← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2455/1996disposed of

International Christian Edu Foundation Govermning St. Xavier'S High School v. Ut Of Chandigarh & ORS

2015-09-04Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan6 pages



        !"##$% &' (!)* +,-./01 2"   ( (,*( 34)( 4 3(  5- 6(7*5, -),

  *4* ,( 35(,3/ *( , 

*. *  

     

       ,, .*!)(.(.*/(80(93*,:435/ ;

,,0!3, .* ; < ,,,:435/ *,430.3 ,5*; * + 4 1- 3)(9,  3((/*( 13)(1!,.  

-(13)(1!,*. ====     ,(* *45, ( 9  >4(*, ( 3 *?(*3 ,

)*3(3

2< "## 1

2@ "## ( "## 1*.)8 ,!*

))(34. .(8,!* *(/ !"@1<"1 A"B? 3 54 3   !  "1<1# $B? 9,), (538 ! 34   "

""

"## *( 5 , /* ( 3 ) 3 * ! (  ! ( . ! ( 3 (3/(*4 5 "#"#  *>  8(3   -) ?1 ,( 35(, 5, 9, . *( 3(**,9)(4*9,8(. (8 C)3 5"2D! ,(/4 0 /.*3( 3)34 3,,( 35(,E(*3 !-*( 343 4*1"#@< ,*) 3/.45 )9(**/(,!* C). ,(,3/( 39(* *.)!,*40*>4 *(/ 

,(*(**45,( 33) 5,*. *),(5,/(,( !$2B?.*> 8(3!(*!,. , ,3 ) 3)3 , . *  (..( 0! , ***( *( !!)C)* 5,.9*!,*( !!)1

81 ,(  , ) *(3,( ,. *,(3 /( (0* .4*4( ( ( )(*9

49,. */4* ,!* *( )((, ..4 8 5( 3 08 , /.45 ) 3(3 "##  ( 3 (..( 0!, !!)) ) 3C.( ,.*

,***.)(8* 9!,!(),(,. *,(4 3*( 3(083)33.(8, (/4 5(8 34( 3 3  9*,,( , (/  )( )3  , . *1,910 (!33 0,(,8((0.(8, (/4 3/( 33 ))3 5,/1,3/( 3*C)**14 !(( 3*)/ (8   *3 5 , (4 ! , /(1  943 0 ! , *   , !* *( )  3)3 , (/4  ,( * .(8(0 ( ,   3)3 9,,   , !()* ( 3 ))4/*( )* ! , )(* , . *45,05( 3( 8 345 ) 5089(8!34) ,(/4 ( 8 , *3/( 33 < * ,(3(..3 ! (/  ! (. 4  , *), 8(3(32 "#AA1,. *9(3*3/. ,! )(.* *(*.(8( (/4 ! D!,)*!(

D!,)*!) *4) (555( 5(04<$()*( 3(..8 89, ,8,(3))3,!4 3*( 59,"2D!,( */ 8 ,(/4 9(*9F34(( (.)!$2B?.*> 8( !4,3(3 "#A#,*. *)(34. * !9(3 )(  3)4/ * ( 3 0( F 0(( ) )!)(  3)( 5 ,

(((08!!4 3* ,(!$2B?.*> 8(39(**(30 ( 3*40:)4.9(3* 08,3/ *(

* 08 (  3(3 "#A# !9(33 , 3)4/ ( 3,( */ 8 *08,3(3 2@ "##2 !/3,. *,(,8,(33)33( ()* !( -) ?1,( 35(,!,) *4) !(*),043 (*,30(**!##8(*( 22.*> , (.)9(* 9F34(*"12A1#21222B? (33 ,./4/154 3 ( )( ,),(5* ,(/ 9(**40:),) 3 */  ,  9,),  )433 , . * !4 *, 5 (  4 3(F 5 ,( , *(/ 9 ()).(0  ,/  ,  *(3 ,( , (/   9430**43 ).!.(8/ !((* D( */ 81, 3(F 5( ((*B*!/, 5  5.(/ 1

81,( *33 ()).,(/ -)

?1 ,( 35(, ( 3 (*3 ( 5( ) 5(3 5 , ) 3 * 4. 9,),,(/ 9(*..*30/(3 ,/( 5( )(* ,)( !,.( 3, ,( )3(! 22B?.*> 8(3!/, 5 ( ( !  $2B? . *>  8(3*  , . * *(3 ,( , . ..*30(39(* ,*.!,)/( 54 39,),9(*

 *4(0 ! 4

5 ( *),  , *. * 08 (  3(3 "$ 2@ "##"(5334),(<22B?.*> 33/( 33 ,.(8/ ())3 58

4 1( 3- )4 *(..( 5 0,(!! , . *  3 4 (    , )*. ) ( 3 )( 3)4/ * 9,08 *4(0 ( 3 (...( .* 9 (3  , ,*),*($2B?.*> 8(3 ,8("##"*!

,*,33

 *4.. ! ,* *40/**  ,( , *. * ,( 3*)/ (3 (5( * ,. * *40/3,(,9(* ),(5! /*,(*./4/!/,. * !3, /4* *) 3  08 , . *   , )(4* ! 34)(   8  ,( 35(,04( 3( *   *. *  , *. *7  3(3

"##< 3.*3 )(  (/4 *   ) *3(  ! (  ! (04()*!( -)?1,( 35(,9F34(,(! <22B?.*> 8(3044 3.* ,5( )5(3 5)( ! ,.1,!1*33**308*,! 5,(/ !/-)?

-)?1,( ,5( )5(3 5, )(* ,( 9(*.(83**3 (*/4),(*,3/( 3,(30 34)3!/ 22B? .*> <22B?.*>

4, )*. )  *43   , )4* ! 9,), , *(3,3/( 3!./4/(<22B?.*> ,. *( 5,(,(45,0 8$2B?.*> @  (  (*  3 4 (    , # , . ! ( //  *! (:8(-(0,(*5 308,,(/( 1,( 35(,

)5 G3 -),*7 &( (5/  **)( 1 ,( 35(, .(8 5 ! !C(  ! ( 3 ./4/ ( 3 54 3   ! , ( 3 (3  9 ,( 35(, -),* ( 3 /(* )

)3 ,9,   *(3 ,( , )// ,(3 /(3 *( 0*( *   !(4 ! , (..)( * 5,(,(.( /01"#@#45,0(..3 * 9  3 3) 5 , . *  (..( 0! , *.4*4( ,/.45 )*1*  )**(8!4* 3( 9, , . 4**  , !!) ! , . ( 3 , ( )

,!  , . *7 )(* )(  0 .(33 08 , . * ( , ,( 59,),,8,(0 !!30!,*. # * .**0 ,*9. !C,( ,( *( **4*     !()* 9,), 943 ,(  0 (F    ) *3(

 *( ) , ,( 3,. *) 3,(, (,(3((380 !C3($2B?.*> 3* 8,)( ,!,(9(*4 3) *3(

*,(3(53*,!, )( (/(...(  *) 3,(,9(*  ))(*   :4*!)(  ! , *. *  (* , ./4/  , *   , , ,( 3 ) 33 ,( (  ,(3  0 /(3 !(4!,. *08,*(3*9,),!3, ./4/ !  $2B? . *>  8(3  ,8 (* 3 4.  ,* 8 * C.**8*( 5,(,(9(* (( 3*40:)4.9(3*

,) )433) ()1,!1,(3 0 (3( ,(,(3  0  !C3  ,. *   ,,,( 3 043 ,* *40/**  08 ) 3 5,(,! ),(0 5 8 (( 3*40:) 4.9(3 * 9(*  8 !/(  &1 ,. * ,( (*3( *4* 5( ) 5(3 5 3*)/ (

 ,8 *( ,( , , 34)( *4 *,(30 (3,.*((...(.()*( ,(! 8$2B?.*> (4 3,*(//( 3,(,9(*

!,*. *( 5,( *7)(* ))3 5  , *. *1 , ( 3* 54*, 5 !(4*  , , .(* ) 33 ,( ,   )3 5(3 5 , !()* ( ))4/*( )* 9,),,(/ *9/(3,,.(* , ,( 3,. * ,,,( 3943,(0C(/ 3)/.(3 (5 ,*C)*,(* 0 4 3(F !(,*

 8(*   9 ! , . )8 ! ,* 9 .

   4 . 1 ,* **4*/4*0C(/ 308,*. "2 (**40/3,(,3/( 3! *( 2D.

4/ ( D . (

4/ * 4 :4*!3 (* , (* ( C0(    *40/3,(,./4/*!C3(,(!<22B?.*> , 9(* !,*. *),(5 5( C0( 8,5,(! * *9 340) *3,*. (*9 ""

() !3 ,(,*. *9) *3,)(* * 5, .*.)  5 F. 5   / 3 ,( , .  * ( 34)( *4

 *1 ,!1 3*.*3 ! 08 3) 5 , *) *3,. *7)(* 5!34) !(* ./4/ ( 3B ( !  *  , . * ,( (53  .(8 , (/4 (*3/( 33 ())3( )9,(9 ,8,(/(3)(,( ,8.*8 3( 5,(/  , 8>4* 1,!1 0!,*. **,((9,),,./4/B(* *0 ),(53( 3,(! * ,3/( 33) 1!(3*, . *1*,( 0 !)3!(.3!5,9F*(!,*) ,!4. * %-  HI  '   -

2"   % --' J( 37