High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/10921/2022dismissed

Rajesh Singhla v. The Serious Fraud Investigation Office

2022-10-17Mr. Justice Harnaresh Singh Gill11 pages

! "## $ &'# # (( ")# # * +* +,*#, - .#+,*#,(# )## # # , !!

/# #!,*#,(# )# )##, /0 10 ( # )# )##,2 ! /! +)!# 3 # 4 ,

#54 1# #66667(# +) *#, 5 * ) # ! ! ( # )##, # !! # ## )### )##,/ # -# ( # ! 8## 9#, # (! ##+#(# +)0(# &!0 56: )## 1 /(0 ( 5 92 , /0

+ )!#/)#(+( !2 # )! # ( # )##; 1(: # !#! ! + +! ) /0

! * 9+# (+ <+! %0! 1 ! /0 # +)0 # # #!1 ( # )##, +!0,

*!2 !, # ! !, /# # +)0 # 0 ! # (+ # ) :# )## ## (( (+ ! 8## 9+# # # .) ( +):# )###!# !!/!#0 # # # ( 7 7 ! /0 1+ =# # 9+# 9 ! )) ( # )## 1! # )## (!!0 / +)!# # )#:# 1# # 1# )## /#!0!0#0(((#

! 8## 9+# , (( # 66(# +)*#,1+# # +# )## # #1# !(!#0!! # / ! /0 1+ =# # 9+# = (# # # # 0 !! # 0 ( ++## )0/# (,# !! #( )##;!+##! # (( #66( +)*#,##!!0(! 9 ! ( # )## (# # # ##+# # ( # +) *#, # )## # !!0 ## # (((!!# +)!##)#(# .), 1 / !2 (# /0 *! >!, ! >!, < <!, 32 %0! ? ?): # # @)# ( # /+),!!# ),! # )##, 1 +# -# #, # )##

/ +)!# # )# , / # /# !1 ( *!>!, A# (# , # # # )## )#)# # +# ( # < 1 0 ( ( 1 #: # # ( #, /++##/0# )##1# <2: +# /0 # )## # 1 #/0# )#### !8##/01# 1 +(+ 8&*#,1 # )##;1( !#+#(57BB!2 #C*2#./! &/0, B: # ))#0 ( # )## / +# # # ! ! ( /0 1+ =# # 9+## #(!) (# !#! ! + +! ( !

, # )### /(0 #0## +# '#(# ## #(# 10(!# )0+# ( # !, # + / /0 )# ###, 1! # ### # (( # +) *# ,0(! (# +)!# ## )### +#/! 9 ! (# # # !! # #2 )! # 0 , 1 # )# +)!#1 #4 (#!0(/# (0:# )##;##+#1/0# )# 7 # )##1 #2##054 12)#(! (# +)!

(! #!#(# ##!)#!1 #!!(# ,# /+## # , 1 1 # -#, +!0 - ?+,*2# ?! #, !0/ ## (/!/0# ## # )## +0 ! / # )#0 / #, ! ! ! ( # )#,1 ! +#!0)) # /!)##,# # # )# , ##! #0 # +) 1 ! # ( .)3 .) ,1 /((!(/###+#,/#!(+ ((# /2 # )0 # + # # # ( B46

(# ## 1((# +#! # ) # # 9+# # +) 1 / #!! /0 *! >!, < <!, 32 %0!, ! ! ! )## , >? . ?. : # )## 1C -#C*#! -# ( ( +) # 1#

.)+#(46B74 /# (+ .) ( +) /0 10 ( )#C## ## '# (# # # # / ( # #!!( .),+#(55!2 / #( (+ .) ( +) # # # ( ! 1((+# !,(# 5 '#(# #/0# !!(# )# # )## ! -#; +# (+ +)0 # 1# .)

12 # )(+: # )## # ##! # # ( /! 1 ( # / # # ( # +) *#, 5 # # +,)(# # # 0# +) *#, 5 + + 1 ((# (+ # )! # # # 8(+# -## , # (, # )## ! # 0 /(# (+ # )# ( # ( #1

(# # # !! # # # )## ( ) (( (# ((+# .)+) ' # !!(# )# % )## !+ +!( # / +# -# =1, # # # # # ### )!*)# +)*#,-# D # # 1# ! ) ((C# (# ( #!! (# #!0)#)## (((# +)0 +## (,# )### #2# )!# # +/ +#-#,!/!#0 /(#) + + ((, / # # #0 # ! , / ##!0 !# 1# # # )# $0 #!0,# =;/!*)@#$ 0!! 0

$E(' 9 ,1 ! # ###! !#0 ))!/!#0 ( ## # ( /! ) # 6B ( # #(09 *#, , !# #+0

! (( # # #0 # #0 ( #0 ! ( # )## 2 )#0 1# , ! # # ( /!, (

!)# , 1 #/(#

+# ( # =;/! )+ # $ 0 !! 0; ) % =;/! )+#,#

+#, ! F @@@@@@% )#(# +#(# ### < # / # 32 %

&# ,1# 1# /# #(# # (((+0! ! ((# # (((#+ ##/#2!%*-**## # +)!! ## ## #2! (( ( +0! ##! /

/ # +(+0! !/( D# + #+: # !0 ++ #+# ( # # ! !# ( )# ( +0! +/# 1# # + # ( ! # )# # (((## +#(#(# )( + # +)# # (! 0#+ #0# #0(# #% # / !0 # # ) )# ( # ##

##+#( / #,(1 *#+ #/ % !#/0# !+##!(##+0 (+)!! #0# # # + #+# ( )##!(# +(+0! <# ## #*#!57(# ###(',## #0(# ###!,+)!#! # ++G+D!#*#!5(# ### +## ###)###(1!# ,# ,# !G # !# !, # /+ +)# ( # ## # +2 !1, 1 # !0 # # +0 ( /2 # + 0#+ ( # #0, /#!)#0##01 + # +(/ ( # # '# # / # # ! + (( # (# # 0 # !0 ! ! # #+, /# + # #0 1 ! 6#

91++)#% ,# 91++!# 6# )#++) +#(+#( (( # &# , # D#+ ( ) +# ( +0! ((, / !0 0, # / # / # + # #0(# ((% D#+(#+##( ! !# )!0 % ) +# ) ( # (( #!0 ( # ))! # #0 ( # ((, 1, # # / # # # # ! (# # #0(((#/0# )## 0! (# +,1 #!0 ((# # ! + (/ ( # #, /# !

# # )+# # ((, #+, (( !# # 3- *#, # '# ) (# # # ##! +! #12 # # ))# + 1 @#+# )!#((#+0 # ##+># +!

,# ,/00## (+ #,##/ # +)!! ## ## ) # ##(/!(# (((+0! '+># +! E(' ,

,# #@)# # 0(H(###H1 #/#1 #)/!()# # (((+0! @@ @@@ @@ 5 % (, # /, # # + ((, + ( +0! , D 0#+# )) &# , # / # ## ( !+##@!# )#( #6B( *# # ( #)#0 /!, # 1, # 1!! # 0 #+0/#1/!#)#0/!1 #!01!!/#!/#!+#0/#0 ,###!!0+# ( #6B( *#1!!#))!0# (#)#0/! 6 (( # # / # # # 1! / ))# !! ! # ! # # ( ) ))! ( /! (# #,

C / ## #!(!0(# #1# (!(!!### #)!#)## 5 : /# # ), 1 0# # / # #1# +(((+0! ,1!!# / D # (!(! #1 # 1 !# ))!#( #(/! #657(# 5

!( ( /!, / # # # ( ! /! #)#0/!,+//0# #)!#)# # 6B ( # *# % !0 ))! (

# 6B ( # *# 1! # # # /(# !((/!#1# (((+0 ! #2 (1 *0 # 1 1! / #)# (# # )) / # / # #)#/0# !+#()# ( +0! # +/# # + # ( ##0 1 #!0 +)# # (! 0#+, ! # #0# #0(# #0 6 * !#,1 ##, / # # # (+ # !( ! # # ( ) ,/# #657(# 5(# # +##,/02 # #(# ###!#, !0 ))!

( # 6B ( # +#+#)!01# #@)# ##/2 # ) ! # / # ( # *#, 1 )! ! !# ) ( # # !#0 + ( +/# # +(+0! 6 % , 1, @)# # # # ## +)!(# #1## (+( #654*( 5,1 +#/ 54 4*# B ( B % , / # /D# !1 # /0 # !+#, +# )! #654*(# 5 I654*@++)(1 #!

, ) ( # #, D0 #! # ( (( 0!1 #/ (((1 ) +#( # /)((# ) +## # !1 ##()@# )# !(( +@++)(+)+#)((# #(( # #!1, !!/!/0# # )! /1# 1# ## # # +0, (# # /! #(#//0#1# , ###( )()! # !((# )! +/!#(# )!/1# 1# ## (# # # ) !!0/ # # ) ( # #, D0 #! (

+ # # +@++ ) ( +)+# ) ( ((# #!1 8@)!#' +)# # ) ( ## # #( # /!,# )(##)# !0) /0# !!/@!KH '# ##+#( / #,#1### @@@ @@@ @@@ 65' =+ #0, ##( < ,#

,# #### ## )0#!(# (#(*#! G# # # )0 #! (+#! # % #+ / ##!0 (!!1 /0 # # ! % !+##1+# #654*# 5 G # ## ##( #! ) # ) # + 1# +0 ( #( ##' )+#9 !*++##)# E#!$ 6 4 5, #,!0 =?

#,## ! () # 3#- 0 #) *#(#+)!#( !((# +@++#+)/ # *#% # #(##2 # # # /## ) ( # 5 ( # 3- *#,1 +)# (#1#(! /!'#1/ HBJ(# ###0)( )! #5(# *#)/ # # #/#(/()( (( # *# / ! ' 1 # # # # # ! )# ( #

+# J ! 2)# + # #)## )! +! ) # ( # %*-* *#/0# ###< ?# $ ##( /-)## ),1 #/ +!0## !!(*#! # ##)0#! +0 D + D ( +! ) !# # , !/0###< ( # * *#!0 302, B,!/!,1 /#2#/+/ # # ( )0 #!, +0, + / # + ( *#! * 1 # (!# ! # )# @#+ /+ ( D ) ## ( # 1 #!

/ !0 /0 /! #+ (

!0 !! #, 1 (!# # # )# ( # )!!/#01# # )0#!1!! #/1# # #/0*#! ( , + +# ( )# ( )! !/#0#/ :/#(# ) ( )# ) #! /+ !0 ! , # ( /0 *#! 1! !# '# / ( # # # 1 (!# # # (# # ) ((+)+#1 !((# +@++ ) +# ) ( # ((, 0 (# )#()!!/#01!/!#( (+#! #!/0*#! ,1 # / #!) 1# # # # /0 *#! 6 ! )+

#, ( /!)!+##H 66% E('! G# ##)0#! # # (+#! # # 1## /+ , # , /+## # # !+# ## #(/!/ #(!#(*#! ( ### &# , # # / # #

#654*(# 51#(## #+# (# *#% ,#1!#/)))##0# !( ( #654*( # 5 1 1 !+ ) /(! # ) # *# =1, #654*(# 5,#)( /!# # ( /! # ( (!# /!

#4(# 5&,# (###(, # +0 #!! 0 # !( 1 # , # #!1!0## #( +!(L +# ! 1 ! # ) ###! $!#0 ( # ) ( # 9*, ))!/! # # )# , # (( !! # )#2 !! # # # )## # % +)!# 1 (! !0 (# #! # # )#% # #!# )##;!+# 77 +) ( .) % -# ( #

+), ! # )##, /+## (! ##+# ( # /#, (!# ) ! ( !/#!0!# +#!(#% +) () ((# (## #(467 # # ( ( 46B74 (+ .) ( +)/010()#C#### % , 2) 1 # ( # !! # ## )### +#(# =;/! *)@ # $ 0 !! 0; ) , # )#### (/! =,# )#)##+ J # )2 C AC3 J # )#/! AC3