High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1122/1994disposed of

Lajpat Rai v. Ranbir Singh And Others

2023-11-03Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary6 pages

#$%&"" &"''()%*+, )+$-./012345"!647"'' , 809247:2/;1;4<=>?5""5 > ?

@0AB09C0;

55555$BB2DD0<9 E2F1G1 C0<H;FI;<JK0<:%9K2F1 55555C21B4<:2<91 L M NO PF212<9= +F5Q0J:;1K+0</K0<:0R$:S4/09274F9K20BB2DD0<9 +F5C0A2<:2FT42DR$:S4/09274FF21B4<:2<93415"0<: +F5IGS;F82U0<R$:S4/09274F9K2V<1GF0</2/4WB0<X YN "5 .K2 BF212<9 0BB20D K01 H22< 7;D2:

HX 9K2 /D0;W0<9&0BB2DD0<9 74F 2<K0</2W2<9 9K2 /4WB2<109;4< 0W4G<9 0U0F:2:

HX 9K2 D20F<2:

+494F $//;:2<9 -D0;W1 .F;HG<0DR $WH0D0 )74F 1K4F9 Z9K2 .F;HG<0D[, S;:2 0U0F:

:092:

"65" 5"''?R 4< 0//4G<9 9K2 ;<AGF;21 F2/2;S2:

HX K;W ;< W494F S2K;/GD0F0//;:2<95 .K;1 ;1 F2/4<19FG/92:

/012R 9K2 4F;J;<0D 7;D2 U01 HGF<9 ;< 9K2 7;F2 9K09 HF4\2 4G9 ;< 9K2 /4</2F<2:

HF0</K 0<:

;1 B2<:;<J 1;</2 9K2 X20F "''(5 ?5 @20F<2:

/4G<12D /4<92<:1 9K09 9K2 ;<AGF2:&0BB2DD0<9 U01 ?] X20F1 0J2 9K2 9;W2 K;1 0//;:2<9R ;< UK;/K K2 K0:

1G772F2:

12S2F2 JF;2S4G1 ;<AGF;21 0<:

F2W0;<2:

0:W;992:

;< 9K2 K41B;90D 74F W4<9K1 0<:

0792F :;1/K0FJ2R K2 G12:

S;1;9 74F 74DD4U GB 9F209W2<95 $792F 9K2 0//;:2<9R K2 H2/0W2 B2FW0<2<9DX :;10HD2:

:G2 9K09R U01 G<0HD2 U4F\ 0<:

4< 0//4G<9 9K09 W20J2F 0W4G<9 C15(>R>>>^& U01 0U0F:2:

HX 9K2 .F;HG<0D5 0W4G<9 K01 H22< B0;:

74F 9K2 2_B2<121 ;</GFF2:

74F 0992<:0<9

$%%

!#%& '% ( %%% %% !

(% %& )& * %

% + % !% % , %! # % %

% -%

% %

% ! ( -%%$%,% ./

0 %

.!% , % !% / .%% ( %

%!! + (, %1% % ,%$%& 2& 3% % %& 4& '%%

% ( %

% ,,% ( , % ./ %

% &6+ -%

##% -%,!% (%% %

%!!

##%% $! !% 0% ,! #

( , % 7!% +

+ % %$ %

!"% # 8 9:; <& = 7 > ( !+ *

%, >% + (

-% .!/ ,%#, % ?@&9:;A=+ %

% %

%!!

% % .%# % % B%, ! ,

# D-! >% + <&>E F + 9, ! B%, ! *##,%+ <&>9 = ( ! $+ .% *

%, >% + =$. ! + # $

%$ % .!/

% %@%

GHI& '%

%!!

.% - !-%

%!!%% !$%, %

& ;& = #! %#%%,% , .% $ %

JKLMNO PQR SKPKQKTUNV

NUNWXMY ZUK[XL \ULKN \UQ]MNU^X TR _[LR NUL NUT[`XM + 8H8Ga6b cDc aD-!b ))+ (%% d.!% % > %$%

%-% + e' %$ % $% e0 , % f

! ,!% !! %!%$% ( !

! ,% % -,$

% ( + .%# % %

,,%,%

% ,,%& :!

% $ % ! , % , % % % $ +

##% -,$ % #%

% ,,%+ a % ! ,% %

%b+ % / , % % $ % 7 (

! (+ (%%./

,%/

! "

"# $

! "

"'( ) # & &&!

++&#

! %$,- .

% $

&&!

*/ 012' 3 "

$% %$

++&&

$ ++&* $

%% $ ' 4+&*

+&- &! ,$-' "-$-

%&&-

+ - %& %

- $ &$

$+ "

+& +& $

899: & * %+%

%$- %+& %

; * %

%# $ %&

$ +

& <

# "7

& * &+&# $+ # *# # = -# %' 5 # ++&*

+ + - %&# & $ +-% &* %& & $ $"

% &$

% &!&&, * "

' 1>' 5

% $#

++&& !

, && * & $ $

" "

&&*

' ?

++&* , *

$ ,-

++&&

+ ,&

!&. &* % $

&* + $' @ , %&$ , $

" , *"&-

+% $' ) #

++&&

%% $ !A 8B-&$C( D= == == EFFGEHIFJKLIMNK BB' 3 3 ,& &$

++&& ! -*# $ $

+ - %& ,

* ++% ! &

&' 3 3 ,& !$$

O' P9#999QR $

$' 3 @ * S + &$

O'P9#999QR' 899' 5 TA- U 6+7#

S ,"$ $/ 08VC W

& * ++% # !

A &# .+ *

-* *

++&& $

@ * S *"&- $

!$ * $; %+

+ &- $

$ $

$ %&,,$

$ 0&

A-

( $ 0+ $

*(' ?

,- !$ O >1#999 !$& *++% C( 898' 5 5, "' OA $ W # 6P9887 89 TSS 2XV#

S &$/ 08B' W %%

$ ,-

++%

++&& Y * " % $,&- $%$' O #

- = &- ,&.' 5 - %# %%

% +&"

# && , ,&

!" # ! $

! '( )*$*** +& (

+( , &

( % &-+ " . /(

& / /+ ( /( ! / ($ % !

(+ ! '( 0

1( (+ & ,

22 ! (( !

3 (2/(

& ! !"4 5*6" . 7% !

! ( &$ %

(+ ! '(" 6$**$***89%

&( ((!

32 (2/("

:;<<;=>?@ABA?< 5*C" # # ,+ &

+ ! '(" 6*$***89 (+ & ,

&& %

&( (( !

(" # D3 E+ +2 &

+ ! '(" 6*$***89

(

&& , # ,+ " # /

22 %

&( (( !

(('(")*$***89" 5*)" #( E+ / ( ! 22+ G I(+2

J$ ,( 7&K LM" # /2 /(( ! %& , ( /+

((((3

7/ / 2( /

($ ( / 7/

(

( ( ( ,!

//&$ % / 2( /( ! (( !

(

& (" #( 3

/2 ( 7 , ( &

&(7

&/((" NO7& 7" P% .& .(+

/ E" Q&"$I0*55J5*REEMS6"T"U4 5*M".'"G"D 3 &I(+2

J (, &K L50" . ( 7 + %7

/+ (

-+ & !V

+ ! / 2( / (( !

//&$ 7 7( ( 3+((% 1$ ( 2/ /(&

$ (

+ ! ( 1& % + ! &( , / +(&" W+

! ( ( 7 , 7%&%,/7( &

&(" VVVV 5X" TTY / 2( ( ,

&& !

& (+!! 3

& (( !

! !$ (2/ / /+ ( /( ! /

7 , 1

//+ / +&3 (

3$ ++(+ &2 ( (+!! &$ !!/ !(!++ !T""4 55*" Z 1+

W ,+ [& I(+2

J$ D3 E+ !O+

,( 7& (+& K L.

( /

+& ( ( + ! '("6

/" D%7 $ # ,+ (

(+ +& \ (( !

(\ " Y

! 2 (

+( 1

//+

(2/( !

%$& '$"

#( )" * +(,( -

.#/ " '"

0"$*12

" '$# "

" "$' "

342 $ " 2

'( '$#

"" '## * "$ "$' "

& *&2 #'

2 $2

'(2

"" !

3 $ """

( 2

$ *""! .

" " '*

#$ $ '# (8 999( : 3

"#2 3# $ +"( ;<2<<<=>

"" "

4. '"#

** 3" 9? " #

''# 2 # " '"# .

$ %$ " "$

!& #

" #"! &( 99@(

'* " 3# !& $" $# #

#"""$# A 9( B"" .#$ #"! &A+"(C2CC2D<<=> @( B"" . D "A +"(EF<<<=> G( #' 7* "

" +"(92;;2<<<=> E( I$ $ #' 7* "

" +"(@29D2<<<=> ;( )

# '.

" +"(E2G@2<<<=> D( B . '.

" +"(;<2<<<=> C( B"" ' &'

+"(;<2<<<=> F( J#"$

. +"(92<<2<<<=> ?( H.

*"* '

" +"(G2<<2<<<=> 9<( B"" " +"(;<2<<<=> 6 +"(@92CF2<<<=>8 F( -K! L$* M$

NOPQ RSTUUV W ROSTXV YZZSX[ \ZQ ]U^XN[S_

S[S^UV` a RbSbU ]NSP cVS[ZdNVb NVdNVSbXN[ @<@G091 +M+ 0M 1 GE?2

* #"! #

'$"

' 2 GC # 2 " " .

3 ! #

# .. " ! * .

#"! "

& *'

. "

. '*' # .

' !2 3" 3# # +"(GF2C<29@<=> 0'$#. +"(@2<<2<<<=>

* # "$

.2 +"(9;<<<=> "* ' #

2 +"(@2<<2<<<=> "" "

1 !& !"

" "

*" 3

" * #"! '$"

# !& ''# 2

' "

%$"

$ "" ' 2

!" # $ %

& ' ( $& ) &% *& &%%! $ +, * %& %- * &%

' &% !$ *%% ! $ !&*% &% $ *

&& % $ .

$ !!&'%

/ !" 0" ) %&'

&%1 $ !& &(

! %' !& !*%! &% &1$

&' '&!*

.2 $& )

&%' $

$ %'

,&! '3( *2 $ * %

* %& % . '' $ % ' 4 %'&%$%!'$5 &" 6&%%'

&%1 57"892999:; &&" <'&! *%%'

. 57"892999:; &&&" =

*%&&

& 57">?2999:; &4" =

&%!

*57"@92999:; 4" A%'%%' !&'&5B?2999:; 4&"

$(&!'&&&( $C%

@9D57"E92999:; B9" A!!

'&%1(2 $ %$%!' * %

* %& %

7"B2892999:;2

%' 4 $ * %

7"F92999:; '( . '' ( $ &%2 $ &' $ !&*%; % .&$&%

* %$

* $ '

& &' (

$& ,'1*%2

&&%1 .$&!$2 $ * % $ !!

% &% $

'( . '' ( $ &%" G$ * %%

&% (

% $ %$%!' * % $ F"?D

%%*

* $ '

&&%1

% 2&& &H& %" BB" < '& (&%1 $ . ' $

&' C%2 $

% &'& '

" 9@"BB">9>@ IJKLM 14:$ / NJKOP Q$$ /&%1:

%' 5 R:S Q$$

5R:S