← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6527/2020disposed of

Anuj v. State Of Haryana And Others

2023-04-20Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj19 pages

  

       

  !"#"

$% % ANUJ   

     

 STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS    

    &'(&%) * )%+      ,,,,,        

  

 

     

 !" 

  

 

 # $      % 

  

 

 #       &&&&& * )%+-%./01   '   

(  )

 "





 



  *

+ 

  

, ) (   +





)

"

-( 

 ,







 )"



  

  

 '

+ 

 )    +    + 

)   . 

 

  ")

+  

  /"



)    !

)

   



     

  

  

 )). 0)  ' ) # ,  1 

     .  *  2    /")





 

 

 *    "

 "))*

+) ) + )

) 

+#

)!

)

-2-





)'

.3 

 

 +)) + 

.





 )  ' 

 , " ,

.    )

)   

+

40)5 )

)



 ") 

 ) )

  , 

.  6664   66664   +

 0 .  

))* /") 

,) "

"

.

.

+ 5 (7 686$6$9  

.

     )).0) ,   



( "9:

+# , 2  # ,  "

 " ) )

66$6$92 , 2 )0)"0 )

.,   )



 ' ,

)

*





 ") +  )  

+)     .   (  .   ,   

    ("

 )   7 

 

)      

* " 

 ;  

  

 + "

+2 )

 886*

 ,

. )

 ) 



2 ) ,  +))  ,) "  )  (

)

*,  ))

 

,    + *  (    " .   ("





" ( *    ' 5      (*.   (

". 

  !

)2  )# , 

+, ,  .

 ) !

)). 3  .

 +

+   , +     ) -  "

  )

2  '  *   ( * 

 

 ,  ()* +.    +  "

"

 ( " $6$ * < 

 



")( 

)*  +" .  +

+ (

  )( , '  

 " "

 $66=  ( ) *    

 ' ( ) *

(  )

.,     

- ) 

 

,"

  +    

-3-

"  ,    )  

)     )

 48



'+ 

 

"

")

(

'

 

 

. +   ) "

 

( 

 ,   (   )    +        

 +   .

"



   ,  ( 

  ()  

 >



+)





+)   2

        .

    

"+  .

   ,  ".

.

".

 

+ 2  

  

.

+

 * 6$  

.

+

". .( "6*  +

  ,   " 

 !) ?  

+ )   -  )). 

   /"

 

 ) 

 



  .) .



  

    ("

)  + 

. + 

)   

 

 (* "

. .") + 



' ()"(

+ , 

  .

  +   (

  ,    ")

 ,  ' ) ( ) *

"

 .) .

 (  > )" )*

 

    ("

)  >+) *

+ 

 ". (,   

  + )*

 



+



2

   + 

.(   (* 





+ 

 ,,   

 8  

 "





 

 )* (* ,*

 

 

 05  .



0  ."(1

) .

 @7 

)A 1  2 * 0 5)  # .+< + # , 1 

 ,

);  ,



  /"





  ")

 ) 

 .) .



  ("

) -( 

    

       0)" 0  2 )



-466$6$9  886    *    )

* ")* 

 + + 

 

 +) 

+ .( 



 .B )1  *# 866C6$6$9, 

   2 )0)"0   *)

 ")2, * .   "



  

+ D ,   ,      )



-   

  /"



) ,  " * ")

  ("

)   

   

 .  *

- "

 ,

 ") *+ +  (*  ("

)   ,







  *

.

 )

 , ")*

)

) 4   ." + ))* 

  

 *(  .

, 

 * )

 ) 

 +

 

.

 +  )  

   

 , )).))*,

.



+  ))  (*2 )0)"0 (*   ("

) 

 * .  ")

  

) ,

.

 

)", +)   "+ )  " .

  /"

 2    B7,  



+  )).))* ,  " *

 +

 



1  2 * 0 5)  # .+< +  # ,   ("

*) 2,

"

E   B7 ,  

  ) +(

+ '

  /"

,) ( )* ( .+ 

+  +

  

).)

( .   (*  ("

) . "

"

"

E+(*  

    , 

  0)" 0  2 )   ) ,   + 

*+

  ("

) 2  

   

, +  !

)2  )# ,  

<

 

  , ) 

"

 !

/" )*    ("

 ) 

-5-

() 

 ()



+  . 

   -     )



) 

.

 () 

 

     .



".

"+  )

.,     

   '

 /"

 ,   



  

 (

   !

  ,  ( ) * /"

( "

 ")

)

"





  ". 

 

 

< (  "(*!

)2  )# ,  ,  

   +)  ) 



  B ) 1  * #  86  6C6$6$9



'



   

)

"



 66$69)

., 

 

66F86 

( .  " C  -  "

   "  

 

 66$6$9  "))*    )   ,    

 "  5"

 "   )

"

' "  , 

)* ,      +

  , 

  /"



) ; ) 

 

   ,

. )

,  

+ 

(  +   .") )*F

 )*,  

 

    

( . )



+  )

*")*  )0)"0      B7,  



+ 

 "

"

E+

  ) )

,  

' 



. +) 

 "

"

E 

 ) +( .



+   "



,   

( ."

E       ..  



 

  2 "

 ) +

+ 

(*)).

.  ("

) (  .) . 

-6- ?  ' > !

   + 

  

 

     

 

 

    

    (

"

            ! "     # " $%% 

&$' 



 



                  

    

              

   

          

           

      

  

  

  

 



     

 

      !             

     

          

   "

    



 

 

    #  

   !  !!$    % 

 



        

    !        

 &      

      

'

    

          

    " %

 

 

 

 

         ( &               

  

   



  

     )    

*            

-7-

    

 '



   (



  

 &        &     +   

  



        

 

    

               '

( ,   

             

   & +       



(  









   

  "    

 &   



 

            (  





    '

 



    

  &     

  

 

       

       --

  &   

 (  (    )   )  

)'

 ./#

*)01*'

02    

  & 

  

 ,  

      

            %    





     

    

 



                     %    

   

   

       

 

    

     (                 

             

  %     

   &  '  *)+, )

-8- "       -)  )

.)+   /) 012+ 3.

)    )   )45 

  $%%   

 &'6 $%%  

  ) 7 % 3   4    '

  /

 )  *   

  '  

        

   

    '

   

 

  



         



 

     % 

  

 

       !  '   5    !!$

            



          

 

      

   

   

   

    

    (         

   



 



   6

          



       

 ( 

        7    7

           

    

       

   

    

                  &   8      

 0% )

.)+ /) 012+3.

)  ) 

 )8 

  $%%'  

 $  '

 

 

 



    

             !    %

-9-

 

   

  #        

    % 



'     9  )  *   0$ 

       #    

  



  

 

          ,      (        

             



     

'

:

&

             ;             



      (      92  :).

); 3   

$$ $& 

 &<$

   

 < )'

2!.=$

$> $ $1=1$* 7$>(     







           

      )      

  &*

    



       % 

 



      

  5     



      



 

:

2 >>>     

       2

  (      

   , <

               

    



       

 

  

   !!$!

-10-

   ? $ ( 

 





 

   

                  

   %     

   +    

    

             

       $1 %  

 

 

      



       )'    + :;   9   

)!>>0*$'

!*%       

 

      (    

 

  



   )               * @         

   .

 

     (  &      ,  

      

  20  

@    

 .  

    

   A    



 

    + :;  (   

           

            :  #   - 5         

 

     )   

-11-



*



  











:

> +

8:

12 +

'  

 



 

5

   ,     

 

 

  

 

  







          (   

       

     

   

 :        @     

  : >..!>! +         (    





 

:  'B 

  

 B 8  

 B  

- 5   ;        $6  

 

       !         

@   



 



     '

  

3  4  )  * ' ' )!>>$*'

1 :'

'

4

=  )0*'

 4 '   '

BC  

)02*'

$11 DE '

B=C= /  )02*'

$11 -C4

'

64 )001*'

$ 1(   







 

       

      

           

D D



  

<

-127  6   

     

         

    

        

                      

             

 

    

        &   

 

   .

.               :

  @   .

(     

     

   



 

   '

/ "    % ,=+) >) 92  :).

); 3 .) )    )   ) ? - 8 % 

 -1) ?@ $

   $     & ( 5  

        !!$      

 

   "       3          &        

 22F  

   

  

'

 ;         !! C    &    

        .1.!>G

  &    

   !

  



 '

    A /   '

A  /    

 & .             !    5      !!$



 H

 (    - 

 @ (   '  

   -  5       (  +

-13-

    

         

 ;         2  ;    ? -        A 8 $%&$

'%8   

   

,     

  

 

              +       (   

     +         

     

   



 + 

 

       % 

 

 < 70(       

    

 +          

    (   

,     

  

 

          +       (     

        +               

   

 



 +

  

          (     

 

         

,    >(  

 

 9

B<B.

 1

? ! ) .C8 $<'7 @?

7%'8'$D 7

 

           

  

     

-14-  

 



            

            

   

  7 (      

 

 %  

    +           E'

 +

 

    

   B"++   *   ") ) A)+=

8 $%    @1 &  D (                 

 

    



      

      

      (          & 

         

        

            

           +         +      4       G   

                    ( 

  

  

 

                                 ) B #@ ( E

(

 9 !$*( 

    

            

     (      



           & 

         

        

  +        

-15-

 +    "C=   #+9 B$%7$3++/A %8 %%D   (                     

      %    

 

    +     

  

  

        

      

, 

  

       

   

  7 22 @        ,)  

;  )   A)  ))2 ? )2

   1

 ? 3 8$%

&7 

            

 



          



           

, % 

   < 7$(  

        

 

  



       

       +       +    

           

       

 



      (





       

,  (           

, 

 7  +  G     (  



    +   

       

      %         



 

 

  

 '



E

( )2 9* >$

<

-16- 7(   

,  

    

   



      



 &    

 

  7 %5   E

9  9 I!

11   

  <7      

         

   

     



  

      

&    

        G   

    

 A  J       G         



    

  76          

  

  

   

   



  

       7 9  - "  

+ ")

(

, !

 +*, 

+ 

 

..

 . ,

. 





(  

 "() "* 

+    .

 ..

 *  ) +

+ 

"

 

),  

 (



 "   "(

!





+ 5"



 ' , 



+ 

   "()  ), 5"



  " ,  " 5"   *  

) " 

+., +*(), "))*  )() 

 +

 

 /"++ ' /" "+



+ 

 , , ") "

 ")   

    

  .5 

+") (

)  () 

-17G  '  !

 ,    + 

 2E2)       @3(

.!;C9

6$ 

$G$66$),  !

 ,   



   

 

+ 

    (



 

    +

() ) .

  

 3"

  !

 + 

 

;C C) @")+):) *)2;1

(

.!;$?96

6$C 

 686G6$G )     ".  

) )   ,   ) +     

 )    

 

)*   ( )   

+" /" "+



+ 

 )

"

  , ++*( ."  .



,  .

+ 

 $6    

.(

 - 

+ 

)"

 , !

+* .



"+

, 

+ 

 

 ..

 ,   

  "

 5"

   ")

   .  (

". 

 (*  

  @   ("

 )  ( . 



       A ' )+ 



+ 

  .

 . (  

"() "*  ,  " 5"   .

 

 ..

       +    

), 

 .  

)

 (

  !





+  5"



    ". 

)



 )  

) ()  ,  +* ( . ."  .

)(*!





+ 5"



   

+ 

*() 

..

 $$  ' 

    ,  , 



/"+

 -  , 

  "$66=  +   ( ) * , "

 (*   

   ")

  )

"



-18- $   "/"



 , ")"+ . ,   5"

* /"

," "

)* ")

 ,  ")

  



 

   ("

) +*) ( + ")      ") *



("

* .) .

   

 , ")

)(  )  +

+ 

 $8  '  

   * . 



 ( "  *  

.  +

". +

  ,    "

2 /")  )

    +"



    + , ") 

 +    *     +  +  /"



 .) .

4

("

*

.) .



+"





++") )* .

 )  /" "+



+ 

   /"

   (  +  (* ) .  

+  

 $  <



)

 



 ".+ 

 ( "   )  ,  

   + 

   

 ,    

+ )

 "(  + . $  -  





/"

  /"

; )  

 ) "

) .+   ,  





   ("

) )  ) 



+ 

  B )1  *

 )  $C  ;  ".

. + 



*

)     



 . *



 . ,  *,)

,  , 



("

* .) .

) +* 5" 



   *    ( .  

     "/"



 , 

(   , 5"



 "

 " 

)*( +   

  



 



-19- $?  ,  

    + 

)   

   

 $ "$

/"4 !

$# $  #%  067#  ,      

 2 +*      

  !





+  5"





 .

+ 

 ),'!





+  5"



 +*  "

 +  )+ 



+ 



 ( 

  

 ) (*         ( ."  (* "



)

)" .." ) 4 +  

("

 



) $G99 +*+  

 '  +

+ 

 ))( ("

  

,  



 4 $ 7#

+ 

  

 

*

 7  #) +

 

"

.,    

 +   .(

 !

  )) "

 + ,  

*

 

    (*   *))(> )"

+

+" .) + 



  "



"



 .   '     

  "  )* )) , ,  ) (   

                .* )%+1  (-       I

'

  ;  .4 

  %4#     ; 

()   %4#