M/S. Cheminova India Limited And ORS v. State Of Punjab And Others
IN TH HE HIGH COURT FOR THE E STATES OF PUNJAB AND HANDIGARH HARYANA AT CH 2
7
%
898 2
!""
#
$
7
% 8 2
%
#"
7
%
( 8 :
# ( 2 9
9 &'(
)&*+,- ./0- '*)'
,'0'
+%$ ,% - ! "
"#"$% ,% - & '
,"$$% ,% - ( )
' !* '*)'
'
,'0'1 .
*
./ * 1
, * * ( "- -, % &$'$&$"#( ) )
02 0
* 0
,% -
0 * 3 0 0 /2 0 ,+
- - /* $ 6 4/
/ / 5 / * * ( $4 54 5 6 - ,+ $$ $ 7 +8- %
!"#$ $ )
* 0 7 7 0 0 3
( 0
9'
/ 0/ 0 0
/* * 0 *
; ,
7 7 0 0/
9 '
0 8" * 0
. ": ' / / / /
* 9 6#%0 . ":' // /
/
/
+8-
*0 0 / ;
9'
/ / / * 7 7 ; / 7
0 < *
$- ,#
/ * 7 /
,-
/ / * * / 7( 0
0 ":
0 / * $ 88:
7
/
/ * (/ / 3
( 0
9'
( ,"4,5
+8-
( / / 9
7 <
) 0 0 9 '
/ /
9 7 < / /
// 9 *
( $4 54 5 6 -,+ $$ +8- / 0 0 0 0,+
-* "
7 0 *
0 / 0,+
- * 9 / 9 * 0 *
8
< / # 9 7 $ 9'
/
0 7
/1 0
9 * # 0 * 0 # 6 / 9 9 =
#0
/ * , / 0 > 9 . * 0
* 7 0 * ,
* 0 ,#
*
,-
7/0 %#
,
/
%6
,
(/ /
#%- %-
/ / ,+
-
1 ./ / 0 1
? 0 0 0 0
,
0 / 0 ,, %+ 6 * 7 7 * 0 / *0 **2 2 0
9
* .
!
"# " $ # %&
' $ ( ) * !
! "#" $ #/-'
) $ * !
"# )+ , ,
-
( ) *
'
& & ' -
# * * ( 7 0 *
' !* 0
0/* 0/ * * * // / / 0 0 0/ /
0 / ,/0 0>
9
*
+8- . 0
**
* * * 0* 0 7 ,
. ":' 9'
* * / /
,-
/
/ * * 0* * 0 * 0
0
0 / * $ 88:
;
0
": ' / * 0 / 0 ( $4 4 54 5 +8- 0 *
/
( 6 -/ / *( ,+ +8-
,-
/0 ,+
-/ * ( "8 8+
- @( $$ +8-/ * / * * * / / / 0 / * * / * *0 * ** 0 0
, / 0 0 >
9 0 * 0 0 0 * 0 / $ " 0 0 '/70
9 7 * * ,/ * * + )
/*
1
/ 0 ( ,+
+8- ,+ &#
5?
2
:
45 1 * *
* * *4 5* 4
5* 4
5 4 5 $A 4*5 / 0 A A 45 1 * * * / A 45 *
,6A 45 / * * * ,6* */ A 45 * 7 7 1
/ 0 B* * *A 5 / / 1/ / / * * / 1 / *A
5 *2/ / 1 1/ / / * * / 1
/ * C 4,5 ?
*
*/ B/ *
* / 1
/ 1 1 *C 4$5?
0 0 *
*D 5 / / 1B / / *
2
*/ 1/ / *C
5 *2/ / 1 1B// / / * * / 1 / *C 4"5 7
/ * / */ *2
E * * /
( $% +8-
$% <#
# = = ""6
% #
'# D 5(
* / 0 2
/ /
4,5@ 6 * * * *D D 4,5@ 6 * * * *A 45* *
0 * 2 0 * / 0
2 AF 45* *
0 * 2
0 * / 0
2 A 4*5 1* ** 1 4$5 *
0 * * *
D 452
* A 4*5 / / * 0 /
A 45 / / /
/2
( $ +8-
$
>?# "
#
4 5 * 1 * / ( ' * *(' 4,5
B 0 3 0 C
, @( $$ +8- $$ &#
= #%
5 ? *
* / / / 0 / * * / * * 0 * ** 0 0
0 * *
/ / / / 0 1 0 4,5 / 0 0 * 5 / * * * *
** 0 > 0 ( > 0 ( **0 * * * * 0
0 G1 D@ D 45H I *
A 4*5H I
( "8-
$ "8- , $> #> ?# "% %
" 5 G1 /
/
0 = = 0 * 4,51
4,5 * 45 1 */ A 4*5 */ 1 0 A 45 */ 1 0 *1 0 4$5@ / * 0 * / / *
*
"
( "8+
"8+ # % " 4 5
45 A 4*5/ / /
00 * / /0 0 / A 45/ / *//
/ / / 00 * 0 / 4,5 7 0 /
* *1
# / 0 7 9
,-
0* * ./ /0,+
-/
* ,6
7 0* ( 7 <* @ * /
%6
,
( "8+
* ,
./ 0 * %6
,
0
0 ,-
/0 * * / 7 <* @ * *
%
,
7 0 <* ,-
/
* 0 / ( "8+
/ ,+
- * * 7 0
E 4 5
@ / / 0 7 0/ * 0 / *
/ * / * 0 * 0 * 09 * 0
( $%4$5 +8- 0 0* 6 0 0 ' 1 * 1.
2** ' 345 !"
"#" $ #&
7 / 0 )
( ) $ * . ( (5 / ,% %"
,%,,
0 0 9 *
* = * 0 // /
0
- / 0 / /
(9 '
** * * * / * 09 7 < 0* * ** *
/ 0 . * 0 ** 22
* 9
+ 7
/ *
0 0 2
0 00 4 * 5 0 0! * 0 / 0 / *
0
,% -4 1 ,5
0 0 ,+
-4 1 5/ *2 0 22 < * (MANISHA BATRA) JUDGE 2 9
Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No Yes/No Whether reportable