Jarnail Singh v. Polc Ludhiana & ORS






















-1-

 


    

  

 



!"

# $%&%!'( )*++,),











 

 

 

 (

 -.

+ /
 0.



 
  
 
!"


  
# 
 
!"


 
$ % &&&&
0.

 +
'(
)(

# * +,
-
-






!
%%./%%0

 


1



 



 
 

)0 2.

)330
'!4
*5(
"

 
 



 
 

 
, %(
-

 






 




 
 






6"
  
$ %* ,

7


+

 

)8
, 

" 
-

 )%22/*

,

7 "

%2 )) )33%

"

,
 
-


-,

 ,
, 
9 

"

,


:2 )) )33%
 
"-






)2')('(

 
1
6 
!
)3;0
'
 
< 
!

)3;0=(

>
<


,

"
























-2-

* +,

>


?
1



/4
,

, 


?


:(
# 





 
,

-
 



 
7=
 ,







            

 !

 

 
+,

-

-
 



 


,






 



%5* @

 
!

)3;0
1
 
-
 


 
 



7
 


 ;(



 
,
 
 




-


 


 
,  
 
 
 


 
-
 
7=
 ,



 

  "

!

7
,
 
 

"



*"
 -

 
 
-*  

"

 


+,
7

 
"

6"
A 



# $%  &'!()(*  *+' ,"

& #   # -  . %)  /+   *+' 01 1!  # 2

 
 


 

  3- 



 4

 . '    / 0 5 ! 5 



"


 

  "

!


 
-*  




+,


5(

 
 



 
 
$ %
,
 
 


, 
%;2
-




-
 


,
 



%5*@


!

)3;0

7 "





-

 
"*

 
  

 


 

# $%  &'!()( *  *+' ,"

& #  "

!






















-3- .(
# 



 
"
,
"

 

 




 
 0(
!
,
"
 


 
 
* +,
-

 

 


-*  


 
 
,



+,




%

 
!

)3;0



 
 
-

,

,
 8(
# 
"
"



,






"


 

  "

!
 
7=
 ,


"
,
> ,
 -
,

-
-

"
 
-*  


+,

@ 
 
6"
A




# $%  &'!()(*  *+' ,"

& #  

+

,
"

# 
"
"
,

 

.

4
 *


  

 


 

 
 

  

 
  

      


 

 

  
 

  

      12 0! / 2

 



   3-  

 4

 . '    / 0 5 ! 5

 

 
  



"



#




    "  
  

  3(
,-

.   %)  6   

        0 ! /




A

 



 
 


 


 

-*






,
























-4- , -,
@ 
 



"
  "
,

 
7=
 ,


 
6"
A

 

9 
 
  










 
"
"

*

$% ! 

 
"


  


    " 

   
 
   

76 ,  * )  / & * 8 '. 05 !

 # 929: 05 ! * 009: 05!1  5


   





  

 


   & 







8   -  & ,  ' # +'

   011!  # 250: *, 01 "

 



 &

' (
 
 

)  *

  



+ %,


 
  
 

)      
 





 
"

 

$  & -  . %)  /+    +  021!  #   ; )' %) (( ) . -
 & 86  . 020!  # 110

#  

' +
 (
    

  
  


 


      
  &   

   

 
"


     &


  

  
  
 
 


 

' +
 (
 

)  * !

    

   
   
   

 -






















-5- .$/


"

 
   " 




   

    



 
 
 
  

./ !    
  


"

 .00/./ !)   1

"  % 2

./        


    

 



  

  3


    

. / !     

 



 3 (
 3
 
  

!)   




 

.

/  


"
 


   %2    


    
 

.

/

 

    






       



 & 


   "      
   

  
"


   
 



 
  
"




       
 


  
  

 



"

 

.

/ (


 


   
   
 

$4

   
 

  




  
 

  


 
  

  
+ %2  !

  &

    

  
 

   
  


 

 
  & 


 

 

"

  
   



  























-6-  
  (
  





(
 ! !

   




 



(


 ! 5 
   
  

    
 


"

     
 
"



  
"

 2


)
   
"




 


"

  
  





  
"

   
"




   

  

 

 

 




  &


  
 

   

 
"



 "     

 "


 

 


 


      &



 


   


"


   


    
"   


 
 &    

 

    

  




 

  

   




5 



 



   


 
  
"

 
 

     




      
  

3 

  


 
6

)2(
1
"

 



 

 "


"
 


,




 
 ,  
 


B





7 "


 
 


,
 



 


  * ,
 
 * +,


, 






















-7- %;2
-

 
-
7 "
 





 

 

 

 
, ))(
1
 

 
"
 
,  
 




# 
,

,

 





 



 
"
 

 
,

7 "


 

  



+


 
-
)330

,


 
 




+




 
,
 
 
, 
,
 
 



 -

 
 )%(

9
 
"
"
 




#%&2!& # !"+

0.





)*++,),

!+
 ,

 + /
C

 
C/$