← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1616/1994allowed

M/S New India Assurance Co.Ltd v. Kka Toor & ORS.

2023-05-24Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan16 pages

 

      

 

 !"#$%&'("'

((($$))'

*

+(+(("""'

(((, $"'



 

 !"#$%&'("'

((($$))'

*

- + (((, $"'

.

 

 !"#$%&'("'

((($$))'

*

/#/0 1 2"""'

(((, $"'



 

 !"#$%&'("'

((($$))'

*

1#'(3 '+ * (((, $"'



 

 !"#$%&'("'

((($$))'

*

1#'(3 '+ * 0 (((, $"'

, 5"64(4(.

7'"8/""

 #'6(4(.

      / '6

(* "9 $':5" ' 8"'$$))' 

 !"#$%&'(

))'$$) (

(&) '92:5" ' 8" $"'"(  8" $"'"(.  ;;;;

 ( <%'

": ))

$"

"88 5 ((  

:  

:   

:    

   

 8 )  "  =)8  "8 $$))'

> 

 !"#$%&'("' : 5 

"

'"8' #( ( < 8)% '':8 '

"8'  ''"4(("3 /0   1 2 ""  )"2  '  ?"2   1 2 * 0  

 8# )% ##= :    '5)) 2    9%$ %@?$  = 2  2

''

. "(7A@.4  8'8'" ' ))8'3$ 2"

28"# /'

)'"7)

' ))8'3$ = 2 5=%?"2 1 2 * 0'"#) $"  " '

"8'" 3/0 1 2 ""

''

2"'8"' '

'="

'6.$(#(' ))8' 3$ 13%9 A%-"

$ '):1 "9((,":' '

0= 22

''

""(!-B@  8'8'" ' "88 2'

 2"

2"8' ))8'3$= 2 5' 5% 2 $  2) 2'#=% $"'"(> 051 2 '''

0'

'""5'0"''

0: 

)" ''

'"88 2'

0 "

)"'2''C

'

$ 8""5'0 2 '8":1 051 2:'

0 5

)% $$) '=0  '"

'2 2%  

)'')%' ))8' 3$   C " 0 2 ' ' "88 2 '

0 8"# =  "

$'

"8' ))8'3$

' 2 5"

3

?"2 1 2 * 0:"  2' ))8'3$3/0 1 2""

#= '" ' 3

 ' ' $"': # 2"

$'

:

#)%:+(+(""> ":/ )?1 2""/#/0  2""  %&

)$+ > 2'"83/0  2""

'  3

( .( #'' '2'"' ' $"''"' $") ,"(.4.'((8"'"88  1 '

:.../! 2

'2 ' $"'"(1 05 2'/") 1''

"1:/ $'(

 ( /'

"  1#'(-   + :   "  "8  )'  1(  3 /0 1 2""8 ) ) #$'

" (( !! "(."8  ) !! 4@ : ) # 2 "#$ "" "

'"8 '"8

= 3/0 1 2"" #"'"5

)  '( 4( B ++"":  " 8"83/0 1 2""

  ) (( / )?1 2"":/#/0 1 2 ""  2'> %&

)$+ 8 ) !! "("8 )! "(4@ 8"2'"8 "#$ ""  "

'"8'"83/0 1 2""( (  $'  "8' ) #'

:3/0 1 2""

24%  $)   "(."8:  244 %    

'    !  !   "(4@(  -      A2  #$)"% /"8

" "'!"))2- )= %' ":!   '  2'

=3 '"8 ')) 2%)'

2'"

2 2''

2 D4:@$#"' )%:  C

5)''", (4:@$ #"'    %''''

#(B '# "8'$) 2

     "(.  "8  :  

   2       $  

, (::@$#"'(' ))2'''  ) $"$'%  ) "

'", (4:@$#"'8"#'

 $"$'%(   '$" 

"8 ''

2 $2"

/"3 ' '2"'

 '/ 3=2"

!"$"'

"(   )'%'''

#"8 '(

4 ( ' 2  '"  "   : #)%:  ?"2 1 2 * 0:

 ">3 '+ : 2'>9 $#3 '+ :  ' #/)1 2* 0  ' ' 1 2* 08 ) ) # $'

"= 2  !! "("8 )! "(@ :

) # 2 "#$ "" "

'"8'"8?"2 1 2* 0  #"'"  5

)   '(   " 2  '" 

  $'

" @ ) #'

:

?"2 1 2* 0 2="

'4% $"

' !"##'

!,/:'<'') ": ''% #$)"%#'"8E ""8   2''

2 )%"8, (:@$#"'( ( 1#'(3 '+  ""8?"2 1 2* 08 )

$' ) #$'

"= 2 !! "("8 )! "(@ 8"2'"8 "#$ "" "

'"8

88 2 3

''5% '( " 2'"5

":  ) "'5)) 2 '

))8'3$'')5''

# '"' '

'  # )'

$)2 5"

3

"$ "  )  28 '

"8)8'#:

8 '

"8 = "="'

  '  " 2'(12"'

''#'8"#9"5#'-"

$ '):/ $' )) 9 -"

$ '):



),":/ $'=

 8"#7((7(22)"8/'

)   "$' $" ) $)  =" ( " 2'"

 ) #':  F$ "8, (:@"''#'( ( /'

"/#/0 1 2"") "8 ) $' ) #  $'

"  = 2  !  !   "(4  "8   )  ! "(4@  ) # 2 "#$ "" "

'"8 3

88=%

  # ''5% '

  '5)) 2 ' ))8'3$'' )5''

#( " 2'"

$'

":

88# )'

$)

3

"

="% # '' !

)-"

$ '):/ $'8"#  8'"9 -"

$ '):/ $'''",3  -"

$ '):  /'

)        "$'  $"(   " 2  '" 

 ) #': $'="

':@"

# )''#'( (  ))'8 5 ) #$'



"

'"8' #  ':'"

 " ") ' '#    (( !! "(.

"8 ) !! "(4"8 5 "'((( (   = 2  2 5  "'

    ))  '  8 5  ) #  $'

:

$"'

"(8 )3"

' '' ''#'

% 2% ) = ) '%'"$% "#$ " "' 2''''

0 5 "''

8 )' $$ 2"8' '

 #''"88 '' ))8'3$

= 2 5=%?"2 1 2* 0'5% 2 $   2) 2'# ' 2"

28"#/'

)'"7)  $"''" '  8) 2''6(#(8"2"

2'"! ' 5"8''

0  2

''"#) $''

0 13%9

-"

$ '):1:9,":'' 5"8' ))8'3$'

'"

"5'0''

0:'))"8

"''

0"(. #8"# 7)

 ' 5"8' ))8'3$ "'$$)%'=0  '"

 2 $ 0 '= ''

' ''0$) 

"))%" "

'"8 2) 2' 2"8' ))8'3$=%

 5?"2 1 2* 0 $"'"(1 051 2 2

 ''

0 "''8 )'(8":'  2 $"'

"'

) =)'"$%%#"

''"' ) #'

( ( , $"'"(.>

  "#$%8 ) $' '

"8 '' ''#'



25 "

)2)"=3 '

 '2'"' # ' = ) '%"8' ) #$'

'$'

= 2=8"#

 3"

"3"

"8 

%$'

' ) #"8' ) #'

= 2  =  =%  ) # ''

"(  B '  2  '"  '  #  "8   ':

$"'"(.'0 $' #5

" $)=% $"'

"( '  '' ''#'(1  $"' %) = ) '% '"$% "#$ "'"' ) #'

( .( ))  '   $"'

 $%  8"  

#

)  "8  '  ) # $'

( (   '  $) 2  "8  '  $'

:  8"))" 2 

  8#6 ( B'' ''4(( '"89((," ))21   

 '" 2) 2' 2"8  0"(!-B@=%  5G//( ( B'' ) #'- + "+(+(""' ('

') '"% "#$ "" "

'"8'"87((/("" 8 ":

'""# 8"#"#G//( .( B'' ) #'/#/0 

'

')'"% "#$ " "

'"8

3

: 8 "'""# 8"#"#G//( ( B'  '  ) #'

 3 '  +   ' (    '

')  '"  %

 "#$ "" "

'"8''"8?"2 1 2: 8 "'"

"# 8"#"#G//( 4( B'' ) #'3 '+

'

')'"% "#$ " "

'"8" 3

: 8 ":'""# 8"#"#G //( ( B'' ) #$'

""'

)"

% 

"8 '

"G /,( ( B''$'

=8"#

3"

"3"

"8  

%$'

G/,( ( B''$'

" 5")"

' '"8 )'$'

/,( ( B''"88 25 ) = 2 5=%  '"

 $ "G/,( (,) 8( 4( <"''$'

)5   

$$"'"8'  $ '

5 ) # ( ( 8'   2  2 #'

:  '  "'"   '  !) #

 = ):/ $'  8'8'" ' = )  $'))' 5 ) #$'

 ' "

5 '(((/"("8 ' #$ 2

C

')5'8"%8 :' #

= 2$"  6   

              

  

  

    

            

       !

" #   $

            # % &'(  #



    )    *++  

   )  #       # % &'(  #

 ) ,-# .

+* +//!0 ,-# .



 +//   123('  (    ,-# .

+4 +//!0 ,-#  .

  +// "  22-#

  3('  (      )       

    .

4* $%   !

"&  $

          5

  (  3 ' ,-# .

+6 +//!0 ,-# .



+// "  ( % 2  3(' (        7

   )  8

$  )$

   

 1                  )        )   

     .



 9'  $         %  $ 

         !

"&  

    %   2  

    )           

  

 * 

     %   

&.

7+ $%   !

"( 8

$& &'(  #



  )      

   

 



     %   

&.

7/ $%   ))' ) #$'

: ' 'H4I$ #

"' "#$ "#"

'2'8"#''"8 "8' ) #$'

'

)) '

))

"( (   2' "#$ "=%' = )'"="  2

: $"'"(.

  "#$% $$" '

!"

'!"

'=%%"88 ) 2$$) :"'

"8  2 5'"

$"'

(, $"'

@ ) #'

) $ ' $$ '"

2 "

)= '

= C ')%

 "

) '"$$$ ''

2 $$ ( -"5: $"'> ')

 !"#$%& # '  $"'

"(  $"'"(.   $ ' $$ '"

2 "

)( ( 5) "

)8"'$'

=

 2"

2 '"

2' "( ( '

  :' = )")%

"8'5  ="

2'

=8" ' '8"#"8 ''#'"8/B3 '+ :/B/# /0 1 2"":"'5)) 2 ' ))8'3$

88 3

 "

$) ''8 ''' # )   = 2

'2 '1 051 25 ,"(.4.'((  1 '

:..:. '/") 1''

"1:/ $':1 05 2  )) 8 2'

) $"

=%/B1 ) + #:)#'"'!"

'"8!?

:/ $'8  2' #"%"8

 ,B1 051 2"'"'%"8)    "#'"' " )

''' ' C "'0$)  '" 2) 2'

 2"8'"88 2'

0=% $"'"(1 051 2('

= 2 ": $"'"(>1 051 2  5:1#'(,375 > " 

 !"#$%&'(:/'

)

"8' "88 2'

08"

) =)'"$% "#$ "'"' ) #'

( ( & "

)8"'$$))'>

  "#$%

"8 

2 #'

"'C '

#"8 "#$ "")%(8

=#

"#=% #  '2'"'  "8 3/0  2""( (  " 2'") "

)8"'$$))':' = )  8)) "  ) )'

2

 "# #   %

 "#'F "'"'F''"84I $ )( " 2'"

') "

)8"'$$))':'  "#"8'   "

) ='00$ 2 5 '  "#=%

) 0/"8

"

'  2  "))2 : 5

'%: "))2@ "")"8 "' $'

 "#"8'   #   %8' "5'

2'' '"

$ ( ( -"5:""'8 %# ' 



=#

(B '" '  "#"8'  5 "0 2(B )

"0 2 /"8

" "'!"))2- )= %' ":!:

'  2 '

=3 '"8 ')) 2%)'

2'"

22''

2D4:@ $#"' )%: 

C

5)''", (4:@ $ 



 %(-

 "# "'= 8"' "''

 "#  )"

2' #3"=  

'"= "

(' "

)"'

$"

=)%="( = ) 3

 '0 2'  "#"8'   '"=D4:@$#"'C

5)''", (4:@$#"'    %)% 2 $" )% '

'AF(/ )%$"5=% /B++"" ""83/0 1 2"":" '



2'

"8'$ "

2'' '

'( .( '2'"' = ) 2  "#'F"8   H4I:"8 )' =8"

 '

$$" "8' = )(

"' 2" "'" "''''"8  "#'F !'' )5''

# #"'4I(8":"8 )' =8"

 '

$$" "8' = )(8":



=#

#=% "

)8"'

  "#$%3 '( 

' )

 "#8' ""84I'F "# "

''"D4 ((, (:.:4@( ( "'$)

"=)8"8'$$))'>

  "#$%  '2'"'# )'

$) 

=%' = )(  = ) 8'""

#'

AF(/AF(/. " 2'"8 = '"8  3/0 1 2"" 4(4(.( ' '0$) "4((: ''%'  3/0 1 2""

 2) '')#"'4% '''

#"8 ' = )  '0

2

( 4( -"5:' = ) "'#% "'"

$"

$ '

('# "8'3 2#' 

 

. 

 



 !"## $"

%: '  $#'3"= =''22"

$"84'"

% : ""84I"8' '

) )%

'"=#'"

$"

$ '

(7"

2''' )  "#"8'   "# "

'", (::4@ .4J. ( (    = )     '    #"

'  "8  @. '"

$ ")) 2F$ "8'  3/0 1 2""( B '# "83 2#'  



&  (    

% )"## $" ' $'8# )%##= '":' " "

)=@'( 7"

2  '':  '   )  $ %  "8  '  ) #'

 "#  "

'  '"

, (4:.:. ::4>4 ( (  = )

# )'

$) "8: 

 " '( '# "83 2#'  



&'

     

 "0$ 2 5 '2"8  3 /0 1 2"":'# )'

$) "8 "

)=

(7"

2''' "#$ "$%=) "# "

''", (4:.:.FK:.:..@( (    = )    "'    %  #"

'  '"

"5'

")   (   $  '  )' '  3 2#'    #  *  

 

+,,#-.

$/   !

!

)2324 

55%0

4:' ) #'

'"=2'

#"8, (:@ '"') ')"

"8 "'

#(  ) #'

8 ''

')'"2', (4:@

 )F$ , (4:@8")"

"8 ''( ( 7"

2''' "#$ " "# "

''"=, (::..@ :.:..J:J4:J4: ( = ) '"') "#$ ""8, (.:4:44@: 

)

''

#"

'(-"5:

   '  ) #'

 5   '  8 )  %  "

 $$)  "  "

 "=3 '

:'#"

' "'= ( .( '  2  '"  '  ) #  $'

"  8 )  =%  )2) $ ''

5 "8?"2 1 2* 0:' = ) "

 2 ''#'

"8/B1#1 2:"="

2''

##" " ' 2  '"  '  #$)"%#'  "8        )%  =

  "' #") #'

= 2$ '" #:$"5 )% '

'AF(/

" 2'''  ?"2 1 2* 0  2, (:@ $#"' )%$''"'' '

')'"# )''#'( 2"8'   '0'"=4% 8"#

5  "(  = )'0

#"')%  "# , (:@$#"' "8' ''#'#=%/B1#1 2"

#'

$"5=% #(-"5:" "'" 8 $"

$ '

= #('#  "8 3 2#'  

   

        



 ":    '          $#'3"= =''22"

$"8'"4% :  "  "8  .I  "8  '   '

)  )% 

 '"  =  #  '"  8 $"

$ '

(7"

2'''#"')%  "#"8'   "# "

''"

, (.@ J.

( = )  '#"

'"8@.

4 '" $ ")) 2F$ "8'   ?"2 1 2 * 0(B '# "83 2#'  



&'

    

 " '$'

8# )%##= '":' " "

)=@'(7"

2'':' #"')%$ %"8' ) #'

 "# "

''", (4 .> 4.

: )$ %"8' ) #'

 "# "

''"=, (.@ 4F ( = ) 2')%$$) # )'

$) "8(7"

2''

' "#$ " "# "

''", (::@#0 2 ""8 , (:@  '"  "5'

")   :  '  #  "0  "

'  '"

, (:4:@( .(  = )  "#$ ""8, (::@( 

'

"C ""8 

2' "#$ "=%%"8  $' "8$$)(-"5:

 ' ) #'

5 '8 )% "

$$)" "

"=3 '

:'#"

' "'= ( .( # ))%: '2'"' "#$ ""8, (.:@ 2''" ) #'3 '+ , (4:@2''" ) #'

/#/0 1 2"":"5

88 3

' ': ''' "#$ "

 ' )%"'" 2

:' '

" )"

= ' "

 2'8 ''''%5"'8 )% "

$$)" "

"=3 '

:' # "'=   ( ..( -"5:8 8"  '

=#

"#=%) "

)8"'$$))' '2'"'"8 ' '2'"' "#$ "#"

'( = ) 2' ' 'H4I$

  #:  8  '" =" 2

   8  '$"$ $$"$ ''"2' ' 'H(4I$ #"' "#$ #"

'8"#''"88 ) 2"8' ) #$'

'

)) '

)) L'

"( .( ''%: '$$) 8 )=%'

  "#$%

' ))"$')% '"'F''"8 ' '$':'$$) 8 )=%

  "#$% $'(-"5: '2'"'C '

#"8 "#$ ":' # '

#

(  '# $$) ))"$')%:'#

))"

$$)

: 8%: '

$"

"8 " 2)%( (4(.

 <  

 !"#$ %&"'

!()$*  "&#

 '# !+,

 "&#