High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/47/1994dismissed

Gurpreet Kaur And Others v. Subhash Kumar And Others

2017-10-13Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu10 pages

! "# $$ % & '#!

("# ) "

* %"!+",

# $$- ),"+",

" %".# "#+", )# /(+",

" 00000

.#$$1/" "" 2

" '3# ".$(4'

$+"5 # " #64'

$7/"1( ) 8+-9$3 $$'$3 "& #%#$:+

# "::

; #$"1# $1 # $ #$( / $" "& << #%#$ +

22'3#/"/+(#$"" =5#,&1# $(1 ( # "# " ,$,1 ;>>

.#5&'11*?@9 <",'3=5#, &1#" 9/#$'1)1*.&9 8", '3

"$&1#+ " /#$# (/11 ( ,$$1 $$ %$$1 ! ! # ("

# '3#$(+/#=5#, &1##"%$$14#594$/";#)" ' < (+#$,+*(&1#"!(&1#+(#( #;

&"/### $5" ((/# =5#,&1#$ ,$$1!!@#(/#$+ /#$ '1 )1 *.&9 8 ", #$3 "

1$1$3'3

"$&1#+ " +( (# "" 51# =5#,&1# $ /## =5#,&1# $$"/ (#+,"( $ $> """# ,

"1,#$ "#4( ("+(*A9 &5#&1#""$"#(

"$&1# /"",

"1,#$ " " ""#$$11#("5 #"

#"#,15 $"

#1$1 =5#, &1#/#(#,#$=5#,&1#:1#( # "#+/$" ""/$("##/(#88 3 1+/ ( $3"+#"("#$(/,1 "#1#$3B11"@/$$$1"##""/ #,1,$"",1$"##$( /'" 9>" #/" *?@9 <

@ # /#$ " $ "($'>" "$'$3 # , #+("" @ *$3@,$,(

# /#$#"/"" 8 "1 @ .( 3+ " + $'$3 #*$3/1#" 3"#",

#) "$5 #"#/ $'$ 3( "#, #" # $(+#"#"5 $ #1$1

" ",1 /#$*.&9 8# $ /#", '##,#$/#$"1,$"",1 $#( #" < #' # $"1 +# $$/1 / ("9

!""# $ % &' ()(!*! & +,- ( '' & '& &

&+,- . &

& $ &/0 &' +,-

& 0'& +1&2 0+,-

# &

!""# & $ 3'&

0 +,4. 5 &

& '0

&& 0 +,4. " 61""5) & $

3'& 0

+,4. * '' &

7 && $ '

&+,4 !

0 '' &0

+,4

( 4 /"#'$"$#1 "##4'

$ '" "1#> "1( #.($. C 1# ",

"1,#$#$1 "+## "1 #4'

$/3#,""+#/# "

3 #,11

1#1 *(&1# #C "' 1 #C "

,3((""( $3' *(&1##("

"+##4'

$#"1$$3#$"##

"1,#$/,$,"#"+## "1 # 4'

$/#1"1$1 ",

"1,#$ / " # 1$1 # ", #

"1 ,#$ #" ' ( $3 ,"+ # # /" "31

( /$'$'(" ""( $("

/"" **A9 &5#&1#+ # #"""*A9*( &1#/#(/#/#*A9*(&1# /$$1"'3/#"D/#1" # ( /## # " 5 $ '" # ( *A9/#(#@) DB*.+/ "" "&9@*.1

"$&1#+", #

"1,#$ "

@"1###4'

$"'$,"*A9 C $ # ",

"1,#$ # ($1"1#('3',1#,/ # C $+*A9/ /"/ $$339 /#"E/,+#4'

$""##/ " /#1"#,$,(

"1,#$ #"$"1#"# ""=5#,&1#4'

$ $5 $# *A9/##"""

',"##/$3#$3 *(&1## #",

"1,#$ 51#", # /# $$"/"""'

#/#', ,"'3/3 #1 # # + $ #/1# # /#$35"(5/## $" ,"3($# "/

1$1 #", # /#$# $ & '&

8 4#4'

$',"#5 1'5 ,$,"

//# "14'

$$',"#$# 1#/ # #> "1( #($ . / '"1 "(1 $'$3 # /+ ", " 1"1 ( "# #""+,#$+# (/$," " (/###"

' "'3#$(4#4'

$'," ## $"1#"""# *A9# $( # ' ( +""#("5 # /#$+'

"1#"( & '9 @ 5#&1##(+##"#

# + "#C "5# /#$ "34#4'

#',"##C / "'3#"&1#" F )"*$ * ( "&5#&1#" $$+ # #"""

*A9+/# (#@)/1" &($$3+ ,3((1"1#F # /#$/"

'3.'$!$&1#";5# &1#,$ * >'

" " # #" *( &1# " !( &1# $$3 /"#"+#,$" ($5C "

,3((

"1,#$/ $"#,'"'3 #("#' #( ,"##3/

/ " 3 / # @ # ("'51 "+#4'

$+',"## "1

#($ / $'$

4#4'

$$5 #"1#(" $1$ DB* !!11/$+#""#" # > ##"+ "#""

19B(

!!11/$+#"( #> 3 / '$$3 / ,'3,#$(#,3 '#" $$ ##"+# + ("$ /1## "# =5#,&1#/ #> ##"+ $ 1"#/##/ '$$3 #""/ , '3(,#$+'

"1#$( *A9*( &1#+#

"1,#$#" 5# =5#,&1# $ /## =5#, &1# $$ "/ " "" @ # ("'51 "+#4'

$(#$ # *(&1#*A9/ $/+# $"1, 3"###"5 $" # #"1$1",1

"1,#$'3 " 4#4'

$$ 5 # #($ C " " , #

"1 ,#$ '3 #$"1 # *A: *( &1# " !( &1# /

/ " #" $$3 # @ # ("'51 "+#4'

$'3#$"1*(&1#

/"#13/1##,"/"" $3) 8+-9 6 $$'$37 "& #=" $ # ""#1 #4'

@#,""# '(("'3$" $ # " "#"

4# $ $1,3

"1,#$ # "/ "'3# $/ " "" *A9*(&1#+# $(# ( # "+ "" # ( " 5 #

"1,#$ +'

"1#( & '@ 5#&1#+##"# " # + "C "5#

"1 ,#$ 4#C "# / "'3#"&1#" F )"+*$ * ( " &5# &1#+ " $$ # # """'3*A9*(&1#/#'##@) /1"=5/+,3((1"1F #

9/#$/"'3.'$!$&1#";5#

&1#+,$ * >'E(

"E"*(&1#"

!(&1#*A9"*A9 + ,$3+ $$3/"

#"+ (",$" ($5C + ,3(( #+/ $"#,'"'3#("

#(/ $"#, ,"##3/ $$3/# $# 1#+# "1 #($. '"1#.4+3# "1#

#*A9"

*A9 / /+''

#""# (' " /##($1#$( *A9 '13/#"$ #", #

"1 ,#$ #,1 " # " "

# "

1$1",1*A9$("'#3/ #" " 1$$3 " # #

"1 ,#$ ( ( '#"+ 51# $ /##=5#,&1#

$$"/"#

"1,#$ "" (# $ E/,+ =)DB*+1, '3!!11/$+#""," #> # #"+ " #" #9B( $ "# > 3 / '$$3 / ,'3(,#$ (#,3'> $$##""##"# =5#, &1#/ #> ##"+$ 1"# /##/ '$$3 #""/ ,'3#,#$+ '

"1 # $ ( *A9 *( &1# #

"1 ,#$ 5 =5#, &1#: + $

/##=5#,&1# $$"/"""4#, /# #," *A9##

"1,#$, #""+#/3/+ (" $ # " $" #, ' (" @ # (+#$3 1$ *(&1#+ *A9'13/#" @#$1# # "',$,/ #

#/##' ,"+,/5'3# '

$ $3> " $ '$+# $$. / $"

5 3 ,/+ ($3 ' # ,/ '$9 2

).) .,$ 29#(',,3

)$/3+@( '$ "3 (3/#,/##/"

/##("1$3+ "1(# $+#("("E/,+" $ %

' + 97$

A##& 51-"

G- A##) '$ G-