Manmohan Singh v. State Of Ut, Chandigarh And ANR.
!
"#"
$ %%&'
"('
"
!"#$%&'" #"%
#
)
%% %%* &'+, $ % %-+#( &''.% % %& %%&' % % (
&'+, $
"('
%/% #"%
##) * " ( " -
$.
' #'
, 12/ % ( 3 $ 4#" $ %56' '//%66%/762#'
, "178&
"
' ., & 9 ..& , 6:& ' '.. "#-"
4# ( ,
' " "
$
-""$,( "
' ';6%6%/7//< =#
/>%
4# " ?"
"
'-3,(.
"('
%/ ' + " , '
% ?
+ & ?
+ $ "( , -.
"&$..3 " + ' "
'
3 ".+ "
'"(# &?,"(( $ ,( "
% -""$ " & "+@
(?
$ "# -3( 3 , # $ ( ,
' "?#.'- $# .
= ,"
'-#"
$( , ""$ # ' #"& 4# " '.. "#-"
4# ( ,
' " "
$ 3 -
4#"
" $A#" , %
"# +'
'
"' '2%;%/7//' , " (( - $ ..4 " B . # $ , ' " "&", '
'- $ # &' ..4 " B .
# ?"."' , ' "
' " ( % (# "#, $ " &.
'&' "
"
( ' '2%8%/7// "# %9 ( "." =
( ,( "$" "$,(.
# C
# '
, '
'8%1%/7//. ? " $
'%"( , .- , '
'6%8%/7//% -""$
" "&.
'&' ",,.#'
( (( " "+
' ,( "
+.# .3'
" ,,#"
,"
',,#"
'" -
'
,. ' ,. ' $$ '
% + '.
',#"
.$ "&( #"
, '
' ( "
-3.
'&' % - #".$" # 3( +"$ 12/ % %%?#.'
"? # 3@ "#, '
"&"3- , "" 3
+ $$ , 3 '
#'
"'
( + -#"
$ ( , ""
$3# ?"
"
,# '"$A#" , % , ;/7 % " 4#..3 + $ ,"'
&?,( ", - " ( , '# $ ,(#' $ $$ "#'
'
.'
% *
( + ? # $$$ "..
'.3, '
' $, - "+ ,-.3"
'"(# &
, # $, .( "
,# ?#.'- $# .
= ,"
% D-.
#( # #- $,"
",.#'
!"# ""$B.S.Joshi and others +"State of Haryana + ,)
-%./)0.) 12$..?
'-3 "# #.. ,,"
$3.*4+)%5, + ,)6% 7.8 9 + ,):
2+ '
.
? ( (" +.+ ,"
'"
.?%
$ &D-.
#( # Gian Singh ;State of Punjab and another %./)0.) $# '
.
? ""# ' . .?"
'-3 #( # $ 4#"
$ State of Haryana ;Bhajan Lal:
%.//%2%
86$ A#'
'""#'
)
!
"
#
$
%&'
(
"
)*+ , #
- +
,
(
!("
( - "
-
(
(
.- -
(-
(
/
(
$
-
( $
(-(
.0
1
(
.
(- *
(
2 ( 3
(
-
(
- -
-
-
.
(
(-
(
(
( -
(
-
-
(
.
# "
#
(
-
(
#
#
-
+ ,
-
#
4 ((.3 .? "
' -3 D-.
#( # (.
$A#'
"' " # & "(( ?
( "+
' ,( "
& , # $
( ,
' "?#.'-
.3-#"
$( , ""$ # '-3 ..? ',, ( ( 3 $ "-34#"
?#.'- "
,# '"$A#" , &?,"( .3 -A , $
". # , #'
, 12/ % " "#. & "# $'" ,"
'"4# .3$.."
? - '(
""
'-3A#',.( , '
"' &
%56' '//%66%/762#'
, "178&152
"
'
., &9 ..& , 6:&' '.. "#-"
4# ( ,
' " "
$ 4#" '4# -""$ ,( "
< =#
/>%
'.
"" "3 ""..
-#'-3 "',' "$ ,( "
' " " , '
'- $ ,# - .?%
" '"..?
'% #"%
# #$ <"
.#,@3 9 "( @ " ') "B 9
( -.
) "B