High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4131/2024disposed of

Jasdeep Singh v. Union Of India And Others

2026-05-19Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja4 pages

E +

E + &!+0 &!+0 &!+0 &!+0 A2:2 A2:2 A2:2 A2:2+0< +0< +0< +0<A4 G5 4 G5 4 G5 4 G5 ,""+ ,""+ ,""+ ,""+ 2H 2H 2H 2H <;

!"!"+

1+ * !

& +% / *"

)*$+,&!& *

"#$"%&'" #()*$+,&!0+ !

!(1!"!"+

"-(+ & &.)

& .+/ .)

1+ * !+

/*& )*$+,&! 1+ * !3

/ ( &/(&.)!!

) / %&- FFFF ) 4 &.5 ) 4 &.5 ) 4 &.5 ) 4 &.5 ' 8&'+01 !8 "!1!"!"+ )1 &'

(&- 9&*0+ "/& , +0 *"

,!"+ !+

1+ * ! + : !+ ; !+ .& !( - 0"! +0 2<<= +.&!"/9 9 " 0&$+/ +0 !( 1 1!"!"+ 3.& *+8 " !

9 +0 0 1&>" # + *&!* ;

< <A 1&*-' 1+ * !+ ;

(+1 &!"$1& !!( ( +9"?!

&,!*( / * @;

(&$(& *.& *,+/ .0+ !

!(&11.",& !& *& *&.+1 /*

$& ! ,+ * + !( 0". & * +- $ $* !(&! ,+91 &!"+ " 1,! +0 .

.& * -.+ + #" # !+ &11.",& ! 8& &* * & * *!

9" * $"* 8& * *& *&!* <2A +8$ ) " !(" ,& ,+9 91 &!"+ &9+/ ! 8& +! 1&"* -' ' !( !"1/ 1/.&!*3&11+" !**&! :2 <2A A&"!8& .&*-'!( &0 &0!

) 8("

",(0&,!"&-/ *& !.'$"* !0 +9!( (&,,+/ !!&!9 !"!.0 (/)" $ $"8 +0.

.!!

*&!*<:

< <2B& *#/"*." *&!*C <2I)"/*-'!(" "

' +0

+&* ! & * "#(8&'3 ) &11.",& ! " 0+/ * !"!.* ,+9 91 &!"+ " &,,+ *& , 8"!( !(

! ,(*/. +0 !( !( "#(! !+

+9 91 &!"+ & * & 1& ,' " & * ,D/""!"+ ) (&-"."!&!"+ & *

!!.9 ! ,! + :< +0 <2:) +.& &!"/9 &! !( &! +0 2<<= & * " !

,, ,+ *" #.') " *"

,!* !+ * 1+"! !( &9+/ ! & 0.,!* " ,&., ,/.&!"+ (! & ?* ( 8"!( + !

!(&! 1&'9 ! ,+/.* - 9&* !+ 1

&11 1.",& !

( &9+/ ! +0 +.&!"/9 &! !

&! +0 :<= &.

&*' 1&"* !+ 1

! &11 1.",& !)(&..-&*%/!*3**/,!*)&1 /. !( +/#( "!

+%,! "

,!+ 9 "!& " *"

,!* !+ 1 +$ $"* &*D D/&!0/ *+!(&!!(,+91 &!"+ &9+/ !,+/.*-*"-/ *!+!(1

! &11 1.",& !

J 67 & *,+/ .0+ !( 1+ * !

!/-9"!!(&!!(1&'9 !" !

9+0&8& * *&!*2< <2A8& .&*!

!+!(1!"!"+ .& *+8 + .'

'+ I <;

<2; & * * <I <C <2;

0/ !( /-9 9"! !(&! !( 1&>" # + *& &!* ;

<A D/& & !( 2<<= +.&!"/9 1&* * -' 1+ * ! + ; -" # # & /11.9 !& '& &8& *)!(&9(&- ,(&..

#*-0+ !(.& * -"!

&!+ $"*+ A<< <+0<A8(",("1 *" #,+ "* &!"+ 6A7 &$ $" #(& *.& *,+/ .0+ !(1& !")+ ,!(1&'9 !8 8&

.&* " 0&$ $+/ +0 !( 1!"!"+ .& *+8

&0!

<2 <2;) !( &9+ +/ ! !+8& * 2<<= +.&!"/9 1&'&-. !+ !( 1!"!"+

.& *+8 +/#(! !+ (&$ -

.&* / * ,.&/ A B4"""54-5 +0 !( #/"* ." *&!* C <2I "/* -' " "!

'+0 +& * !& *"#(8&')+$

9 !+0 *"&8(",(8 0/ !

!( &11 +$*) *+

* & * ."* /1+ -' !( + + K-. /1 9 +/ ! $"* + *&!* :

<H & * <2 <; 1&* " !

!( ,& +0 & 8& 9&.

& 8& 9&.

& 8& 9&. " #(& " #(& " #(& " #(& "'& "'& "'& "'& 9+ "&. / 9+ "&. / 9+ "&. / 9+ "&. / ! G ! G ! G ! G

&!"+ &. "#(

&!"+ &. "#( (8&' /!(+ "!' +0 (8&' /!(+ "!' +0 (8&' /!(+ "!' +0 (8&' /!(+ "!' +0 *"& 4 *"& 4 *"& 4 *"& 4 ", ", ", ", 11.",&!"+ +

11.",&!"+ +

22I+0<25

22I+0<25& *4", 11."

", 11."

.",&!"+ "& '+ A;BI3<:

.",&!"+ "& '+ A;BI3<:5 6;7 + + +$ )"9".& "/8"!( 1, ,!!+!(1&'9 !+02<<=+.&!"

"/9 !& **,"**- -'!("+/ !$"*+ *&!*<B <A <B1&*" E + B E + B E + B E + B B;; B;; B;; B;; +0 <A !"!.* +0 <A !"!.* +0 <A !"!.* +0 <A !"!.* L/>(*$ " #( "+ + L/>(*$ " #( "+ + L/>(*$ " #( "+ + L/>(*$ " #( "+ + +0 *"& & * +!( K +0 *"& & * +!( K +0 *"& & * +!( K +0 *"& & * +!( K 8( " .& & * 9" #1& !+0 "!

",!& # 8&&,D/"

*& *!(8& */ * ,!"+ 228 8& 1&*+ < < <2AM(+8$ ,+91 &!"+ & &9+/ !8"!( 1,!!+!(&,D/"

.& *8& .& *!+!(.& *+8 + .'&0!

<2;

.$& !1+ !"+ 0

+9 1& &# &1( + H +0!(&"*%/*#9 !"?!

&,!* *( / * @6H7 H7

+9!( 1.'0".*+ -(&.0 0+0 1+ * !+ 4" E B;

;;<A5) "! " $"* ! !(&! &0!

1&" # +0 !( &8& * -' + < <2A) !( ,+91 &!"+ &9+ 9+/ !" # !+ 2;A)CB)2A)CA<3 8 8& *1 1+"!* -' 8"!( + A <2A +8$ ) !( " + 1+ "!"$ &$ 9 ! 9&* " !( 1.'

' !(&! !( ,+91 &!"+ &9+/ ! 8 8"!(

1 1,!!+9&%+ "!'+0.& *(+.*" #/ / * 1 !&,D/""!"+ 8& .& &* !+ !( .& *+8 & + :2 < <2A $ ) !+*&') + *+,/9 ! ! + " 0+ 9&!"+ !+/,(00,!(&- - - +/#(!!+!( +!",+0!("+/ !

!)& /,( ,()" !((/9-.+1" "+ +0!("+ +/ !)+ ,!(&9+/ !8& .&* *!+ - 0","& '.& *+8 45+ .'&0!

<2 <2;)!('8 !"!.* * 0+ &8& * +0 2<<= +.&!"/9 / * ,.&/ / A B4"""54&5 +0 !( #/"*." *& *&!* C <2I "/* -' !( " "!

' +0 +&* ! & * "#(8& 8&') +$ $ 9 ! +0 *"& & *1"! !

!( & +/ ,9 ! +0 &8& * *& *&!* < <2A"

1 "+ !+:2 <2A)!( !(,+91 &!"+ (& +!- 1&"* "*"

1 1,! +0 9&%+ "!' +0 .& * (+.*" # / * &,D/""!"+ & + :2 < <2A + D/ !.') " !

9 +0 !( &"* * #/"*." & 8.. & !( %/*#9 9 ! 1& *-'!(+ K-.1?" ,& +0& 8& 9&.

& 8& 9&.

& 8& 9&." #(& "'&9+ " #(& "'&9+ " #(& "'&9+ " #(& "'&9+ + "&. + "&. + "&. + "&. /!G /!G /!G /!G 4/1 &5) 4/1 &5) 4/1 &5) 4/1 &5)!(1!"!"+ & (.* !"!.*0+ &8& *+0+.&!"

!"/9 N2 2<<=&1 !,(*/.+0!( <2:,!

??????

J 6;7 11 1.'" # !( &-+$&"*) !( 1

! 8 "! 1!"!"+ " &..+8 8*

1+ * !+ :& *A& *"

,!*!+ .& - 0"!+02<<=+.&!"/9" 0&$ $+/ +0 !( 1!"!"+

.& *+8 &.+ # 8"!( +!(

- 0"! " ,./*" # !( !&!/!

!+ ' " !

!" !

9 +0*,""+ 1&*" />(*$ />(*$ />(*$ />(*$ $" #(K $" #(K $" #(K $" #(K,&4/1 &5

,&4/1 &5

,&4/1 &5 (&9+ +/ ! -*1+"!*-'

' 1+ * !+ :& *A8"!(

1+ * !+ ;8"!(" 0+/ 8 > +9 !+*&' & * * !( &9 - *"-/ * -'

1+ * ! + ; " 0&$+/ +0 1!"!"+ .& *+8 8"!(" !8+8>!( &0!

6B7 ! "

" 9&* ,.& !(&! " ,& !( *0/. " +! *+ 8"!(" !"1/.&!*!"9)

1+ * !+ :& *A(&..- ."&-.!+1&',+!45+0 ;<)<< <<3 !+!(1!"!"+

.& *+8

(&9+/ !+0,+!

!45(&..--+ -'!(,+ ,

+00","&.0 +9!( ("

1 + &.1+,>!& *!(&9 9(&.. +!-!

&!*&&-/ * + !(!&!?, ,(D/

!( !(1!"!"+ .

.& *+8 8+/.*&.+-&!."-

!' !+> $"$&.+ +0!(1 !8 "!1!"!"+ 6I7 *" #&11.",&!"+ 45)"0& '(&.. &.+!& **"1+*+0 4

5 4

5 &'

&'2H 2H 2H 2H))))< <B !"> E( E( (!( 1&>" #3 &+ * (!( 1+ !&-. 3+ 3+