High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/570/2002dismissed

Rajinder Singh v. Pb.St.

2019-10-04Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan,Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan17 pages

!! #"$"

%&$'

(

) *

!! #"$"

%&$'

+ , +

- !!

#"$"

%&$'

!# $

%&$ ' %&$ ' ' $

$$%%

( ) * ++++ ' $ ( .$ "!!/%0 " 0"" "0$ "

0-!-01 "0"2""

'13 !"

%$4 /" %#!! 4/2 ""

0 2 ." 0

*!-/3& !0 $/2

2" !0 1/202" !$ 1 "

%!44

! 1 ""$/"

- %&- 5$ ""

% 5- "

% !6 2" "

!-7 8 (( 5- 2" "

$ + 0!"" 2!

!! %"""

&- 5$2"

'1$-'

1"% - "0 !!1!, (( /5-

! 2 $!'"2 "% $ " %"

'$ - "

"0 !!- " 2 $!'00 - '1"

%" 9$!!

" "4 % 5- / - ! 3 !!

2 9$!! :!/&!2 !600 - 5- !! -2 $ " %0 !! 2!*12 6!!06 "

;

& <, <('!

5- *02"

'6'19$!!/2"/0 - ! 3 !2"

'1""*

"2"

" 0 '

/2 100 2!

!!/ ) */2 2"!0=$ 2 - ! 640/00$"" $ %

0!""!"

640/

1% -6!!:2! 9$- 00$""

$ ."

!""6"/

- 2"

6!!4

, !""

:!% '0 -! $" "

0420 2"6/' 4 2"0 0!"

!"" 2 2 6") 640'!

9$!!

%% " %'

1'!

6!!:2!' 4 !"" %2 2 %'04" 0 '04"

0640'!

!6" " !

" '04-""&!20- 0/ 2"6$"'1-" %"'1'

1% -6!!:2!/ 2"/

"6%"

"'!

2" 1"!->- - > *!! 00$"?""! "21% - "

2 " 0 62 "9$!!

"$2 4

" !/!4

! 610'$

0!9$!!

'" '1 0 - ! ""

!0/

6' 0 2" .='!2"!0 "

&" % !! $ ) 00$" 9$!! 0"$"

0!- .='!'0 - " 00 $ 6$!%% " '"" ""$/% !1 4 !0 "' 2 -'

1"!

0 @ "

/ ) !

2 " 0 00$" - "0$"$":! 9$!!"$00$-'

$"2" !6&!206$" 0 *""

- 2""'1 0 - ! * .6"

%%0% " > .> " "- '!

- " $=

!0"

/ '"" %20/

- % -!@.2"0 *.!

!0 %%0!"2

6!3 " !/!4

!0 !!0 :" $

!0 12

"""" '!

% - "

$" ! !0 % 0 *-020 60 -"2 6!!2" 4

"""" % - 0 - $ % " !/ %

A" 0 "2 " 2 !"

"7 6 0 61-- *00$"2"

"0") 00$" 2" "

+ (( ' / "$%%"0!

"$"

- 4 0 0!40?0$ '

20/420 $! "-0 6*% / $"$0 "0!

"$"

- /

40?0$!44 0 6% -" """" ." 0

*!- $"4 0

40"BA&C ?@

"""" /60 61 -- BA&C ?B3 $" ! !0 %0 61 BA&C ?

00$" - 2 "

((

9$- 2""

8 (( "02"

((< % 0 - ! %6"

% -! "/ 0!!"

00$"2" %! $ %)/ $/2 "$ !0 " % 0$- "!$ 0!!

00$"% %0 "" 6$0

& % %%0"% 20 00$"''

42 A0!$"6!1 '!'1 $ %"" "/6

+((</

$ %"" "/% -2/ 2"""

!"" ")$ 0/$ @ - %0 0"/ 0 % %%0" $ 0 "+

2 0 8(/8</+ 8/+ 8?8(/+ +?+8/8 / ?8(.&2"%-"

00$"/

20/ 1 !

10!- ! 26/ 00$" $ 01 !*% / 0""

' $ 0 $" % "0$ 60/ "0$ A-"-$0"+2 """/" !"'!

2 &C !)/6!3 " !/!4

!/"

-0 !!!1 A- &!2 $ (( ,

-% $% !!

2$" " "

611 '

,+ -/-0 !!!1 A- !6 60 1 %:BA& % % !!

2$"D

. &

(

# )

(

)

(

# )

' *

&C & 9 "

0 $0

- -A- '

1 %9$!! (( % $% !!

2$" "

0"D

- .

# /

0$" % /"

"-2"

$1 6 ! 67 !$A!!1'!

6""!

-""6- /202""$%%0

0$"

10 $" % $00

-/ $"2 - - $ ''! - ! "' 2$" 2"-- ' 2 - -/ 2"2 $"00

"$02 ""/ '

12" %'1 3 !"

%$4 5- "

!6 &C+:4& 2 6 "0!- % !0

00$0"BA&: &C89$0/!4/%%0/!4

! ' $ !6 0 6"

%$ ' ;

& <, <(- !6"

%:'/" % #!!;4% %5- "BA& &C 3 44 / % -! 2 ""/ "

%%6 BA&2

" 0" 1'1 . 2 - &C, &

" %

0"BA&;?

BA&;?, 6"BA&;?

BA&;?

/ 00

-/ 4

" 0 6!

" !/!4

! (( &C 3 ! / &C< !6 &C( &!2 6 1 2 "" 00 $ % 0

"$ "0$ "

1 - !" 0 " &C "

'!)!2 -00!!1 "

0 &$/% % 2"0!""

"2!!"!"" 0

'' 4/ 6"

BA&E6 -0"- 02"

&C "

'! % -!2 "" "

%%6 BA& &C . 2 2"--' !0 1'1." 0

*!-23 !0 - !

- 0 2 ." 0

*!- "

." 0

*!- " "-

BA&C ?'!

2"$0"

- /"$=

!0"

/ '"" %20% -!@.BA&C ?

2"0 3%$ " 01 - -A- '

1 % 9$!! 6 %'!

" %0"

-/20 $0'% ." 0

*!- "6' 4

!0 """" 3%$ "'--'

!0 1 + (( 2) 2""

"$%% "0!

"$ "

40 0 6 % - "

"""" 20'"76-- 0 &C+ ." 0

*! -/ . % " 0" " 6"

0 $0 '1 - 3 6 6 $"

0$- " : &$'!0 & "0$

6 $ &C" "

'! /.5 !"$0""1/&C;" 6/&C"5- ! 6'2 6 '1 00$"3%$

60 %-0!

BA-%%6 / % 0!

" 60 % "0$ - " 00$"20 $0 ++ &/20!! 0- 00$-"

0" "

00$"2 $

-'$ 1 "-/0

1 0 6'%!"!16 !6 "0" % $- "/ ! ! "" " )$ 0 $/ 6 $- +

/ 0 60 " 0 00$""% !!

2"D '

1 #

( 31$ 1 4

)

6 )

1 -/ 3 9

-0 3 4 % # , , - 3 9

# (% # 91 # #

#( ( 6 3 # , 1 )

6 )

1 #

( 31$ 1 4

- , - :!

-0 3 9

# (% # 91 # #

#( ( 6 3 # , 1 6

6 , , 3 .

1 . 6

)

6 )

1 , , :!

-0 3 .

1 1

6 - 3 9 / 6

)

6 )

- :!

-0 3 9 @! 6 '1 $- % 0 60 " 0/ 00$"?0 60 6%!"

!"'% "

$ /

0 % 20 2 ""$

/ 2 " $ 0 $0 $"!0!! !"6" "-$- / "6' 4$

% "

"! C6!0 $"!% "'""

$ 0 * %"

$- 60 '1 ! 0 $"! % !! "2" "0 "

%3 !" $'

%$!20"

6% - %0

061$1 0 / 20$- 2""

!1'$

'1! 0 $"!C

$ %! 4 62 %0 "00$-"

0" 0"/ - 0$!!1/ 0 ""

6' 4 !0 (( '

209$!!"$%%% !

$"/2"/ !6&!2!"

06 $"/ $' 4

" ! 610* $!$-0 "

-4"

%% "

"6 !6" $/ /!6 -$

!0 /%"

0 *$2

6!3 " !/!4

!*% / 0 - !

- 0 2 !020"=$ ! 2 " 0

- 0 / !1'10 00$"/ 2 " 120120 1$".% 3 !2"

" "

" 0 / $!

""'!16'-

2 " -

" "12 ""30 $!

6 ""'!16"$0 !6" 0 /%2"

" "

" '6'1-""

!0/20% -'""% "

@.""3 !

"$%%1$1 0 / "--1'$

%0 00$"

-% "

/ 1

%!0 1$1 - 10 0 "

"2 2 - 12 $ $$ !

6/- 6-0$!

"0 "" 2"0'' 4'1- 9 !"" 0"

3 !"

% " /

- 6"$!

'"0 %1$1 " "

/" $

62" "0 "

2 "$" 0 2

2"/ "

'!".%2" "

- %3 !

!0/ "-"61 $!- 00$") */"

2"4 2

-! "

"/- "'

1% -6!!:2!.% 2"

/0 $!612!!6 - '

9$- "

%"1'

1% -:2!3""1'1'

%:2!"-"

' $! 00$"9$- "

" %6!!:2!!! 12 """" 0%0!!1 %!! ""! "0!$9$- %#!!:2! " 1"9$- ""! "

"%$!!1 6 0 *% / - %"-"9$- - %0 - ! @."

'"" %0

"$!

61'%

-- 0$!

'""

% 0 - ! 3 !2"

" "

" 0 / 2" 0"" 1% !0

0 -" - ! ?12 ""/"0

$ "

"2 2

$!61-$06 0 .

'- 0 - ! "!"

$ "-0 !!/2 00$"0"$2"

$1*% /" "0 "

!6 -0

' $'

- 0 $ / " $!0 60 -/ "

1 2 """/ -!1/ !6 &!2

-6"$%%$" 0 - 2 """ "0 "

' $'

* - ! "

" 2

61 6 $"- 12 00$"

, - '120- 66 !6 00$" "0" 2 !1 ""

"0$ 0 60 -!!1/

12 """2 $!6'!"

"0 0 $!

0$! ""$'"

00$" "0"2 !1*1 -"!6"

6"$%%$" 0 /209$!!!

"!%.

2 $!6' "

"$ $!

1 "

"2' $

4 $""$ '!1/ !!

2 0 $!0$! "

"0 6 !6"

- 0 "

"0"2 !1*00 $ 6'1!! 12 """

" 0 %0*10 $!

1- !

0 ""A- - $- 60'1!0 $"!% !! "2" 1 00$""

' 6 " "%0

!1/""$0/'% % $'

" $!'6

"$000$"/ 2"/! 0 $"!"6- !10 $ 0 % 6! 0 "/ 2 % "$0 $- $ % 2'1!0 $"!% !! "!04"-

!! ""! "?00$") *"'" 0%0!!1 - '1-6402 - !6 -/20 $" 0 00$""'- "

/- " /9$- "'

1% -6!!:2! "!1 '"6/!! ""! "2" 0%0!!1 %'1 12 """ $ .

61$0 --

'1"04-" -/ % /%

- '19$- "'

1% -:2!"

- $ $!/"

- '1- % ."0

!" 0 !!"/ - -"/ "

4 2'1"0 $!-" %'1"

-/04- -/ $ - -" "-*12 """2

""! "/ "0/ 1'!

"-0 !!" 0%0%0

- ' 2" @./ 2" 0"" 1 % !1 "

%0 B12 """6" 00$"?""! $ % 20 4 !0 1 -/ 1"$%%0

00"

" ""! ""

" 1 2"

0"" 1 % !1 %0 *00$"

-"!6"=$"

% 1 "

%0 / "

-"!6" % % - 1 2 """

*% / %0 %""! " $ '1 12 """

' "

' % %"

- ! % "

%0 "

6"!1%%0 "0$ "

1 - $- 60'1!0 $"!% !! "2" A0 2 %) /

2 2"

0 6% - - 00$"/20""$!

%%0 " 0'! 1 % "0$ "

13 26/2%!

!- "

*0 61 %2 %%%0 % --00$" $!6% !1! - 0 '

"0$ "

1 '$ '

"$!

62 "0$ 0"2 "$" 0 .

"=$ ""'! "

% 0 /00$"

!7 0 61 %2 "% - """" 2 $!!

- $'!$000$"- 6"

1 2 " "

" " %*10

16 '1%$!

0 %!0 $"!% !! "2"

"0$

A-5- ! /

% / "0$ "

1'0 -" $'

%$!/2"/! $"!"0 "$00 0!$" " $!'6 '1 $ C $ %! "=$! 1 60

=$ 120-

"* "0$ "

202 ""

0 "

'A-?

A-B0611 2 "" 0

2 ""'

A "? "

- 0 * "0$ A- 1 2 """ 0 3 !0 - ! / !6 &!2 $?12 """"!1"0$""'

6/!!

- " $!0 60-00 $ %

0 6 '1 - " 0 %0 *% / A- %5- ! "

-41 %%0" 0!!12 1'6$ "6'2

6'1 00$"/'1 "0$ - $- $ % 2'1!0 $"!% !! 2" $00

"0$ "

1! !

0 4 !0' 2 "'

00$0'$ 60 "'' $ 3 26/ 2% @. "!%/ "%0

"$0!

0 /"

. !1 '"6'1 ! $ 0" %0 60 0 '6!'! -

6 !"

"%00@$ - / -

6!" - %0-! "61%%0$!

*% / "$- "0 C % "0$ " "$00""%$!!1 6 0 "

00$" '1 " 2 % "

'! $'

'1 '0 /0 60/!'!60'

0$!

2" * -0! 60 $!1 0 '

" 0$! 60 * 6"

"'0 $0 %- !-* 00$"0 $!

'! !$"'!A ! % !!%!"- !0 "0"*00$"'-2 $"2 "' "

04020 0"/ $ 0 - ! 2 6!! 0$" $"

00$ "A0 0 - ! " 2 0 --

'0 %0 $" 1% -$!2%$!""-'!1*0 --

'0 2"

0$"-$ %9$!! $"

&!2 !6@ - - $" $" "

% 9$!! /

0$" " '0 -"

'$ !10!*% / 00$"2 !10 60 %

%%0 %-$

%%0"% 20 1'0 *$- ""'1 ! $ "

"$%%% - 1!!! 1 %- 1/ !"% $

'2 1 - "-""00 !1*00$"?0 60 "2 '!""$!

%"$" " %" 0' 4

0$"

-" 0;0""10 - !0 "'-'1 %)$0!"

/$/

2 -0 1 "$- ' " !"

- 0

; $

6: <

' ; $ *% < '