High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5002/2020allowed

Neena Sharma v. State Of Haryana And Another

2023-10-03Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil7 pages

!"#"$%&'('&

% )*+'

, +, ++ * ****

! "

# $ ! % , $-

./-0"12 ' &'(

" ) *$ +, !

-, , !"../ - , 0) ,! ) , 1,$ "

2 '3 .4.4 &5, '( 6 . ) 6 ! 5! , '7 %7/28 !

) 4'

.44/ %4 .4'9: 3.;%28

&%4< "6!(6 &.(

= !," ,6 + .8- -" * 1, , ) !! $ " $ '7 './28 ) "") ,! ) .4 4> .447 $ .7 > ! , *$ ) , ,! "$ -?

8.433'8.44' " 6

=" $ , *$ ! ) $," @

- 2 - )" " )! .9 ''

.44> ) 4'

.447!",$ ""%'

.4''

&%(

$, 5 5!

) ,"

6 !

*5 '4 ,! , ),"6 ,! '9 '9328 " '% 9'.28 ,! *$ ) * !* $ " ,$ ! 85 ),"!, " $

&7(

= !," $, , ! ")

-, )"" , -, @

! !6 -"8000 -"80 " ,

&3(

! ) , .3 4.

.4.4 , ,

. % " !

)

2 " &/(

A ! .!

" " ! " $ , *$ 49 4/ .44> .> ''

.4'447 .4';&5, .2'

.2%( ,5! ! 6 ,"

5 5! !

,61, "" !," "

"$ !

B , ,"/&'(&5, .27( $ ,!

, ) 4'

.44/ ,! ! ! , ) $ 85

- 3 - 5! "! "! !"

!# $ %"&$ " '( )*+ ( ! ) "$ , *$ 5! "" &>(

" !," &;(

! 6 )!!, !" !" *

5! 6 !!, ) $ 5 ) 4'

.44/ %'

.4'9 ,"

" 5! '7 %7/28 6 6 ! 6) ",!

: 3.;%28

&9(

) ! 6 6" , !

6 " *$ ! 2 6 ) $"5 " !"6 ) ! ) ,! ! )," ,"

, )!)," , )$ 1, 6"6"! " C $ ! 0 ) !),"6!"" ",!!) ),"6 1, , ! &'4(

$ ),"6 "")$ , ," 6 , -, ,!&, ( $ $ " , ! )

*" 6 6 " 5! " ! 6 "

),"6 6"")8

- 4 -

!" !" " !""# " # "

!" " ! $ " "" " " " " " " " $ !%

" !" " " " " ! $ "" "# ! !" " $ " " &''(

0 !

" -"8000 " $ , " -" * ) .4 4> .447 ,$ ! !

$ ! '7 %7/28 6 ) " ,!

: 3.;%28

6,'3 .4.4 '/ " $ !

$ *

6, '/ ",5",+, )!! 6 * &'.(

0 !

& - *. /#.0 1& 22 ( , -, " " !$ 6, $ ""$ 6 " , ) 0 " "$ ,5" !, )"" 1, !$ B,

- 5 - " !$ ,! ,5",+, 6" "$ " )," ,"

$ +,! " !" , "+, ! &'%(

, ") $ $ ! 5!

6 " " ! 5! 61, 6"! )!6

"6 5-, #& ) & . 3& 4 1& 2 ( ) , -, )"1,$ !

$ ! 5! ! ,"

6 , 8 &'()" "" $ #* " """"! + " " " %! " " !#!"! ! !" " !" " ! ""* " " # &',- "# """ "!

"""%! "" "!"!"!" " ! ! """. " " ! % " )" # !" !

- 6 - " "!" !""" " /

! " " " """" ! " !" " "" #""" & &'7(

0 %"&$ ", ! &, ( )" $ 8!" $ , *$ , 5! ) !

,61, " 8 !" "!

$ )"") > '

.444 ,"" ) ! ," " ! '.

.44% ';

.447 "

! '

44%28) , , , !

$ $ -,

"!"!%"&$ ",!&, (6 " $,6" 6 6 , -, "6,6, *$ " 6" !" ! ! , , *$)" $ !" 0 !* ! )" +,$ 1 ),"6 , ,,6 "-"8000 "6 )$ 6 !" '4 &'3(

$ ,! "")

, ! ,"6" 6! ) D , E $, -",&( & ( 8'. +,$ ,!&, (

- 7 - &'/(

!! $" ) 6 !, ) "") 5 2"

'3 .4.4 &5, '( !

! " ! "" 6 , ) " ! ! ! &'>(

!! $" 4% '4 .4.% " , $-

./-0"1

/-0

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No