Joginder Singh And ORS. v. State Of Punjab And Others

    
      
 

 ! "# !$%&%"'()*)*    + 

+  + ,-+ +   

+ +  +
 ( .

/ * +
 0/  


   

     
  !"

# $  %

&&& 0/  1 *

/ !

'      () *(*! +,  
-!*.    $  *-
 /00  1+  2 2.

33 4  $  %  00    3 1 
 / 51  (((6(7 (* *(*(3 
 

 8  53 9 3  
53 

3 3                     3     

  0  3       **:;**<      /    1  

=  3 3 3 4  $

 $    

*

' 3  3 9 0   $ %=   3    33  51+
. 3  0 (* *(*!+, 
-!!.9 0   0     $=  351+
.9 9  $  9    $         0$            9 "

9   $   $,=  3() *(*!+
.   3    3 0   0  

 0 9  9  !:

!* *(!)+, 
-).

$ 0  =   3 $- 1 9 0     100 '  0 !% *(** , - >$    $=  351  (((6 (7 (* *(*(3   %*(%)6-%(:1
/
         8    53  

 ?      9 $  $0$ 9 9 @ 3$ ?9 33  $        () *(*!     =    3

  
 /00  1 

 9 $/00  0 3    0 9 9   !:

!* *(!) A   76  0# 
 ?

0 3/00 *((7+"./ +/ .<!:  3 $   0  =   3 $ 1 9 0    /00

 0 !) (< *(** '

, 3/00 =    3 $ , $  %

 3 , 3 3 33 $  3+
.     3 3 0 9  9303  

' % 0    3   !9 

1  3 1$0

3  3  @        0     1  /00   0   00 3  51   %*(  %)6-    %(:      1
/        !:

!* *(!)  +,  
-).

 '     51  =  93    %  3  9  3 3 51+
.   0$9 

   0-   0 1 
/ ' 

 3 4   90 ; 

 53 

3 3  $0 ; 9   3 ,

+

++ +   /
+/     +

A   0 $9 3 0         3 3    0    $      0   $ %9  1 3  3 09  9   20 2  9             *+.    2 -1   + 1.2  *+.
 /00 

- 1 *(!!+ 2 *(!!2.  0   1 $   % 0       *+.*+.*(!! , - +.C$"234%' C0 00     /00 0 - 1 0$     $ $30 $, $$ 093 3     0 3 3        $     30   9  /00  
 3 4D +.C"'5!&%6!' '6%'&C01  9  0$0 $  1   - + .

3 0$0  1 D +

.$ 3    1 D +

.$     09 

    $  1    DB :

'3 09   $ 

    9 $ 9  3 3   $ 3

3() *(*!+
.

' 

3   0   9   0

<

?   3 0  

    3 
                  1 /00              3      9    %6* !7:+"./
/    3 3  3 5    30 $8    . 2 7&* 8'9: +  ! 82' %;< &
"22%&&%"' 

.

  

54* =)>11 .8'9: +  !
%7%4 +8334%!&
5"3'*/ 6* 7&* 8'9: +  ! 82' %;< &
"22%&&%"'



1 =  

%7%4 

+

++ +  

/
+/    +   +

' 0 $   93$ $  3 %

$ 3   *(!! 

  3 

    -   1          
      000 0  3 39 0 9    

 )

92  2   0  *(!!  3 

  09       3  1 '   1 /00   $ %9 3

193  3  19   !  

!(

1   3 0 3  3  9 0      3     1 /00 3    % 3$ 3 4  9   3+
.

/ ++ !!

'    0 $       

!*

' 3   $   %9  1  3   9 0  0       $$,3 $  3() *(*!+
.  9     ,0 9 1 /00 $9  ;0 3 

 

1 $90 $ 1 3       

!"

3 $ 3() *(*!   0   0 $    ' $ $*(!!0    =

 00  00  3   1


   $939  9 , $   3 3  '   / A99 !**(!!3

0  $   9 

3;

=

3 $0  

 !%09   4            ;

3  3$     

=

$;

0 5    !* !%*(!!, - )* "?!5& '6 #8'$ %"'& "# <!
"22%&&%"'*-+!.'-/00 9  3$0  9    $ 3

   9 00$-





 


 
 



 

 

 !







!
!

 !

  

"


 



 













 

#


 






 
#
 

 $

%

&
'


 ""




"
(  (


( (


"


#

) 

*+ $

&
,


'


"

'   
 ""



 
#

"
 


-$ )@* "?!5 "# <!
"22%&&%"' " 8 %4%A! <! &!57%$!& "# $!5 %' "##%$!5& '6 %'7!& %; %'; ;!'$%!& #"5 $"'68$ %'; %'7!& %; %"' - '/00 0$  =

$ 0  39     $- +.  $D + . 3 30  $/00 D +. 38 $/00   D +. 3 0

!%

      3       !*    !%      *(!!0      1 /00 9 $    $     3 3         $   3  $ 0  0    -    1
/ 1 3 

33$  9   $   0         3          0    0 9     1
/     '  1  /00        

,     09  $9  0  33$

/   !7 1 9  0  

  3() *(*!+
.9

.  $&! &%6!

5 
   3$  3  9  3        3  33$0  $ =

 0   $ 1
/ =

    0,    9   9

!:


   $44"?!6

!<  3  +. $ 6%&3"&!6   3$

0/   '85B )1     E

3;

 F;

 E 

 F;