High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/1193/2023disposed of

Kashmira Singh v. M/S Mohinder Singh Kahlon And Sons

2023-02-22Mr. Justice B.S. Walia4 pages

!"#$"%&'&#()** + ',-&. /&(0, 1"!&!&#(". 2".'3'

4' #,&(5"./&(0,+ ,6#( /#(' 1*"'7#(5"(!

#. -) #(896" .*3'!&%"*/*: 6& ."'"(!)

.*-&!+3- ./ &(&;52#% !"$#.!,"7"!&!&#(".* <<< */*: 6& ;*

. 6

, 66"(0"&(!,"&('! (!7"!&!&#(&'!##.5". (("=3."> 5 !"5 >** 7 ''"5 9? !," 6" .("5 &2&6 350" 3(&#. &2&'&#(; / -. 6 ; 5&'-&''&(0 !," 776&% !&#( $&6"5 9? !," 7"!&!&#(".4350-"(! 5"9!#.$#.'! ?&(0"="%3!&#(&(2&"@#$7"(5"(%?#$ 77" 6$&6"59?!," 7"!&!&#(". 0 &('! A350-"(! (5 5"%."" 5 !"5 ** &( &2&6 /3&! #*B #$ C @,"."&( !," '3&! $#. ."%#2".? $&6"5 9? !," ."'7#(5"(!' 76 &(!&$$'@ '5"%.""5* 7".3' 6#$#.5". (("=3.">."2" 6'!, !!," 776&% !&#( $#. '! ? #$ "="%3!&#( !&66 !," 5"%&'&#( #$ !," 77" 6 7"(5&(0 9"$#." !,"

#3.!#$!,"6" .("5556*&'!.&%!350";D35&, ( ;@ '5&'-&''"59?!," 6" .("5 &2&6350" 3(&#.&2&'&#(;/ -. 6 ;#(!,"0.#3(5!, !-"." 7"(5"(%?#$!,"%&2&6 77" 6@ '(#0.#3(5$#.'! ?&(0!,"7.#%""5&(0'* D" .("5 #3('"6 ."6&"' 37#( !," 5"%&'&#( #$ !,&' #3.! &( E

8; #*#$; 5"%&5"5#(*** F , 2"%#('&5"."5!,"'39-&''&#(#$6" .("5%#3('"6*

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

.5".36"C ." 5' '3(5".)

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

:,"."!,"7.#7".!?#.7".'#(#$!,"A350-"(!5"9!#., ' 9""('"&G"53(5". ("="%3!&#(;!,"%#3.!@,&%,&''3"5!," "="%3!&#(- ?#.5".!,"."'!&!3!&#(#$'3%,7.#7".!?#.!," 5&'%, .0" #$ '3%, 7".'#( 7"(5&(0 !," ."'36! #$ !," 776&% !&#(*

#@". !# ."H3&." '"%3.&!? $.#-; #. -7#'" %#(5&!&#(' 37#(; A350-"(! 5"9!#.)I"$#." - J&(0 ( #.5". !# '! ? "="%3!&#(#.$#.!,"."'!&!3!&#(#$7.#7".!?#.!,"5&'%, .0"

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

8 5 !"5 **> &( #*>FB#$>*"6"2 (!"=!. %!#$!,"' -"&'."7.#53%"5 '3(5".) L* !&'(#!7.#7"."=".%&'"#$A3.&'5&%!&#(!#"(!".! &( ( 77" 6 0 &('! "2&%!&#( #.5". (5 J""7 77"66 (! #( !"(!".,##J'9?."$3'&(0!#7 '' (#.5".&--"5& !"6?#(!," 776&% !&#(!. %" 96"!#7#@".3(5". .5".F36"B#$!,"

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

#-7 (?; /

FF$#.$3!3."03&5 (%"*K 6!,#30,;7."'"(!."2&'&#(7"!&!&#(&'(#! 0 &('!!,"."$3' 6

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

9?0. (!&(0'! ?#$!,""="%3!&#(7.#%""5&(0'7"(5&(09"$#." !,"6" .("5 &2&6350" 3(&#.&2&'&#(;/ -. 6 $#.**;!&66!," 5"%&'&#(#$ &2&677" 6#*F#$ (("=3."9?!,"6" .("5 556* &'!.&%! 350"; D35,& ( 0 &('! A350-"(! (5 5"%."" 5 !"5 ** (("=3." 7 ''"5 9? !," 6" .("5 &2&6 350" 3(&#. &2&'&#(; / -. 6 &( &2&6 /3&! #*B #$ C &( % '" !&!6"5 ' E

8;@,&6"5&."%!&(0 !," 6" .("5 556* &'!.&%! 350"; D35,& ( ; !# ," . .03-"(!' &( !," 77" 6;@,&%,&''! !"5!#9"7"(5&(0$#.' &573.7#'"#(*F* (5 !#! J" 5"%&'&#(&(."'7"%!!,"."!#&( %%#.5 (%"@&!,6 @* "2&'&#( 7"!&!&#(

@&!, !," $#."-"(!&#("5 5&."%!&#('* **