High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4971/2019dismissed

Jai Narain Sharma v. Balwant Singh Malik

2023-12-13Mrs. Justice Amarjot Bhatti11 pages

!

"#$#%$&'( #$ ))

!!""

$% & "'

!# *+

*# + % )- .

,

(%"

. !!

#

!%( +%( #

.

3 %(-

!/

%!" +%( #

.

7 %(

-

& "'

. !.

.

& "'

!.

.

#

#

#

:%

-

" :% & 8"5-

. -

- ;-

5

!. # #

.

( #-

< %!

- . .

(

( "

%4" #5

( #

(

(# <.%#

5 # ! +

5 !

# 5

'%" //

'%" .""

( #-

#% #5 /% (# <.%#

#- #

(

4%

"/ %4"

5

"#

!# (# <.%#

# #%( '

( (# .5 .

=%# #

% :'- .%" (# .5 . # % .

.

#5 /%

!! .

(#

5 -;-

!%! .5 .

=%# #- (# <#

.) # (

(

4%

"/ "

(% /"

!#

(#

""

4+.#

#

-;-

5

## !# 5 #% -

!. #

(!

/%#

(

( " %!

- # '%"

#

# ..%!

!#

//

(% /" :%

=%#

4/ !

% 4 =%# >

(# .5 . #

%

#

"'

5 5

""

.#

""

5

""

)

!.

. .

=% !- #.

// . %4 ( - " :'- #% %! ?"#

#"5- "

# . ## # # !"

5 4+.# ".% @

#5@ .. " # #. %4 ## ' %4" #5 :% % 7;

= :%

-

" :% & - .# - "

# =%

%

. -

##

- ;-

5 ##"

'%" "

%

. . 7-;-

.# <.%#

# .

*! #2* # 2 (

*!# - %( "- " /%#

""(

"('

/

#"

# ;-;

#'

5 ) #

'

#

..%# #-

(# ( #% .)

/

!

.

4%#

/

5 ;-;

# -

#"

4 <#

1 /#- ' 1 !%

# %//

.) .)

""

. ## % 5 #% -;-

. ;-;

'

//-

-

5 /%# ## 4% "

(% /" %!

"

- # 4%

#

#

(% /" 9/

"5 7-;-

"!

. ## %

!

""( ""5

/.

4"5 !%# 6%

.%.#

//- 5

"" %.- #%(

.%"

# # "( . ;

.""

4%#

; !"5

# ' ! 5

"5 .#

!"

" B !" ( - /""'

% ' #

;

!!

"

!#

"

"

"

!# $

"

"

!# % "

!# &

; 9 ! #-

"/ #!!

# # 4<

*C : /%# <

*C - , ,%

*C- ) ,% - 8")- :% & - :

5

*C

& '

+

*C;

." .

9 4%#

//-

"/ #!!

# # 4<

6C : /%# <

,%"!

6C -

6C- % ,%

6C

+ "

6C;

." . 1 /#- .%"

# .% # ><6 ><6

)6

." .% # 5 . 9

.- .%"

# .% # ><*E- ><*A

><*F

."

.

7 /#

(% #

. .%"

4# -

. %(

- +%( #

.

7 B"

(( +%( #

.- !!

&12;7

- %(- +%( #

.

3 B"

(( +%( #

.- (%"

. !!

4

(% #

. .%"

( #%( #

.

4"

. .%"

(%

. +%( #

.

7 %(

-

!/

+%( #

.

3 %(- " ( 8%# 4"'

'(- %-

# .

#%# !!

!!.

. .

##

><*

##

5 - ;-

!! <

. <

-

=%# <#

// ;-;

#%( ) #

.. ("5-

*!#5 6 " 2 (

*!#

(#

( #% # (

<#

% 15 '("5

.! # .

(% /" %!#

"%

- 5 # #"5 #

/%#

'("5

.!

-;-

<# 9/ .#-

(

5 %.

.

-;-

"5

;-;

!#2!"

// .%"

/ # #

6C '

! . # #

..%#

><6C2 !# 5 # ;-;

..%#

C

)'

4%# %%"#

!#2!"

//- .) %#

% "( . ; >< 6 #%(

.%"

.""

.)'"( #

!# !#

><6

><6 !.# "5

!#2!"

// :

. !"

#- .!5

><6 :

."

<.%# 4#'

%""

.!5

><6

/

' %"5 ! .

6C

,%"!

6C

1

. '

!#2!"

-;-

# !#2!"

"(

( #

3

5 % %!

( !.%

( #% 4"

) !%# # . 4 #

! # %#

#- #

.%"

"

/ .5

5

- ;-

"( ;-;

%4=%#"5- #% 7-;-

1/- 8%# 4"'

(

"

/ !.

.

4" #

..!#

!#2!"

) "

/ !.

.

"5

.

(% #

. .%"

( #%( #

/%""5 & "'

)- !#2!"

!.

.

:%

-

" :% & 8"5- . -

><*

## # #

##

/

:

./ %# . -

2-

5 - ;-

/

"" &#

./ <

'

=%#

!%# !#2!"

<

) ,% *C '

! . .% #

""# #

%

!%# # 4#' #

..

!#2!"

-;-

<#

# . 4 # (

""-

/%#

.!

4% "

(% /"

.%" !

-

""

4+.#

# ""

4" #

#

// #

/

#

:'-

!%#

( #% #

-

( #% ' 4#

# (

4"

) %

# - .

-;-

#

"( !# -

'""

. (% /"-

#

"% %- #

#

%

// #"5- % !#2!"

!

'

& "'

#!!

# # 4<

*C :

!

/

#

'""

5 #

-;-

:

<

( #

#

*C ' #

# . 4%# # %

! "# . - .%"

( #%

*C ' ! <

, ,%

*C

!

- & '

+ *C;

# # 4<

! # # # .

# B# :!

./

( #%

# # 9 4%# .-

#!!

# # 4<

6C

./

,%"!

6C

!# # #

### #' #

'""

(!

<

(!

# !

' 1/-

5 . .

. . # 4"

#

%"# % B "5

! ;-;

)

..%#- ""

# 4"

-;-

5 !#2!"

."

"'

5 5

""

""

<# < #

// . %4(

4%# #% %!-

%"# (#

!.

)

%"5

### ><.%# #-

><*

#

-

#)

. // . %4( - 1

. '

(#

!.

)

// . %4( - " # ! - ' )'

4%# %%"# # .) %#

5 # !#2!"

5 1/- =%#

'

)'

4%# !%# # .%.#

#

" <# <

!#2!"

(#

!.

)

// . %4( - " &/ #- !#2!"

"( .

><*

# /#- !.

.

# #%#

;

.# 5-

"# : "( . ; ><6

/#

# #%# # 9 - #

5 % 5 %!

#-

! 4"

"# %.

"( 1/- )

(#"5 4"

#

'""

# !!""

8%#

. . ' (#"5

!!.

#

%4#

=%#

"

" 9 '

.% # . -

5

#/

8%# 4"'

%!" %"# #"5- #

(%"

. !! "-

.. ("5- *

!!"

5-

! / !#.!

. #' 8%# 4"'

# .) .. =% #

C# ! (2 A C# !# 4" A2