United India Insurance Company Ltd. v. Shanno And ORS.

2023:PHHC:062988

   

       

 !"#!$%&%"'(
)*)

'% !+'+%'&,-'$! "./'01 +) 2//!33'  4!-&,& 56''"'+" 6!-& 2) !&/"'+!' &

"-.( "'783! -),& %$!)5)93% -!&!' (

-).% :,'+-;+4"$ !#"- 6!//!33' )

-) <%4:,.-5%'%;+4"$ !#"--!&/"'+!' "&)
'+ ) === )5)93%;) -3 >
? -0!- %' 6! //!3 %& #"- -!+,$ %"' "# $"./!'& %"' "#

&)@;;
AB-+!+ " 6!-!&/"'+!' &$3%.' &80 6!3!-'!+ " "- $$%+!'  3%.&-%8,'3;:-'3)1!-'!+ ",'&!3$"' !'+& 6 %'$".! "# 6!+!$!&!+",C6  "64!8!!'&&!&&!+&/!- 6!.%'%.,.BC!& ,'+!- 6! %'%.,. 9C!& $  %'& !+ "# "' 6! 8&%& "# 4!-C! "#

%'%.,.9C!&#%D!+80 6!18",- "..%&&%"'!-;-0''+ 6! - ! "# BC!& #%D!+ 80 6! !/, 0 "..%&&%"'!-; :-'3) 1!-'!+

",'&!3#,- 6!-$"' !'+& 6 +!+,$ %"' "B-+&/!-&"'3!D/!'&!&"# 6! +!$!&!+",C6  "64!8!!'E*F%'& !+"#E
A-+"# 6!%'$".!"# 6!+!$!&!+&.+!80 6!3!-'!+-%8,'3) >? " %$! "# ." %"' " -!&/"'+!'  "&)
 '+  "'30 & 3!-'!+ $",'&!3 #"- 6!//!33'  $"' !'+& 6  6! B-+%./"&!& 3%8%3% 0 "' 6! //!33'  '&,-'$! "./'0 '+ 6! "B'!- '+ +-%4!- <"%' 30  '+ &!4!-330) ' 4%!B "# 6! &  !.!'  "# 3!-'!+ $",'&!3 #"- 6! //!33' &; '" %$! "-!&/"'+!' "&)'+@%&+%&/!'&!+B% 6)





>?

-) <%4 :,.- 5%'%; 3!-'!+ $",'&!3 #"- 4! "- -!&/"'+!'  "&)
 '+ ; B6" %& /-!&!'   %' ",- ; $$!/ & '" %$! '+ 4!6!.!' 30"//"&!& 6!/-0!-#"--!+,$ %"'80$"' !'+%'C 6  6!." 6!- '+ ,'.--%!+ &%& !- "# +!$!&!+ ,8-%G 3% B!-! -%C6 30 B-+!+ $"./!'& %"' 80 6! 3!-'!+ -%8,'3)  1!-'!+ $",'&!3 -!3%!& ,/"' 6! +!$%&%"'"#"'783! 6!5,/-!.! ",- %'

   

    !

"" # "$
% &% '(%$ (   )   "  *"! + ,  ,

!

 "
 &' ( %
%$

!    , -  

 )

 * !  " ./! * 0% 123 ;/45%6


  5!

 , 7 

!  " !

 
3 


$ /45 2 3 6


   8!

  ,  " !


 


&,/6!3+80"'783! 6!5,/-!.! ",- 4%+!"-+!-+ !+ )) %' 51  %4%3  %-0 ")& ) @* "#  %' $&! % 3!+ & 8!

  ,  " >@? 64!$"'&%+!-!+ 6!&,8.%&&%"'&"#3!-'!+$",'&!3) >*? +.% !+30; 6!+!$!&!+ ,8-%G3%B&C!+*0!-&  6! %.! "# 6%&+! 6 "' 
)
)
 '+ B& B"-G%'C &  $3!'!- %'  -,$G 6",C6 "' 6! 8&%& "#3%$!'$!"# +-%4!- "#  6!40 4!6%$3! %&&,!+ " 6! +!$!&!+;% %&$3%.!+ 6 6!B&B"-G%'C&+-%4!-'++-B%'C&3-0"#

&)*;A /!- ."' 6) "B!4!-; 6! 3!-'!+ -%8,'3 80 -! %'C 6! +!$!&!+&,'&G%33!+B"-G!-&&!&&!+6%&."' 630%'$".!"' 6!8&%&"# - !&#%D!+,'+!- 6!'" %#%$ %"'%&&,!+#"- 6!-!3!4' /!-%"+80 6!5  ! "# -0' ,'+!- 6! %'%.,. 9C!& $  '+ 6! BC!& #%D!+ 80 6! !/, 0 "..%&&%"'!-;:-'3)6!-%8,'3#,- 6!-80 G%'C%' "$$",'  6  6!+!$!&!+6+3!# 8!6%'+6%&B%+"B!+." 6!-'+,'.--%!+&%& !-





-! !+ 6!$&! "8!"'!#33%'C%' 6!!D$!/ %"'3$3,&!&$"' %'!+%' 6! +!$%&%"' "# (   ) : $&!&,/-  '+ .+! +!+,$ %"' "B-+& /!-&"'3!D/!'&!&"# 6!+!$!&!+E
A-+%'& !+"#*F&/!- 6!C!'!-3 -,3!)"'783! 6!5,/-!.! ",- %'

:$&!&,/- B6%3! G%'C%' " $$",'  6! +!$%&%"' "# "'783! 5,/-!.! ",-  %' (   ) : $&! &,/-  & 3&" 6! #$  6  6! +!$!&!+ 6!-!%' B& 3%4%'C %'  4%33C! B6!-!%'6!B&-!&%+%'CB% 66%&C!+# 6!-B6"B&8", *0!-&"3+ '+,'.--%!+&%& !-;,/6!3+ 6!+!+,$ %"'.+!80 6!%C6 ",-  "B-+& /!-&"'3 !D/!'&!& E
A-+)  ' (   ) : $&! &,/-  "'783! 6! 5,/-!.! ",-  6!3+ 6  B6!-! 6! +!$!&!+ %&  &,-4%4!+ 80 /-!' & '+ &%83%'C&;"'30 6!." 6!-B",3+8!$"'&%+!-!+ "8!+!/!'+' ;'+*F B",3+ 8! -! !+ & 6! /!-&"'3 '+ 3%4%'C !D/!'&!& "# 6! 8$6!3"- '+ *F& 6!$"' -%8, %"' " 6!." 6!-8, B% 6 6!!D$!/ %"' 6 B6!-! 6! #.%30"# 6!8$6!3"-%&3-C!'++!/!'+' "' 6!%'$".!"# 6!+!$!&!+; &%'$&!B6!-!6!

6&B%+"B!+." 6!-'+3-C!',.8!-"#0",'C!- '"'!-'%'C&%& !-&"-8-" 6!-&;6%&/!-&"'3'+3%4%'C!D/!'&!&-! "8! -!& -%$ !+ ""'! 6%-+'+$"' -%8, %"' " 6!#.%30%& "8! G!'& B" 6%-+)5!$"'+30;%'  * !: &, '$ ""-+%' !!'

",-  -!<!$ !+ 6! $633!'C! " 6! B-+ "' 6! C-",'+ 6  %'& !+ "# &&!&&%'C 6! $"./!'& %"' "' 6! 8&%& "# 6! - !& /-!&$-%8!+ ,'+!- 6!

%'%.,. 9C!& $ ;
@H; %'$".! 6+ 8!!' &&!&&!+   6! - ! & /-!&$-%8!+80 6!!/, 0 "..%&&%"'!-:-'3;80"8&!-4%'C&,'+!-(
 



  

  





     

!

     "     # "

$%%%%&! '

  

            

  (%&!     

  

  "

)  

* + , 

    " # 



     -

 "

 



 -

    



  ,        

 ."#   / 0  '" ) "  

@



) "  "   -        "  

     1" "    





    #   

 #    /       " ."    "  -

   



 

   

  " 1"  

   







  ,         $2 0            

            # +  (  3 

$  4  5      

  

"



    "  

 #  



  

   "

    

  "

  "    "





#  

 

"      -

 (  "

  "



) "  

 "

   

 !       ."#      

  

    

 1" 

 

 "    

   

 "   " # 6  78 9   ."#  

 "

  





  2 * #    "  "   

#

       



        

 

   

"  " #6 78 

   -, 



  

  

      

"        #     #  



       

: >?

!3%'$! 6& 3&" 8!!' /3$!+ "' 6! +!$%&%"'  %'5!

   , - !!

 7 

!   ":   &, ' B6!-!%' &%.%3- $633!'C! B& -!/!33!+ 80 "8&!-4%'C 6  '" +",8  6! '" %#%$ %"'%&&,!+80 6!5  ! "4!-'.!' -!C-+%'C3%'G%'C"#.%'%.,. BC!&B% 6 6!$"'&,.!-/-%$!%'+!D%&-!3!4' #$ "-8,  6!&.!%&'"  8%'+%'C&&,$6"' 6!-%8,'3) >? "&%.%3-!##!$ ;%& 6!+!$%&%"'"# ""-+%' !!'$6"# 6%&

",- %'8!

  ,  ": &, '$B6!-! 6!-%8,'3&&!&&!+%'$".!E₹
@;
A;& /!- 6!.%'%.,.BC!&#%D!+80 6!!/, 0 "33!$ "-"#%& -%$ :-'380 6"3+%'C 6  6! -%8,'3 B& '"  8",'+ " $$!/  6! .%'%.,. BC!& '" %#%!+80 6!18",- "..%&&%"'!-'+ 6  6!-%8,'3B&-!I,%-!+ " '30J! 6! !4%+!'$!)' &%+ $&!; - ! "# BC!& '" %#%!+ 80 6! !/, 0

*



"33!$ "-%& -%$ :-'3&B!-!-!3%!+,/"'80 6!-%8,'3B!-!,/6!3+80 "'783! 6! 5,/-!.! ",-   4%+! "-+!- + !+  )) %' 51  %4%3 %-0 ")& ) @* "#  %' $&! % 3!+ & 8!      ,  " >H? $$"-+%'C30; %' 4%!B "# 6! +!$%&%"' "# "'783! 6! 5,/-!.!

",- %'

:$&!&,/- &B!33&%'4%!B"# 6!<,+C.!' &-!3%!+ ,/"'803!-'!+$",'&!3#"- 6!-!&/"'+!' &;."# 6!$"'&%+!-!+4%!B 6  6!-! %& '" %'#%-.% 0 %' 6! B-+ /&&!+ 80 6! 3!-'!+ -%8,'3 80+!+,$ %'C
A-+"# 6!%'$".!"# 6!+!$!&!+ "B-+&/!-&"'3!D/!'&!& '+&&!&&%'CA-+"# 6!%'$".!"# 6!+!$!&!+ "B-+&+!/!'+!'$0"' $$",'  "# 6! +!$!&!+ 64%'C 3!#  8!6%'+  B%+"B!+ ." 6!- '+ ' ,'.--%!+ &%& !- & 3&" %' 4%!B "# 6! +!$!&!+ 3 6",C6 B"-G%'C &  $3!'!- 0!  64%'C  +-%4%'C 3%$!'$! "#  6!40 4!6%$3!; '+ 6! -%8,'3 64%'C&&!&&!+ 6!%'$".!"# 6!+!$!&!+E &)

;H
A"' 6!8&%&"#' 4!-C!"# 6!'" %#%$ %"'%&&,!+,'+!- 6! %'%.,.9C!&$ '+ 6! - !&&#%D!+80 6! "#%& -%$ ;:-'3) >? $$"-+%'C30; #%'+%'C  '" .!-%  %' 6! //!3; 6! &.! %& +%&.%&&!+) &;(< !

' 7

  
)*)   - #&  ; <&

  ; <&