Kanta Kumari Bhatia And ANR v. Baljit Singh And ORS





  
 


























 

   !!" # "" !$%& '

"   

"















(')!  !! # "" !$%& '

"   

"


!"#$

%&'() $
'&)$
*&+(

* (+%

','+ - .



!!"/ !" ( 

0,'+ -

(&'"

(- ','+ - .

  1/ !" ( 

,'+ - .

  23
"-   0 / !" ',-.-
*,/0
%

" $'&  4!! '"

. /  -  ' 4  !" .!

' /0 

 -!" "

5& -   4'

' /0 

 (  --'

 !" /!, % 6!  .

 "7

/!78 9  ' ' )!   4"    ""

/!0, 0, 4

 ' '   --'

  

 + & & . :;<:=111>>:, 4

 4" + !!&  (# %319;?" -!",   1?;= 1>>2, +

-!

' 4"  /0 -5 / &

 &"    
)3;1:@ 6!   .

  " A

..

'&

-!

B8, 4  4" / & '+  /0     13!$ %&    "

 '  &!&     

..

'& +

-!

-  . 

"  "'

 '  5  

 -5 & & 

' .  '  

   

 ( #  4 ' ' )!   !

&4  (' )!  4 + !!&


--'

/ ')! '(' )!   + ' $ "  ' )!   "--/

 $ "  

 "

 4  (' )!  4" 5    !  " !, %    "

 " - '   

  4" 

 !-  +'

   ?:; ' ' :=111>>:, &" '

!- %  ? (' )!  6 !!      2: . 1>>;8 .!

 -!&- .



$ ""..

'/0

  --'

 4 ..

'& +

-!

 "  -!3(' )!,

'"..

'! !

$ " "!&.-

. "

.

 &  ", .- . &  - '0!

&  ",.- .& !4 -& .'! + '.-

& "'

/"

" !"

 + '-"



.-  "!&'".&  4"!!0'  ! " !,% . 4

4""

. (

 "& , '/'4

4"

 '' !& &  "'"

 . '4"- 

$

- - '''

 '- ' - "

"& ' .

4&' '& ""& " 4"& '2C0 "

 .--'

'4"  !

'4 % 5 .
', +& !0- .
C:::<3

  2 !3 6 !!   1?;= .1>>28!!

& '

'')! 4"& 2; 0 "  &   . )  ""

/!0, 0

4" -+ !-, "

-! 4 5  ' /" "" +& !0 - .
1;,:::<3   4" !"

    (<" % 5 "&  '4" +& &!-
;:::<3  &!

&"!

4"& &
9;::<3  / "'

" 

",

"

, ,  ' !!

4- .
1:::<3

& ;

" - "

 -!  "   '&     --'

 ' 5  !-  '    "

 ' &!&  '+&

..

'& +

-!

 /0     1

 --'

 ' 

 5  !-  -- . "

 ' &!& '+& .(#/0')! 6'

'8,

 4" '+&  " +

-!

 "

!0 '  &!& !0   &

'' 

..

'&+

-!

 =   "! +'

- , 

 /!  '

.'& 

--'

4"-"

''  "

' &!&  '+&

..

'&+

-!

/0"'+ 

/!!!

.
1 !- .

 $ " "..

' /0 -!3 (')!4 -!3 + '

!!

'- .
?,@2,:::<3 C   "". ', -!"    4  / -    !"

5&

- 

"!!

'/0

/! @  !!

4& - .
1 !-   -! (' )! , 

 /! 

5   --  .

!!

4&

 .- "*3 68 

  '' ' ! " !, %  ' 

  (

 "&  ,

'/'. :=111>>: ?:111>>:F 68 

4"

 ' .

+ ".- '  ' 4" "

 '  "'

"   !& ' !&4"!"

F 68 

 "..

' 2:G '"/!0, 4  4" 

 '"/!0F 6+8 -! '"

 "  4 / & .  '- " '

" ! & - !"

  !

.

9; '0". 

--'

/ ' "..

'0 .-! !

"" "

+ ' .!! "!0 '& "  ' 

. ,

 $  ' ' 

"' "F' 6+8 

 4" +& "

 '..-!0  4& ' "& '4" 4 & / & >  &



4'

'.

'

.')! ,

/!""

""

"- "
?:::<3 . 4 1<?' 4" '- 4'" " ! " ' /0  !0& 

! ! .1=,- .
?,@2,:::<34"!!

' 1:  '- "

!.



!!" "& 

-"

.(')!,-! " 



"

" !H , 

&  !

"  4'"  '-!   - !' / / &  ' '!"

"..

'"/!0 4 , 

& , 4"   '

-! ' "   '"/!0 / 

 /! "   !!

' 0 - 4'"

" ! - & ",  '-! ", .   '-!

", '"..

&, '- & ", "' , .   -", !

.   . !.

, '"/!0 "..

' /0

  -! -
 4"   .!

   -! ' "..

 .- "   4"

 ' .

 !&, !& ' "

 . /!

  . .- $ "
 "I +'

  . '"- & ' "

'

 .   '-! ", 0"

 0 '  +! .  "

 '/0

- .  3 "/  .
1 !-!!

'/0

/!" $"' /!

  11


 .'

.')! ,!

 "

! .

  !!" " & 

 4" /  2; " .& 

/! "5 "- "
?:::<3  4  5

&  + 4 ""

' 4" "'



'4" .) ""

/!0, 0'4"!"

/" ""

& ,-!"- !'   '-  0 +'

-    "  &', ' "!! 

 /! !0& +'

-   ' - !' + 0 4 !! ""

"" -

'"
;:::<3 " /"

+ "

-"

.
 

  
  

   

 -!"  !

 ''   -

4'" .   -", !

. !

 ' ..

- , - '&'- .



 - !',!

.



4.

'. ! " 19  ' - "

!  &     23
"-    0 " &   

 -!  -!3(')!6 !!   2: .1>>;8,

/! " 5    --  !! 

 .- " -!'& "

" !H ,  '-! ",  ' "..

& - 4

  4'&- .
1!-! ",4 "$"' /!

'-!!".

 .

-  1?  ' - "

! .

     23
"-   0 ".

& 

- !!

'.

.')! ,/0

/!"! '0 &

"'

 " 

 /! "  ! ' ! ! . 1= 
 .- 

! ! - '" .11"-!3 +  " &+ &

'

" ";;0 "

!!

'/0

/!"
?,@2,:::<3"$" ' /!

-!!&.

 -  12
  &+   - .! 

&    "/"" "  ' - "

! .

  " ' "! .  '

/!.' - !!

'/0

/!/

 -"

" -!! .

-  " 

 /!  

 -"

(')! " ""

""

' /0 5&   --  !! 

+  !

'" "

 !0

& , (' )!  4"   !

. %  5
'' " "..

'0!

.- '  !

"5 /0  /  " .-  - !0 -!!" .

 !!

4&

 "!"

"..

'4 5 "& ', " ..

- '  !0 " '!0 !.

 / !"

" . -"

/!

5 -- !0

 0 "

  - & "  + ' /0 

-  ' '!0,

 '' '

" !.

/ 9: 9;'0"'

' / 

" ! ", '- & ", "' '"

 - & -+ . '"- & , ,

'  + ' ! !

 .- ",  I " -  "

 '-!-

-5 ,  '!"

0"

 0

& ,

'"..

'2:G'"/!0,4 4"  ,/ " .-  !"

 -!!" .

 4'& "

  " --  1; 

&  + 4 !! 

 / .- ", 

  4 -!3(')!" !

'," ""

""

'".

!!

4"*3
 

    !"    68 ( '-!
>C::6  .!

8
;::D9;K19;:: 68  " !- & "' '-!

"J
;::<3 '0.

9; '0" 68   '-!
1:::: 6+8 '"..

&
1:::: 6+8  "'
1:::: 6+8  '- &
1:::: 6+8 "

 - &
;::: 6+8 ) .. -"
?:::: 6D8 ) .  .!.

9:::: 6D8  .

2:G'"/!0
9;::: 
1299::
1=
 

 -"

. '

. ' )!  , 

/!

5 "- "
?:::<3 4 " / !

"'

5

&+ 4""

',4

4" .) ""

/!0,0'4"& & + " !!

4- " !"  !!

&  

!"

  /" "" ' 4" -  D 0

 / - !'  '- +'

- " -  .  /" "" ' -  D   ' 1C " .) ""

/!0,

4"& &

 . !!

4- " / "'

" "!0 

&  + 4 

 "" ', " -  " 5  "
;:::<3    ' . 5&'

'- .1<?'. -

4'"

! ",  . '

-0 4 5"    / 6
;:::31===8
???2<3 " '- &!

,

/! "5 &

'"2C0 "/-!3  + 4 &" E31 "" '&

'";;0 " &4.

,"

"

/ "  !! &

"/' +

4"

, 

' 4"  . )  ""

/!0 ' 

 4  / - " +!/!

     &

', 4 /

 !-  '(  & .&

'

"  

"2C<2@0 "!

""&.-- + 4

 "  . 4.

', " "- , &

'"5 ";;0 ""  "!' 4  # $  

  %  & '

 

     

   (  , ! ! . 11 "  !-/!

  5 

 .'

-0" /"

+ "

-"

.
 "'

, -!"   !"

!

 1;G '' -

4'". -"

--'

 '5  !- 

0 1>>:


-"

.
 "'

, 4

 

 --'

 ' 5  !-   

 0  9::C,

  4'"!

.!

'..

- , -  ' &'-  .

   - !'  4" !!

' "
1 !- 

&+ 4

 - '

D

0 1>>=,-!"

!


;:,:::<3 4'"!

.!

'..

- ,- ' &'-  .

!' ' 

 " .
;:,:::<3  4'"

  . -  .

 4.

 '
1:,:::<3 .

 . !

"

  4 -!"

!

',"/! '".

!!

4"*3

 

    !"    68
-

'')!  
;::: 68 1;G .68/  / ''

'" . -"
;:::L
C;:K
;C;:  68 1<?' .68'

'- '" !

'
;C;:3
1>1=K
?@?2  6+8  . ! ! .11 " ! ' 6
?@?2M19M118 K
;:=:@@ '

.. ;:=1:: 6+8 " ,!

'..

-
;:::: 6+8 ) 
;:::: 6+8  ! "
1:::: 
=1=1:: 1@  ""

I ! .0/ '"-"" ,/ 

!"   -- ' 4'

 /! "  '. ' ' 

!!

-!3(')!6   2: .1>>;8" - '. 
1,::,:::<3 
1,29,9::<3'.

. ' )!   6     1?;= . 1>>28  !!

' /0 

 /! " - ' . 
?,@2,:::<3
=,1=,1::<3

- 

 4!! -0  " J C;G   .  

' ..!&

-!  "!!-! !H 

-1
0


















'&)$
*&+(
$5






















%&*$