Chandigarh Industrial And Tourism Development Corporation Limited v. Pritam Kumar And Another
! "#$#% # &## # #% #
'( ) )
'*+) )
,-.',*'-/*'-0%(/10'1'-2-0- 3--' 4'* '-05*0',' 3 1 -, ) --'
1
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- 6- 7-., ,' 8
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- 7-., ,' 9
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- -,- / ,' 9+
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- #.'6 7-., ,' ::
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- 7;-' 7-., ,' 8
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- 5'-, / ,' 8 9
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- "-' 5*0' ,' 8
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- 4-6< 5*0' ,'
8 ,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- %,'0 , ,' 9
8 ,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- < 7-., ,' :
8 ,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- #,=- 5*0' ,' +
8 ,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- * 5*0' ,'
8
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- 4-6< 5*0' ,'
9
8 ,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- (-' 5*0' ,' :
8 ,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- 6,5*0' ,' 8
8 ,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- 4-> ,*,'< ,'
8 ,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- #'* 2,' ,'
8 ,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- *-, ,' 8+
8 ,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- 6- 7-., ,' 8+ 8
8 ,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- '(, 5*0' ,' 8++
8 ,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- 6, 5*0' ,' 8:::
8 ,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- (-' / ,' 88+
8 ,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- >0 7-., ,' 88++
8
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- 5,0-'7-., ,' 989
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- $,-0 7-., ,' 9898
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- 0,, ,' 98:
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- #'* 7-., ,' 98:8
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- #-/ 7-., =' ,' 98
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- #0'- 7-., ,' 98
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- 7; 7-., ,' 989
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- #'(- ,*,'< ,' 988
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- 1 7-., ,' :
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- '6 7-., ,' :
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- (- 5*0' ,'
:
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- %1> 7-., ,' : 9
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- #-/ 5/- ,' :
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- >,7-., ,' : 9
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- >, , ,' :
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- >65*0' ,' : +
,-.',*'-/*'-0 %(/10'1'-2-0- '( 5*0' ,' #?
@$2 )" 7 "#
#$#7#2
! ! " #$ #
$
! " % &'())*+( ,+%- &'(-.%,(,+%- &'(%++/0(,+%- &'(-.,-(,+%- &'(-./.(,+%- &'(-111(,+%- &'(--*.(,+%- &'( --..(,+%- &'(%++/1(,+%- &'(%++.,(,+%- &'(%+%%)( ,+%- &'(%+%,0(,+%- &'(%+%1%(,+%- &'(%+%-%(,+%- &'(%+,**(,+%- &'(%+*+)(,+%- &'(/)-+(,+,/ &'(/-,0(,+,/&'(/-*/(,+,/
2 " % &'(/)*+(,+,/ &'(/)//(,+,/ &'(/)/-(,+,/&'(/)0,(,+,/&'(/)0.(,+,/&'( /)11(,+,/ 333 "#
#$#7#2A"
%
" 4 "4
56"4 "4 "
,
7 (& 8 9 : 7
& ;
#" < =$ 8
,,0>,,1"& "9 6 8 8 " ,) +/ ,+,* # ? (%$ 4 ;4 & 6 " *+ +1 ,++-# ? (*$ 4@ 4 " & 8
*
7 6 8 A 6 "
8
8,++)(,+%.
" 8
4 4 7 4
4
74 "
7
"
?"
" ? "
"B
4 & 5 " ?"
4 #11-02' C
! "
# $ %
&' ( &&)
)
%* + , & - %
"
"
%
+
.
& )# .
%
$
)%(/
"
0
"1
%
"
$ %
%
0
2 =//'
$
"$ " 0
( ( & ( &
% Rs.
& )4#
%
$
0
*
- )
$
*
1
.
#
% %
/
76 "
4 @
6 8 B
A
4 *+ +1 ,++- 4 " & 8
A "
**&#,$ " 9 %-/1 #" <% #=$ 4" ;4 & " B
4
4 & 8
6 " @ 4 6"& 8
'
8 ;4&
" " "
9 5" *+ +1 ,++- 4 * )
#7# ' &
8 $ 9
) * 8
:
;
#!
#<
# ) * 8 9"1 , .
* *
%
=
) * 9#>
) 8 6
? #( : 7 7# '7)
( ') % "
"
%
"
*
% 0
) % %
& & ' ?% $ % $
" * 8 $
? ? 7#&# @+!
7 '# ')
&& 4 ')
"
"
%
"
*
% *
"
5
)%
"
"
%, 9 ? .
$
9
.
.
$
.
<
.
A
.
& ( & '&4 & 7( 7 4 '&4 & & '&4 &4( & (&4 ('& &' '(
: ( & 4 ('& &'( '7 4 ('& & 4 ('& & 7 ('& &4 '
((7 ('& & & (& & &4 && (' ( & 4 &74 & (' & &7 & 4&4 & &' & 7&' & & &( 7 &' & 4 &4 7 && & &7 7 &&44 & ( ( & 7&&44 & ( 7 &'
7&( &(4'& ( (4 ' &' &(4'& (7 7 & '7(&7 &(4'& 4 ' & (&(& &(4'& 44 & &(& &(4'& 7 7' & &(( &(4'& 74 ( & &4( &(4'& 7 && (&4( &(4'& ' &(&4 &(4'& &&&( 747 4 (4& '
&&4 747 7 (4 & & 747 (4 & &4( & 747 ' (' &4 & 747 & 447
$
.
&( %
"
.
(#
"$ %
"
"1
%* B &
"
& 8* ) '
"
" *
*
C " * $
0
) %
?8 :% $ )?8%
"
%
"
"
*
% *
"
5
0
:% $ )
"
) $
@ ;
"
"
"
" * $
% @ ;
) * 8 $
$
= ! ? 4# = @ & '#7&&)
&( 7 ' - @
# D9
* 8 2 .
" 4
*+ +1 ,++-
4 &97&D 4 &97&D 4 8 & A 8 8 9
D""
7
" & 8 8 4
"D8 E
4
"
7D8 E 842" 7
8 " 8 8 8 "
7 *+ +1 ,++- 4@ 4 & 8
7 4
7 44
" "" 8"& 8
7
6 4 8 8
7 6
"
"
6
"
" " " 7 6
4
8 7@ "
4
"" @ ;4 &
? 8 " 4 **&#,$ " 9 @ " " 7
8 **&#,$ " 9 " ?
8 7;4& " 4 8 7;4&
> 8
) " 4
&97&D "& 8
8D""
"
"B & 8 7 & 8 8 9
D""
7 6
8 5 F
8 "&97&D ., " ""
/+ " 2
& 6 7 6
" G2
& 6' 7 *+ +1 ,++-
4
4
8
7 *+ +1 ,++- 4 4 & 8
2 & "& 8
7 4 8 8 "&97&D 7"
6 "&97&D
"B
7 8 " B
4 " %/%0"& "9 "6 " &97&D ? @ "
"
7 6 " 4 8 7;4& ? *+ +1 ,++- 4& 8
7 " ""
98 " "
4 )
,.
+- ,+,/" & 8 8 8 "
""
,1 +- ,+,/ 8
8 "' G 2
& 6H
4 H 8 8
*+ +1 ,++- " & 8
H
4
4 &97&D"
H
" 6
42 7 ?" ""
4 )
%5 %
"
)
$
< ; ) ! * *
"
*
;
$
E
$ .
*
) &&
&& A
( <
5 ) "$
$
? ('
& 7 ')
%
%
* 8
"
" !
" ;
) = ) * )
7 '
" ;
= 8 ) * %
$
:F"
8 ) = *
< ; !
0
"
! < ; !)% )
8*
? &44
(## && $
, % *
% *
0
" =
> *
8
0
"
* 8 ) % *
"
H (/ %
% $ )
$
"
$
(/
% *
* *
-
7 4 8 8 8 " & 8
" 7 6C&97&DF
8 I 9 8 "
"
" ""
7 ?" 8 4 < ; *
;
$
E
! $* *
9!? & & )9 &7 <) * &4&7) *
*
* 9
;
$
E
9; $
I.
@8 I!@?!.!.8 !? ?! &( !@ &'7 "
% ! I
$ .
*
$
*
( &&
$
? +8##&47
' &&
? &74
' && JJJJ JJJJ JJJJ JJJJ ;
*
0 %
C
,
G8G
8 ? & &'(4
8&'(4
B
" G8 G
8 =
* B
G8 G
=
* B JJJJ JJJJ JJJJ JJJJ
.
*
JJJJ JJJJ JJJJ JJJJ
"
*
"
"
" 8 0
$
"
*
5
$
JJJJ JJJJ JJJJ JJJJ & 8
%
& & 9
,
I$
"
*
"
" < ;
$
*$ 9
"
% $
$ *
"
" < ; ) )
"
" < ; $
%
"
*
%
@ *9 $
"
%
** K
?
%
$
%
*
) )
& @0 ,
=
%
$
*
)0
"
*
$ ) *
8
"
* )
* C
;
.
#9
)
%*
0
* $ *
" AF8F 2 %+
5
88 "4 8 " **&#,$"9 5 " **& 4 3 .
$ L
& %5
%
$ M8 M<) %5
"%*
))
%5 )
*
)% 1
$ ) A$ $ ) A$
)
%
$
$ , $
$
"
%
% "
%5 ,
+ $
"
0
)
A$
5* %
%5
$
"
%
"
*
C
% "
"
) C
) "1
"
8)"
" E "
"
"
" A$ % 0
*
, $
%
* E "
0
) )
"
%*) 0 "
5
@
* $
) E " ) 5 )
%
) 5* $
"
) " E " E "
*
E "
"
%
" A$ " E " "
$
$
"
&
( %5
$ "
"
*
) ) "1
"
"
) *
$ "
"
"
%5
9 I0
L
3E " 2
%
* $
*
9 2 %+ % 5 8"4( #,$" **&
8 6 ";4&4
$
6 "
$ 4$ 4"
4 " 4 8
"
$ J $ " 4$ 4"
4
9 6 4 4"
4 "4 8
" 7 4 &
@ "
? 8 4( #,$ 7&
" , 7 4
" 4 6
7@ " 4
"9 44 **& 9 ? @ " @ 4
9"
"4( #,$ ?
< = "?
<@ = ?
< " = 4 9
:
4(
4 6 < = 4"
4
" 7 6
;4&
" 4"
4
4 6 @ " "*--/'*0 %%
9
A
& ;4 & 6 46 8 6 4@
;4 & **&#,$ " 9
8 46 8 ;4 & ? 8 46 8 7";4& 4 4 A 8& 7
?& "4 3
"
"
% , $ %5
$
"
%
*
%
$
"
E "
9 8 "
* "
9 8
0 *"
%* 0 **
"
%
0 **"
*"
)%
1 $
% 1
E " * %
9 8 %
"
%
* "
%5
C
*
% *
*
"
5% *
:
"
$ "
)%
" *
*
1
C
1
* @ % C
1
"
5% *
$
% %
$ "
* ) "
1
) % C
"
5% *
"
* %
9 & 8
) %5 %
"
)
% )
%
%
"
$
%
$ "
)
) % %5
"
5 % *
% 0
)% $ % :** $
% E " * "
5% *
%
*
"
5% *
2 %% % & A !!"# $" @ " 4
"
**&#,$
6
" " 6
88 8
7& @ " 8 8
4
**&#,$ 4 7&
8 3& :*
"
% $ "
%5 "
) "
*
1 * " )
*
"
) )
*
9 8 E "
1
%5 F
"
1
"
%
8 %
1
*
"
"* C
E " F %
9 5 I0 *F %
&
)
%5 %%
#
%5 )"
% *
*
%5 )
"
"
1 *" % % * "
%5 F
*
5 %5
"
% *
*
%5
3 C
C
%52"
*
)%
1
*
)
"
"
"
%5
*
$
" * %
8
$
1
"
"
"
"
* .
F
"
1
%
" %5
*
%
"
1 * "
%
% "
%5 % %
)
% $
) $ ) )
$
) )"
E "
%
:* %
*
9 8 "
2 %% , & %& ' ( $)$$# " *$!A @ "
"6
**&#,$ 4 7 & "
@ "
4 4"" 7 ?"8 3& 8 *
%
% "
)% %
1
% .
%
" .
%
.
%
$
" .
%
"
%
"
*
#
)
E " * $
%
9
;
8 E " * $
*
.
* " % * *
#
1
&& )
" E " %
1
9
;
8 :*
%
$ * " 1
"
9
;
8 2 %,
5 "( 8 8" **&#,$" 9 4 "
4
"
6 ";4& 7
4
">8 4 " ? 4 9 4 "
4
;4 & 4( %*
9
4 9
"
7 6 : "
6 " @
7
"?"
"? *+ +1 ,++- 4 & 8
"
4
8 44 4 8
8"
?
'8
& 7 "" 8 2>& 8 8 " &97&D
4 8 8
""
" 6
4 46
4 "
?"
6 8 > 7
6 %/
76
8
" B
7 (&97&D
8 6 84
4 B7
9 8 9
6
" " 9 88"
8 " 7 B7
8 4 B
7 48 " & G " B
( 6
8 ' *+ +1 ,++-
4 6 " &97&DH6 "&97&D B7
H 6
8 H&97&D
6 "B7
H6
> @ 9 ?
"
"6 ;4 & 8 4
9
G B6 8 ""
" 8 8 "&97&D 7 8 8 4
""
4 4 5 8 " " 6 "
8 " ;4 & ""
4
" ?
"6 ;4& ? " **&#,$
9
A & @ " &97&D 8
"B7;4& ? **&#,$ " 9 ;4 &
@ " 6 B7
**&#,$ "? 4 " >
8 ;4 & 6 8 6 &
8 " "" 8 ;4&7 4
;4& "9 4
"9 9 8
? %.
96"4 "
8 & "
8 #$ 4 8
4
%0
7 6 >
4
4 7 "
8 4 & "
4
"
**&#,$"9 %1
8
#$ "
"
"#
#$#7#2 " %
+) )
>N ' 6 8> K> ' 4 K>