High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/12348/2018dismissed

Fojiya v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2019-02-06Mr. Justice Hari Pal Verma13 pages

!"" #$$ %""

& "'$ $( "$

))))) !$" %'*+', -* "

"'("" $',.$'(/ --0 & %(+ "/ -* "

$%'' 1'("" '$ /($"("" %" !

2$'3

"' " 4 ($$ / 5/ 3$""$"/$$ !("

6'"'((/" , *"'(""

*$"3" 7 8 9 " 9 9 %" $ 4 9 9

6"' %" 7! %"

"' ! ""

'/ , %:/ ;

$ -"

3$" " < , !

/ %"" !("

6$$,$$

-2- !'$/$ ,

" "

/ $( "8 "

3""',"" "'*$"3"$ ,(" 3 = /$"" "'("" ( $":

3 " $ "'$($ $$"3"'$,/ /"-$%''$

- $$

',,$"$

'//+'/+/ 1'$/ + $"" %',/ >?!@ ($"/ $3 % '

6A !("-$%''' "'( $":$ "

"$ ' 6' $' $ "

3 "

/ & /$ $ "

"'" ' "

"'$ $ "' ("$

"' ( $": $ " ' $"$;9

9 $%''""''

"'( $": ""

, /$"'<'"'( $":, ,(/""

', "' "' ,/,,$

"'$,"

"''

$3*$$ "'" "'6// "("$',$"A; 9 "'( $": / 36"'', "''3 "

*/& $("/ !(""

"A, 6$"3$"''

$("/<'"', "'

( $":'

"'($(" $/( " "

"'$($ $, %6 "B>6'" / @""

(//"'( $":"' 6'/ ($$3 ' , "' & 6* $3 $ "' ( $":

( (/3"'"'1'$/ ""'(/ "6"'"'""

A( "

A// ' " - 3/ 7 8 9 " 9 9 %" $ 9 9

6"' %" 7! %"

"' ! ""

'/ , %:/ ;

$ -"

6$ 3$" " < ,!

/%"" !("3$"$%''- $C"

-3-

"'$$

$"","

"'( $":%" ! "'

%" 4 6$/$ "'$ 1'"$/"*$

"'72$" $ ," (3('8

"'($"("" $$

! " #$ %& # ' ( ( ( ) * + % # ' +# # '

# ' ( ( () * "

, -.

#. # $ %& # ' (( () * . . / # . 0 ,% # .. . # . 1 . # # . 2%&3403%& ,%# #

/ # # / # ,%. . .5%5%303%& -/

. #

-4-

. -/

# # %0 / . . .#

# # /

#. # #/ .# 1 # #

# / # # ! . / # ,%# # #1 " #D 1' ("" '$ "' $"" "'" "' ($$ "*"

"' "''

!'" $("/$ "' ,"" "6"'("$6$$""/

"'("" 6$"A ' *"

"'( /- 3/ ( 3$"'$76 $"

(( 8A' "6 "' ("" $ %'' 6$ (

, 9-""'"", *$(

*"6$3* $%''"'"$"'("" 6$, ""'"", $'6 / ""

$"6"''("$"', ,"

$'6//"", " " 6// /3"

', "

A( ' $ 6 6"' ', 1' "

4 $ %'' '$ ,/ ,,$ '* "A "'

-5- ("" "

',", /'

4 "'$($ $6"' ,, "" 3* "3$ "

"' ("" /$ ,$" ( $ "

'$ $"

A//'7"'$3 ,(/"6$3*"' ("" "

"'( / "'$$

6''78 49" 4 %" $

- 6"' %" 7! 6$ 3$" " !

/%"" '=3'

!("1'("" 6$"

/"'$ ($ $ "'" "' '* 3 " (

, 8A'

$ %'' $($ $"

3""'$

($,$$ 6"''*'* "'3 /"'("" " "'33$""', 1'("" / 36"'' ,/,,$$("/$ (( '"'/ /( /6"'2$""

"A" 3$""'$ ($ $ " " 6$"A3$""',1'("" '$/$ , ($"" "

$( "8 "

/ & "

$ - "'7 8 E 4 %" $

9 9

7!"6$3 "3$"3$"'"1' " "' ("" , * ((/"

/ 5/ 3$"" $" /$$ !(" $A3 *$"3"

"' $ " "' $, 6$ $,$$ * ,(3 " 4 -33* 3$" "'$

" 4 ("" '$ / "' ($" ("" 6"' "' (," (3('8 * C $/

"'("" '$3"'""'("" ' ,/ ,,$ $ 6// $ $("/ ($ $

"' / /" (( '"'/ /( /6"'2$""

"A" 3$""'$ ($ $ " " $"A3$""'$"' ($$$3

-6- (" ' "

$""/ "' $$ $ "' $ /"/ ($ $ 1' $ $("

,,""3' $, ,3 / "' "'"3 "' ("" ' ,/ ,,$ "

A// "', $ "' ,""$ "$ " "%"'( /'$ " " *$"3" "'("" , *((/"

*$"3"

"'$ ""' $, 6$ $,$$ / 5/ 3$"" $" /$$ !(" * ,(3 " 47$"',""$ "*$"3" "'( / "'("" 6 /$

*$/1'$($ $'* $( /"'/

"'("" "' ,3 /:"3 "'""

' %(+ "/ -* "((3

$%'''$ 3"'""'($/

"'72$" /"$"'""'$ //3"

( ,,"" ( "' ( $": 1' ( / '$ / *$"3" "' ,"" (( //" ( " $ "' //3" $ 6 "

$$""" * %"// * ,(3 " 4($$/3$"" /"'$ 3""

"'("" "

/(*" ,(/" ( "$"("" "'$$ 33*6"'"'( /( "//" ( "&'$ ( "'" (

3,"" 4 ($$/ -" /' 5/3$"" !("

6'$%''$ 2""

"''3 ,3$"',$378 49 " 4 %" $

- 7! 3$" " !

/ %"" '=3'

!("

6''$"A

-7- & '$ /$ ( ('

*"$ " 9 $' "' ("" ' , "' $""3 "' "'""' "6""

( "'"'78 9"9 9 %" $ 4 99

6"'%" 7!%"

"' ! ""

'/ , %:/ ;

$ -"

3$" " < , !

/ %"" !(" ( 6$ ,,"" 6"' "' ( $":

6''"A C %"" $/ '$ 3 "'" 7 8 9 " 9 9%" $ 4 99

6"'%" 7! %"

"' ! ""

'/ , %:/ ;

$ -"

3$""< ,!

/%"" !("

"'( /'$ ///" ( " "' $ $ "' ( $": '$ $"" "'" ( '$ " ,,""( '$' $ "6""

( "'"'$$ 7'*'/ $/

"'("$ 7" $ " $(" "'" 7 8 9 " 9 9 %" $ 4 99

6"'%" 7!%"

"' ! ""

'/ , %:/ ;

$ -"

6$ 3$" " < ,!

/%"" !("""'$"

"'("" 1'$7 6$*$"3""'( ///" ( "6$ /& 6* "'("" 3 ,(/", *((/" "

/3$"" $A3 *$"3" "' $ 6'' 6$ $,$$ * ,(3

" 4 6''$$",""

'//3"'($" (""

-8- !$/

"' " (

3," " 4 ($$/-" /' 5/3$"" !("

6$"'" $%''$2""

"''3$ ,3$"',$ 3 7 8 49 " 4 %" $

- 7! 3$" " !

/ %"" ' =3'

!(" 1' $ 7 6$ 3$"""'$"

"'("" ""'$6$2""

"'$ "'" "'("" 3 "' ,(/" 6'/ ((3"' 6"$$ : $ !< " $(( " "' ( $" $ 6$ "' /'

$"/%,// ', "'BF$!</$ " $(( ""'( $" $6$/'

$"/ 7"'($"78 9"9 9 6''6$3$" " "' '$"

"' ("" //3"

( 6$ , "' ("" $$'

"'76$3$"%" $99

6"'%" 7!%"

"'! ""

'/ , %:/;

$-"

"< ,!

/%"" !("& 6* "$ "'$

"'("" "'"/" %" 4 6$"'$ "'$$

$"","

"'( $":%" ! !$/

"' (

*" " 9 $' , "'

"'("" $'

6$"'"$''$," "'$

*""'" "'

$76$3$""'("" $$'6$,$3 $ , "'( ">, "'

"'( $":@"'( $":

//$"$ "' "6" "'" "'$%''$

" "'7$//%,/

*"'$/$ $' "' ("" 1'$ "' ( / '$ (( //" ( " 3$"

-96''"'("" '$(( (","

* A /3"

/ ( "$"("" & 6* $"

/3( "$"("" $', * ((/"

*$"3"

"' $ 6'' '$ / /3$""* " 4 7

!" # $%%&'$( ' ##)*( +,% " '$ '/ & G/ %(, " "'" "' *$"3" $"' ""

"'/*$"3" " $' *$"3" *$"3" '$ "

$"" 6(3 " "' / *$"3" /"

3"' 1' -(: " '$ /$ '/ "'" "'

"' *$"3" $ (,$$/ " *$"3" $ ( '" 1' /*" $*" $ $ ," (3('$ 8 4 "

"' $ 3,"( $ 6 7 8%9 # %62 # - - // . 7 809 / ## # #. ' . :### # ;/ # # # # . ! . # # # ## /

# .. + 7 . / 7 8<9.

-10- =8<9, #/ #### 7 809 #. ' . / ## # # / #. ' # / # > / # 7 809 8?9 # #. 7 809= < + #// / # 7 809 #.

' ###7 # #/ #. ' . # . / # 4 / / # / ./ / . # # ' # # / - # / / # # # 7 # @/ .

-11- =/ = # ==

> ==/ # # / # / / . / 7 8<9# %62/ ##/ / #. ' =#= # =#= / / %% + / )-#*#-#.

#/ !" 01 )

'$%%2(+32, ##/ / #/ ## / . #

" . # #

. # #/ #. / . ##/ %0 "#. / %430033<#-

. 7 # ." # ! / . # %%320335 # # 0% . . 1 " 7 .. # 7 # %03%033< ,?2 #0335-#

7 #1 .

# #-

-12-

%430033< .

. 7 %2 . # ' # # / " . #/ /## # 7 #A/ 4) 5 / !"4

'6&&7(+$$3B #/ # ## .- # #

. 1 ##/ " # 02% # - - . / 7 + / / # ' .

. 7 . - / # . D 1'

'*3 3 "

"' /6 / 6

8 8 9 $3"' ""'"78 9" 9 9 "'$ //3"

( (/6"'"' ""'" "' 7 8 49 " 4 "' ( $": ' , "' ' " $(( ""' 6$ "' "'6/'

$"/$6//$"' " "'" "' ( $": ' , "' '* $' "'

*"$ " 9 "'" "' " 6" "

( "' 7 8 9 " 9 9 $ ( 6$ * ,,"" "' $ 6'' $/" "

//"

"'$7 "'$ " $"'""'$ //3/"

-13- "',(3 " 4($$/5/3$"" $"/$$ !(" - 3/ "'($"("" 3*

$ $,$$& 6* $"//"$,/"'""'("" $'//"/" "

*/"',$*///6/3"'/"3" "'/"/ " " 4

!"#$ .3"" <'"'$(A3E$ .$ <'"'( "/