Mahabir Singh v. Shiv Narain

 

 !

"#$#%#&##  # #%# 

'()*+,-*./0/+1 22

(3(4/56/173 222228(/9(1)::*88(1) ;*50<0 63/=>(5(/1(1-+)3*50 22222?*0:+1-*1)0 

#@A B$C@D"

E #@# # %#& 5*0*1) >+1*,+5)3*(::*88(1)2

52;/1+-3(<-35/F-=+.()* ,+55*0:+1-*1)>+2GH10<5(1.*+9:(1I2 J KKKKKJ  #@# # %#&L"D 2 H1M<5*-(::*88(1) 3(0 ,/8*- )3* :5*0*1) (::*(8 0**N/17 *13(1.*9*1) +, )3* .+9:*10()/+1 (9+<1) (O(5-*- 4I )3* 8*(51*-

+)+5 ../-*1) 8(/90 P5/4<1(8F 6+1*:()

,+5 03+5) Q)3* P5/4<1(8R =/-* (O(5- -()*- G22 F +1 (..+<1)+,)3*/1M<5/*05*.*/=*-4I3/9/1(9+)+5=*3/.<8(5(../-*1)2 2 P3/0 /0 ( 5*.+10)5<.)*- .(0*F (0 )3* +5/7/1(8 ,/8* O(0 4<51) /1 )3* ,/5* )3() 45+N* +<) /1 )3* .+1.*51*- 45(1.3 /1 )3* I*(5 2 6/1.* )3* .(0* /0 :*1-/17 ,+5 )3* 8(0) 9+5* )3(1 G I*(50F )3* .+<10*8 ,+5 5*0:+1-*1) >+2G 3(0 1+ +4M*.)/+1F /1.(0*)3*0(9*/0-*./-*-+1)3*4(0/0+,)3*(=(/8(48*5*.+5-2 G2 H) /0 0)()*- /1 )3* 75+<1-0 +, (::*(8 )3() )3* /1M<5*-(::*88(1)F (7*-  I*(50 () )3* 5*8*=(1) )/9*F 3(- 9*) O/)3 (1 (../-*1)F O3*5*/1 3* 3(- 0<,,*5*- 9<8)/:8* /1M<5/*0 /1.8<-/17 03+5)*1/17 +, 8*7 )+ )3* *S)*1) +, T /1.

3 (0 O*88 (0 0)/,,*1/17 +, 9<0.8*0F +1 (..+<1) +, O3/.3F 3* 0<0)(/1*- GU +, -/0(4/8/)I2 * 5*9(/1*- (-9/))*- /1 )3* 3+0:/)(8 ,+5 (4+<)  -(I02 P3* P5/4<1(8 3(0 (O(5-*- (1 (9+<1)+,?02VFW/1(883*(-0FO3/.

   

  !" # "$  %&'"!   ($ ) " $$"  $"

$$ *' +(  ,) " '-     # '" ' .

 ,)  /',! '"   '- "'

 ,"'

" '"

0!"

 " , ($"

' "



) ,

  

$$  *'  1!'"  (    $!"  / $  #! ' *!

, **'  #   0!

-( ' 34567822 9:;22 <494:4=>7?22 @7>7AB6C22 D>4EB522 F>54722 F>:G67>HB22 I=;22 JE5;22 7>522 7>=EKB62

&  LL

'+'

  '- 



'

  M $   N *'  '0!  '(  " "! M ,)

- " +'  ,'-

'+ '

 "

-'- ( 

!"'- $( 

'"

,'')   O # .

 "

 L"  & P ,)

  '

"  '(" /',!

Q- !( +'

 

  *'  "    ,)  '- !   ! # L"

 NP +'

 

 N

* 

$$  #'-

--'+

$$  R,  S!$( ! ' "    ,) ,"+'-   T/'" ! " ($ "'U '(

- '  T0!" ($"

'V "!

' !



("  *!

-  $   +' '( '

" 

$"''

" "   ' ,#   !  # 

'

 W'" 

(! # ()   ( '

($"

'

  "   !(

$ '

"!##'- 

+' '( ! -"

#

"'!"

'



 $   "" #

+ 

( ) ($"

' '"  (  M* 

*,) " ')

""!" "( ( "! # "'!'  " * "!+'+

 +' '(" * +  #  ' '+"V
! *'

*'- 

$$  ($"

' "    ,)  M'- ' "'

 '#*'- T / +'

     ' '

"  

$$  "!## $  $-'

!  

'

   $-'

'"

#( # 



  !

"# $%  % &% ' " (% )  % &( %+ + & &% '

% )"  " %

"  '%

)

 *  (  )" * ) %

,

- 

) ). && %,

). % *  & )" & * &%

)  /( ). & )% )( ( & , * "

& % %* )% )" +  % 0%

),

'

).

+  ) , "  

), ). , % , )1 %, %&# $) + %,  .

*  + &, * )% )" &+ .

& + %+ )" + " '%% ).

*&%

) %+  & )"

))&  !

).

%+ '

&% *# # $) %+ &

) +)", %+  )% 

) %+ !( ) 

  ). (% )  )" ( " % %'  % '

( '

.  %   %+ * # %+ %+ "

!

%

) %+

*

 .

!

). (

 " ! %+  )%,

%

) %  !

 + * ) % 3 ). "

%)&

 %)"

 ).  

"#  !( )  & (" !  " % +' ! ) .' 

*&% "#
(%+ , %+  )% % %+ % *

&& " )%4(%   "56 71 11 11 # 8+ % % & * )%

) " " ! ( ()"  "

 )% + " ()"  # 

) )."( % "

!

%:#,,; # 

) ).

* )%+ :#<; #

"

& 1 )  :#,,; #
(%( * "

& 1 )  :#,,; # %% )")%&+.  :#,,; # % .%

)&+.  :#,; # 

& )' )& :#,; <#  ))"(

). :#,,; #

 .   &% :#,,; # 

* ) %  :#,; % :#,<,;6 #  )=! %+ >( *  (%

)?

@ABCD??

EFGHHI??

J??

EBFGKI??

LMNNFKO??

PND?

?

QHRKAOFS??

@FOFRHIT??

UV??

EWFWH??

QAFC??

XIFONYAIW??

ZAIYAIFWKAO?   ::

 '

 , +  ) %+ && " )% +"

&&( "

) ## , &( ).  *) )% "

!

% % %+ 1% )%

-

)  %

) % .+%   *!, % %+ & *)%,   

" *), + )"  ). + !

%  '

).

()&%

) "

!

%  '  

*&% ). + ) ). && % )" +'

). % (  %+ % & *!,  " "  & * )%

)

:# :#,,; ! %+

%  && " )%  * 8 !(), [ + $$, [3  (%, \  [ + ! )

"  "% " <##, + &+ %

"

" ! %+  .+  (% % %+ 1% )%

:#,, ; '

"

"  "% " # #<# ] ). ()% 

", %+  )%  &+ "  )=! %+ >( *

 



!"##$

%&'%(

##$ ) *% 

)) %(#

$

&%' % #

##$ '

) + %%

) '%)

,%'

-

.%( ,  % , % % 

''

'

* %% ) ' , % &

) +  % -'

+  &

-/  + &&% # , &'%+ %

%'

  0  ) '

) %&+ # - '

 ) * & 1 , -

  %  -/ ,%  % +'%*'

% &

, 20  &+*  %3 +  - % * %

&,  +   *'& , &'%+ % ,

+ * %% ,

- ) , &&%  4 *'& " 6789:;55 <755 <=>55 ?@>A>:<55 BCA>D55 <=>@>55 9A55 :755 E9A?F<>55 G9<=55 @>;C@E55 <755 <=>5 CBB9E>:<55 9:55 G=9B=55 <=>55 C??>HHC:<55 =CE55 AFI>@>E55 JFH<9?H>55 9:KF@9>AL55 M>@<9:>:<HND55 A9:B>5 <=>@>55 9A55 :755 B=CHH>:;>55 <755 <=>55 OCB<FJ55 7O55 <=>55 CBB9E>:<D55 <=>55 JC::>@55 7O55 9<A55 <CP9:;55 ?HCB>D5 CA55 G>HH55 CA55 H9CQ9H9<N55 OCA<>:>E55 F?7:55 <=>55 E@98>@D55 7G:>@55 C:E55 9:AF@>@55 7O55 <=>55 7I>:E9:;5 8>=9BH>D55 <755 Q>55 K79:<55 C:E55 A>8>@CHD55 <=9A55 9AAF>55 E7>A55 :7<55 GC@@C:<55 C:N55 OF@<=>@55 AB@F<9:NL5 R9<=55 @>;C@E55 <755 >:=C:B>J>:<55 7O55 <=>55 B7J?>:AC<97:55 9A55 B7:B>@:>ED55 <=>55 C??>HHC:<55 =CE5 AFI>@>E55 A9J?H>55 CA55 G>HH55 CA55 ;@9>87FA55 9:KF@9>A55 9:BHFE9:;55 A=7@<>:9:;55 7O55 H>;L55 S>5 AFA<C9:>E55 TUV55 7O55 E9ACQ9H9<NL55 S7G>8>@D55 <=>55 W@9QF:CH55 =CA55 CGC@E>E55 C55 AFJ55 7O5 XALUYDZZZ[\57:5CHH5=>CEAD5G=9B=59A59:CE>]FC<>L^5 _

*%( % .%

, &'%%/ ) )&  &%&+ &

% '%(, ) , )

% %&+ ) ' # ,%  )% , ) ,

) 0 %&  -  ` '/ + # , + ) &+*  %   , ** '' %  `%  - ,& ,   % )) %(+ '(/

#$   + % -%'%/ &, , %()'

(  %)) %()+ &'



"#$ !

%&' a* 



#$  b

) 4 

!#$  c* &%'%  * 

#$ d' 

##$ 

 

!" #$$"

# % "  " !" "!#" #&' ( &$"%#  ( )% * +" # #,+" !" #&' ( )%-* # "# #.#" , !" /,'#  ."+" !" # " (  ""%  !" "!#" #&'   +". ( !" 0' &" 1 23454674811 9:;11 <;=;11 >?@A1

-  B - %!#

," C $" #'& #' (& !" # " ( !" #.# 

 % "# D#  .!! .

," $# !" #&# #$$"

# . ! # $" ( . & !% (& !" # " ( ""$ ( # " (" $ ( !% 0' &"  (# .!! !" #&' %!#

# # ""% # !"# "#%# "# #.#", !"/,'#  /!" %# #&' ," E"$ 
F) "# !" &#G&'& # " (  ""% 

 %%,'%#  !" #&# #$$"

#   /!" /,'# % " " &#E" "#"% "(( % "

"#%" !" #&'  !" #&# #$$"

# # !""# "% ##". ! #. H

( !" #.# !" #("%# "G "  !" $"%" #$$"# % %$%"(  " #$$ # (# ,"%$%"(#

 )"

%  % " " %" # $ ( !" 0' &" !" "" /,'# (""%%# &$ #" IJKJL1AMJ<2MJ?NO1 P<2QR1  

S#&# T!" !"%$"#E *"#%" U"%*V T!" !""$ #, U"%*V