(O&M)Durga Dass v. Hira Singh Etc.
!"
# $#
% &'
'
()'
* +, %&, -
### ..//'!+01!'!+
20
3 3!&, ()'
* +, %&, -
'!
+,
### . !!+ 0./'3!+311
!
" #
$" ! %&!"
" #
' (( ) #%"*"
!
" #
$" +
, #
' ( )("
"''
- (( ) ' . / '" (
(( ""
0 '"
"
0 '
"1 "
1"
"!
"& 2 '2
'" #(( 1 "
1"
" #(( & 34 '
-
"1
"' ( "
56 $6 ' (
"'"
( ' %
' 0
'" 56 ( )("
"'' ' .("
"''/ 0"
$
56
" 1 $" "
$""
% ' % "
0 '
0 56
"1 (
05
" "
%
" ( "''$ "5 6 %
0
' $ - %"
0
" "
$ 5 ( " 1 $""
6 ' %("
0 '
0 $"
$""
% ' ( " '5
" "
%
8"(( $"%" 92 - ' "''" "
2934 0" ':;<
;
$" "*"
;' '") " ( ( 6"
'
'("
"''& 2 7 ')2 ("
"''& 9 4 7 ')2 = 2 );( '9
);
%
- ( "
' "( ( 6$ "
"'' % 6
2233 "''0
);%
%
% ' "
"
' "
2934
0
>7; 2233- "''$ ' % "% '
'
"""0"
( ( "
0 "( ( 6 $""
"% "'' 0( 0
""
' " ' "''$"0
0" "
" '
$""
$ % ' " "%"
- " "
"% "''5 ' """0"
"
"
"( ( 6"
% '
#
"( "''' % " - ("
"'' '" " ' ( %
"
0"
"%
,"
0(6 "
"%' %"
"
0 "( ( 6 ( ' ""( "
?
"%"
$0
'
' "''- 5%" $" >7;2 $ " " "5
"%"
;- , ( "$"'
%"
" " ' %"
6
'" " " 0"
8 % '""
0 ' $" ' "'' % , $5 ' " "
( "$ ' %
% ' $" $ 6 $""
0 ( ' %"( '
"
" (
"'"
( ' %
' 5
0 '" "'
6 '%"
0"
"%' %"$"'
- "''0 "' ( %
"
"%" $"$ >7<;2
22 '" ( " ' (
"'"
( ' %
'
2934 2233
2 - '" $" 6"
0
'5 0
(
"'"
6 "''
(
"0"
0
- "( '% ""
56 "''"
' ""0"
@"
'
"0"
'"
#0
0
"6 $"
" "
- ("
"''0 "
"
" "%"
""0"
56 "0"
0"5 !
!"
0 56%" ( 0 5"
"0 ' "
(( ( "
5
% "% '
(" 6 ' ("
"''$"!
!"
0 05 ( ( 6 '
"'
%
-
" "
""
5 - ""5
11 !
211-
4 " ( ( 6 "
$"
5 "
$" 0
"6 5
'" ' 9
( '" ("
"
$ 6
"
% ' ("
% ' $"
"1 '% ' $"
0"
;
:
("
"''
0
'
2934 2233"
'
' " C :
("
"''
%"
6 $""
" 6 $""
0( ' %"( '
C 2:
("
"'' " ( "
56$6 '
(
"'"
( ' %
' 0
2934 2233C 9:
""$""
"% C :
("
"''
'5 '" "C< :
"( ( 6"
5 "
$" 0
"6C< 4:
("
"''
" '" ( "C< 3:
("
"''" (( '" ( "56" $
C<D :
""$""
"% C< :
""5 E)
2 11C<D "
"'' 7%"
: "*"
<
;$" '0
2934 $ "
" 5 ' 1 (
6 ' " 0" >7; 0 "5"
0 '
2934 @ ( 5 $""
0 ' "
' "
'
'("
"'' 56 :; ( 5
" ' 0
2934
:;2 %F (" "
0$"
'0
>7; 2233 ( 0 "5"
0 '"0
"
' '
"( ''
%
'
); - "''& @5 !"
0 (( $"
5 7:; 5
% '("
- "% ' 7%"
<:; 5
% '$" <:; G "!"
0 5
% '
$" 4 E( "
0 0 ( "
0 '
"1
"
"
'
' "'' 0"
"%
(& '
"
0 3 < '" '" (( 0"
0 '
"1
'"#(( 1 $"
""
0 1"
"(( & 34 ' 92 "%" '"((
$# #0 "
56 5
' ("
' , '5
"6 "
& , ( 0 "
"
'
"0"
0
2934$
(
- 6 ' 0" ' "5 "0 (
' %:; "*"
<
;$" - " % ' "
$"
'0
2934"
>7;&
' "
$"
'"0
7%"
?
(
0
2233 ("
"'' 7%"
:;2 %F (-"0
" 6 "5 56:; "*"
<
;$" 5 " "% 6"" $ "5 0
2233 >7;:;@5 !"
0" 0
$' ' ' %9 '
$ ' 5
$ 09 '
$ ' ?
'
%
$(" " 2934 2233 - "
'(6% ' ); %0"
'0
>7; 5 "" "0
56 ;< 0<- (6% '
%
6 " (
-
" "
" 6%
5 0
- ' ( ( 6
5 2 );( ," '9 # 56 " *"
<
;$" '9 ' +"0
""
B ( ,"95"0?
' 0
$ $" ("
"'' - $
"( '
%
6 & ( "
$ "
"''- ""'" 56 "''
'"5 !
!"
0$"$ % ' ""0"
""0 $ 5"
"
(( 56' $"
$
0
& " "0"
0
2934 "( (6" (
- ':;@5 !"
0("
"''
& "0"
0
2934 $ "'
29345
"''$
0
"' "
5
0
>7;B
'
5 (( "
" ' 1 $ ;
7%"
"
'@5 !"
0:;("
"''& $ "
0 ;
7%"
"
H
!
"
#
"
$
""
"
' '
"
(("
"
!
' >
# "" (2( (6 '"0
$(
$" "% '"( "
1 $"
"
$" ("
( (6 ' 6 '"0
"
0" '
<
;$" "
$" (("
"
5 ( ' "1
$ ( (6 ' 0
$(
6 (6 ' 6"
<
;$" 0" $(
"
"
6"0 '
% "0 ) %5"%( "
' "
0$"
- ' ("
"'' 6$ 0"
( "
"% '
'
2934 "
' %
" '
% >7; (
56 ("
"'' %
$"
'
6 "% 5 "
( "
5" '
>7; 2233- " ( "
0
" 0
2934 2233 ( "
'
$"
" )( "
' ' %9 $ 0"
?
' 0
>7; "0 ' $ 5"
5 ,(( ' "$ "5 (
' % ( 0 '
6 "
?" $% 00 5 $ % '
6% 00 6 ' 0
:; @5 !"
0 %
$
56:;2 %F (-"(
"
0 $(" - 5 "
'
'" #(( 1
); 6 '
'0
>7;
6 "% 6 ':; @5 !"
0 :;2 %F (?" 56:;@5 !"
$ % 00 $":;2 %F (' ); %
' );$
56"%5 % 00
" (
- ("
"''
,
0 '
""0"
' $""5 !
!"
0 0
''
$" '(6"
0'
6(6 ' "
0" '"
"
0 '
"1
$ "
"
"
' "''
$"
'%
65
""0"
$"" 5 @"5 !
!"
0'" "' ( "
0"
< 0< 34 " !
"& 43"
$"
0 >7<;9 $ !"
$"
'%
6 0
"I "( ( 6"
'
'("
"''& 2 7 ')2 ("
"''& 9 4 7 ')2 = 2 );( ," 9 5"0
0
2934 "0"
2934"
5
4;3% ("
'
0
>7; 2233
$ ("
"''
(
% 56 "
0
6
' %
6>7; ' 0" '<
;$" : "*"
?
'0 "
0
% '0
2934 7 0
2233 >7;
);""
%
-
" '0
>7;
);$
""
"
%
' );- "
' "
2934 "
5
0
>7; - ( "
$ "
% '0
2934 >"
$% 00 $":;2 %F ( );
(" :;2 %F (% 00 %
6 ( "
$ "
"''- ""( "
>7;
$ 5
' " ""0"
'
( $ "
' % "'' 0( '
$ 5
$""
$ '0 "
0 ' %"
0 ' """0"
( 5 '" "
' % "'' " ""0"
$""5 "
"
( ( 61 %"
0 , $5 "5
"
"( ( 6 "'''" "' ( %
"
"
0"%' %"
"
0 "( ( 6- '" $" >7;2$ %"
'5
$
" ' % 0
@
'5 0
"
$" >7;2
""
"
' "'''
"
' 0 " "' %"
'" ' %" $"'
"0 '("
"''#0
>7; " 6 (
56$6 '
6
0
>7; $ "5 '" ' %""
0"
< 0 <"0
% ?" (
56:;2 %F ( "
$"
- " 56 <
;$" );"
56< 0<"
(
' "5 "
0$"
"' " 6(
56:;2 %F (!"
"
0$"
'
>7;" 7%"
$
"6 0 >7;(
' % :; "*"
<
;$"
0
'
0"
"
("
:
"
$"
>7;2 %"
'0
#'
%"
0 , $"
( '' % '
'0
("
"''$" $ " "' ( %
'" ( "$""
$ % ' %"
0 , $ ' '""0"
"1 "06(
6
(
"
'
' ("
"'' '"
"
0 '
"1 " 56
'" #(( 1 @
6 (6 ' "%" '
((
" ?
& , ( 0 5
- "% "
'""0"
' $""5 !
!"
0
' 0
( (
56 ("
"''"
6"%( "" * 0 >7<;9 '
!
!"
05 ' '" !
" & 43 34 $"
$
- " "$' ( "
7 'I 0"
% "
09 "
"0
" - " ( I 0 $
$"$ #1<"
" ( '
'
"
0
44"" 0A "0 ' "''
!
!"
0 ( %
"
"
0 < 0<' %"
"
0 6 %
'
"
0
-"
0 '
% ' '!
!"
0 < 0<
:" "( % < 0< $
'"( ( ( 656$6 '
"
44B
1
0
<;9 <; "%" "56 "
0("
"''!
!"
0'" (
0
44 " 0 !
!"
0" " ( "
7 '
) " #(( 0"
0
<;9 <;$ "%"
0 <;
<; '
#""
<""
* 0 """ - '"0
2934( (
56 ("
"''" ' "
" '1"
"!
"& 43 '345
- "0"
0
2934$ (
'
"1 ""(
56$6 ' "
0
6
(6 ' 6 ' 0" '<
;$" "(
>7;-
'
' " " (
"
5
5
( :; @5 !"
0"
" "% 65 ' 1 (
"'"
6 "0"
0
"
% ""
'"
'" '"
""
(" ' :
'
<
;$" :; " *"
$
5 '
"1 94 ( (6 ' 6 '" 0" 0
'0
2934$ 7"5" ;
"" 5
56
' @ $
"
(
"'"
% $ 5
$ 0 (
'
6 0
"
( :; "*"
<
;$" $"
" 56"%" < 0<
60
$""'
- ' "5"
0 '0
293456< 0<; "
% "%" 56"% 5 "( ""$
$"'
- "$' (
$ %( "
0 "
%
"
$ 5"
@ $
"
0
'0
' 6 "5"
0 '0
>7;
' >7
'0
>7;" 6(
' % "% 6 ':;<
;$" "*"
5 ' % "% 6 ' :; @5 !"
0 ("
"'' & $ (
"'"
6 5 6 5 , 0
9 '
$ ' "'
=2 );( ," 9 $""
0 '0
$( ( 56 "*"
<
;$"
'< 0< ' %""
0 %
"0
@"
"@ "0
#( % '
(" ); "0
- <
;$" ( "%( "0 % "
"
" 0" @ 5"
"0 ' " 0" '
(
(6 ' 6 ' 0" '<
;
$" ; $"
"
(
@ 0"
0
>7;" 5
5 0
$"
6 ' 0" '
<
;$" " 5
" %
"
% 5
6' , '""
0 5
-
'
' <:;2 @5 !"
0 "
" "% 65 ' 1 %
0
09 $ ' 'I "" 6 "
"5 5 "0 "
?
("
"'''" 1"
"!
"& 3 432 ' ( %
"
0 ' % "
"
0 "( ( 6 7 'I - '" $" ;2 '" 5
" 56 < 0 < "
$" ' " " &
%
"
'
%
$ - ;< 0<
'
2934 0
2233@" "
4 0
5 '
5 5
' '" ' ("
"'' ( ' % "( '
$ < 0 < %"
6 $""
0 ( ' % " ( '
- %""
'' 0
'0
"
'
' "''"
$" >7;2
5 5 " @ !
3 '1 '1"
"
"
(6 $"
"( H
"
(
"
D# 0 "( " !
3 H
)
*
"
D?
"5"
0 '0
2934$"
$
0" ':; <
;$" ;
0
2233>7;" 60 (
56 "''56 7%"
: <
$" $ (
6 ' 0" >7; :;2 %F ( "
0$"
'0
>7;5 %""
( ' 56$6 ''""
0$" >7;2"
(
6"
" "' ( %
"
'" 56 ("
"'' " 1 ' "''"'
'0
2934 $"
$ 0" '
$" >7 ;
0
2233 >7; $"
""
"
' "
0
2934-
7"
' "
0
2934" (
' %
" '>7;-"0
""
5" $
> 0" "%, ' $"
0 "
0;
&# + +
, (
-
+ . / ,% ( + .
# "
/ 01 2 00 03 04 526 07 5 86 03 52116 0 5006 0 5016 56 08 51136 50106 . .
:
. .
"
( "
( 08222; 5
6
*
.
"
(% + .
- < - ' - ; - (
) - - - ; ( /
*
1;0
. - + .
02 4
"
( 2222; 5 (
6 "
*
=
( 222; 5 (
6 "
"
> ) ?
( = -; - ( (; + .6
"
"
( 222; 5 (
6
)" -
(%
"
'
#
)
"
"
#
"
% #
"
'
-
"
"
'
02 24 18
+
01 20 18 ! @
@
! . - ; / - (; + . + + < - ( = -; - ( (; + .$ - "''$ " 7%"
"
$"
' 0
2934 5
"
" 0
'"0
"
5
0
>7; 2233$ "
$" >7;2- " (
"'"
>7; );"
56< 0<"
" (
' "%( "0 ':;<
;
$" "*"
E "( 6 $ :; " *"
(( "
$"
5 7 6 ( 5 '"
2934 "" 5 5
0
>7; 2233 5 "(
''
' ("
"''5
" '0
>7; 2233 (
' % "% 6 ':;2 %F ( $ ("
"''& @5 !"
0 $ (( $"
5 7 :;B
"1 "06 5
&
5
! ( =
01 20 18
02 24 18
$ 6 0"
0 "
$" >7;2 "
(
6"
" "& 3 '432 "''
'" ( ' % "( '
$6
%"
6 ( ' % " ( "
"56 %"
'5 0
- "
" $" >7;2" , ( ""0 $ 5"
5 ,(( 5 % ' 0
>7; $
"
$""
0 @
'
2934-
" '0
>7; (
"
6$" $" ( 0"
5 $
"
- ;< 0< $ (( $"
5 7"
" "% 65 ' 1 "%(6
'0
2934 6 0
@ ""0
>7; :)#@ " $ 6$"
5
7( "0
0 '""
0 ' 1"
" !
" & 34 '
4356("
"''0"
"% 7( "0
'" $" >7;2"
" ( $'" 56 "''0"
"%
" '" 6$" # 0 '" ;
7%"
"
'" $" 0
#
5 !"5!"
0 "
"' ( %
"
5 5
6 ' %$ 6( ""
0B
"1
8" #(( 1 "06
""(
0
"( ( 6 "''' % ' 2);( ," '95"0
);
%
6 6
$
$""
05 ( "
$ "
( "'' ( "
5
$
%5 ">7$ 1 & "" 6%
("
"'' ( "
' "( ( 6 5" '
2233-
"1 "06
&
'
"
A
"
"
"
B
"
1 188
*
18
188 $ -
0
2934 ' " I "( ( 6'
" "
' 2 );( ," '9
);
%
6 2934
6 '$"
$% 0" ':; <
;$" >7;
5
0
2233 >7 ; "
"
' (
0
2934
); $
2233 $ (
"'"
"( "
0
>7; $"
$ '
' "''
0 %"
0
" "
%
$ $"" 5
""
'( "
0 " ( 56( "'' 5 '" "
' % "'' ""0"
$""5 $
(( 0"
0
>7<;2 $ "%" >7<;- " " 0"6 (
"6"
'"
"
0 '
"1
8"#(( 1
0
' 3934 >7; 2233 >7; "''$6 %"
6 $""
0 " 6 $""
0 ( ' % "( '
"06
5 "
& "
'
' "'' 0"
" ?
& 9 ( "
0 "%""
#
"
"
0
>7; " (
"'"
" $"
'
' "'''
"( ' %"
0
" "
$ $" " 56(
""
'( "
0 " "- " "
% $" 0 ' " "- "% ' 5 0
'""
0 ' " "56"5 !
!"
0
34 $"
$
0 >7<;9
>7<; (( 0"
"
0
>7<;9 >7<; $
0 >7<;
>7<;- "''
(
"'"
6 ( '" "
' % % """0"
"
"( ( 6 6'" "'
( %
"
$"
'
:" >7;2'" 56 < 0 < "
" " " ' ( %
"
6 5
"
$ " 6
'0
5 6 ( "''$ $""
0 ( ' % "( '
$65
6 ( ' %"(- $"
>7;2$'" 56 22 " "$0 "%" $"$ 56 "'' 6'" ( " 2" $""
$ % ' %"
0 , $ % ""0"
$""5 ?
%
'0
5
$"(0 '
"% %, ' ( ( 6 5
"
$"
>7;2 '" 56 "
(
6"
" "' ( %
"
(
"'"
6(
' " % B ( "" "
'
"
'
"0
"" ! ' "%""
0
>7; 2934 $"
$ 7 0
>7; 2233"
5 % 5 "
'
@ /5 #( 7 1 "
!
!" !" #$ $ % &
%#%'( )*+ !"#$ ,--.*+ */0/)+.-1 ?
" "$"( 0
( ' %
$ 5
"%% " 6 %"
"
'1 (
"
0-
(
"
0 %"
3 "$ "$ 5
" '"7 ' ( ' %
$3 "%""
'26 ' (
"'"
( ' %
$ ' %3?$'
7( "
H '"7 D"
#"
'B"%""
#
5 5 "% ( " '"7 $"
"
(( 0 '$"
" '"
" - '
" 1 8" #(( 1 "06
"' ( "
56(
"'"
( ' %
'
"'" $""
( " '"%""
- 2 -
"1 '% "
& ' $;
H:
""5
11 211D?
"
"'''" 1"
"!
" & 34 '43)4220"
' ( %
"
0"%' %' "56"( "
0 "''' % "( ( 6"
'+"0
" - "
( ' %"
"
0 '
"
0"I % 6 ( "''?$ 6' '""
0 '
$" >7;2"
" " "'' % , $ "
"
'
% '
" '
>7; ;#' '""
0 '$" >7;256 " "' ( %
"
$$"$ 56 "'' ""
' ( "
56$6 '(
"'"
( ' %
'0
' 5
'"
0 (
5" '
11 !
211 ( " "5
5 % 5 "
'@ J5 !
( "
% 2%3/!'0
) ) ,*4+5 16 $ ""
( '5
115 0
5" 5 5" "' "6
5 ( % 6
5" '"
" 0?$ ( '5
' 11 5 5" 6"' '"
( "
0"
(
" 56(
" "6 ' ' $ "# 5
"
""'" $""
( " '"%""
"
" 0' ( %
"
$ " "6 ' '
(
" ( "$"
"' ( "
56$6 '
(
"'"
( ' %
'0
(
"
" " $" ( %
"1 8" #(( 1 "06 ""
$ 5
!
2 '115
'
5 "$"''
0( "
0 % ( ( 6 - ' '"
"
0 '
"1 '"#(( 1
""
(
.,4,5 !"1 9 - , 0 5
("
"''
' '" ">7
'0
>7; ;
56
"( '
%
'
);' ' "( ( 6" 6(
56 "'' :; @5 !"
0 (
" "
$""
' ("
"'' ( ' % "( '
$'" ( ' "
' % "''"""0"
$"" 5 ( - ' "''
' '" "
" "5 "'' (
' %$"
" 5
("
"'' (( ' % '""
0 " -
'" (
"( ( 6"
"
$" 0
"6?
% 6 "
'
% '0
>7; ; , ( "( ( 6"
( ( 6:
'" 6
(
"' - "( ( 6" '
" ( ( 6 ' ' %"' 56$6 '
44- '"
"
0 '
"1 '"#(( "
( "
0"
'
' "''
6 & $ % ( "
"$ "'' " ' ( "
56$6 '(
"'"
( ' %
'0
>7; 2934 0
>7; 2233
5 % !
' !(
"'"
"
'# $"
&2 %2#/#%#$"($ 7
!8$78!#
8# 516 !
%
"
# )
' 1
16
"
"
56
C
"
4
D
"
"
!
"
516
C
$ ?$ 0 ' "
' '(
"'"
( ' %
" " 6 $" 5 0 "' (6
,"
0 % ((
$" ?
9
/!
/""/:%/ 0
)/!'
,*-.+5-.,"$ 5
E00
*
"
%
"
"
$ ?
%) (( !0 # );
/< ,
--516 @ J5 !
( 1 ' $;
E
%
)
"
,
)
)
"
- 256
- (
'
)
#
"
"
)
"
-
#
*
)
- "%" ''
"
0 ' @ J5 !
( 1 "
%#% /*"$ "+ 2; 0 !'
) !"
#$ ,
--5 $ "5
" $ $ ( ' %
'
"
% "( $"
" '
1 %6( ( 6 " ""
(
"'"
( ' %
?
'
*%5 ">7; ("
"'' "
( "
" ( ( 6 "
% '
2233 ' " ( ( 6 $
% 00 - $ "
( "
' "( ( 6 "% '
2934 2233- "
$"
, ( "
"
0
5
'"
' "( ( 6@" 6
" "0"
" "( ( 6" 6
'"
"''$ 6 $""
0 ( ' % "( '
$ %"
6 $""
0- '" (
6
' %"
"
'" ""0"
$""5 !
!"
0
"
' % "'' 056( "
0 ( % (6"% %"
0
" "
"$""
'
'
("
"''- ' "%(65
("
' "( ( 6
$" (0 '"% " 0
"
"
' '
(
"'"
( ' %
'0
; ;&
" (
$"
5 "''' %0 "
0
"'
6
((
1 $"
B
"1 8"#(( 1 "06 "'' " ' ( "
$
' "( ( 656 (
"'"
( ' %
'5
0
56
'
' "( ( 6"
"'
- '"
"
0 '
-"1 8"#(( 1 "
& 2 ( ""
"
'
' "'' = ?
$ 6" '
6
$ 0 '
' ("
"
5
" % " "
(( " "%" $(
) *
Whether Speaking/Reasoned Yes/No Whether Reportable Yes/No