High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/12329/2018dismissed

M/S Sujan Multiports Ltd v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2019-03-12Mr. Justice Rajbir Sehrawat20 pages

!"# $%&%!'() ) *&+,- ',.%/!0&1#) )))))) %%!' 0 2 0&,& + !" '

'#!4 0& ))))))) &/!'# '& !0 5( 61)++7 0 & '( -8%0+ 40 :

.

!

"

"

"

" # $ %&'()*+,+ "

-. -.

!

-/!. " -/!. "

#

-/!.

0%%101%2( 3,4'* "

$5 6 "

7 %&1&01%2( 3 ,48* "

5 ! + 6 "

" 9

"

3

: "

! 4 " "

" !

" "

" "

" "

9 /!9 " $ %&'()*+,+

" /! /!

" " 7 %&1&01%2"

;4

!

!

"

#

$

%

! #

&

'

!

( )

)

& *

+ ,

# $

&

, -&

.

./(./

0

" 7 + $ 5 6 "

9 "

9 $ 8<0 +,+ " "

"

+

"

"

"

"# /! "

,

"$

"

+ "

$97 "

,

" "

$

" "

+ ""

$ 010+,+ ,

" = "

> "

"

4

? 9@"

$+

! 9 + "

#$ %

&' (&)

"9 + *

#+,-

.. 4

" /! # "

"

:"

"

, /! !

"

"

"

! + /!

9

" + "

$ %&'()*+,+ " , $ %&'+,+;4 ', / ##/ 0 1

2 / 23 4 / 1 (%*+

&

2 &

3

,

'

4))) (0*-

'

+ 2

"

5.

0

$ %&'()* +,+ $ 9 7 , $ # :$ %A1+,+

$ %A1+,+;4 .

23 / # ##/4 2

",

&

2

& 2

6

( &

3

%

%

&

&

( 7

8 2

2

3

6

'

0

$ %A1 +,+ :

"

> " $ 011 018 +,+ "

: " # :

$ %&'()* +,+ 4 : " "

9@"

$ + @ (* =

: " # "

! "

#

$

$ %&2 +,+ 9 $ %&A+,+

B : $ 011 018+,+ " @

: $ %&'()*+,+ " :

" @

9 9

$ 010+,+

#

!

$ %2)(<*+,+ 3 # # $ %&'()*+,+ !

# "

# " #

# "

"

9@"

$+ 5 # 6 5

//7 ..($

&' +,+#

+ C " : + # 3 " $ %'2+,+9 $ %&'()*+,+

$ %&'()*+,+ "

:"

"

# 4

9@"

$ + '%. ;,5 0(* " "#

9 +

" "

! $ %&'()* +,+ " #

# 3 $ %&'()*+,+ "

"# +,+! # "

"

" 7 $ %&'()*+,+ $ 011 +,+ : ! $ %&'()*+,+ 3

"

"

$ 01)+,+$ 018+,+ "4 : "

9@"

$+

"

$ %&'+,+ # ""

/!""

$ %&'+,+ , 7 + : 9 /! $

$ %&'(0* +,+

"

# " + $

:

$ %&'()* +,+

: -. -" .

: B

" "

9@"

$+ * .. $ $

'.! 8 #

# 9: ' $ $

) !; ; 2 %< =2

$ $

!

" /! 9 /!

"

/! " "

+ : ! # "

/! # " # +,+ "

"

7

"

$ %&)()*+,+ 9."

$ +

: #

3 !5 ; 1 *( $ $

. !

9."

$ + "

B4 = # - . -3 .

9."

$+

- . D3 3 "

, !

)&' + ! " 3

9 + "" $ %&'()*+,+ "

" $ %&'()* +,+

"

$ " 9."

$ + , >

#+,

($

&9

"

4 3 $ %&'()*+,+

# $ %&'()*+,+"

"

"

# D

9."

$+ " "

:"

"

+ " "

$ )0$ /=$! + :

E " $ %&'()*+,+ /!

9."

$+ " 3 3 $ %&'()* +,+ " "

"

9 9."

$+

" 4 "" " 9."

$ +

: $ %&'()*+,+> : " $ %&'()* +,+ "

" 9 9."

$ +

"

-

' . $ %&'()*+,+" "

$

$ %&'()*+,+ " "

"

"

" ""

" $

" $ %&'()*+,+ " !

@/!@ "

"

@:);9 9 "

"

#3"

$ %&'()* +,+$ "

"

$ %&'()*+,+ !

"

"

$ %&'()*+,+"

@/!@ 3 :D /! " " "

"

#

/! # " " "

+ " #

"

+ 44 +

#

#

@ 9

/

@:);9 3

"

" !

"

3 # + $ )A2D81%+,+ "

$ %&'()*+,++ "

+ 9@"

$ + , 4 ;

#? *2

. .

$'

!

+ / "

"

+ " "

"

9@"

$+ @ % *( $ $ $ '' * 2 > . $ $ $ ! 9@"

$+ 3 "3

+ " "3

" + " $ %&'()*+,+ " $ %&'()*+,+ " : "

$ )A2+,+ !

+ "

!

"

!

"" $ )A2+,+ ;4 2#

/

A / 1 # BCC 7

#

"

8

<

,

&

&

&

&

&

&

&

<

&

&

<

7

6

<

& ' &

)

#

"

8 &

=

" 9@"

$+

@ 9

$

+ "

" 4 "

@ 9& 9 9 + " "4

@9

9

9 9

9 >

"

+ " "

"

B "

" 9 $ %&'()*+,+

/! " @9

"

" @

9@

9

" @,

9% $ 0 +,+ 7

,

7 # " "

"

" "

+ " : $ %&'()* +,+ "

"

: # $ %&'()*+,+ 9 "

7 " 9

9 + # /!

/! /!"#

" /! ! "

/! "

"

" " $ "

+ 9@"

$+ @($*

"

! "

" " : "

"

9 9@"

$+

:$ %A1+,+ " $ %A, +

" +

! /! + " ""

!

" "

#

$@(*$ ? @(*

+ " " " $ %&'()*+,+!

# " $ %&'()* +,+ $ %&'()* +,+ " #

- . B # @

9

7 :

"

" + $ 5

" 9 + $CC C&

# 6

$ 8<0+,+ "

"

$ )A2()*+,+ > # + ;4 "

&

#

"

>?( ! +

"

>?( !

"

>?( !

& &

&

,

)

&

7

&

"

>?( !

"

&

&

,

%

%

#

<

-

)

%

<

"

"

>?( !

&

@ 9 @ 9

"

5/

!

!" !

#

# " !" !

# $

" %&' ( $

# $ $ #

# # " #)# *

$+ , "# -

# # " " "

# " "

.

# $ %&' (

, -

$ $# $ $

$/ ! + " "

+ "

"

" 9 " " 9 + $ 8<0+,+9 "

! " +4%2 '%;

,&4%< *

A

A- *

;

A-