Raj Kumar And ANR v. State Of Haryana And ANR.
! " #$ % &' ' Judgment pronounced on: 30.11.2023
STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER
()*('+ , +'- .....
!
"# $%& '(# )*
#"#+ ,%-#&$&#.## )*
///// , +'-/'0#123 1.
#.0# 1.* * *# ' * ' 2# ) (# 34 56 # 758 2 , ( 57957:9;;9689;<: ) * 4 # #% = & 58 )
* >* 4=? * ))( , ( ;:6 4= -# # # * ))(, (;<:4=-# % %##%( #=. @#*# ,2#*& ( *#++# 0 * 4' 2#2 2(. @)%. ,00#A &*(# )* *#*#1' 34 *# 1 2 * #0 ) #+ ,0# # . #%%22*#* #.)*( &*-*%# - 1.* 0 %. ) 22 * #0 #* )%% -* * 5
-2- #%2-** #((0 %( (" , #B,#%-**0# 2#'1#2 *0# #% #(* )0*0 (*#%%2# 0# ,#(2A#1% ))(& * 34 -# 2 # ' 2# (00( *
-# 1.* %(* #0 #.# ,( 1) *=,* -%# 1#%',#%%.# (;:6 4=-# # # (;<:4=-# % & 0
-# ,2* !# *#((, * # 0
-# 2# 1.* ,1 ' #% , (#% #2 # 0 #((, - # -*% * -2# *((
) !# 1#%4 #%%2 *#* # 34 *# 12 #* #() $, #-*-*0
#%2#1)*='%=,)* #0%# -*(** (0 %##(%#0 *#'1 )%%, #**0 %.)* (0 %##'A* ) #* ,-# #")(1%
)*%# ,(*# 1.*0
#='%=, ( # 555:5 *#'21 #
, 5:)5:<:# -*(*
)*
, %# *# 1 *# ' * ' ) * *
%( #%%. )#% :<58 #2# 0 #((, # *#)# ,
%0#.(*#%%#-# )% 5:58#2# * 0#2#((, 4 #' *#* # ' 2#-# # , *)%,() $, #-* *#'2 #%2 -***2* %( #,* (0 %#-# #% 0# 1. 5* ##% =00
) (* ,%=# #%*2# 2*#0 #2#112 * %# # #2# *%(-"2, *)%,() $, # B,.-# ( ,( 1.* ##%=00
) (* ,%=# # # -#% *# * ()4
($#%)%( 8:584-# #%%2 *#* %(-# -"2, )%,()
-3-
0($#%) %(-*,#02#. * ##% =00
) (* ,% =#
()(#%%.( #) 2%# (( C )#% 0 %(# ) * C , # ) 2 #1, * )#% , ( 5<; == 12 -2 ),* ) 2-# #% ( *#*))( -1# *#
#(*# - '(&*' 2#)*(# ,2*1# ) 0*#2(.( ,(#)# 1 ; %.1*#%))*
*# 1)% -**# 1 )0 *# * ' 2# * 0# *# #%# . 1 ((%, # * )#% *# 1 )% #2# # #0& *#&
, * # ,% # -%% # # ,
%0#. #2# #((, #'#& #+ ,0# # #+ * 4 -# #% , *# * ##% =00
) (* ,% =# *# #% ( *# * ),* ' 2#*(# 1( ,( *,2** #=0@#(*
(* #
1.* ##%=00
) (* ,% =# -# # +, (#. #,# ))(# #'%% 1. * -' * ##%=00
) (* ,% =# , (%;;)* = ,)4 #&*(&* # )* ##%=00
-# (*#%%2 =D!587<)58# #.-# 2# 8:58 #2# *0 ,2 7 4 *#' *# %# (, % ) * # # *#' 2 *,2** (,0 #
#%2-** 6 *)#( # ( #1'0#,
, *(# ) ) "2# ))' 2# 1# *2, # , ! *#*(0 %##*# % 2 *34#* #()
-4- $, #-*-*0**# # 2('%
, $, # *# (#( -* *2* %( ))(#% # E %2* #0
,A* *' 2#2#2(.*# 1-"2, )%,()# $ #" ))( C *# (* 2 * ' (
,( 1.* ' * ##%=00
) (* ,% =# *# #%# .*% *' 2# ,)) )0 1# # * 12 ( 8 *#1'( *#'1( #%2-*=D!
587<!58-*(**#'1# 1.*(, %# *# 1 ' # , ! # * ' 2# -# ((%, # )#% *# #%# . 1 )% # -*(* * -# *0 %) (#(*0'%# 1 *==)#2) 1.* *- #.)#(# *((,% 1 0 *# -# #* %#()((,( ( *))()* -# %.## #();"0 # %#)(,% 1 #(( * *# #0 *((,(1#5 #0 -*# " %#()55 #0 * ##% =00
) (* ,% =# #'%% 1. * -, (%;;6)*= ,) 4 # C #
#2# , ( 5<; # ,2#) 2)(()* -*(* #
-5- # +, (#.),(# * # *# 1 #. 1.* =, ) '*,2*#%%2#))%,() 0$#"))( 0# & *-'& ,(* ))( #0 0# # #. *#%%2#-# *, 2#% 2 * ##%=00
) (* ,% =# *# 0##% ,1 ## ) 2 *
, # *, -* # )+, (#% (,. < ' * (# &* *# * (% *#0)#.#%%2 ),(#. #1% * #.%") $, #-** # ))(3,*& ,(*))()*#")$ ' $, #-* #%%2 E)%,(*# 10 %# #
* (# (' * #%%2# %'% %% ),*& ' *,2* * *# 0 *# # ='% , , 1. #2# $, #& *-'& * 0)#. #
#.#
%(#, ;:,%5# &)#.&# # -**
)* 2# 2*%# B, *# 1 #(( 1. * ='% =, # # 0 0# , *(#1 ,0 )*#1')#(# * #0 B, 1
%# # 0#)#( #1% * 1)#' 2#( ,( 1.# 4' 2#22(.(#1B, # *#,* 0#.(#%% , E %#*' 2#90 ( ,(&)#.3,*&* #% )#% (% # *-*(0 %## #+ ,0## . %# $, # # -*. -,% $, # '%' *0 %) * (0#%0 (%%#, #
#%. 0 1)% 1.#1,2 0'# # ))#% 0 %(#-*, #1% *2*%"
-6- # (0 %2 * (*# ) ' -*(* ,(* #%%2# 9#1, 0#.1 (' *#'#. 01%#(),* *F1% , 0=,)4 #*0#)
#
!"#$ *% # , >
! " # $ ! % $
% # ! ! # " ! ! ! # # # & '
% # # # ( : * F1% E =,& * 0# ) %
-7- & '
( #
)! #*) *# ),**% # , ) * " # # ! ! & # +,- + ! ! % .
/ 0& # + , 1.
/ 0&# + ,2
343 +
56 72
354 5+
2 48 69 ! # +,
% 7 24 + ## 24 # # 24 # :
" ; . # +< , 2;. # +< ,
354 +
372
3543+
2 48 59 =%0 > # " # # - , + # ?
@A > - =%0 =%0@ " =%0 ## B?C
-8- =%0D # + % # - % + " + & =%0 + 8 C !
! & " # E +
-95 4 * 0# ) +,-, . / (, (,',(0 (
#
"!
*) &*F1% , 0=,)4 #*% # , )3 " ## " # + # # -
% % # ! & # + - # @ # @ # - + A # # < -! # 2/B C ?
# < % 223** 4 3 +
* 9 0 + + # + < , 13**5+ 234+
3573**5+
2 4 56%03**5 + 64 , & F F # +, &223**543+
73**5+
2 45887 %0 3**5 + 3
4 / D # < % 123** 4 +
3**73** +
2 4
59<% # + . C223** 4 +
8
7%03** + 354 G # + B & 12
334 3 +
7
-10-
4 +
2 4
67%0
33+ 3 640& +,# +2D "G422
3343+
*7 2
4 3 +
2 4 6 9 + , & # G#,+ 2
33435+
72
45 +
2 #43 57%0
+ 594 % 0 +- # + B &
4 +
72
4 +
2 43
4 , G + B & - - B &, # " + B & # + # " & # + # " # +# # # ( 55 3,*& * F1% , 0 =, ) 4 # * 0#) 1 2
/!
#
" 3 * # * 0#) 4 5 + 6
#
"!#) *% # , )5 % F . 2F . #
-11- + 2
4 3 +
8* 7
+
';+ 6654 # - & #
%@ ! @ %+
5588 # 7 % > > # B# #
% - +
# , G 0 2+A
# ,G 0 2
4+
8 372
4 +
2 45 34 # #
% 7 @
% $
% # ! ! # " ! ! ! # # #
-12- & '
% # # # @
%# C%H0 I +# # +02C%H0 I +# # +02
48+
8 3
+
2;H+4
84 $
% F
#
%
% %# & ## & ## -
% # # # -
% "!
# %$
% # ! , G 0 1+ A
# , G 0 2
4 +
8 37
4 +
2 4 5 34 # # # !
-13- ## #-!
# %# # & 5* A # # # # # " !
# -# # # %
% # 0& B2
%# 0& B23** 433+
873** +
2 46673** ;< 4 # A # #
-14- # # " # @ @ @ ! % #
%
! ! ( 5 3,*& * 0# ) 21 #
7!* 7 -*-# *% # , !
# # # " # " $ # A # # ! A - & # # & # " #
A " # # # ! ! & # % #
-15- & # # # A > D - # - & % # # # # % % - # # % # # @ # K A # # K# # K" @ @ # @L!
-16- 1
*! #"
&-*-# *% # ,
%& # " # > F# ! # " # # % # ! # !
' > " # " %# - 57 * %#- ) "2 # ) ) ' 2# #. * #2(.12-%%%# -&*, % * #1% **#
,(*E( #%((,0 #( E * (# # -,% (
# )( ) ' 2# #. * #2(. ( * - E#!
-17- #.# B, 1E(
#2%.&#%%2# *##
,
1.#.(20##%(#1% , )'"2 ,(*
-*
1%.)*2*))(#% #2' 2#*# 1#% # ( ' $'2 0,(* -2*#2 2#%& '#2, # ,(1# #%%2# (# ) 1 (, ,(' # #
, ( 1% 1 ' # % ) 2 ' 2# * * ((,0 #( * (,0 ( ,
* ' ( # * ' 2#((%, (#1 # 1#1 , ##% 56
0##% *# 1 , , * 1# -*) * E#!
#. - ) 2#' - 1 E( # * #2 * *2 ( * 1# -*)& 0#. 1 ,0 *# * 4' 2#2 2(. *# ( ,( * ' 2# # 1# ##% 0#* #% #%%2##2# #. 94' 2#2))( * ' ,#%(# #(.# *(&0'(#10 , 0 % #2# *4' 2#2))(*2(.*)#% *# #%# . 1 )% # 2 ( # 1) * (0 =, *
#.)# ))' 2#*(# # #* #2*, (# 1#(( 58 * 0#.& ) # ' & #" (, * 0 . # #'#%#1%*0#(( #(-*%#- 5< * # #(( 2%.
)& # * #2& -*%1. # #) # 0, +'-3 ,(/ +:/ + D**
#"29# G D** #1% G