← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4071/2023allowed

Anil Kumar v. State Of Haryana And Others

2024-12-10Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri18 pages

           

  !"# !$%&%"'( ) )  

          

  ( * +),,,



 !"  

 #   $%   

& ' !"  

( )



  !"  

( *

%

   ( + 

,,,,, ,,)

-. -

.

  &

   " ))/ 01 

 "

 2   

 

"

( ) *



  

 & 

 - 3* *-)4 2

5-)6     & "   

7 

)

    &  

( *



"  "     

&

 " 

*

8 ! &   "

"  

"  &   2 2

  



( )09&   



 

 *:

:/ ):)-   

  

  2  " "



 "  "

  "

 "          2

  2 

  ( )09  &   2 "

     '

 2     

+

;

"  &   

)::< 

( +22  "    !   "

4!

"   

( *&        

 "

  .



( +         "

  & = 

)< :) ):):

.

  ( *&    "

     

  ( +  

    

   '  

& 2  2      &    

    *:

:/ ):)-  

  ( *&       "

   "-:+    0 !

" " -<>+ 

"!

           * :/ /)+4    

  (  +   &  

    

2

2  

 

 '!    "

 !!



   

     - 3* *-)4&      * :/ /)+4 2  2  ? "  4   &

  

.

 !  2  

&   )::<        "

 

&

( + 2" &



  

 ?" @ !

 &   "= 

  &

   "  " &   2

 &  

" !   &  2

 ! 2 2"

  " &

"!

  &       & "

  ! 2 

  " !

&

2 

 &  

& 

   &  0   " *:: 01  

" &  !



  2" 

   " *:: 2    2

9         

  "   

    &    

( ) &  

( )      0 !

 @#  "  09#   



 & 

2  

= 2 

"

!

 

 ( *&   2 2  !"



( * &       

( +2



"

4!

"   2 

=  &

( *&   09#  2"  @#  



    - 3* *-)4   "    

 &    &      &

 ( +  2

 

 "

  * :/ /)+4 

2

2    2  

    &2   2" &



"!

 

&   

 A# "'  0  



  

 

 

 

 

!

"   

  "     " & 2  ""  "

2 2

/

;

  "   

    &     

  ( * &  2  2 2

2 ( * &   

)::<  ( + !   "

  2"  @   * :/ /)+4  "

  "    2      '!     &

 &  



 ( + 

  ?  " @ !

  &        &           0 =     - 3* *-)4 &

2  ?

&  

 "  

 



      

B

  &

 -<>+"C2" &



"



( )

 & ( *  



!    

  "#$    %  &  

'

B

  &

 -<D3 C

&   "   

"!

" &  "   "     

  ! 2  #  

"!

  .



  !     &

2 

%

  

( +2  

  &  

    

 "

4!

"   

)::<   2    '!

                   :* :/ /)+4  2      



)< :) ):):

 &     

 

  "

 2  &

/  

( *&  & "  

 

( * &      2       

  &  

  2"  2  2  & 

08 ( -<-):)*2"  &

0  &  

2 "" 

  !

 

 "

 2 

( *& 

  2   

&  

" &         &   &2 2 

   * :/ /)+4 2   

&     !

  

4    

      

  2" 

 &  & "

   &      ""

 "

"!

 2"  !

&

  &

&  & "  2          



 

):)-  

 ! 2 2"

  " !

&

2    &     2 2 

"!

 "



   

(

      

    " &   " "" 2 " &    &2

   " 

 @  &  2    "

 

>

1 !



 

" 

<

.  !!



"   2

&    

( )

( *& 2"



" !

"     0 !

" "-<>+ 

 2   - 3* *-)4

0

&     "  

"          &  

  "   

  ( *& 

$  "      = 2 & 

" 

( ) *  2" !  24  

   &

2 

 &      & "

 "  "

 "



    "

    "

       

 

 = 2  

" 

&    2

2   ! &  2     22

&

&  2

  7 

"!

  

&   



         "  

  



 # 

"  !

       !2""& &  "

 0     &

  

    2 2  

 " 

-:

9:) :> ):)+ 

" 

( )   

  " 

     !     2    2"   E

 &  2

 2  .      :) :> ):)+   &0 

"

   "

#$

%%$ &$

       '



  ( )

    '          )         *  +'

 (    ,    * -$

 #  #'''.            '  '

 

  

    '

 

   )

) ''

   '



      !'

' ,    /   0  

(     ')      )'

'



  ) '





 ) ''

  

'

     )'

''

   

,

      

!1 --

;

" 

( * 

 +3 -<>+"  *)-<D3  

      2   &

 

   .

  +3-<>+"  *) -<D3

"

    )

* +    % & , -.

.

    -  / .

    / 

      1   .     

    .

      /       

-.  /  /         /     .               

  /

   

-.

/  /    *

% & 2 1 

 .          3  /      /  3  -.

  .

       45-   

1

    

  6  -

  /

   /   #      - .             *     /  .

    /      * %& 7     

 3    /0   % &                 3  

-.  /  /    

#      .

            /               45     

 

(

 *6 81 :   :

  

  /.

*  * +  90! "#    

#  -.

      /    9 %& ; * %/& +  

 

   /   * %& ;

. 



.

    -   

.

 

<  -  ..  *

     1   

. 

   /     .    /

 

1 * %&  .



  -    3   



    / "# /   * % &    

 

 0 

/ 

  . * %& =   ; / * %.&        *

2 %& 2      =>/

*        * +   /             /  * %7& 

     -       "#  -.

- "#  /  .   # *  -)

  

 22 

   2 2

"!

&  "      

?

        2 2   

  !"

   

 "



@ ( "" & 

   

 

22

 "

 @& "   "

 ! 2 

"  &   



      

" &    2 

  ! 2   7   

"!

 

&  

.    0! !"

    ! !  2  "



   

  

 "



  2  "  "

  2  "  %!

   " &   

"!

" &   4 " & 2  2 

"    

""



  "  "

 "

  "

   

   

 !20  2  " 2  

&  F  ?

.0  "

! 2    & "

  "" @

 ! 

  "

"!

" !

&

  "     2  



 -*

1  &!

  

" 

( + 

 "

4!

"   

)::< 

 

):): 2

 

):)- 8

2    

        2 &  

( +2

 !"

" "

2

    

G!

&  +3-<>+"   

&

" 

( * 

"!

" !

&

  "    

(" "2 

  2  2  !"

  &2 "

@ !

(2  

 2   



 "

    2

   2    "      & "

  "" ! "

        "2" !

&



." &   ""  "

2  22 

  @

 !  7 

  -+

  

"

  &

" 

 ( ) A# "' 0  2 34 0  "

! 2 

 ' 2 &  " & 

"    &  " 1

 '   2 34  A# " 0 2  2 > )-B C  ' &0! !"

   -

1 0   111       2      ""   !  

  2    "        &   2 2 

"  "    &

20   &

" 

( )

&

" 

( *     &

  "  2 

 "!

 .

 ' 2 &  " & 

"    &

-3

1    2 

& 

 &        " &!

& 4   &   

"

!    &  

 2" 0   " *:: 01    " &  !



   2          2  2

      

  "     !  &

 2    2

-/

8 & "

 

-<D-  0# "?& 

0  "5 , 6   7 '1.893

     &     A          "  *-B-C      0    1

2   &!  ++    0 1 

 & "   0   " *::  01   A    .

 !   

 ' 

"

   ) * !   .   /  ; " 

=>/   .   :-; +'

   .<-8=9>? 9 * ! .     

.



  .    * ! >  3   -     

  -  -     

 .      /          /     /  /

- 0-   

?

    .

    .

    / .  .

 ?

    * 7 -     / >     . 

     /    

 

  

  -.

 .  

  

 

     /   .      -     . /     3

  / 

 

/

       .   

   -     .  / . 

 * !  -  ..

..

 

  - 1   /    @. 

/

   =>/     * "      @    .

>.  -    . - >         

    / .  

  -      

  /   /  * 7       

   3  -   /  #.

 / -

 .

 .

 

/

    #      -    / .  

 * ! 3       /  * ,  -    -   3   ..

      /    /    /   .

- .

         



 *   - 1 

  ..

 - 1   / >     @.   /  =>/ .    

  * " - . -  -

>  -                / 

 /

- 0-   

?

    

   .    / .  .

 .

    *

 * !      #' ' -  '

     '

.  8= $   -  ! 8    3  -   A .A  A  A -  .

 1    

% &%& 

% &

 * !      -   

/ .

A 

/   . 

     A*

-D

 .

  "   :

6#' 1.

<-8 %  %=  ?& 

0 &     

  &&  & & %!

  

 

&

!  &         .

    !

 22 



 & ?& 

0 "5@()6 

@ '

1.8883 4 +!93 4 ->

.

  ?&  

 0         !

'   "   A',' '

6A

: 

   '

1.

3 4

   "  

 2   !  &       & 

( > -/

 ' 

"

    ) * 7         .     /  *      /   / 

 .     /     *        /   +** ,#  2* B* C

7D %

&

 (

/ @

  +** +  -  # "    /     -.

- 9 )

* !  

       



-  3   -    *  - -   3 

/ /  E 7    - 1  -      /     E 7   

/.

  

  -      

                 E

* F    E F  .



  E F /   

       #   E 7     #    /      -  /   

           E    # -       3        > > / -    

  * (* ! 3  

  / .

/  .      .

 -  -

.

   /  .       .    /     .   /  -      /  

 "   ,      7 '/B89C - =!

-              .   

        

?

   /  .

   /    ?

     .

-          * 7 -      .

        

 $   * 7 

  

3.

  .

 .   

   

 /      /       

     / .       -

  / 

 

  / / 

 * !  - -       

 '

6<0 ('3=41*

7      /   -        

)  G* ! .     / #  - -     

-      

 ((0



7*

H* !           .   .         .I   .  )  G*  ((0



7     9

"

$            

  

    '  )$ ,    /   

     /  

-*G

2 -   

    -  3     /   / ..

 >.  /   

/ *     /   

   -   

- -         ((0

 * 7  -   

  # - 

 

.

      -          /.

   /   *G

-<

 A# "0 "5<' ('6  

 '

18834-!88. "  

 2

 2   &2 "   "

2  "   2

2  &   

 &   " & 2 

 0 2    2 .

 !  

"

   H>-*   

/    -     90 %& ! ?

    . - 

   

 

 



  * !   /    

((        

    /   *

%& ! ?

    -  .

    /   1   

   

 .

  

 3*

%& =   /       /  .

.    * %& ! ?

     +   3   .

 /            .

   3  

  /     * !    1     / / # 

# .

  -  # 



  >

 3   3   .       .*

%& ! 3   .  / 3    

. 

.

  *

%& !    

 

  

3   .* %& !    

?

      /   .

    /  

*G ):

1 '   & $!# "0  !



9  "D' ('6   1. "  :> :) ):)* 2 &    & "

  "  

"!

" &  "  

.

 !  

 ' 

"

  

  )7 / 

 .

   ?

     / 3

 

/     , *           / 

       /    *G

)-

1  H+,  :  A'

    '

  '('  )   

  ? 6#<5  '

1.

34

% ?& 

0 &     2"

&   0     &    

<

 ' 

"

   H< .   2"

&  "      &     .   & " 

 0        



"

& 

!   " 

            !

          

  "

(22   

  

 "

  .   "

 "&   " 2  36  E'' 5 A( -.3

94 

!! F  ('   

.3

 4 

!F3

 4!

3

4 8.   #'  ' 7'.3

49

=8E<-

 8 8.   ? #, ':.3

4 

!

!E

 4  

 3

4  9=8E  <- 

    %%8    5 '

  '

34     @.3

48

%!E3

4!

4=9E<-

  %941 ))

1 

"

   & "

  !

2

"!

   & &   

 "

  "  "2    2   

)*

0 =  

  2  .

 ( ) *



" 



  

 - 3* *-)4  2

5/6  B C   

 1

 2    "  &  2     

)+

1" 

  

 

2

     &  





5<6  B

)3

"

 "

&  

( ) * 2  1  2    2    &

     "     -: :::4  2"     &  

  =   &

( ) *  &   2

  

,,   -:

-) ):)+ 2 8 

 I 4( 8

  &  I 4(