← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2516/2003dismissed

(O&M)Durga Dass v. Hira Singh Etc.

2025-09-16Ms. Justice Ramesh Kumari26 pages



              

 



!"

 # $#  

 % &'

'

()'

* +, %&, -

### ..//'!+01!'!+

20

3 3!&, ()'

* +, %&, -

'!

+,

###  . !!+ 0./'3!+311



     

 !

" #

$" ! %&!"

" #

'  ((  )  #%"*"

!

" #

$" +

, #

'  ( )("

"''   



 - ((  )  '   . / '" (  

(( ""

0 '"

"

0 '

"1 "

1"

"!

"& 2 '2

     '"  #((   1   "

 1"

"  #((   &   34  '

- 

"1 

"' (  "

56 $6  '  (

"'"

 ( ' %

 '  0

       '"   56   ( )("

"''   '         .("

"''/  0"

     $  

  56   

  "  1   $"  "

 



$""

% ' % "

0 '

0 56 

"1   (

05



" "

%

 "  (  "''$ "5 6     %

   0 

  '  $   -   %"

0  

" "

$    5 ( " 1 $""

6 ' %("

0 '

0  $"

 





$""

%  ' ( " '5



" "

%

 8"(( $"%" 92   -   '  "''"    "

   2934 0"  ':;<

;

$"  "*"

;'   '") " ( ( 6"

'

 '("

"''&  2  7  ')2  ("

"''& 9 4  7  ')2 = 2 );(  '9 

 );

%

- (  "

' "( ( 6$  "

  "'' % 6

2233  "''0

 );%  

%

%   '             "

"

 '  "

 2934

 0

>7; 2233- "''$ ' %  "%  '

 '

  """0"

 ( ( "

0  "( ( 6 $""

"% "'' 0(  0

""

 ' " '   "''$"0  

      0"   "

  "  '

  $""

 $  %   '  " "%"

- " "

"% "''5   ' """0"

 "

 "

"( ( 6"

%  '

#   

 "(   "''' % "    -  ("

"''  '"    "  '   ( %

  "

 0"

  "%

,"

0(6   "

"%' %"

"

0 "( ( 6  (    ' ""(  "

?

"%"

$0

'

 ' "''-  5%" $"  >7;2 $ "    " "5

"%"

  ;-   , ( "$"'

 %"

"  " ' %"

 6

 '" " " 0"

       8 %    '""

0  '  $"     '     "'' %  , $5   ' " "

(  "$ ' % 

%  ' $"   $  6 $""

0 ( ' %"( '

      "

       "  (

"'"

 ( ' %

 '  5   

  0 '"  "' 

6 '%"

0"

"%' %"$"'

   - "''0    "'  ( %

  "

 "%"    $"$     >7<;2 

22     '"     (    "  '   (

"'"

 ( ' %

 '

   2934 2233

   2 - '" $"   6"

0

'5  0

 (

"'"

6  "''

(

 "0"

0

  - "(  '%  ""

56 "''"

' ""0"

@"

 '

"0"

     

 '"

#0

 0



"6 $"

" "

 - ("

"''0 "

"

" "%"

""0"

56 "0"

0"5  !

!"

0 56%" ( 0  5"

"0  ' "

((   ( "

           5

% "%  ' 

(" 6  '   ("

"''$"!

!"

0 05 ( ( 6 ' 

"'

%

- 

" "

""

 

 5  - ""5

 

11 !

211-

4 "  ( ( 6  "  

  $"

  5  "

  $"    0

"6 5

'" '   9

( '"  ("

"

$ 6

"   

%   '  ("

    



     

%   '  $"

    

"1 '% '  $"

0"

;

:

("

"''

 0

 '

2934 2233"

'

 '  " C :

("

"''

%"

 6 $""

" 6 $""

0( ' %"( '

 C  2:

("

"'' " (  "

56$6 '

(

"'"

( ' %

 ' 0

  2934  2233C 9:

 ""$""

"% C :

("

"''

 '5   '"   "C< :

 "( ( 6"



 5 "

$"  0

"6C< 4:

("

"'' 

 " '" ( "C< 3:

("

"''"  ((  '" (  "56" $  

C<D :

 ""$""

"% C< :

 ""5 E) 

  2 11C<D     "

"'' 7%"

: "*"

<

;$" '0

 2934 $ "

" 5 '  1  (

   6  '  "   0"    >7;   0   "5"

0  '

    2934  @     (    5   $""

0 '  "

 

 ' "

'

 '("

"'' 56 :;        (    5      

"  '  0

   2934

 :;2  %F (" "

0$"

 '0

>7;  2233 (   0 "5"

0 '"0

  "



 '   '  

"( ''

 

 %

 '

 ); - "''& @5 !"

0  ((   $"

 5 7:;  5  

%  '("

 - "% ' 7%"

<:;  5  

%  '$"   <:; G "!"

0   5  

%  '

$"   4 E( "

0    0      ( "

0  ' 

"1 

 "

"

'

 ' "'' 0"

  

"%

(&  '

"

0  3 <   '"   '"  ((   0"

 

0     '

"1  

'"#((  1 $"

""

0 1"

"(( & 34 ' 92 "%" '"((     

    $# #0            "

  56 5   

'  ("

 '  ,  '5

"6 "

&   , ( 0  "

 " 

' 

 "0"

0

   2934$

( 

- 6 ' 0"  ' "5 "0 (

' %:;  "*"

<

;$" - " %  ' "

 $"

  '0

 2934"

>7;&

 '  "

$"

  '"0

 7%"

?

   (

0

 2233 ("

"'' 7%"

:;2  %F (-"0

"  6 "5 56:; "*"

<

;$" 5 " "% 6"" $  "5 0

 2233 >7;:;@5 !"

0"   0

$'  ' ' %9 '

$  '  5  

$ 09 '

$  ' ?

'  

%

$("  "  2934  2233 - "

 '(6%  '  ); %0"

 '0

>7; 5 "" "0

56 ;< 0<-   (6%   ' 

 %

6 "  (

 -  

" "

 "  6%

5  0

-   ' ( ( 6

5 2 );( ," '9 # 56 " *"

<

;$"    '9 ' +"0

""

B ( ,"95"0?

'   0

  $ $"    ("

"''  -  $   

"(  ' 

  %

6     & (  "

$ "

  "''- ""'" 56 "'' 

 '"5  !

!"

0$"$ % ' ""0"

 ""0 $  5"

"

(( 56'  $"

$

  0

& "  "0"

0

   2934 "(  (6" ( 

-   ':;@5 !"

0("

"''

&   "0"

 0

   2934 $   "' 

 29345

   "''$ 

0 

 "' "

5

0

>7;B

' 

5  ((      "

"       '   1    $   ;

7%"

"

 '@5 !"

0:;("

"''& $  "

0  ;

7%"

"

 H 





    

  

   

 

   





 

 

   

   

!

"





 

 









 

 

# 

"

  

  

 



 

  









 

  $

""

 " 

'  '

 

"

(("

"

!

 ' >

#  ""  (2(  (6 '"0

$( 

$"  "%  '"( "

1  $"

"

$" ("

 (  (6 ' 6 '"0

"

0"  '

<

;$" "

$" (("

"

5 (  ' "1 

 $ (  (6 ' 0

$(

 6 (6 ' 6"

<

;$"  0" $( 

 " 

"

 6"0  '

  

  %  "0 ) %5"%( "

 ' "

0$"

  -   ' ("

"'' 6$ 0"

(  "

 "%  '

 '

     2934  " 



   ' %    

"  '

% >7;  ( 

   

 56   ("

"''   %

$"

   '

     6  "%    5  "

 (  "

   5"  '

>7; 2233- "  ( "

0 

" 0

 2934 2233  (  "

 '

$"

" )( "

 '  ' %9   $ 0"

?

' 0

>7;  "0  ' $  5"

5 ,((  '  "$ "5  (

' % ( 0 '

6 "

?"  $% 00  5  $ %  '

6% 00  6 ' 0

:; @5 !"

0  %

$

56:;2 %F (-"(



"

0 $("   -  5 "

 ' 

'" #((   1        

   );     6  '

 '0

>7; 

6  "% 6 ':; @5 !"

0 :;2 %F (?" 56:;@5 !"

 $ % 00 $":;2 %F ('   ); %

 '  );$

56"%5 % 00

" (

   

 -  ("

"''  

 ,  

  0  '

""0"

 ' $""5  !

!"

0 0

   ''

$"   '(6"

0' 

6(6 '  "

0" '"

"

0 '

"1 

$ "

    

  

 "

 " 

'  "''

 $"

 '%

65

""0"

$"" 5  @"5  !

!"

0'"  "'  (  "

0"

 < 0< 34 " !

"& 43"

$"

0   >7<;9  $        !"

  $"

 '%

6 0

  "I "( ( 6"

'

 '("

"''&  2  7  ')2 ("

"''& 9 4  7  ')2 = 2 );( ,"  9  5"0    

  0

     2934  "0"



 2934"

5

 4;3% (" 

 '  

  0

  >7;     2233     

$ ("

"''

(

% 56 "

0

6

' %

6>7; ' 0"  '<

;$" : "*"

 ?

  '0 "

0 

% '0

 2934  7 0

2233  >7;   

 );""



%

-

" '0

>7;

  );$

""

  "

%

 '  );- "

 ' "

     2934  "

  5

  0

  >7;  - (  "

$  "

% '0

 2934 >"

  $% 00 $":;2 %F (  );

(" :;2 %F (% 00 %

6 (  "

$ "

  "''- ""( "

>7; 

$ 5

'  "  ""0"

 ' 

(     $ "

' % "''  0(  '   

$ 5

$""

$  '0 "

0 ' %"

0  ' """0"



(  5  '"  "

' % "'' " ""0"

$""5      "

 "

( ( 61 %"

0 , $5  "5

 "

"( ( 6  "'''"  "' ( %

"

"

0"%' %"

"

0 "( ( 6- '" $"  >7;2$ %"

 '5 

 $

 " ' % 0

@  

 '5  0

"

$"  >7;2

  ""

 " 

'  "'''

 

"

'  0  " "' %"

'" ' %" $"'

     "0 '("

"''#0

>7; " 6 (

56$6 '

6

 0

>7; $ "5 '" ' %""

0"

 

  < 0 <"0

% ?" (

56:;2 %F (  "

$"

- " 56 <

;$"   );"

56< 0<"

(

 ' "5   "

0$"

  "' " 6(

56:;2 %F (!"

 "

0$"

 '

>7;" 7%"

  $

"6 0 >7;(

' % :; "*"

<

;$" 

0

 '

  0"

"

("

:

 "

$"

 >7;2  %"

 '0

#'

%"

0 , $"

(  '' %  '

'0

   ("

"''$" $ " "' ( %

 '" (  "$""

$ %  ' %"

0 , $ '  '""0"

 

"1 "06(     

6 

    (     

 "

 '

  '   ("

"'' '"

"

0 ' 

"1  " 56

  '" #((   1    @     

6  (6   '  "%" ' 

((  



    

   " ?

  &            , (   0   5



 - "% "

 '""0"

 ' $""5  !

 !"

0     

 '  0

  ( (

  56   ("

"''"

6"%(   "" * 0 >7<;9 '

!

!"

05   '   '"   !

"  & 43   34  $"

  $  

 

- " "$'  (  "

  7  'I  0"

  %  "

09     "

"0

" - " (   I 0  $

$"$ #1<"

" (  '

 ' 

"



0 

 44"" 0A  "0 ' "''

!

 !"

0     ( %

  "

  "

0     < 0<' %"

"

0  6  %

 '

"

0   

-"

0 '

 



 % '  '!

!"

0 < 0< 

:"     "( % < 0< $

 '"( ( ( 656$6 '

"



 44B

1 

0 

<;9 <; "%" "56 "

0("

"''!

!"

0'"  (



0  

 44 " 0 !

!"

0" "   (  "

  7  '

) "  #(( 0"



0  

<;9 <;$ "%"

0 <; 

<; '

#""

<""

* 0  """ - '"0

   2934( (

56 ("

"''" ' "

"  '1"

"!

"& 43 '345

 -  "0"

0

 2934$ ( 

'  

"1  ""(

56$6 ' "

0

6



 (6 ' 6 ' 0"  '<

;$" "(

>7;-

 ' 

'  "  " (

 "

5 

 

5 

(  :; @5 !"

0"

" "% 65 '  1 (

"'"

6     "0"

0

" 

  % ""

 '"

 '"  '"

""

("  ' :

  '

<

;$"   :;   "    *"

 $  

   5 '   

"1  94 (  (6 ' 6 '" 0" 0

 '0

 2934$ 7"5" ;

 "" 5

 56

'  @ $

  "

(

"'"

% $   5

$ 0  ( 

'

   6  0

 

  "

(  :; "*"

<

;$"  $"

" 56"%" < 0<

 60

$""'

-  ' "5"

0 '0

 293456< 0<; "

  % "%" 56"% 5 "( ""$

$"'

-  "$'   (

$ %( "

0 "

%

   

"

$ 5"

@ $

  "

0

  '0  

'   6 "5"

0 '0

>7; 

 ' >7

 '0

>7;" 6(

' % "% 6 ':;<

;$"   "*"

5  ' %     "% 6  '  :;  @5   !"

0  ("

"''  &   $ (

"'"

6 5 6 5 ,  0

  9 '

$  ' "'

=2 );( ," 9 $""

0 '0

$( ( 56 "*"

  <

;$"  

 '< 0< ' %""

0 % 



  "0

@"

"@  "0

#(  % '

  ("  );    "0

- <

;$"  ( "%( "0   % "

"

" 0" @   5"

"0  ' " 0"  '

 (

(6 ' 6 ' 0"  '<

;

$"  ; $"

" 

( 

@ 0"

0

>7;" 5

 5  0

$"

6 ' 0"  '

<

;$" " 5

 " %

 "

%  5

 

 6'  ,  '""

0 5

-

 '

  '         <:;2 @5   !"

0  "

 " "% 65 '  1 %

0

 09 $  '   'I "" 6 "

   "5  5 "0  "

 ? 

("

"'''" 1"

"!

"&  3   432  '   ( %

   "

0       ' % "

"

0 "( ( 6  7  'I - '" $"  ;2 '" 5

" 56 < 0  <  "

 $"     '     "  " & 





  

%   

 





   

 

   

 

  



 

"

 

 

  









   

   

   



   

 

      

' 





  

%   

 

  $ -   ;< 0< 

 '

 2934 0

 2233@"  "

4   0

 

    5 ' 

5  5

 '  '"  '   ("

"'' ( ' % "( '

  $  < 0  <  %"

   6   $""

0    ( ' % " ( ' 

 - %""

 ''  0

 '0

" 

'

 ' "''"

$"  >7;2 

5 5 "    @ !

3 '1   '1"

"

"

 (6 $"

"(  H







 

"

   

 



 



 

    

 





    





 

  

 

    

       (

  

 







  



 

 "



 

    D# 0  "( "  !

3 H 



)

   

 *



 



 

"

     

    D?



 "5"

0 '0

 2934$"

$

0"  ':; <

;$"  ; 

0

 2233>7;" 60 (

56 "''56 7%"

: <

$"  $ (

6 ' 0"  >7;  :;2 %F (  "

0$"

 '0

>7;5   %""

( ' 56$6 ''""

0$"  >7;2"

(

6"

"  "' ( %

"

'" 56 ("

"''  " 1  ' "''"' 

 '0

 2934 $"

$ 0"  '

$"  >7 ; 

 0

 2233 >7; $"

""

"

 ' "

0

 2934-



7"

 ' "

0

 2934" (

' %

" '>7;-"0

""



5" $  

> 0" "%,  '  $"

0 "

0;

&# + +  

, ( 

-  



+  . /   ,% (  +  . 

# "





      /  01 2 00 03 04 526 07 5 86 03 52116 0 5006 0 5016 56 08 51136 50106 . . 









:



. .   

 

"

( "

 

 

( 08222; 5

  

6 

*

 . 

" 

(% + . 

- < - ' - ; - (











 

 ) - - - ; ( /

* 

1;0  

 . -  +  . 

 





 



 02 4  







 "  



( 2222; 5    (

6  "

   



  



  



  *      











 



= 



 

  

 



 

 

 



 

  



( 222; 5   (

6 "



  "

  













  > ) ?

( = -; - ( (; +  .6 



 "

 "



  

 ( 222; 5      (

6 



  )" -

 

(% 



"

    

 

  

 

' 



 





  





 

















 # 





 

 





 

   

 



 

 

  





)



  











"

  





 

   

  "

 





#  

"

 %   # 





 

 





   "





   





 



'

 

 -  



"

   

   





 "



 

 



'

 



 02 24 18    





     





 





 

 



  



  







 

 

+

 01 20 18 !   @ 

@ 

!   . - ; / - (; +  . + + < - ( = -; - ( (; +  .$ - "''$  "   7%"

 "

$"

  '  0

     2934  5

   "    

" 0

 '"0

"

5

0

>7;  2233$ "

$"  >7;2- " (

"'"

>7;  );"

56< 0<"

" (

 '   "%( "0  ':;<

;

$"  "*"

E "( 6 $ :; " *"

 ((  "

   $"

5 7  6  (  5   '"

 2934 "" 5  5

0

>7; 2233 5 "(

''

   ' ("

"''5

 

" '0

>7;  2233 (

' % "% 6 ':;2  %F ( $  ("

"''&  @5 !"

0 $  ((   $"

5 7 :;B

"1 "06 5

&

 



  

5 







   





! ( = 

 

 

   





  



 







   01 20 18

 



 

 



 

  

 

 

  











 



 

 



 02 24 18  

      

 

 

 $ 6   0"

0  "

 $"     >7;2  "

(

6"

"  "& 3 '432 "''

'"  ( ' % "( '

  $6

  %"

   6    ( ' %  "  (       "

"56 %"

 '5  0

 - "

" $"  >7;2" , ( ""0 $ 5"

5 ,((  5  % '  0

>7; $  

 "

  $""

0  @          

 '

 2934-

" '0

>7; (

 "

 6$" $" ( 0"

5 $

"

- ;< 0< $  ((   $"

5 7"

" "% 65 '  1 "%(6

 '0

 2934  6  0

@   ""0

>7; :)#@ "  $ 6$"

5

7(    "0 

  0  '""

0  '  1"

"  !

"  & 34  '

4356("

"''0"

"%   7(  "0 



'" $"  >7;2"

"     (    $'" 56 "''0"

"%

"  '" 6$"  # 0  '"  ;

7%"

"

  '" $"   0



#

5 !"5!"

0 "

"' ( %

"

5 5 

6 ' %$ 6( ""

0B

"1  

8" #((  1 "06

""(

 0

   "( ( 6  "'''  % ' 2);( ," '95"0

 );

%

6 6

$

 $""

05 (  "

$  "

 (   "'' (  "

 5

 $

%5 ">7$ 1  &  "" 6%

 ("

"'' (  "

 ' "( ( 6 5" '

 2233- 

"1 "06

 &

    





 

  '



  



" 

 



 







A  



  



    

 

 "





     



" 





  

 



 

 



 

" 



 

B

" 



 1  188  

  

 

 



  

 





 





*   



 

 

 



  18



   

 

      



  188 $ -

0

 2934 ' " I "( ( 6' 

" "

 ' 2 );( ," '9 

 );

%

6 2934 

6 '$"

$% 0"  ':; <

;$"  >7;

 

 5

0

 2233  >7 ;  "

"

 '  (

  0

     2934  

 );  $  

   2233        $    (

"'"

"( "

0

>7; $"



$ '

 ' "''

0 %"

0

" "

%

$ $""   5 

""

 '( "

0 "   (  56(   "'' 5 '"  "

' % "'' ""0"

$""5       $

((   0"



0    

    >7<;2  $ "%" >7<;- " " 0"6 (

"6"

'"

"

0 '

"1  

8"#((  1 

0

 ' 3934 >7; 2233 >7;  "''$6 %"

 6 $""

0 " 6 $""

0 ( ' % "( '

  "06

5 "

&  "

'

 ' "'' 0"

 

   " ?

& 9  ( "

0 "%""

 #

  "

  "

 0

  >7;    "    (

"'"

 

"   $"



'

 ' "'''

"(  '   %"

0  

" "

 $  $"  "     56( 

""

 '( "

0 " "- " "

%  $" 0  ' " "- "% ' 5 0

 '""

0 ' " "56"5  !

!"

0

34 $"

$

 

0 >7<;9 

>7<; (( 0"

 "

0  

>7<;9 >7<; $



0 >7<; 

>7<;- "''

(

"'"

6 (    '"  "

' % % """0"

  

 

 "

"( ( 6 6'"  "' 

  ( %

"

$"



 '

   :"  >7;2'" 56 < 0 <  "

 "  "   "  '   ( %

  "

    6  5

"

  $ "  6

 '0

5 6 (   "''$ $""

0 ( ' % "( '

  $65

6 ( ' %"(- $"

 >7;2$'" 56 22 " "$0 "%" $"$ 56 "'' 6'" (  " 2" $""

$ %  ' %"

0 , $  %  ""0"

$""5   ?

%



 '0

  5

$"(0  '

"%    %,     '    ( ( 6     5

 "

 $"

 >7;2 '" 56 "

(

6"

"  "'  ( %

"

(

"'"

6(   

 '  " %   B (  "" "

 '

"

' 

"0

 "" ! ' "%""

 

0

>7;  2934 $"

$ 7 0

>7; 2233"

 

5 %   5 "

 '

@ /5  #( 7  1   "

 

!

!"  !"  #$   $ %  &

%#%'( )*+ !"#$ ,--.*+  */0/)+.-1 ?

"   "$"(  0

( ' %

$ 5

"%% " 6 %"

"

 '1 (

"

0-

(

"

0 %"

3 "$ "$ 5

"   '"7 ' ( ' %

$3 "%""

 '26  ' (

"'"

( ' %

$ ' %3?$'

  

  7( "

H '"7 D"

#"

 'B"%""

#

 5    5 "% ( " '"7 $"

 

"

  (( 0 '$"

" '"

"  - '   

  "  1      8" #((   1  "06

 "' (  "

56(

"'"

( ' %

 '

"'" $""

( "  '"%""



 - 2 - 

"1 '% "

& '  $;

H:

 ""5

 

11  211D?

 "

 "'''" 1"

"!

" & 34 '43)4220"

 ' ( %

"

0"%' %'  "56"(  "

0 "''' % "( ( 6"  

  '+"0

" - "

(  ' %"

"

0  '

"

0"I % 6  (     "''?$ 6' '""

0 '

$"  >7;2"

" " "'' %  , $  "

"

 '

% '

" '

>7; ;#' '""

0 '$"  >7;256   " "' ( %

"

$$"$ 56 "'' ""

 ' (  "

56$6 '(

"'"

( ' %

 '0

 ' 5

'" 

0 ( 

5" ' 

11 !

211  (  " "5  

5 %   5 "

 '@ J5 !

( "

% 2%3/!'0 

) )  ,*4+5 16 $ ""

 (  '5

 

115 0

 5" 5 5" "'  "6

5 ( % 6



5" '"

"  0?$ (  '5

 

 ' 11 5 5" 6"' '"

( "

0"

(

 " 56(

   " "6 '  ' $  "# 5

"

  ""'" $""

( "  '"%""

 "

 " 0' ( %

"

$ " "6 '  '

(

 " (  "$"

"' (  "

56$6 '

(

"'"

( ' %

 '0

   (

"

"  " $"   (   %  

"1  8" #((  1 "06  ""

 $ 5

 

 !

2 '115

 '

5  "$"''

 0( "

0  % ( ( 6 - '  '"

"

0 ' 

"1  '"#((  1 

""

 ( 

 .,4,5 !"1 9 - ,  0 5

("

"''

 '  '" ">7

 '0

>7; ;

 56     

"( '

  %

  '    

 );'   ' "( ( 6" 6(

56 "'' :; @5 !"

0 (

" "

 $""

 ' ("

"'' ( ' % "( '

  $'" ( '  "

' % "''"""0"

$"" 5   (    - '  "''

   '  '" "  

" "5   "'' (

' %$"

" 5

      ("

"''    ((   ' % '""

0     "  -

   '"  (

 "( ( 6"



 "

$"  0

"6?

% 6  "

 '

% '0

>7; ;   , (  "( ( 6"

( ( 6:

 '"    6

 (

"' - "( ( 6"  '

" ( ( 6 ' ' %"' 56$6 '

 44- '"

"

0 ' 

"1  '"#((    "

 (  "



0"

  '

 ' "''

 6  & $ % ( "

"$  "'' " '  (  "

56$6 '(

"'"

( ' %

 '0

 >7;  2934 0

>7; 2233

5 %  !

 ' !(

"'"

"

'#  $"



 &2 %2#/#%#$"($ 7

!8$78!#

8# 516 ! 

 %





    



"    



# ) 

'  1 

16 



    



  



   



 

   

  





   



   

      "



  

  

 

 

           "



          

 

  





  

    56

C   

 



 

     

    



   

     "

   

   



 



  





       

 



 

  



     



     

 



   



4 





   

         D

" 





   

     



   

 "



         

 



 

 

 

         

!



  

   

 

 



 

 

 

          

"  

    516 

 



   

  



   





     C  

     



    

   

 

    





     $ ?$   0  ' "

' '(

"'"

( ' %

" " 6 $" 5 0 "' (6

,"

0 %  (( 

  

  $"     ?

9

/!

 /""/:%/  0  

)/!'

 ,*-.+5-.,"$ 5

 E00 

* 





 

 

 

 

    

   









  

     



 

"

 

  



 







  

  % 

" 



 





  







 



        



 

" 

  





   

  



  



 

    $ ?

 %) (( !0 # );



/<  ,

--516  @ J5 !

( 1  '  $;

E

% 

  

   

 

 



)

 

 "  

  



  



 



 ,   



  

 

   





)



 







    

 

 

  



        

 )   

"





     - 256 



-   ( 

'  

  

  



)





 

 #





 



 



 



   " 

"





 



)

 



 

 

" 



 

-     

 





 







 



 

  

 









 

 

#



  * 

 

   



  



)

  

     





 

-    "%"  ''

  "    

0   '  @ J5 !

(  1   "

  %#% /*"$ "+  2;     0 !'

)  !"

#$   ,

--5 $ "5

" $ $ ( ' %

 '

 "

 % "(  $"

" ' 

1 %6( ( 6 " ""  

(

"'"

( ' %

 ?

  '

*%5 ">7;     ("

"''    "

 (  "

   "  ( ( 6  "

  %  '

     2233   '      "  ( ( 6  $ 

% 00 - $ "

(  "

 ' "( ( 6 "%  '

 2934 2233- "

$" 

 , (  "

"

0 





5

 '"

 

 ' "( ( 6@" 6

" "0"

 "   "( ( 6" 6

 '"

 "''$  6 $""

0 ( ' % "( '

 $  %"

 6 $""

0- '"  (

 6

'  %"

"

 '" ""0"

$""5   !

!"

0 

"

' % "'' 056(  "

0 ( % (6"% %"

0

" "

 "$""

 



'

 '

("

"''- '  "%(65

 ("

 ' "( ( 6

 $" (0  '"% " 0

 

"

"

' '

(

"'"

( ' %

 '0

; ;&  

" (

$"

5 "''' %0 "

0 

"'

  6

(( 

1 $"

 B

"1  8"#((  1 "06   "'' " ' (  "

 $

 ' "( ( 656 (

"'"

( ' %

 '5

 0

56

 '

 ' "( ( 6"

"'

- '"

"

0 ' 

-"1  8"#((  1  "

& 2 (  ""

"

'

 ' "''    =  ?

$ 6" '  

6



 $ 0  '

'  ("

"

 5

   "   % "  "

      

  ((      "  "%"  $(

)     *  

  Whether Speaking/Reasoned Yes/No Whether Reportable Yes/No