Sagar v. Union Of India And Others
B5'%!%!" '
6' (0(
"%&' (
!"
B5'(+" $' %(
')!
')!
')!
')!
+,"
+,"
+,"
+,"
* * * *
'(' %* '(' %* '(' %* '(' %* !(!" *
(!" *
!(!" *
(!" * + !, + !, + !, + !, 2 1
*
*
*
* + !, + !, + !, + !, 2 1
:- 5
:- 5
:- 5
:- 5
- - - -
5 & !1 $6")
5 5
0,,
+')!
03,!) 5 ''(& <07 $6")
"(')0%"
'(+" $' %( 5
===== ===== ===== =====
- - - -1 5 >-?
5 >-?
5 >-?
5 >-?
'(' % #!,'
2
&
%!.
!/
/(&
&!% 2
>#"
(&" % @
:?
+'%!%!" ' 1 !7!
"
"7+, ! % "5D
EEFE 1
1 1
)%1 !(%' '$
5 %!%,'$
6' ( (0( .0(&7
& 0 !
"%&' (85
5
7'
) !7!
)"7+, ! % G0'(%!"
3'!
! 6",6
!7!
"7+, ! %
+' % ! !
! 6",6!
')"6' .
7(
7+&'% 7!
'1 9
7( ") ! '1
7(
7( ! / ") ! '
7(
3,'%( ))0('$1
7',.1 .0(&7
& 0 !
$!(),"(0 '
))0('$1
!7+,!)
-'
)"0 (', !%'
)0(%"$.
(! )'
H5 H5 5 -'
)"0 (', #0 %&'
(037!%%'$
%" .
+ "6!(!" (
() 0+0,"0(,.
)"7+,!'$ ;!%&1
%&0(1 (0##' ( ! &' ' % $'#')%(5
-'
)"0 (', !%'
.'$
,!
3!,!%.
%&' '"#
(%' '$ -'
)"0 (',
0'$
!7+,!) G0'(%!"
+ !7 !,.
$!(),"(0 '
%'7' % ))0('$1
7',.1 .0(&7
& 0 !
$!(),"(0 '
;5 -'
)"0 (', #0 %&'
!%'
(0##' '$ 7" '
7" %&(5 &0(1
.'$ #" 5
5
-'
)"0 (', '(+" $' %( 1
!(!
(037!((!" ( $'7 '+,.
5 5 "++"('$
0!
%!" (
!('$
! (%
(' !"0(
%0 '
$1 %&0(1 $'(' 6'
)" )'((!"
!,5 -'
)"0 (', #0 %&'
(037!%%'$ ! (%
+,'
" (
2H
)%1
%&0(1
7'
"0 $!(7!(('$5 -'
)"0 (', (''/( +, ')" $
)0(%"$.
)' %!#!) 5 25 %"$ .1 /'
')" $5
5
)"0 (', !6 %!'(
" '
%& "0
')" $(
)0(%"$.
(! )'
H5 H5 1 ;&' '!
! 6'(%!
!'$ "0%
+ '(' %'$
5 5 "%
;!% '(('( )!%'$1 "0% ;&!)&1
" '
'I 7! '$ %!,, %'5
$03!% 3,.1 )" ),0(!"
;!,,
/'
!%( ";
%!7'5 !7+,!)
G0'(%!"
(",',.
$!(),"(0 '
%'7' % ))0('$5 (
+'
6' (!" 1 %&' '
%' !
)" ')%
)" % 'I)'+% $!(),"(0 '
%'7' %5
+' %! ' % "%'
(0)& $!(),"(0 '
%'7' %(1
3(' )'
)" "3"
%!6'
'6!$' )'
&",$ ,!7!%'$ '6!$' %!
,0'
(",'
!7+,!)
',!
0 (03(%
%'7' %
!('( (' !"0( $"03%(
3"0% ! '((
"3A')%!6!%.
! 6'(%!
%!" 5
$!(+0%'
(+"%5 )!%.
;'!
'G0! '$
%% )&'$ $!(),"(0 '
%'7' % $'
;!,, #0,,.
%'(%'$
%!7'
!6 )" %' %!" (
!('$
!6'
!('
$'3 !((0'(1 (&
%!")!
$0 !
)"0 ('
&!( $''7 !%
++ "+ !
$',6'
$''+ %&'('
!6 )" %' %!" (1
'1 ,'(% !%
+ 'A0$!)'
"%&!
!3,'
3 "0 #" ;
! $!) ,!/',!&""$
3()" $!
+ ")'((
! %' #' !
'6!$' )'5
% A0 )%0 '1 !% ;"0,$
++"(!%'
'#'
A0$
(('$ (&0,
6' (0(
0 A (&0,
6' (0(
0 A (&0,
6' (0(
0 A (&0,
6' (0(
0 A (('$
9
9
9
9 > * * 9?1 ;&' '! 1
',.!
$')!$' $!
A0$ 7' %( " :3,'
0+ '7'
"#
6' (0(
7!, $01
0+ '7'
9J
7%5
A70 !(& 3$0, 7!$ & $7!.
K - $""
+0 6' (0(
0A %1 )"%!)( " % ", 0 '
9 J
>?
'
,0 0 6(5 ,,0, 3!$ &7 !70%%
5:1 > ?
> !7!
,?
J
D!A
6(5
+')!
-'
++'
> ,5?
"5>(?
E 21 $')!$'$
H5 5 21 &',$
%&0(*
L
;',, '(% 3,!(&'$ + ! )!+,'
)" #'((!"
$'
! &' ' %,.
6' .
;'
/ +!')'
'6!$' )'5
0)& %'7' %>(?1 %&'7(',6'(1
#" 7 (",'
)" 6!)%!"
! $!6!$0
70(%
() 0%! !M'$ 0%7"(% 0%!"
)" A0 )%!"
(03(% %!6'
'6!$' )'5 " '"6' 1 ')"6' .
'##')%'$ +"(('((!"
+'%!%!" ' 1 ;&"
(03('G0' %,.
!7+,!)
(",',.
$!(),"(0 '
%'7' % ))0('$5
+' % ! ( ,!#'
! $!6!$0 ,1 "0 %(
"3,!
(% !/'
3'%;''
#'
+' ("
' (0 !
'##')%!6'
$7! !(%
,("
! 6'(%!
%!" 5 #!
'6!$' %!
,0'
$7!((!3!,!%.
$!(),"(0 '
%'7' % $'
;!%&!
$"7
$A0$!) $0 !
)"0 ('
))" $ '(% 3,!(&'$
+ ! )!+,'( ;5
$A0$!)
+,'
!,1
'7 "3,!6!"0( )! )07(% )'(
!7+,!) %'$1 ! ),0$!
%0 '
%!" (1 '6!$' )'
,! /!
;',,
(+')!#!) ",'
%% !30%'$ )"77!((!"
"##' )'5 + !7
)!'
'I 7!
%&'('
)%" ( '((' %!
' (0 '
+ ")'(( 7!(0('$1
30('$ 7!($! ')%'$58
55
! $''$ + ") (%!
#",,.
%&' '"#
$$,'$ ( +'
)0(%"$.
)' %!#!) 5 25
#!,'$
,'
)"0 (', '(+" $' %( 1
, '
$.
(0##' '$
+' !"$ 7" %&(
.(1 (&";
! 6",6'$
>(?5
&!(
A0$ %!%,'$
<0,;! $'
6' (0(
<0,;! $'
6' (0(
<0,;! $'
6' (0(
<0,;! $'
6' (0(
0 A 0 A 0 A 0 A (('$ H
H
H
H > ** 9?J
',.!
$')!$' $!
A0$ 7' %( " :3,'
0+ '7'
0((
<& %""
6(5 "7'
').51
!&
> 9 ?
J 3$0,
'&7
%0, 6( 5 / > 99?
J 6'$ 0, 3!
!/& 6(5
(&%
"%&' 1 >2?
> !7!
,?
9J
"&$ 0(,!7 K 0(( 6(5
> ',&!?
'+" %'$
2
J !7!
++'
"5E H5 5 %!%,'$
L&!%%
!(;
,!
03& 6(5
N'(% '
,8J L!%!(& $&!/ K
6(5
N'(% '
,81
+')!
-'
++'
> ,5?
"52 5 5 %!%,'$
L"&
,7
!#
!/&
6(5
0A
%8J !7!
++'
"5
5 5 %!%,'$
"+ < !(&
K "+ , 0(7
6(5 !"
/0 & 0$& 6(5
$&.
$'(&1 >?
> !7!
,?
HJ &',$1 %&0(*
LH55
(+''$.
'I+'$!%!"0( " ,.
6!% #'
+ '6' % 0 $0'
"++ '((!6'
%!" J 7!%!
I!'%.
)" )'
))"7+ .!
))0(
;',,
)0 %
!7+ ! 7' %
3!,!%.
$'#' $ &!7(',#1 30% %&' '
"6'
)&!
(")!'% ! %' '(% 6!
(+''$.
&!(
'+'
%'$,.
)%0 ')' %
$')!$' $!
3"6' '#' '$
0+ '7'
"0 %:( A0$ 7' %( $";
(' !'(
$')!(!" ( "+' !
0+ ';
6!(% #0 $ &%(5
)" )'+%
(+''$.
%!),'
'((' %!
#0 $ ,!#'
,!3' %.1
%''$
+ '(' 6'$ "0
" (%!%0%!" 5
(+''$.
! (
)%0 '(% ! %
!7+"('$
%!7'
'(%
)" ('G0' %
)" %! 0'(
'(1
7',.1
! 6'(%!
%!" 1 ! G0! .1 ,1
++'
'6!(!"
("
+"((!3,'
+ 'A0$!)'
'(0,% $0'
!7+' 7!((!3,'
6"!$ (! )'
%!7'
)"77!((!"
%!,, ) !7!
+ ")''$!
)" (077
#!
,!%.1 )"0,$
6' %'$5
(+''$.
,1 ,.
G0!)/ $!(+"(
(! '
G0
) !7!
A0 !(+ 0$' )'5
"6' ) ";$'$ "0 %$")/'%(1 6.
6",07'
;" /
'(0,%
+ '((0 '
",!)'1 ! $03!% 3,.
/''+( ' %! '
) !7!
A0 !(+ 0$' %!
7')& !(7 (% '((
! 5
'I)0('
/''+!
(;" $ 7"),'(
! $'#! !%'
+' !"$ %!7'5
(' 6'
) '$!%
) !7!
(.(%'71
!% /'(
## ! (5
%''
(+''$.
! %' $'$
6"!$ "++ '((!"
+ '6' %
!7+"(!
"3,!
+ ")''$
("
$!(+ %)&5
%''
(' 6'(
%& ''#",$ +0 +"('5 ! (%,.1 !% + "%')%(
! (% "++ '((!6'
+ ' !7+ !(" 7' %J (')" $,.1 !% ',!'6'(
I!'%.
+03,!) (0(+!)!"
$0'
0 '(",6'$ ) !7!
'(
(%,.1 !% + "%')%(
! (% !(/ '6!$' )'
;!,, ,"(% 7'7" !'( $!77'$
((
%!7'1 %&0(1 !7+ ! !
3!,!%.
$'#' $
&!7(',#5
"'( ;!%&"0% .!
)" ('G0' )'( + '% !
$'%' %!"
6'5 ))0('$1 + '(07'$ ! ")' %1 %!,, + "6'
"%&' ;!('1
(03A')%'$ +(.)&","
!)
+&.(!) $'+ !6 %!" ( !,,!#'1 0(0 ,,.
" ' "0( )" $!%!" (5 G0 ,,.
!7+" % %1 30 $'
$'%' %!"
(0)&
# 'G0' %,.
,,( 6!,.
! ")' % 7'73' ( &!(
7!,.5
&' '
.'%
(+')% %%'
$'(' 6'(
)" (!$'
'5
%!" ( ',
3'!
! 6",6'$
',
)"77' )!
G0 %!%.
)" %
)%1
95
N&!,'
)" (!$' !
! 6",6!
)"77' )!
G0 %!%.1 /''+ 7! $
"0 ( ' 07'
2H
)%1
9 %'(
"0 %(
" ,.
+03,!)
+ "(')0%"
6!
%!(#!'$ !%(',# %;!
)" $!%!" (
("
"0 $( 3',!'6!
0!,%.
'$E
%1 ,!/',.
)"77!%
!,5
(% !
' % "0 (
2H
)%1
9
70(% 7'%!)0,"0(,.
() 0%! !M'$
! (% )/$ "+
))0('$:(
#0 $
(+''$.
,!#'
+' ("
' $' '$
%" .
0 ;
.( A0$!)!
+ ")'((1
%!)0, ,.
;&' '
(0)& .>(?
'!%&'
%% !30%
A0(%!#!'$
' $ )"
' % (" (5 ! $!6!$0
/'+% 3'&! $
! " $!
+' !"$ %!7'
/!
'#0 "0 ( $";
2H
)%1
95
,'
!(, %0 '
!%( ;!($"71 " $'
' (0 '
(+''$.
%!7',.
$!(+"(
('( )%1 + "6!$'$ )" (%!%0%!"
(+')!
"0 %(
)%5
%0 ',(" :(
'.'
+ "% )%'$ .(
(.(%'7 %!) ! '##!)!' ).
# 0(%
,'
!(, %!6'
+0 +"('5
$0%.3"0 $ ' (0 '
!%
3')"7'
)"7+,!)!% 6!",
! $!6!$0 ,:( #0 $ &%(1
"%;!%&(%
.%&!
)" % ! '$
%0%'5
N&!,'
$'
,!
"6' '$ "0 (
2H
)%1
91 70(% (% !/'
A0$!)!"0( 3'%;''
,'
!(, %!6'
! %' % )0 3 7'
$ 0
) "( )%
'I+'$!%!"0(
","
%!" 1 ;!%&"0% A0(%!#!
0('1 !(/( (#" 7!
+ '% !
$'%' %!"
+0 !%!6'
!7+ !(" 7' %1
"0%)"7'
%!%&'%!) + ! )!+,'
'G0!%.5
"1 0 'G0!6") ! #' ' )'
;&' '
!,'$ )" ),0$'
;!%&!
("
%!7'1 '(0,%!
+ ","
%!" 1 !% 7!,!% %'(
! (% + ')!"0( #0 $ &%( ,!#'
$1
(0)&1 )" $!%!"
"6' !$!
%0%" .
'73
) '
2H
)%1
9 "0 )" (!$' '$
+'
)%(
!6'
;" $(1
+' % ! !
)"77' )!
G0 %!%.1
"0 $ 0 $0'
,1 #'%%' '$
2H
)%1
958
6!';
%%' 1 !7+"('$
2H
$( $!,0%'$ ,!
%!),'
" (%!%0%!"
0##!)'
.1 #0 %&'
$'%' %!"
0 $' % !
)%(
)! )07(% )'(
H5
6!';
3"6'1
,,";'$
,,";'$
,,";'$
,,";'$5 '%!%!" '
" $' '$ ','
('$
!,1 !# 'G0! '$
('1
&!( #0 !(&!
!,E(0 '%.
3" $( %!(# )%!"
-$5 )" )' '$
"0 %E0%.
!(% %'5
$$!%!"
)" $!%!" (
!7+"('$ )" )' '$ "0 %E0%.
!(% %'1 (&
'7 3"0 $ #",,";!
)" $!%!" (*
>!?
(& 7!(0('
%'$5
>!!?
(& 7+'
'6!$' )'1
$")07' % .1 $0 !
>!!!?
(&
3(' % &!7(',#
3'#" '
>!6?
(& )"77!%
!,5
>6?
(& $'+"(!% &!( ((+" %1 !#
.1
"0 %5
>6!?
(&
!6'
&!( )',,+&" '
073'
6'(%!
##!)' E )" )' '$ ",!)'
(&
&!( )',,+&" '
073'
;!%&"0% + !"
+' 7!((!"
"0 %E
!(% %'5
>6!!?
(&
% .
>6!!!?
(& (037!%1 #! (% ;" /!
'6' .
7" %&1
##!$ 6!%1 3'#" '
)" )' '$
"0 %1 '##')% ! 6",6'$
)"77!((!"
3'!
','
('$ !,5
#"0 $ ! 6",6'$
&!( 3'!
' ,
1 &!(
##!$ 6!% "%&' ;!('1
7"6'1 #" %&;!%&1 )',, &!(
+,'
30% )"0 ('1 (&
%!")!
7' !%( %&' '"#5
5
3 '
#" '( )" $!%!" (
%&"('
!7+"('$ )" )' '$ "0 %E0%.
!(%
$! ')%'$
&' '!
3"6'
(&";!
(0##!)!' %
0('1
%'E)"7+, (&
7"6'
)',,
$' '$
))" $!
,.5
"%&!
&' '!
3"6'
(& )" (% 0'$
'I+ '((!"
"+! !"
7' !%(
! )'
$')!$'$1 +' $!
7!()',, '"0(
++,!) %!" 1 !#
.1 (&
,("
$( $!(+"('$ "##5
> -
-
-
-?
+ !, + !, + !, + !, 2 1
6!
N&'%&'
(+'
/!
E '
(" '$*
'(E"
N&'%&'
'+" % 3,'*
'(E"