← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18783/1997dismissed

Chander Bhan Singh v. State Of Haryana And ANR

2016-11-16Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan4 pages

   

       

!"#$#%&'&()*+,*

-!($#.-!(/&(0- #"&"&(#. '

1#.'2'

/"!"#!.3!(!!($!("-#.

#'4($#(" '

)  56  / 7 6/  .#'#(")8 (#."-#4#"&"&(#. . !2.!9 #:;''&'"!(" !.3!(!  -#"-#."-##4."#.':%!:(#<'4!4#.=!3>#!::<#$" '##"-#?2$0=#("@ + >#.##..#$""-##4."#..("  -#"-#."-#?2$0=#("'-2:$>#.#4."#$&("-#$&0#'"@ 88 88 6/ 

6 (#-!'%=#4.#'#("(>#-!:"-#4#"&"&(#."!''&'""-#

2." ("-#4.#9&2'$!"#!:'&#  +,<-#("-#%!'#<!'"!A#(24 .-#!.&(0;((#-!$!44#!.#$(>#-!:"-#4#"&"&(#.-#.#.#;"-&'

2."4.%##$#$"$#%&$#(=#.&"'"-#%(".9#.'3&(9:9#$&("-#4.#'#(" <.&"4#"&"&( -#4#"&"&(#.<!'<.A&(0!'!(('4#%".&("-# 4#.!"&9# /%&#"&#';!.3!(!#<!'4.="#$(

,!'''&'"!("#0&'".!.;

4#.!"&9#/%&#"&#' ($#.2:# > "-#2(?!>/"!"# 4#.!"&9# /#.9&%# :!''82:#';  &('-."5"-#2:#' 5 ;"-#4#"&"&(#.

<!'.#B2&.#$"4!''$#4!."=#("!:#C!=&(!"&(&(-&0-#.'"!($!.$;<-&%--# !&:#$"$'!($%('#B2#(":3;-#<!'.#9#."#$""-#4'"('4#%".; 9&$#.$#.$!"#$+

-#4#"&"&(#.!44.!%-#$"-&' 2.">3<!3 &:&(0 +,

;&(<-&%-"-#.#'4($#("'"A"-#'"!($ "-!""-#3!.#<&::&(0"0&9#(#=.#%-!(%#""-#4#"&"&(#."4!''"-# -&0-#.'"!($!.$$#4!."=#("!:#C!=&(!"&(&(!%%2("'%%.$&(0:3;"-#

8+8 &9&'&(#(%-"-&' 2."'#"!'&$#"-#'!&$.$#..#9#.'&("<!' 2."-#.>'#.9#$>3"-#&9&'&(#(%-"-&' 2."&( 8+,8

 "-!"&"-#4#"&"&(#.!&:'"4!''"-#$#4!."=#("!:#C!=&(!"&(&(-&0-#. '"!($!.$;"-#/"!"# 9#.(=#("<&::>#!":&>#."3""!A#'2%-!%"&(!0!&('" -&=!'&'<!..!("#$2($#."-#2:#' "%=#'2""-!""-#4#"&"&(#.!0!&(!&:#$"4!''"-#'!&$ $#4!."=#("!:#C!=&(!"&(&(-&0-#.'"!($!.$-#.#.#;9&$#.$#.$!"#$

+

((#C2.#88+ ;"-#4#"&"&(#.<!'!0!&(.#9#."#$""-#4'" ('4#%".-#.#!"#.;"-#4#"&"&(#.<!'0.!("#$#C#=4"&(.=4!''&(0 "-#'!&$$#4!."=#("!:#C!=&(!"&(&(-&0-#.'"!($!.$2($#.2:# > "-# 2:#' ;9&$#.$#.$!"#$+ 

((#C2.#88D <#9#.;"-# 4#"&"&(#..#"&.#$.='#.9&%#(

*-#4#"&"&(#.%:!&='"-!"&( 9&#<#C#=4"&(0.!("#$(+ 

((#C2.#88D ;"-#&=420(#$ .$#.$!"#$ +

((#C2.#88+ &':&!>:#">#B2!'-#$"&'2."-#. 4:#!$#$"-!""-#'!&$.$#.&'$&'%.&=&(!".3!''&=&:!..$#.'<#.#4!''#$ !0!&('"'=#"-#.''&'"!("#0&'".!.'(+

((#C2.#88* !($ "-#'!=#<#.#<&"-$.!<(;9&$#.$#.#($.'#$(

((#C2.#88  -#.#.#;"-#4#"&"&(#.4.!3'"-!""-#&=420(#$.$#.$!"#$ +

*

((#C2.#88+ '-2:$>#B2!'-#$!($&"'-2:$>#$#%:!.#$"-!"-#.#"&.#$ .='#.9&%#<&"-##%".=

*!'!(''&'"!("#0&'".!. -#.#'4($#("';&("-#.#4:3;-!9#"!A#("-#'"!($"-!"'&(%# "-#4#"&"&(#.!&:#$"4!''"-#$#4!."=#("!:#C!=&(!"&(&(-&0-#.'"!($!.$ $#'4&"#!$$&"&(!:44."2(&"30&9#("-&=;"-#.#.#;"-#.#9#.'&(.$#. &'&(!%%.$!(%#<&"-:!< -!9#%('&$#.#$"-#%!'#"-#4#"&"&(#.;-#!.$"-#:#!.(#$ /"!"#%2('#:!($-!9#!:'%!.#2::30(#"-.20-"-#&:#

88 $=&""#$:3;  2($#.  2:#  >    "-#  2:#'     ;  "-# 4#"&"&(#.<!'.#B2&.#$"4!''"-#$#4!."=#("!:#C!=&(!"&(&(-&0-#. '"!($!.$;&(<-&%--#!&:#$#<!'#!.:&#..#9#."#$(+

-# 4#"&"&(#.!44.!%-#$"-&' 2.">3<!3&:&(0 8+,8

;&( <-&%-("-#2($#."!A&(0"-#.#'4($#("'"0&9#(#=.#%-!(%#""-# 4#"&"&(#."4!''"-#$#4!."=#("!:#C!=&(!"&(&(-&0-#.'"!($!.$;"-#'!&$ .$#.<!'B2!'-#$!($&"<!'2."-#.>'#.9#$>3"-#&9&'&(#(%- "-&'  2."  &(  8+,8

  "-!"  &  "-#  4#"&"&(#.  !&:'  "  4!''  "-# $#4!."=#("!:  #C!=&(!"&(  &(  -&0-#.  '"!($!.$;  "-#  $#4!."=#("  %!(  "!A# !44.4.&!"#!%"&(!0!&('""-#4#"&"&(#.-2';"-&' 2."0!9#(#=.# 44."2(&"3""-#4#"&"&(#."4!''"-#$#4!."=#("!:#C!=&(!"&(&(-&0-#. '"!($!.$<#9#.;"-#4#"&"&(#.!0!&(!&:#$"4!''"-#'!&$$#4!."=#("!: #C!=&(!"&(&(-&0-#.'"!($!.$!($%('#B2#(":3;"-#&=420(#$.$#.$!"#$

+

((#C2.#88+ <!'4!''#$;<-&%-&(=39&#<;&'4#.#%":3&( !%%.$!(%#<&"-:!<-#4#"&"&(#.-!'.#:&#$24("-##C#=4"&(0.!("#$ 9&$#.$#.$!"#$+ 

((#C2.#88D ;9&$#<-&%-"-# 9#.(. !.3!(!0.!("#$"-##C#=4"&(""-#4#"&"&(#.2($#.2:# > "-# 2:#' .=4!''&(0"-#'!&$$#4!."=#("!:#C!=&(!"&(&(-&0-#. '"!($!.$(9&#<"-##C#=4"&(0.!("#$>3"-# 9#.(.!.3!(!( + 

*;"-#4#"&"&(#.%2:$>#!0!&(4.="#$<&"-2"B2!:&3&(0"-# $#4!."=#("!:#C!=&(!"&(&(-&0-#.'"!($!.$;-<#9#.;"-#4#"&"&(#..#"&.#$ .=  '#.9&%#  (  

*  >#.#  -#  %2:$  !0!&(  >#  %('&$#.#$  . 4.="&(-#.#.#;"-##C#=4"&(.$#.$!"#$+ 

((#C2.#88D <&::("-#:4"-#4#"&"&(#. -#'#%($0.2($"!A#(&'$&'%.&=&(!"&(1&$#.$#.$!"#$ +

((#C2.#88* ;!>2"&%#.'<#.#.#9#."#$(!%%2("

8D8 ((4!''&(0"-#$#4!."=#("!:#C!=&(!"&(&(-&0-#.'"!($!.$<#9#.; 9&$#.$#.

* ((#C2.#88 ;"-#'!&$.$#.<!'<&"-$.!<(-# 4#.2'!:.$#.#($.'#$(

((#C2.#88 '-<'"-!"&"<!'

("2(%($&"&(!::3<&"-$.!<(-.20-"-&'.$#.;<-&:#<&"-$.!<&(0"-# .$#..#9#.'&(;(#=.#%-!(%#<!'0&9#(""-#'!&$&%#.'"4!'' "-#$#4!."=#("!:#C!=&(!"&(&(-&0-#.'"!($!.$;!&:&(0<-&%-"-#3<&::># .#9#."#$""-#4'"'('4#%".'

/'/&=&:!..#:&#<!'!:.#!$30.!("#$ ""-#4#"&"&(#.>3"-#.$#."-# 2."-#.#.#;"-#&=420(#$.$#.

$!"#$+

* ((#C2.#88+ &'("$&'%.&=&(!".3 (9&#<"-#=!""#.;$("&($!(3=#.&"&("-#4.#'#("<.&" 4#"&"&(!($"-#'!=#&'!%%.$&(0:3$&'=&''#$

6/   

*+,* '?A' -#"-#.'4#!A&(0 .#!'(#$ ) #' -#"-#.#4."!>:# )