Kehar Singh And ORS. v. State Of Haryana
!
"
# $
$ %
"
!"
#$!
% %! #$!
%
! !
$
& % '(#
)* &
+ (#
)
& , )
+ !
& % +
)* & (
) (
%!& -(
)
' ( (' (
./
#
- )
"( &
1( $2 3 "(
*
2 *
.04/.546/.5
4./.5 7$8
( *
( (( '* * ( (
" $ *
9(
(( '
(
( (
" $ *
9( :2 * ((
( 2
,,; * ( % ( ' (
) * ((
.0446
4.7$8
*
:
<
.07$8 " ( ( =( > <
47$8 ; ( (
"
/:
(
( (
=( >
' <
467$8 " ( ( )
"
0/:
(
( ( )( >
)<
4.7$8 " ( (
=(
:2 *
(
( (
"
/:
(
( ( * (
* ? ) ( *
(
(
' " @
-
550 6 ( ( # $ (
( 7# "($
$+7 8
* *
)
+) ( + !
) 7 * =
1
( 5505 ( * *
? $( * * (
" *( *
2 $(
*
:
1 (
" ( ( )
* 1 2 : : * 3 "(: *
& : * 1( $2 :
"( : )
(
2 ( - * * 2 "
1( $2 : )
* " * 3"(
"( :
(" *
( 2 /4 ( (2 ** 1
(
*
(
" ( *
$ * * "
9( ) * ( * *
( (
( * * )*
-( ( * " * '
2" $ *
9( ' (*" *
$+78
* ( # 556*
* (
* )
(
) * ( (
" $ *
9( - ( 2
( ( ( ( :# $ 7"3 550( ( $
.0/.5/46/47$8
(
) 7# "( )
=( -
( *
* , '
-7 ) 1 @
6.8 $
:(( - ) *
)7
"(*) )
7# "( !
:
(*
!2
) (
( *
*
7 @& -
* * * (3"(*
7
"( ("(3 8* * 2 : (
1
4 550 * 1
.
5502 :
(
) *( * 2
* 2 3 "(: )
*
* "( :
( )
* * 2 * 2
)
& : ) (
)
648 $ * 7
"
( 8
= :1( $2 * *
9
(( ( ) 1( $2 : *
((
458 $ )
* ) ( ) *
(
=( $?5 # $
$?" *
-( ) *
( $? # $? -2
$? & - * 7
( $? # :((
( ( * ) *
:
A -*
0(= () ((
& ( *
* 2
)
(
((( ) (/.( B(
*4/.( (
= * ) )
* " *
* ) ( = )
) ) * ( "
(=
( (* "
* ) ( (
*
2 * ) (
* ((
(( =
C(=6(* ( * ) (
(
( * )
* ) ( ; )
2
*
*
( *
2
(
' D (<
' , * :((
* ( *
* ((
*
((* .
$? -2 ( :
=( " ' 550
(
*
:
A
- * ( *
+ ) C( (= ( ( = 4 ( ) ;
$ ) (
$
* F: *
)
*
(=B()
) F:
*
4(=() ,
* F:*
)
.
(=()2
3 4 * 2
)
7 '3 *
' 3
4
'3 .
*
*
* =
E -2 ( : =( $ * * " ( 4 (
* '
:
A
( = (
7*
F: * )
- '* * *
=
-2 =(
9( ( 4 (
*
' :
A
-* *
0(= ( )
,
* F:* )
- ' *
*
* * =
$? & -* ( " $+78
! * 5504 (
( ) 8"3
6.0.
(
3 044/50 ! * ( :# $ *
2
'0 4 ( 50 )
-*
)( !
) * -* *
4 ( 9
* -
* F:
2 8- * )
*
D
<
' * )
* 0 550 (
*
(D <)
*
- *
.
550 8
(
* *
:
$ *
* (
2<
(
D*2
< - * ) * ( (
1$ *2
& -* ' *
(
( ) ) * $?!8"( $?8
($?4!8 $ ) "'$?.!8# ; $?8
$?6 !8!) "($?!8"( $?4 7# "($?.
"(
$? ;
G ) 1 D, < ;&
- : H= $;
* ) $?0"
$
? =(
448 $ ( ) - 2
1($2 : * )
?'(
" , ! %
?
( ?
?
! % 2 1($2 :
?49( (
+ ;8 !H, 1 )
"'
(
0 555*
* (
555 ?.1($2 (
? 1 2 9 ) !
( * ( 550 550
550 ! )
( I &/
$ - ) ( 8
? 8 ; ( !
2 ) ( !
2 9 ) * ( 550 550
(
2 : ( * (
(
550 -
)
( * (
.
$ $
(
8 )
* *
(
' - 8
)
*
(
*
(
)
( # 556* = *
* (
:
&
*(*
( 7 * )
(
&
- (
( * * ( -
(
2 * ( " $ *
9(
) (
7 ( ) * *
) )
( ) ( (
&)( )(
(
(
) ) (
( $?5 # $ * 7"
$?" * ( ) ,( ) ( ( (
*
* (
* '
( " $ *
9( - ( ( ) ( $? # *
:(( (
* 2
( ) ( (
$? -2 * ( : =( ' ( " $ *
9(
$? & -* *
"
'
- ( **
)
$? ;
G ) 1 D, < * =(
,,;
* (
(
(
*2 ! * ( * 7 ) 1 ) (
( ( (
( ,,;
( ( ! *
* *
'
(
2 " :
'
1 ( ( 2 (
( *
C:7
- @ * )2
5505 ( )
: 7
( " $ *
9( )
) (( $?5# $
2 " $ *
9(
"
($+78
7# "(* ( ( (
$+78
$+7 ? $+78
(
( :# $ *
( H= $& ( 5506 ( 1
( 7"H= $&/( $
550 ( - * 8
(*
) (7 @& (
550 - * * ) ( ( :# $
?) =
& ( :# $ ) *8
( $
) (
( *
-( = (*
" $+78
*
) (
*
)( * @
( * 0 550
.
550 H) (
" *
* ( 2<
(
D*2
< - * ) =
)
- (2 (
)
* ( ( :# $
' :"
( * ( *
(
( :# $ *
( ( )
( *
(
" *( (
1
" * * ( (
) ) (
$(
(
# $ ( (
!*)
8
)
) 2 ( )
*2 ) (
- 1( $2 :
550
2*
(
)
550 *2 (
2 ?'(**
" , ! %
* 1( $2 :
550
*
*2 ( (
)
550 H) ) * 1($2 : ( 6 (
550
) ) * /J
( ?
( 550 1( $2 : ( * (
= ( % !*) * * * ( 1($2 : * ) )
(
* *
&) 1( $2 : *
(( 8
* ( *
( - 1($2 :
8( 2 : *
( 550 550
*
) ) 5505 ( ?.1($2 (
**
!
( *
2
( (
( &)? 8 (
:
+ =( * ( C ( ! * 2 ) = *(
- ) 2 : 2 (
- 8 *) *
) )( &
:
- # 556 *
* :
(
( *
* ( * *
1
*
(
= : *( & : *
( * (
' ( :
* ( * 7"
( :# $ *
( 7 8*:*
: * * ) ' 2
" *
" ( ( : =(
'3 .* 2
*
( (=( 2 ' )
"
) (
*
' -
* * : * ) '"
) *) )
&
: :
@
( - )
(
( "( 3"(2
1($2 (
- )
)
(
, %!- ,
! !-
./0 & ':