← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4729/2019allowed

Gurnam Singh v. Bhakhra Bias Management Board And ORS

2025-01-07Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj9 pages



   

   



 !

"#$$%  &'  



(  '& & 

 '    &#) *& $ '+ '$

 $ ,,,,                             + '$

 - $. */ !             !  ""

 " #     $ %     "   & !         !   '( $   )* $       $ ""$ +  "$,! $    

    -  "          .

.!. "/0*'/1(0  - 2," 3-2,45 "      



   $ "#"$ & 6*7    /1*80**0     !                   2 ,"  32,4 $ 0*/0  ! '($ 8/*80*/69  !&   ! '($ )*$ 

 $ $ #9  !   &   

 "  :/1  *(*/0*/6         $   8/*80*/68/*80*/'! &    $  

" :/0)/**00*/' */*60*/'8/*80*/)3 ! )*$ 42 !   & ; 

"   /1//0*/6  "    <!  0'*'0*// #$ ,    =.

  !

   >#   ?# !:,5@A088 0*/*   "$ +%#"   ,      "      !   ""   $ ""$  "$! " )*$  ""    "80A >#,"   

" "/3/4 +      B "  "" "$  B  $ ""$         $

" $ "   #!&   !   )* $  "!  ""  " #   "!      " !   !" $ "B" "" $#   !

!&   ! '($  )*$ #     &   ! " !  #!"$  !" $9   ""$    */*60*/)   !! $ #   &        $  # 9   $ #       

"

" # " $ #"     !! '($ 9   " #  " !  "!     "#  ""   # 

  "   9   

 #  /1*80*/(  "!

   >!  #$   ,             ""!    

 ,    !    "  C     !  !""$ #   !      !  "$    ;  "$ 

 ! #"     "$9   # !:,5@A088 0*/*"D.

  !

    >#  "#   ,    #  #! #  $ "  $  #&""#"    5 2#" E"F    !

G""  4 /11' $ # "  ! $  #!! # 9    #>!       #" 

  

    

   

     

 

                     

   !

       

"       

 "        



 

         # 

$  $    

 

 !%$    &

   

   !'   $   

"  

  !

         ! '        (      

 

 

         )       

 "       

*   

 

      !%  

 )



       "$       

   ! +  ,   -   .

  $      #  

    

      (  *        

 )      

 

          (  ,  !'    

    / % )     0   

    

            

     

 $   $  



     ( *        !(   $ $ 

   



  

       $      

    $    

     !'

  

 (  1223  

     

  

    

  (  *   1223 ! 4   

      

   

 

 

  5

 5      

) 



     $    (      1223!6 $ 

     (       

  

     

!4

 

    & % 7    !0 888  888  888 19 % $ 

  

$!:  (  

 .   ) &; &)    





3

 <

  

 (   ,    !'  

  3+  !%

        !%   $

(     



              =9     $ 

    

     

 

)      !6

       =9  $

  

 # !0 #>! "$" - #$  +%#"   ,  +     #       "$  >#+ $  

 ,    !    "  #  ! !    $      " #  $ ! ""  "#  "

" ! )*$  "!

 " /1//0*/6  "80A ,"

   "F+ # > !

 ",5@81A6 0*/0 "! " #   " # !:,5@08/6' 0*/' " " #$   > !

 #     ,  .     ""#$ , ""#"#    # "

   

!    # "  "   #  !

;  >#     !  #   !      #" "$    !   '( $   )* $    "    "   /1//0*/6             " #"   .

.!. +    #        !  &  $ "$ #    $  

=      $  0*/0@/8   " #"         

 C    #     " "     B " /1//0*/6   #$  #E    & !        

    *(*/0*/6  /**00*/' 9        /1//0*/6#$...*A*60*/' " #"     

"   # "   "$ C    "  "        ! !

    ""#"      #"      !#     !   " #     

  $ "#"$ & 6*7"    "#   C "      !         !       

 ! #"$ # 6*7     = 5 2#"3 E"F    !

G""   4   /11'? #   #! & "$     "$

 ! "B#"C  #    !# "#  >!  





   &  #      " "$ "    " #  #"     $ "     "  

 C"    >!    + # > !

,5@81A6 0*/0 /(*10*/' >

!

  ,5@08/6'   0*/'    8//*0*/'   ""   "          E    $  " #      $"" $# 

" $#9  #> #$  "$ #E     >##$ ...      "!  "       !    "    

  &!  "   !      !"$"  !    /11'  " $     #!   "  ""   " $ "!" #>   @ !

 $   ! 

   $    " " .  #   !  #!!#  

 #   #!  #  "$     "$   ""$   "$



  "# #  $  $ C " # >      $   #  

 

    #" "$    !      "   B

"         !      "$    ""$

""! 

"  " $#

"""!"+  !

"""!" "  !

" " # " +  #   E #& "" !    #"   9    #      ""$  "& # # !

+ "   $ , " "   $ !

  @2        #   # & "$   "   "9      

 " !   !      ;   $          #  

     #&        @.

.!. 

 " $#$ ;  >#/1//0*/6 "" "$  B  $ ""$          $  $ "   #!&    ! )*$ "! ""  "#  "!     " !    !"  $  "B"   ""  $ #  9       "$   &   ! '($ )*$   /H/$ 

 "$ "  #    #        "        "$   ! "  # : ! # #$   

  ! #"    "$ 

#  " $#& 9  

 !"$""         !  "" E"  " # E$ %    #$   0*/60*/)#$  !                2,  8/*80*/)

2 - "

"   E $! $  &  #           $     #"# "                         

"!

  ""#"#"$  "!   I )7         "!      "" "# 9  "!"$ !"$ """#"#" $  '****B@#  5"

 G ;C

, !  .+ '$

 /



-%$      

4 "5   />5?

4 

  />5?