Gurbax Singh And ANR v. Financial Commissioner And ORS
!""# $ %&'($)* +,*!
-.$/0123$2
& 4&-&
$%$55&&677$&8+ -9$.+2$:1$232&
&7:&
!"#$%&!&% '"#()!
&'
( ;
0:2-+0:%$<2 ( 0$:2-+:%$+ 27
( $:02$5$+::
-9$.+ 20$
( 0:2-+:%$ ( 4=$&012+:%$+ &7: ( ;$$-7$+:%$+ >
& &7:
????? &% '"*+, 21$% 27&+<2$&-%%&&&@@& $- $5+<2<$&&$:.$$ $.1$::&7% $: 5$&-1 !# =$$& !A 5$$&+ 2$& . 2$ 2 55&&:57-1:::$:,*
!""A6/- @ 8+<2 :%:12&7 ;7$012@&7: #+2$& $=%&:$2$77::$ !"#B&%)$&72 7&& 2 7&-$%)$:1%--$>$:&%+!"##6 &2C!"##%D8
- ( ;
0:2-+ $: 0 -& $&&&: .) ( 0$:2-+ :%$+7&1 2 7& &-.5& 2$ 2 $2 27&$- $5<$&$$ $.1$::!"#"
;7$012@&7: #<2-57$:127&+<2< %--&7&&&& ;2$&$&
A+
+ #+"
+" $:!*A+ :$ $77%$ $%E-& 77)12& 2&$:$77%$2$:
.:%::.)2&&&$%$2.$%= 27&: : :$: ,
!"B, 6/- @!8 $: -72: .) 2 55&&!*
!"B
<+$- $5&-.5:$$77%$ 5 2$5.1$$2.$&& 2- &%&&)&2<125.7&&&&$&$-7:$+ .-2&$52$&.:%::
::$:,
!"B,<$&%2$1:.)27&$ $77$+<2%2<$&:&5&&:.)2%< 2:7$&&:.) 2 $%$55&&&+.-<2.)&=5:) &2&.$%=:7 25$+$$77%$-:0%,, !"## % $%E-& 277)12&<$&5:2)$!"B"$: : : :$: !
!"B" 6/- @A8+ 2 7& < 2:
:$5 ;2$&$& B"$: ,+.-<21$:;2$&$ &
A+
$: #+2&$5<$&9%:
77$7 :$1$&2 $ 5::$ $5E-$;2$&$&
A+
$: #+2$:. $<:.)2%:::$:!"
!"
6/- 8$:
25$<$&5$::.$%= &7: #;7$0127 :$ $77$$1$&2: 5$:+<2%2<$&:&5&&::::$: ,*
!" !6/- @#8 <+7-&-$%25$::+2
&%.:-2)+:::$:,B !"
6/- @B8+$:
. 277)12&<21$:;2$&$&
A+
$:
&7: # 7 : $ $77$ $1$& 2 $ 5::+<2%2<$&:&5&&::::$: ,* !" B 6/- <+2 $%$ 55&&+ : 57-1:
:,*
!""A6/- @ 8<2-%12 $%-5 $77: :$$:$=1%&:$2 :& 2&&&$% :$:,
!"B,$:2 $%$55&&:$:!*
!"B +$%%7:
2&7 $%+;7$012<$&$.&$.&22&1 $:%--&7&&&&$&$$. 2$77::$/%7.) 7$%1%:<&$)&2=2$&$1:$<$& 2)$ !"#"@B*$:!"B*@B!$:2$%-:2$.$.$&& $%%7$% 2&$:+2-&+-1&2&- &1$&:2:$: $<12<7.)-72:12:&/-& @B$:
%$+( 0:2-+$:%-& &7: &-.5&2$2$.&% %2$12::$:,
!"B,$:
2$1$$: $)!*
!"B +27&%$@$1$2 %$5+ &&% 2& 2$ .%5 $ 2 $77%$ &-.5:.);7$012@&7: #2)$!"#"+2<$& %&&) 57$:1 2 7& $& 2) < 77 $: %&&$)7$)$:2$ 5: :1&2$$$: $)$& 72: 2%$:+2 +2$77%$-:0% ,, !"##%2)$!"B"<$&5$$$.$:+2-&+-1&2& - :&5&&$ 2<7
2$2$:2$:%-& 27$&$:$77$&: 27$7.=
02 2 $%&%:$.$:$&<$&2&-.5&&&+
$5 2<2$2: 2 $%$55&&6/- 82$&$=%&:$2%- :$ !"#B+<2%2&2 &&$E-5 $< 27-7& 1$ 77)12& 2$&-:0%,, !"##%+<2%2$:&$&-:'@
!"
#
$%
&
&
'(
)
%
)
* +
%
!'
,
-./
0 2%- :$&:&7- 2=2$&$1:$<$& 7$%:%:+%:$.+$$&:&7- 2E-&$&& $&<222: 2 $%$55&&+<2-/$51
22-%:7$%:.)27&&2<2%--& 7&&&&$&$&72$77::$+2$&.%:+ 2$&<&FF 2-&+5)<+2:&- & 5 $%)$:+ 2 +&&-&$$. :5$777$/$%2$7 2 :1&::.)2 $%$55&&+<2%2$:$&-:'@ C
!
"#$%&'" (
%)*%&'#
+
,
"#$%&'"
-
.
/
/
""
0+ 1 + 2
!
(
+
,
+
,
"#$%&'"+ -
.
/
2 !
. 3
$4$#0 $
5 2%-5-$$:1 2$ 5:.&$&$:
/ $&<$&112-122 :1&+&$:2$2& %2%- :$+5-%2&&-%: $- 2 7&+/%7 %2:& !"B,$:!"B
2 55&& 2$: . -5: - 2 $% 2$ 2 : :$: ,
!"B,<$&$&&$:.)27&+.-2&$5<$&:&5&&: 21-:2$25$<$&5$::.$%=+.-27-5$ :1& 2$1$$5 225:)2$&$=%$ &2& .$%=:7 25$+27&2$$$:25:) 2-&+5) <+25$E-&.@%&::$:@:%:: &-$)+ 2::$:,*
!""A&2.)&@$&: 25$&5:.$%= 2 $%$55&&%%:
27$&+2-122%-&+$:%:$77$. 2 $%$55&&,A ,*!
2& - & &$1- 2 $% 2$ 2 55&& <-: :%: 2 5$ $%%:$% <2 $< $& /7:-&)$&7&&.+7 $.)<2$7: -52& 5 2:$ %7 % :%7) 2&:+$&25$<21$: $5&7:1$:9-:%$&%!""A+ +52$<:%$:&
7&$:&$<:
+01'-1 *&% , +2 "#()!
4 4 35 +6 78 +3
:
4 4 +;
: