /#F5#'"#$ / !1#($1#("'0&44&(9A&--'5($#/,#%"&( *C"0#5'"1'%"8 C&( , !15(" %-51( &( "0# '0&44&(9 A&--'8 <0&%0 <!' !44/.#$ AE "0# %14#"#("!5"0/&"E(* D0#'!&$'0&44&(9A&--'<#/#4/%#''#$ &("0#1("0595'"8 B!($/#F5#'"/!1#($1#("<!'1!$#(-E&( "0# 1("0 !E8 D "#/ %!//E&(9 5" "0# %//#%"&(8 /#1!&(&(9 !15(" ' 8 8C +; !($ '8CB8*C+; %5-$ (" A# '!(%"&(#$ !5"1!"&%!--E!($"0#'!1#%5-$(-EA#4/%#''#$5'&(9 &%#/'("#/!

AE <!E 9#(#/!"&(9 ..)' , !&)) 0# 4#"&"&(#/ '05-$ 0!.# !44/!%0#$ "0# %(%#/(#$ '#%"&( / "0# '544-#1#("!/E '%/-- " <!' 5/"0#/ '"!"#$ "0!" "0# , /#5($' <#/# !5"1!"&%!--E "/!('1&""#$ /1 ,4/"!-"'E'"#1'!($'5A'#F5#("-E8"0#!15("&'"/!('1&""#$ <&"05"!(E4/A-#1'""0#A!(6!%%5("%(%#/(#$8&"0#/#&'(#///'&( "0#$%51#("'#"%("0#%!'#"0#4#"&"&(#/ "0#/#&( 8"0#E0!$</(9-E #("#/#$,!15("<&"05"%(.#/"&(9"0#!15("&("/54##'/15/' !($ --!/' &( "0# '0&44&(9 A&--' ( "0&' A!%6$/48 &( /$#/ " 9#(#/!"# '544-#1#("!/E '%/--8 051!( &("#/#/#(%# <!' /#F5&/#$ &(!--E8 "0# , /#5($ !15("&(9 " ' 8 8C +; &( /#'4#%" '0&44&(9 A&-- (DCBB * !

($ '8CB8*C+;&(/#'4#%"'0&44&(9A&--(D * B*+;<!'%/#$&"#$&( "0#&/$#'&9(!"#$A!(6!%%5(" ( ;D*; 8"0#4#"&"&(#/<!'9&.#(/#5($!'0#0!$ (" %-!&1#$ 0&90#/ $5"E $/!<A!%6 0#/#/#8 "0#4/#'#(" %!'# 0!' " A# $#!-"<&"0'#4!/!"#-E 0# 4/#'#(" (# &' "0# '#%($ 4#"&"&( &-#$ AE "0# '!1# 4#"&"&(#/'##6&(9"0#'&1&-!/A#(#&"("0#4/#'#("%!'#8,4!&$AE"0# 4#"&"&(#/ <!' %//#%"#$ !' '8 8* +; / '0&44&(9 A&-- BC* $!"#$ DB B !($ '8*B8*D+; / '0&44&(9 A&-- B* D $!"

CB B<#.#/8"0#/#5($,4!&$<!'/#G#%"#$$5#"$/!<A!%6 &( !/">@"!6#(AE"0#4#"&"&(#/0&'4/!E#/"0#4#"&"&(#///#5($&' 9.#/(#$AE%&/%5-!/$!"#$ B !($%&/%5-!/A#!/&(9 B+ D;5'"1' $!"#$ C D ; 0#'# %&/%5-!/' 0!.#A##(&''5#$/"0#"/!('&"&(4#/&$/1 B"C B( "0# %!'# "0# 4#"&"&(#/8 "0# '0&44&(9 A&--' <#/# $!"#$ DB B !($

CB B #(%#8 ! 4#/5'!- %&/%5-!/ B+ D;5'"1' $!"#$ C D ; &''5#$ AE "0# !/$ 1!6#' &' %-#!/ "0!" /

#=4/"' !#%"#$ $5/&(9 "0# "/!('&"&( 4#/&$ AE $#%-!/&(9 $/!<A!%6 '#/&!- (51A#/'5&=#$<&"0/8"0##=4/"#/'0!.#%('%&5'-E/#-&(F5&'0#$ "0#&/,+%-!&1'

##/#(%#8!""0&''"!9#8%!(A#1!$#"!G5$91#("4!''#$AE "0#&905/"7#/!-!&(

!"# C

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

#(<0&%0"0#4#"&"&(#/ /#F5#'"#$ / /#5($ , "#/ 0#!/&(9 "0# %5('#- ( "0# !$G5'"1#("8 "0# 5/" 0!' '599#'"#$ /#5($ , !"#/ !$G5'"&(9 "0# 0&90#//!"#$5"E$/!<A!%6!.!&-#$AE"0#4#"&"&(#/<&"05"/#5($&(9 , !15(" 0# 5('#- 0!.

! 0# /#'4($#("' !/# 9&.#( -&A#/"E " !$G5'" "0# !15(" !-/#!$E !.!&-#$AE"0#4#"&"&(#/(!%%5("0&90#//!"#$5"E$/!<A!%6!($ 4!E"0#A!-!(%#,4!E!A-#"4#"&"&(#/<&"0&('&=<##6'/1"0# $!"#/#%#&4"!%4E"0&'G5$91#("

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

* !G4

)#'+ )#'+