Roshan Lal And Another v. State Of Punjab And Another
!"! # $%&!
' &' && % ****
!
"# $ % %& '( )* + ,- ! '() * !+,& - - . /0%(+1&2(1&113'
() !+5+6+&162170- !$ 8# !9 " &51&&11, '
,) !
'&) %!"! 8!:(11+&1(2 8- ;!-
%( 8 ! ! !" '<) * " . " ! ! %(
0 &11< !
8 ! ! ! 8- '+) : != =!" > ? ! (3(1&1&&
- 2 - 8 " ?
# ! 81,1+&1(5 %& '2)
# ! %& - >" %&: !
!! %&8" ! : " 8
%& =! '7) @ !!
8 '3) *- !!!" "" 8 8 ',)
! ! ! " ((17&1(< 8 9 0-
8 =!! " 8;:"?"
:; " % !. "!
"
! 8 " !! * ! =
!
"#$
%&
- 3 -
'
(' '
) !
'
* +
, &
"#&"
- '5) ! "
%&
" !. ((17&1(<151+&1(+
- " ! ! 8 (1 "
6
A 4A:! ! A ":8!! ! /0 8 (1 " . /0 '(1) 0
%( "
%& (&(1(55, %( ! ! %& &3((&117 !:" "
"8 %& !" 9 0 -
!
! !" " %( %&
- 4 - !" 8 9 "" !
" &51&&11,'
,) 8 "! 0 '(() @ 8 1,1+&1(5 8
%&
8 "
= " ! !! ! " 0
"8!
8 84 ! %( ! ""
'(&) > ! '(<) 0"! " 8 %&
8 " B2 % " ; #9 ! !!
! !88 8 0 %& !" " - ! 8 '(+) * ! " ! !
8 8 8 ! ! %&
"8 %(8
%& !
" : !
- 5 - !" " %( * %& = 4 !"8 8 " ! " 8 "" ! %& 8
9 : '(2)
! !.
!
! 8 "
" 8 !" => ? ""! 8 "
40
! %&! 8 ! - ! @ ! '(7) 0 !
/0%(+1&2(1&113'
() !+5+6+&162170-
!$ 8# !9 8. " &51&&11,'
,)!
8 '(3) !8 !"! .'( )* + ,/
* +
1. Whether speaking/reasoned?
Yes/No
2. Whether reportable?
Yes/No