Suresh Dehra v. P.K.Tatyal And ANR
!"
#!$%& "' & "
"() *
#+)
!,-.)/
&
&
&
/
!
"
# #$!
") 0%1 "$!2 3"& " "41 % & ' &( )
* ' + ) #,
------ 3"& " "415$ .)
) (
/ ,,0.,00. ((+ '1 '/(
) ((/
() #. & ( 2& )(3(
) (( (
/ ' )
% 6 "!& , )) (' ) (' .405.664' ( '
' ' ' / &
)
1 ( #789:6906;;<= (
* ' (1 #75699>5.5,9<'/?)@ & #.7 <'( )
/ & 1 '/&/ ) & (
/(
('
(( )(
) ((')& ( /) ((+ '1 (.44) ( ('.655 () ( 1 (
) )) (((
: ((+ '1 '/ (
)&( (
/ ,,0.,00.' (().405.664& & ( 789,6906;;<
(175699>5.5,9< ((
& ) #.' ) / A@#,B, .405.664'/( ) ((( ) (1' (9
( / (/ )
( ('
( & ) ( 7=:
=4<'/ &)
( & &
( ) )
( #.' & ( &/ ) )( / ))( ) (('
()
/ )& )($ ' (( ?)@ ( &( )
()
((
'( / A' 1 ( (1/ )
( ' ) (' '
) (
(9
( ) ( () ( ( )) ) (
&' ( / & (
& ( ( C ' )) ' ) ( ) ' (
( / ( (( (((
) &D
( )& )($ '
) ? ) @ /
' ) (
( +E ' & ) #.
' ) (
(&
()&
( ' / ) &?)@
2 B ( )
(
/ /
@ ( ) ( ( ( ) ((((
& ) #.'( & (
)&
A' (
& ) &( ( & )( )' ? ) @ ( C
@) &((A@#,B, .405.664'
' (9
( )7=:=4<( )((( !&&/ ( ( / ) ( ((
& ' ) (
&
'
( ( C )( / ( ' ( )
D) E )(
)&
( ) / ) C(
(@')' ) (
/
; ( ) #,
) ( @ / )
( )&( (( ?)@ ( ' #./ (
& )( ) ((A' + ((
()&
)') ( )/ )(
((
' ( (
/ /
(
))(+ %2 "3 2&& 2 4@ &( )
& ( ( & C
1 >@ & ( ) (
($( )) ( '
( )
(((
& ) (175699>5.5,9<& #.' @) 1 ))&/) ( ((
)) 5/&' & (
(' & ?)@ ) )2& )(3 ?)@ ( ' & / ) & )( & ( ) ' )+'/
/ (
) )('
& ( ( E /
& )( &
6@/
9 ()&
'/( ) !
C
( ( (
( ( )@ @ 'D +( )
! " # $ %&'()* +,%+ '-- %
!
"" # "
$ "%
& '
(
(
)
*+ )' ( () ))( ( (( @ ' (
& &
(( & D +# $ +' ( ) (( )
)
& (
/( ) /1) ( / ) &
')' ' / & / ))( C(
1/(& /) ' ( &1 &' ' &( ( ) & & ) ( ((& .0 #.78- 9+9 9.'& /
' C&/ ) ) (F
++ +, :;- . ,,-9+,7-.; A
/ ()@ '
)( (+' @ & '( '
( ' ( ( (@ ( ) /1' & ) '/!C(& ( ( ( +)@ )'
/(& ( /) & /
)
' /) %2='
) @ 3 ' ) +' )) & ) /)
' / ) /+E '( ( ' ' ' ) (F ((
( ( ()( ) '& ) &
'/ C( /' ( ( ( / + /
)
' ( ) ( &) )
(F@('& @ &
'
) (
C( /) /1 .. &'D +( )#. +
,/"
01 %&'(2* +,%+ &3-' & )('
) *& &( ( '( & )( & & )
( % ,-"
.
'
'
"
.
/
"
/
'
0 0
1
.
+ ) *+ .,
(
( '& ((
)& &( ( C/ & )( ) ((((
& ) #.' // (1 ( / ( (& ) ( &
& ')'( & & ( &
.:
/ ))(1+45+"0 * * &'6( %&&'''/D +'/
/
& ) (1'
)&
/ /
( @/ ( (
& /
() & '?)@ &(
' )(
)&
.B ((
'
(
( ( ( (
& )'+ ()&
( ) () ( ?)@ '
/))) &( '&( )
()&) ) (
78+ +, %, .;D + !+,"! +, )3&&&
%%-9- ( (
( ' 9 ) (
& ( ( ( C ' )) ' )
' )) ( (7/ &<' ) ' (E &(( ) (
3(.44) ( (
&(
( )
( .4@ ( ' )( ) )
& #. 1(
( ( &( ) (' '
))
' & ) ) 1 )(
)&
(
(( (
/ !+,+ ) & ( ) (' /( &
& )&( ) (( ((( 1
( .405.664@) ( )(
' / / ) ( / C )( ' (
@ ( '
& ( (
' ( ( (
/ ((
' (
/ ) & ) (
(( (/ (
& ( (.44) ( .> &'
( /
' ( &
(( &( C( (& # (
( /
() '/ (C # ' & ((((
& ))) &( ( @((( ('( )
( / )) ' (& ( ) ( ' (C / &/ & () /'+
/ (
( (
)
/ % :;<&29&=*!+.% , +> ?
:;<&29); )33)=*!+.% , @ .5@( ) ( '1 &/ ' ) ' ) F ) ' (E ')) ) & ( ' (
( 9
( / )
/ (
% #.9+-. 7,.9 ₹ ))
<:
( C )<
<:
<:
(
<:
)
<:
.- /
<:
:;<&29-; )33)*!+.% , !+, 9(/
= *!+.% , 6.7.-&.
.6&(( ( ))
' ) ( (& ()( 9!C =>G + 7=>< !C=5G * 7=5<( ):;H ;H (& 8 ('/&' &( (
( )/ ))( ( ()( ((
'
( / ) )) ( ( #& '1 &/ ' ) '
) F ' ')) ' ' (
( 9
( / ) ( (
% #.9+-. 7,.9 ₹ ))
<:
( C )<
<:
<:
(
<:
)
<:
.- 5
<:
,0@&/) &('
.--;
(
/ ,,0.,00.79 9 %
7,.9 ₹ $#.;B.),00, /
<:
$#.;B,),00, /
<:
$#.;B:),00, 5
<:
$#.4;B),00, 5
<:
,. ((
( )>H ) )) )(
( F
) /
& #.I,'& ?$)@ ,,
) ((
( ') ' ) ,: ( )
() )((( 3"& " "41
$!&
+"1 2
3 .45 3%
2 4 5 3%