Ghanshyam And ORS v. State Of Haryana And Others





 
  


!" "#$%$&'

( )

* &%*+ , &-!*".% "!$!$&".%

/! !"  .+ &  &-!*".%  "%0&-"&!%
 '12 3//
3/ 33 



 






 
 
 
 3/ 334 . 5




 




  


!

"



 

 #
$

"%   "
 

&   
'#

"



  

 
 


 

(
) 
& # 
#






 




 *
+, 
-




 
../


, 
0 




 %
 


 

 

1 "

#"
  
 

,*/
2

3


+$4
$
 
.56/7
 
.8 5/ .56/
2*93

# 

5:

5/ .56;2*<3

 
#

#
 
"


#

 #
 

 "


#
 




" 




 
#
 
"





"


 " "

/5
  


=5
  
 

"

"
 " "

> 
" 


#
 "
 %
 

%
 "
"

 
> 

"

"
1
  

> 
#

 "
 "
#
 *?* 
 


"

  

 
 @
0


 %%  

 

##
  "

 

"
  

> 







"


# 


$
$
 

 
# 
  

 "
# 



"


#


 #
 




 "

# @
0

%  
  "










 
 


9%.5* .56<
(
263
 
5= .5.6
2*:3


 

#"
*/
2

3

+$4
$
 
.56/7
 "






 7
A






 # 

,*/
2

3


+$4
$
 
.56/7




  

#

#
 
#
#
> 


#
 #




  "

#
 
#

> 
 "




 

  

   



#


 

"
 "

 
 


+$4
$
 
.56/7 
 # 

#
 !







#
#


 



 "


 
"
A



  
" 




  


 <







  
" "
  
 
#

# 


 6:


 

 
 # 





 "

#  ##



 

#> ##

./


 





  "


*
 "
 B 

   



#
# 


 


 6:








> 

.

<


(
#

  

 
"


)
 


 "



 
 




 
 "


"



 "



0

 # 

"

 

 

 
#
9:


<5



 


#

9%9%88*6
(000
 
..

$ 

 #
) 
2*,3
&   
,
( 
C
688<





 #
(
) 2*,3
&   
,
( 
C
.56.

 

66 5< .56.



C
:


 
( 
C
.56.


 

 #



  
#
6=

<5

$
#> ##
"

 


 
#
<5


<.

 
  
 
./ 5= .56<

 
> 

:


"

!
 

  
"

"



 " 

A






 
 "

,
;


+$4
$
 
.56/7
 # 

#> ##
  

/5


!



"


#
 



" "
#> ##
   
 # 

 

!
#
 

#





#


 







  "
 "

#
 


#





  
1

#
0
 
 
  
 
..

.5..
>
*65

CB!


 # !
!
("
&   
'#
"


 # 


 
 "
!


 


0





 


1



# #







  A



 *(  

#










 

  


  
 


# 

 



(  
A



(  
 # 












(  




##

&  
  

(  
  
 # 


  



 

" 
  

 


1  
#

   






 

# 
 

  



 D
B
  
#"

#


 


# 
 # 

#

" 

 



  



"



  




(  


 







A



 *(  
 # 


 " "


 



 " 


 
#

 "

,
;


$
$
 
.56/ 



 




 #  0






 


"
"

 
 
 
  

! 
 

 
#  >
0


 






 

 

 
  # $
  
 

 

#  ##

#> ##
"

 

 


# 


C *(  




1  
#

   

%

 
# 
 

  

 D
B
  
#"

#


 


#
 

$
$
 *.56/
$
#


  




#" 
 
,
;


+$4
$
 
.56/7

 

#
  

 #

 


 



 *
+;


  

 #

  & 

 #








 
# 


  







=5
  

 

$

 "
 "
  


 



" 

 


"



 #
 

 "

 #



" 


 



 " "

/5
  


 
=5
  



!


 " 
 !
#
#


 
 
 
 

 
 # 


 ##

 

 "

#> ##
.5
  


 





 " 
2  




( 
, "3
$
 

  



"




;
2

3
23

;2

3
2 3
 *
3
"

/  6. #!. /781 #!.

 9 $&!%
.$!".$ 

. # 5#75 !$&

:" 0."%"&! - !" ,$&7%

!" 8$.!* ;

:"$&&7,8". - +%<); 

, 9$,7,

7. -"#$, 5 0$&!% &5+ 3
$



#
  
 
#
#

 
5-"%! 0".%& %* 55 :"! , 9$,7, 0$&!%  
# 
   /  6. #!. /781 #!.

 9 0$&!% 905 & !$ &  "&-".

", 5"

0$&!% %* 55 8" :$="&! 55

", 5" !" #*".%

 /0"#$ 5 # !":.+

", 5" !" #*".% $->?-$=.#"-?% "0 . !"- 7&, ..$"- ", 5" !" #*". ,." !* &   +" .%  :"? >$ " %".=$&: $5$! .+ 0".%& 5?  . ,$5$! .+ 0".%& 5 >.@$&: 7!%$-"!*"/! !"

55 ", 5" !*$% # !":.+ %* 55 8" :$="& , .@% &5+ 5$:$85" >$->".% %* 55 8" :$="& 0$&!% ) /0"#$ 5
!":.+ , 5" !" #*".% $->".>** % &! ."1, ..$"- &- * % &" . ,." ,$&. #*$5-."& &-? .

;
7&, ..$"- - 7:*!". % &5+ 

$

"."&!5+ 85"- 0".%&%  B ! ;

B

$% 8$5$!+C  .@%

8=" ;

B ! ( B C   , .@%

8=" ( B

 .@% 

$%" %"% "8$5$! !$&:

$%.-".%E A$%$& 3#,!.%

"

 7,8

/"5

A 5$- #".!$ $# !" $%%7"- -7.$&:5 %! &" +" . 8+ /

$&#57-$&: $!%

8. &#*"% $&  .+ & 4  *! @4 4 F* &07. F 5 &4 F 50 & 
* >5  "-$# 5
55":"4 F .& 54 
* &-$: .

* . -75+ #&%!$!7!"- "-$# 5

 .- &5+ ;

$

"."&!5+ 85"- . ,"&! 55+ #* 55"&:"- #*$5-."&

"&?>,"

& !" #*".% * =$&: ,"&! 55+ #* 55"&:"- .

B -$

"."&!5+ 85"- #*$5-."& %* 55 8" 0.=$-"- , 9$,7, 0$&!% G
705"# %"

&5+

", 5" %07%" "&?>,"& * =$&: ,"&! 55+ #* 55"&:"- .

B -$

"."&!5+ 85"-#*$5- ,05+""% H %07%"% >.@$&:$& %! !":=!4 #"&!". =!4 /%

G
#." !"- 7&-". #!% ..75"% ( /! !"

> .-? !$ & 5 > .-  ." #:&$I" # -",$# #&!.$87!$ & /! !"? !$ & 5

> .-"" " #*".% J

# -",$# 0".

., &#" /! !" > .-""? !$& 5 > .-""!" #*".% . ."%75!%4

55>$&: %* 55 8" !*" #.$!".$  . "&!$!5","& ! 0$&!%' G B ! ( BC ( B ! ( BC ( B ! J BC) J B ! J BC J B !

BC


" #*".% :$=$&: :- ."%75!% $& !*" 5 %! 8 .- "9 , 0


 





, 






  
 
# 

  

# "

  
 

 

1 

 



 




  
  

 

 




 
(#

  

"# 






"




 #
  
 
 "



 "

# 







 
 
 




 
 >




" 




" 

 



 "



#


$
4 
(#
,

/ !+  "= * : 7. &-!*".%A%*"/! !"  6 %!* & &-!*".%4

/
G) 



, 




  
 
# 


 




 
   

 
0
/ !+  "= * : 7.H% 
%70. 4 
4 
(#
,

 

 *

(
+6/ 
 


, 




  

 
# 


 




 
   

 
$ 



 
 

 
 


(  







 




  "


  

  

 



  "


  


>
 

 B
"


  6;

$ 
,




F.$%*& & F @@ &!* =% =".&,"&! F". 5  &-!*".%
JJGJ/

J  
 
 E9/
$
  
 

  


 >

 
6<


, 




 


> 

  "


 #


 
 


(  
# 0

##  
 

 

#
# 
 
 



!
0

1

##  




#  


 
 
 


 !





 

 


!
F

 
 
#  
  

 



#



 



#



   

 "

   

 


, 

 
 


 !

0




# 

>


 


 "

  
 


 >

" 

  
 

 
E# !

"

 


  
 E E
6=


G"


 
,

/*". /$&:* &- !*".%=%&$& &-$  &-!*".%4 JJ ;/

  
 


E

# 



 





  "
 
# 

"#
 
>





 
 
#
 

 


   
   E
0
/ !+  "= * : 7.H%

2(3
(  

CB 




  
 
95 5:

.56=
 "

  
 "





,#
G 



!


#

  
  
 !
0&(
, 
(  
 
$H
, 
"#
G
 

 
,"
(  
  

J


 


#!



> 
  
0

 





  
 "
> 
  
#

# 
  

# 


 
 #


 



#!
"" 




"
,

CB 
!

"

  


(  


 
> 
  
 




 



 
(  



1 
#

" "

#!
$ 







( "
G"



"
, 


& 
H



 


(  

CB 

 


"" 


 # 


4 
(#
,


A







 
 "
 # 

  
 
..

.5..
 # 

CB!


 # !
!
("
&   
'#
"


 "
 


 
 "
#

  

"




# 
  

 

 
   
0


 

"




 


 




 


 


 




 
,

 



  

   I #


  "



  
 




## 

 


("

 
 

 

 # 



0


 

"

 

 





 






 
 " 












# 
 

 




 



  -


 "
 
 K3/ 33L

( )

    7-:" %@* &
- 
!

"%

'% - 
  

'%