M/S Jrn Engineering Works v. State Of Haryana And Another

      

 

     ! ""## $ %& '(%  " 

  ! "   !
! #$%$&'



#!(&)$$*+(,-)./('$ #'0$(**$,,(&'  


&'')*+ **$(,1&)$#!$/'2&34 '0$(#+(&(
(,1$))$)(5/'-

36 #%0#'-'0$

3/'72% 2,$)(8(2&%''0$#)$#)('$)9

:

*(%%$);+'0$(#+(&((5#2;1&(,-0(&)28(#06 #%0#'-'0$#2;1&(,7 /,(2<2&8 ,,=2&8%1;%'(&'2(,>1$%'2&% ,(=

?627 "0$'0$#&'0$ (/'%(&)2&'0$/2#/1<%'(&/$% '0$/(%$- '0$ )#2;1&(,=(%@1%'2 2$)2&1*0,)2&8'0$#)$#%

,=$#(1'0#2'2$%&'0$8#1&)'0(''0$)#2.$#=(%&' /(##+2&8  %'('1'#+  )/1<$&'%  '0180  '0$  8)%  2&  '0$ *#$%$&'/(%$0(.$;$$&2<*#'$) #<1' /1&'#+(&) '0$1%'<1'+0(%;$$&*(2)&'0$%(<$A "0$'0$#&'0$ (/'%(&)2&'0$/2#/1<%'(&/$% '0$/(%$- '0$(;%$&/$ 0(,,(&=1,)#$%1,'2&'(''$<*''$.()$

  '(5=0$&'0$1%'<1'+0())1,+;$$&*(2)&'0$ 8)% 2&>1$%'2& (&) '0$#%'('1'#+)/1<$&'% =$#$ ;$2&8/(##2$)(,&8=2'02'A 62227"0$'0$#&'0$ (/'%(&)2&'0$/2#/1<%'(&/$% '0$/(%$- '0$#)$# #2;1&(,2%*$#.$#%$2&&('1#$(&)/&'#(#+' '0$)/1<$&'%&#$/#)AB 0$  #$,$.(&'  (/'%  (#$  '0('  &  :

-  .$02/,$  ;$(#2&8 #$82%'#('2&C94C9 DE=(%/0$/F$);+'0$

2/$#% 5/2%$(&) (5('2&$*(#'<$&'0$)#2.$#*#)1/$);2,, $&'#+ #<$#<(&+'

G%$=,,$&;$##+"#F%- ('01#(()-(#2)(;()60$#$2&( '$##$ $##$) '  (%  "7- 
  C3  /0(,,(&  2&=(#)  %0=2&8  /&%28&$#  (%   18,(;()-  $=  $,02  (&)  /&%28&$$C  "  6(  1&2'   G%  $$*(F &)1%'#2$% ')7-(&)0(&)=#2''$&%,2*2& (.1# '0$(**$,,(&'0$ )#2.$#2&02%%'('$<$&'%'('$) '0(''0$8)%=$#$';$1&,()$)(''0$ *#$<2%$% '0$(**$,,(&'0$%'('$<$&' #1&H1<(#-$<*,+$$ '0$ (**$,,(&'=0=(%(//<*(&+2&8'0$8)%-=(%(,%#$/#)$)%'('2&8'0(' 0$=(%%0=2&8=(+ 02% 2#<''0$)#2.$#(&)=(%28&#(&'(;1''0$ )/1<$&'%#$,('2&8''0$(**$,,(&'0$8)%=$#$)$'(2&$)(&)(%0= /(1%$&'2/$)('$) :

=(%2%%1$)''0$(**$,,(&'$*,+=(% 2,$) (&)  /0(,,(&    ::  )('$)  :

 =(%  #$,2$)  1*&  =02/0  =(% *#)1/$)&

0$%'(&)'(F$&=(%'0(''0$8)%=$#$;$2&8 %$&' #@;=#F''0$(**$,,(&'(&)(/'1(,,+;$,&8$)'" )/1<$&'%  '  %1;%'(&'2('$  '0$  (.$#<$&'%  =$#$  *#)1/$)  ;$ #$  '0$ $&(,2%2&8

2/$#0$/0(,,(&*#)1/$)=(% 1&)&'=#'0#$,2(&/$(%2'

=(%*#)1/$)( '$# 9)(+% )$'$&'2&(&)2'0()&'2<$ #$<.(,

8)%<$&'2&$)2&2'$&(,'+1&)$#!$/'2&3 6D7 '0$/'=(%2<*%$)

3 .2)$#)$#)('$)

0$**$,,('$1'0#2'+)2%<2%%$)'0$(**$(, .2)$#)$#)('$):

30$(**$(,*#$ $##$);$ #$'0$#2;1&(,<$'

'0$%(<$ ('$&9

:-0$&/$'0$*#$%$&'(**$(, $(#&$)  /1&%$,  #  '0$  (**$,,(&'  (#81$)  '0('  '0$  *$&(,'+ 2<*%$)=(%2,,$8(,-'0$#$/1,)0(.$;$$&&$.(%2& '(5(%'0$8)% =$#$2<*#'$) #<$#<(&+(&)2'=(%(//<*(&2$);+/0(,,(&
C3 (&);2,, $&'#+0$(#81<$&'2%;1''#$%%$);+%'('2&8'0('"/1,)&' 0(.$F$*''0$'#(&%(/'2& 2<*#'1'%2)$'0$;F% (//1&' 0$/&'$&'2&%#(2%$),(/F<$#2'0$)/1<$&'%*#)1/$) %0=$)  2<*#'  ;+  "-  '0$   8)%  =$#$  <.2&8  #< 18,(;()  ' (#2)(;()-(%*$#'0$0(&)=#2''$&%,2*(&)'0$%'('$<$&'%#$/#)$)-'0$ 8)%=$#$';$)$,2.$#$)''0$(**$,,(&')2#$/',+0$#$=(%&)/1<$&' (//<*(&+2&8  '0$  8)%  #  '0$  %(2)  '#(&%(/'2&  2$  '#(&% $#  '  '0$ (**$,,(&' '=1,);$=#'0<$&'2&2&80$#$'0(''0$$<*,+$$ '0$ (**$,,(&'  =(%  (//<*(&+2&8  '0$  8)%-  +$'  0$  =(%  &'  /(##+2&8  (&+ )/1<$&' #'0$'#(&%(/'2&;$'=$$&"(&)'0$(**$,,(&' 0$ (/''0(''0$8)%#282&('$) #<$#<(&+=2,,&';$

(&+0$,*2&'0$*#$%$&'/(%$(%'0$#$=1,);$&'(52&.,.$)2&'0$0(&)%  '0$2<*#'$#% (#(%2<*#''#(&%(/'2&2%/&/$#&$);1''0$%1;%$>1$&' '#(&%(/'2&=1,);$8.$#&$);+'0$*#.2%2&% '0$/' 0$#$2%(&'0$#(&8,$''0$<(''$#'0('2 '0$8)%(#$';$ 2<*#'$) #<1'%2)$'0$!'('$ (#+(&(-(%'('1'#+ #<
C32%' ;$2%%1$)0$ #<2%%1$)2&'0$*#$%$&'/(%$%0=%'0('2'=(%2%%1$);+ "(&)'0$/&%28&$$=(%%0=&(%"&%1/0/2#/1<%'(&/$%-'0$ 2%%1(&/$ #<
C3)$%&'$&%1#$'0(''0$'#(&%(/'2&;$'=$$& "(&)'0$(**$,,(&'2%;1&)';$)2%/,%$)''0$)$*(#'<$&''=1,)

9 0(.$;$$&()2

$#$&'/(%$0() #<
C3;$$&2%%1$);+'0$(**$,,(&'

#(',$(%'2&'0$/,1<& /&%28&$$-'0$#$=(%%<$<$&'2&'0(''0$ 8)%(#$;$2&8%$&'''0$(**$,,(&'&;$0(, " 0$%'(&)'(F$&;+'0$(**$,,(&''0(''0$8)%=$#$;$2&8%$&'

#@;=#F=(%&'%1;%'(&'2('$)-(%&(8#$$<$&'''0$%(2)$

$/'=(% *#)1/$)0$/0(,,(& #'#(&% $# 8)%=(%*#)1/$)( '$#()$,(+ )(+%-'0$#$2%&<$&'2& '2<$ #$<.(, 8)%2&'0$/0(,,(&(&)'0$ %(<$0(%#280',+;$$&&' 1&)=#'0#$,2(&/$ 0$#$2%(&'0$#(%*$/' '0$<(''$#-2&%*2'$ '0$ (/''0(''0$ 8)%  =#'0 
3  ,(/%  ))  =$#$  )$'(2&$)  ;+  '0$  (1'0#2'2$%-  +$'  '0$ *#2&/2*(,G#$(,=&$#6(%*$#'0$/(%$ '0$(**$,,(&'7&$2'0$#/(<$ #=(#) 2&'0$*$&(,'+*#/$$)2&8%&#*#)1/$)$.2)$&/$=02/0=(%%,$,+2&2'% *%%$%%2&-'%1;%'(&'2('$'0$%'(&)'(F$&(&)'0$(.$#<$&'%<()$ #'0$#$(%&%<$&'2&$)(;.$-&2&'$# $#$&/$2%=(##(&'$) 2&'0$#)$# '0$#2;1&(,>1$%'2& ,(=<1/0,$%%%1;%'(&'2(, >1$%'2& ,(=(#2%$% 0$(**$(,2%)2%<2%%$) ,


&'')*- ,.  )- /* /* 9

<F "0$'0$#%*$(F2&8G#$(%&$)

$%G "0$'0$##$*#'(;,$

$%G