M/S Northern India Land & Finace Corp. v. The Municipal Corporation Fbad.
! # $ % & %"' (! ) #*"
+ ,(+- .%/.
0(+- " 111 " ''"" /2)''3 4%5/6 &)
" 678. 9 4%5/ %') " 56 111
+ 3 "
2 :% 9
;+<% =(
//> >
;+<% =( > ?
;+<% =
?
;+<% 9=(%)2 " ( -3 " ( % "%)'%'2 //%2 ) )%'5( 3 %5 ) ) !% ( 5 "
)
/ 05" %""
-@5"'
"%)' %'2 )%'5 %' ) %%" ' ) ( % " " "% '( /% 5 0' > / '(%-''5+/"% (%" ''2 " / &3 % 2 '5( A 2( ""
-' % ' '2B ."
5 !' 8<%" '+ /'5 /)3 " ! )/"'<+/ (! )(3 >
> ;+<% = / 5 /( 0B'25 ( " "( "%)' " 0 "%)' ' ' 3 )
% )2 3 - 2 + " -'"/(3 )
''%
/!% (" 3' " " '%"3 '( "'(//%2 "%)'%'2)%'53 ) %)2 A3- ( " - "
- :%"' + %'( 3" %' ) % 8-%''2( 3 5 )3 ! ) /"'< +/ ; "
)2
" = " ' -'"/3 03%')
%)2 +/ "2/ *?( 9(
+" 3 " /% % :%' ''/ '
5 / 3 % '
;+<%
9 =%)2 +/ 03('% 5' 5 / >
> 3 %)% )2 '%( % '
;+<% 9=( 3
% 3 0(
//%2 "%)' %'2 )%'5( // 3
/ 8 % 3 ) /"' 3 3 2 + 5 ( "
% ''/-'%5*( >(?>
)' /
2% 0A3- ( < '-'"/ 53 )) )2 "' ' ! ( " %' "2/ ''/( / % 0 0 *%''2( @5"' 3 -""
-)2 . &3 ' ( 3 ' + %'( " %' %"%)'%'2
%% !3 %( - ' ?
9 ;+<% =( "
:% +/ '0 ""
-' @5 "'
/ "2/ ''/
' -'"/ 3 0 ( %"' ( ! ) ;
"=(/< 2
"2/ /5''/(-'
( >
>
?;+<% ?( C ( "-'2= % ''/
?'
/*9(?(>
:% % ''/(- ' > >
? ;+<% = *" 3' :%'%' ( 3 "2 '2 "2/ . /% ( :%
* (
(
3 % ( %5 % 3 2""
</% + :%( %'2 5( 3 ' /
" 5 5 @5 "'( - '
? ;+<% = D% -'( @5"' %"%)'%'2)%'53 '' %4% (" -5 - /% *?( 9(
2% 0' * (9(
% ( "
'// 23 0* (- 9
;+<% =( " %5 ) " ) %" 3 ' -'"/3 03 )
%(' 3 ) %'@ % "%)' %'2 )%'5 E 5( - ' >
;+<% =( " ' " "%)'%'2)%'5 3 )-'"3 32 " ""
- @5"'(3 3 ''3( ( 3 " "% " %' ) 0 - & 3( )-( ) % 3 / ' ) '
"(/( '( " /<% -'"/ 3 0 /5 '2% "' ."
5 !' '2( 8< 3 5 )2 ( &3 % 2 '5( A 2( 5
( - // ? ?( 3 5 /
> ! / (<%)2 (% *%' %4) . %'* ''+ * F 5%' -'"/*%'(
>A3- ( '
2 % -'"/ 3 0( "' 3 3 %)' "- %+3 "' 3 ( 3 ' ! ) /"'< +/ ' /53 '@ ' "'3
+( /
- )3 " ( +/ 3 0 - '2
2 % -'"/ 3 0 / *?( 9(
( 3 3 ) " )2 '@ 8< '-'"/ 53 )")2 "'3 -%''2 /
- % //%2)%'53//3
/
/ 5 /(
( 3 ) /"'3 " 32 + - ) ( 3')')
(
( +/ / *%' ;= ''+ *%'(
> A3- ( " ' % //%2 )%'5 & ( " 3 0 - ."
5 !' '2 8<( '
2
- %'' ' /% 2 /
/ '@ A3- ( %' "
2' " / 0 //%2)%'5%' ))% < , %5
%' %)/ )5' %%)'( " %') % -5 ' 3" %5 "%)'%'2)%'5 "'
' % :% "' " " :%
/ !% ( %)/ % %'3
' @5 "' 4% )% ' % ''/ 5 0/( %')'03 2( %)/ " "'' ''/' '2"2/( ( 3 '22 0- "(/5/ ' (' %' "%)/ ' % ''/()'
"
2 % ' -'"/ 3 0( / %' % '
;+<% =( 3 '22''%@5 "' % "%)' %'2 )%'5 2 -( %)/ %' % //%2 " ""
- '2 % "' - ' %' " " % "" " ' ""
-@5"'( % 3 " "%)' %'2 -( '
?
% :% ''/ %
" 0( / '% % '
;+<% =+( )5( 3%')"" '% ''%% '
;+<% 9=( 3 "%' / "3 3 3 B
! "# $ % &' ()*+,,,-. / &0$1 2 3
4 56#$1 $#0 $#&
37 &3 1 8 95
: 7 ;& 5$ 7 :1 1& &3 44& 3$ &' 7 '545 345 53 0 ; 4$ &' 53$ 03
7 2 &;% 3$9&0< 53'& 0=
0$ 0 153 $
% 3$ ; 0 4# 7
652 3:
&9
&3695$# 3<0 $ 53$ 0 $&3$# & $ $ 37536 %& 3$&'53 $
% 3$ >,>>?@ $53 $
% 3$ >>*A)A,-. >>@?+ @3753 $
% 3$ >>*A)A,-. >>A?+ +0753 $
% 3$ >>*A)A,-. >>*?++ ($#53 $
% 3$ >>*A)A,-.B
( "# $$# 4& &35C 0-4&%;
31 37 0$ < $& $ 0$ $# 4&3 $0 4$5&3 &' &%% 35$1 - ;
:
54 :
7536 4#
4#&& #& ;5$
4&%% 35$1 4 3$0 53 ;0536 7 D$3 > & &31
:
7 95$#53 ; 05&7 &' $#0 %&3$# '0&% $# 50 &93 & 04 &0 $#0& 6# 31 &$# 0
6 341'0&%$# 7 $ &' 60 % 3$ 374&3 $0 4$5&395
: 4&%;
$ 7 95$#53 $9& 1 0 '
536 9#54# ; 0
>?. &' $#
3E : 4# 7
7 & 7 37 &3$0&
7 0
$054$5&3 &'
30 6
$ 7 2 &;% 3$
>?!A $# 5$ #
$ 37 $0 3 ' 00 7 '0 &' 4& $ $&
:
7 &%;
D 7%535 $0 $5&3
:
7B
8< (- %/ // % 3 4% 3
'5 ""
-@5"'( )% % '' ''/ *?( 9(
' " * (9(
'2 %
( %' '2 ) 2 ( ' "'%)'(''3
' "' %' '2(3 "
- 03'5 " *(? ( >
;+<% = ""
-' @5"'& ('2( 2( %
%5 "%)'%'2)%'5 & %( % 3 )'5 ' @5 "' 3 -/ %' ' /"%( 4%% ( - ) "2 //% "'3 3
'( ' "2/ %' / '% & %5 ( ' %' "''2/ %' '32 % / ""
- '2 % "'( ( / '%( '/"' %3 "%'/( "% 23 ' 0 - A3- ( )5 0 "'2B3 %' ) @5"'( '23 5-E ( '5 ) ""
-@5 "' %' '' ) <" % 3 /"%''%
& )5 ( 3 " ''3 :%'2( 9
;+<% =(
// > >
;+<% =( > ?
;+<% = ?
;+<% 9= :% *" ' ""
- @5 "' 3 3 /
/ 2 3
/ %'3 3 3%' ) 3" %5"%)'%'2)%'5 ( S.J. VAZIFDAR ) ( ARUN PALLI ) ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE JUDGE 12 .04.2016 Rajan