← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2435/1994disposed of

(O&M)Jagir Singh v. Phool Singh And Ros.

2016-11-16Mr. Justice Arun Palli31 pages

 



  ! "# $

% $  & '( "&)   ** ++ "

,! )+( "&) "- ) '!

  !*"- "

!

.# /0.(.0(  

  

  

 

 



     

   

 1+

"( "&)2   

     

                      

                                     

      

     



     !          "          #    !$% &&%       

        '()!% &&!    * +     , -$!

+. / #  

     

   

      0     112



    

   , #$ &  

   

     

 

           3    

         

                    

   ,   "      4 , 5        *234     

                  #

3 3 6  +  5 7        

      )       '

            *234



            ,  ))                      4 8 

   

   

                  "        

  

% 1                 

  

  6  4       7      * 4               

  

,                   

   !9 &&)

      

    

      

       

     

 

                     

  

           

  1                    8 

  "   :/;   

          

    "

  ,       "       

   

"      +.



  <    

   "             *23 4             ,     

  =           

                        

      

    =  

           

#              

        >        

 ? 

  "   

       

 $ 4 8 

   

 

           

       

   



         



                  

                  ' #    

     

  

 

    

  6 #  4   # ( :

0      

       @+ A<** !          A<** ) 0        

       A<** %

 ;

9           = *0

   =  * 4     

      

    =          6 +             ,    =  /  B    #  +  ># ?           C=

0) #

0) 1# +#   *234 4

1 5 *  D /+ 

  *0!* 4 D * >     / 3 B    



  C=

0) #

0) 1?,   = ,41      E3 C=*09 #2+ 

       ,      F  5           C= 0& # 0& 1 & <                                   "     

 "     "     3 =     

           

 

   

  "               

         ,          '

    

  @+>     

? "       ,           " 

@+  *23 @+              ,     

 

               "        

#           

 "    

     %    :";  ,      

    

"   



     

   "

  ,                 

"   

       

$ 

                                              +*74     

,   

     +76         

          *0!* 4   !% &&!   +. 

  5  '()    1                   ,       

    

   



     "       

      

, #$ & ,       

    

     ! )           "     >   ?        ,    

       8          "                 4

, 5    =                  #      = *0!    8                ,  

         

         

              ,     =       >             ?          = 

"            



                "            ,                  ,          !()         

 *     +.       ,                 

         

<     

 = 

6+       "        

  

                             ,    !% &&!      (          

   :" ;   

            #      



 

      #  $()                         "    

 * 4>  ?

     

 

8          .     

                    

       ,         =       :        ; 3 =         

     

                        @+

=             

        

  5,      =  @+>

?

                            @+   '  

,    

 

  

       "   3 =                   5 +

 ,        :  ;     "         G                                                      *  + +@+                 =                                  

     

 



!           

        

4   



    



 

        

       

 

     

 

)

0!+  

        

        

     

    .     :";      



   "        

  3 =     * 

   

  

  

%           . 

*        *  C=7



                             

  <                

   * 4>  ?   (    

8

       "     

%

0)    +  #  +  #    5  

             <   4      

  C=

0) #   

        >    ?

         "         ,     "     

     

 B 

        + 

         

 !       C=

0) 1       

               

  3

 

       

         



0%#      *23                             C= 0% 4

* 4           

   3 =     =   

        

     

$

      "                    "   

   3 =               "     

0$     @  C   "      *

  0" 7    5      *0!* +"

    7     @ &&!   

  9(

(    "

  3 =      "     8  "     "

'

0'  B 

      "                 

     

  ,      E  &&!

   

"     > ? 5     

     

             =  

 C=

0) #            < 4       

      "  + 

          

                  =     

                  ,  

  

         =   ,        

  =  

    

     " 

   

        



9 ,41     09     *  + 5                *234!

&&!                          "       "       6       

 <                E3   C= 09 #                                +  

$ 4*4   

           

 3    > 09?        

 

          C=

0) #

0) 1                  +,<        

  E3  3 =                

 =  ,             ,   

  ! &&!E3                  

           B

                    "     

       4 

&              

0&       

    

=      8 

 =   

   , - !

!' &&!   

       

   C= 0& #

0& 1 ,        "     

 =     

  3 =  

 

  "   " ,                  



     

 

    :  

;    "



  

   

     !     

   

           

    * +

     

 8     



 8# 



   : "; ,            



  6+> ?                                  

    3 = 

     +.  (        

(), 

             ,       "

  

+  "    +.

         +B     '(         # 

   "               

   

         " 9(   

                   

        

              = 

       

  "                  

  + + ,        + +    9()  "      ,        >

?   *  * +.              

        4

     ,  =              2                , 4

  

    $(   +       

  

    

          "                  

   G G

 4     =         =            "     ,  

             

"   ,   

                

     G G  

"     

$ !

,                  

     

             



     " 

        

    

 =              

                   

       8 

  +   

            E       =    

     *0!           

  

 

=  @C   7         "        @C   *0!               '() 



  

(,      



 =     

          *0! 



     

!! #   

   

   

 E3         

 

    

 

       

 

   

            

     

       +    *    

                       4   .           



        

   

 

       4  *     

       

 



             !) #     = 

             



 

         <  4    

      

   =    

               

      

      3                  

                   

                    #       "     

         "

    

 

  3     

   !% 4                         

         

         

             



      

             =                       

         ,          "        !

<     

               

 "

      

    

  



"       ">

  '( '()@ ? 

G

     

          

     3                :

      

         

                        = 

          

       

   E                       

      

 "     

      

"     !$ <                   

    

     !' 4                 

 

   

     *234  #

33 6 

+  5 7  

     

      ,              !   > &&!?    

"      

   !    ,        

     !  

   <   

     

  H 

                     #          =      '  

9                   

            )                           

       # !$% &&%,      I !H                

   . 4  )      ,     !9 #   71  4 



%          )9 &&    

  #   

 

!

       "3  

            !& 0   

   6* +

  

           C= 0% # 0% 1 0% 4                      *234,                              3         !

&&!          ,      

   

    

  

     ,  =         * C=7 

            +     

    

 1/   1    *  

 

 5   

           *                              > 

* <     ?                  



      

     "   

  

 

         

    

     ) 6+ =       



E3 

   

  =      

   

              

            

   B   

    

                8  *       

    

    

       

    

      #          

        )  

  6#   #                  

    *     

     2          

        

  

,  =  

        

 

                                ,                  

        

    

  =    

B

        

 

 

    8=" 



 =    #         )! 3

6+          

 

   



 

= "        ,    



    

  " )) ,          

 #                    

                       8      ,           

    

      



          0&        ,      

   >         

  ? 

                    

,                 

  

         

     

 

  

               *0 !

 

 

    "

  3        *0!



          "     



    0$           

         

     !                       

  ,               3         >  ?

     

    

       

  "      



  )%  8             

   



 

 8    

          #                     

       

    



        

            =        ,     



       =      "     

"

 6+    

                 

       =              

#        

           

,  



       " 

!

&&! &(< 

     

 

           E       

      3   



 "    "      4



  

  " 8      

   



  

        

5  

               &&!          

" >    

"   ?

            

  



        

       

3   +   !!  6 D  # &99        

( 



 

          

          

  

 

         

        

   

    

  

 

       

    <          , 6 D 

&&)    > &   ?    

       &&!           !>$?  * 6 D  

&%           (

 !"    

 

           



    #  

     

    $

               

     

        %     &%     

&&)

         

          

     8                      3  +   !!  # &99"     

     

       

                                 "

    

          8 

  

& &&)      =     

                         

 

  

  +   !! 

 

    "                     ,                8  F +   !!

 # &99  !>$?  &%        !% &&!

$        

      

 3   

       

 )    =  8                          



  

             

                         

              

     

               8

      

               3              

 

      

" 

           

    C= 0% #      

              

 *23 4     0%4 "   *234     3       

      

           *23



         "    " 

 4 ,        5            

                            =    

3        C= 0% #           



  



( :, < +#!% &! 9*6 

4

  

* >



?    

 , <  , < > 



?5 >



? C5>



?;

 #                  

           :         ;      

    (

 

  

&'( )*+,(-,5

#*!! 6+7'

'- - ! %8%9 .!/

01 



.!2 /!

3    



4 

%  

   )=' )=&     

                       

          #                 

             

   !

&&! 

   (

56(7.85 9'

* :9 &;,,<!



  

 

 6 



     =

     ( 4 

  

 5(7#  >?

4 7(>

  

 

:,( .0.9,(    

.?

/?3 

 



4 @@@ AB8>9

'<: B B       

% + 

       

(

6(7

 ;56(  1  9' *:9 & ,, < 



  

  

    



 

          

  6(  

    2!  6(

 2!% )$ 3   4            =   

   

     *23      

          

          

          

             

      

                   

  #               

4                       



     

                 

         :    ;              

                          )' E

      

4         

           

  

   6  D   #            9H     



   E                

        

     

  

"   

                       4               

    ,       H

H    8   !H



  )9 4     8    

   #         

     *234  #

33 6  +  5         )     

       '  9      





   

  3         #        

%            ! 

 *23       

  #

33 6 

+               

    =

> ) ?

=           3              

 

 

     F                      

"      





 



  3   

   ! 

                               " 

 !         

 C    

 =   

          

 2   , @ &&!

          =        

   8

       !  

     G  ))   

      !! 

   $      

   

           

 &! #     

! 

        

     3      8   

 

       

  )& ,            8         

    4             

   !H                  "        

 

        )!  % B   

  

         I !H  

 =        &&%

   &H      3        3                8 

            

        !

' &&%    &H            

     

I%H  % ,      

    =                       

 9       !H    

   

                   5     5.0(9 :

' $2% $     0   "    F  0   

F