High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/668/2003disposed of

State Of Punjab v. Raj Kumar And ORS.

2019-11-21Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan,Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan16 pages

! "#!!

$%#&'#

!&! (

$%#&'#

! "#!!

!&!

"+&$%#

++#! "#!!

$%#&'#!

!&!

$%# & $%# & & #

# $ %

&#'#!& +(

&##!&, +

# -& .# &/01+' # #% ++2'-& .&/0#' ! +(

3##!&!+

&##!&!,

# - &'1.%+0!#+#'++#! +

&#'0% +4/+0+% +(

& # ' 5!' .'0!'0!!##!0+!#6# '0#+%+ %0'+#6+'+!0!1!!+%+ 60% + "+&$%#!'7#!!.#!+&"+ 2$'+ 0'+.1'+ '+!!%2#0#&&1+'5!'$%# +0+ 8&+ . %#+!# *

) )) . !& ' '+! !+!# !'+ &0!&.2& *6#!1!%##+&1+' $%#00!& 9'#+&+ 82&+!''&#00!&'& '#& $#+!' :+ 00!& %'# $%# 00!& '# 00!&!&% #& !'+.!+0.'6'& 2#+/0'!''& #2'&;&1#6'+%'# %##+21+' $%# '!& &#+/''! 6' 00!& +&!+#!0+&# <6#!

=&1+'

'+!% #%.!'/+0%#!+&1+''##!.1'# !'#%+&# 6#3' #%'!#+#' +0+&. ' 00!& 2 1+' !% #!0 #!! 9'#+ &+0%''!'0% ++'#%0'6 # ' #! ##0'% 9# ' +2' & -! .

%% #0'6"+ 2$'+ 0'+'& ! +&!0' 7!# 0%#%+! 9#&++2'!:>+#+2'9#,7#. %#+!#.'!

&!+!#'# $%#1! !'#1+'' 00!&'+% ?'00!&'&%&0%%+%''6 1 &'#!!!'++#&1 &#+!6&%& #&1#6.'##.!'+1!! 21+''00!&

) )) ."+&$%# 21+''+!0 +&#$%#1 ''!'00!&!!'+.'1/#.#0'+2'#. '6 !1 '# && &6 6+2 07 +0 ?' 0% + !!0&'00!&'&0!&'#&'

@/+2 +&#$%# '#.0% +"+&$%#1!#0&+21#&! +0+ 8&+ ##'%#' +0 '16.'0%0#!!

5!'$%#.50'#2. +0!9'#+&+&2'+! !%AB #0#&&1+''+% 5!'$%#&+&!!0 0%%+!!+60.'##.'%&'+!&#!%AB 4

1!0'!%&!#; +0!+#%7+2#6+ '&+ 6&+#6#2+!#.1'+0'1!00#&+2 6& 6&+ 6&+#6 #2+!# +2AB 5!'$%#'1''!' 00!& -0##+&+;!#0&+2!1+'#2#&&& &6 !'+.##+2+;!##AB ,+'#2#& & &6 !'+1!!+/+ -!+ .%#+!##'#! 2+2 ! %#%B%++ 0&0& '# *

) )) .

&/+2'.-.8&+ 2!%/#++0+%&&' #2+!#&=5AB 94#0!&#0+!*) . * #& 1+'0+*5 -1' 000##0&##& #2'!+ '#!AB - ?'+/!+2+'+!0!1!

%#7&5!'$%#.1'#0#&&!%!1+!!!

00!& 1# ##!& + '+! 0! %! 1+!!! 1# #0#&& /# #+0 !1#7+ +0!!!!+ #0% ++/!+2+&'##% ++!.'

( 0' 2+!'00!&1!##&&+ &+'#5 ; 2+!%#+!#.1'! +&0+!&0%!# +&+ '0' '00!&#0!!#/+&&&#0+

( # &'+&+2''0&#0+ * 51!

B0 !+/ 6#+ 6'#!!+.0%%+&'0!' #!!+!8&2.%#+!#.#%1'#.+1!!!+2&&&

!!+!8&2.%#+!# #0+'0!.+&+2#+%0+0!.0'#2# 0!&#0+! * &*) 51!#%&2+!' 00!&.1'+0'.'6 &&2+ 6&0 +%&#+ -1/#.

&#+2'&06'#+ .00!&82+&!''&#'&B+#&

#+2 ' 0#! #!0+ /+&0. + B%+& +!%0'! )1+!!!.!#&+ ! 1C : "+& $%#0% + #& ' ' !!#+!!%&+'+!!% +0AB

: # 9#% ++!&'(

) )) .' 2 1+'# 9# +2'.'&0&0&'!%#%B%++ '&& &6!'+ "+!0#1!7&! &+ B 1'+0' 21+'!% ! 1!!'%+0 AB%+#'#2'' +0 +0+ !

"+!0# + !# # 1! ! ! -& ' 26.#%%&+0 2.%#+!#&#0+ '%+0 AB%+###.'0!&'1!& %+% '!'+&.1'+0'1!!+0+0!&'+'#&+#60#! # -#/&06!%#%##!AB 3++

) 0!&'AB 3##' 26AB =

: 5!0# &/ +2'. -. +/+ @+!.

%#+!# 1' '& 2 ' =5 #2+!#& & 0##+& +++ +/!+2+&0% ++/!+2+'&+ &'0' + '#&!&+'#2#& :* # + +2'. 2& *D 6#!. 0'# #!!+.#!+&"+ 2$'+ 0'+.!&''71!"+& $%#.!+0'#!+&!#'+!'!&+!/+!++2#%!1+''+%

!'+1!!+!#"+&$%# '1!%##+&1+'

$%#00!&+0% #)) 3' $%#.'+!'#82&+!'

'&#&%'#$#+!':+!&% #!'+.!6+2 ''+#!1!1#7+2.!!0'.1#&%&+2%6#'+# ! ?'6 !0% +&' !!&1#61!2+/&1'' 00!&% #&'&0!&.!'0% 07'## '! 4*%'!'#%##+2.!6+2'## 6#& '##.!%0%#%+!1!0& 1'#+!+' #!0'+2'#0'"+ 29'#+ -#'#!& '#'0%#%+!.''&21+'"+&$%#!'+ &!'0% +&'!'1! +2% #&&&%&%6 1! +2%& 6'00!& -#'#!&'

) )) .' 1!+#%& 6"+&$%#:#2#&+2&'!'+& '.'00%+&"+&$%# 21+'!%'##!!' /+ 2&!1&& &6!'+1! 6+2 07+0

?'00!& &'%''6'&7+ &'&0!&&''6

'& 2 +0 !+ # 2+2 '! %#%B%++ 0&0& ?'1+!!!!0&'!%+!1!2+/' &0!& 6+ 0+#'#1+!

:D-@7'

+#+2' +21''&#+0+&+' +/!+2+&!&#2#&+2'+!# : - #+&# . #% 1+!! &#& '+! +&/+!AB $ :(- '+&#+2'.'##% 1+!!&#& '+!+&/+!AB @

: -! .% #0'6"+ 2$'+ 0'+ !&''7#!!##+!'+!/+ 2&!'+1!'+! &2'#1'1!%##+&1+' $%# 6#!# +#3' '6'&&+#0!/#'&1#6#+0 !&'!.'+## +!1# 0#&+ 3 0%#%+!1!20&+ 1'% 6' 0'6&00!&'&2#&'#!!'#3!'1!7 2 1+' 6'00!&3!'!6&1+'00!& 4*%'!#' 0%#%+! -!&''&!71'0!'#&' !' '& &+& ' '! '# + 1! # 4* %'! ' 0%#%+! :)5!'$%#.+0.9#&!#1''& 0&0&'+/!+2++'+!0!# 6&!&+'#2#& 00 !+#!0+/+&0.!%!' 00!& 1# #0#&& &# 0+ # . + 1'+0' ' +0#+%++20+#0%!0!#+22+!!0'00!&1#

* '% '6&+&'!%.0&+2''61#+0& '& ! 6+/ /&+'+!0! 5'+#&0.'6'&B%+&:#+&#+2'

00!& $%#'&+ &1#+# 6.#+2' 2+! #!0+.!+2''1! +/+2!# 6#%'+!#!+' '!#+&#+2'3'!'+1!!'#%#&1%3 '1!!'1''0%71'!'+1!+!#+! 0&++&'##'+%%&+ 6#!'&'+!'%&& !'+&& :#+&#+2'!&' $%#'&7 #%+'+!'!# '#%'! #'+0+&.1'# '1! +/+2 21+''+!1+ #'#+2#2%!. #&!!+!8&2&'0. %#+!#.0/+0&'00!&#0&#0+*) 5.

1'#!.0;+&'%#0&#0+ * 5 $%# &$#+!':+00!&1'1#0/+0&&#0+*) 5 1#!0&&#25#'#6#!0'&6+ !

40'&+& 6%+.&#25# %'0'

?'+!1!&./+& &2%&& *

''00!&40/+0! 22#+/& 6' &2% &'&###& + (

#'+!#.

#6+2'' 00&3' &2%'+#0/+0+& !0 !!+&&'6 0;+&'0'#2#%&2+! '%.1'#!.'0% +1!&+!!+!+&1+'' &2%! & +/#&&'&###&0#+%+ #/+!++

#6+2''!% 00&300!& 0/+0&&!0& #0&#0+ * 5&'/6+ +%!&.1'+0'

2+/!0%!+'%+ 6'&0!&

'& !+ &!# +

.#6+2' 00!&40/+0! !0&#0&#0+ * 5

+0 '0!!#!'!+2 &2%.'6'/ '#& 2'# ?'# +! ##!+ ' ' 0% +4/+0+% + (

& ' ' ++#!+

E&# ' 0+#0%!0!. # - &'1. &/0.

#!+'#.+!+&!%+0!0#+!!+!'#

' '0% ++(

& ' ' ++#!+

?'2+!#6+!&+#0&'&/# 0% 06# 7' #&%+0!0#+ -!' +&#%#+ 6'-+2'#@2 #/+0!%%+.!# # !

: '/ '#& #& 0! # ' !4 00!&40/+0!. #&0! #'0% +4#/+!++!!1 ! #&0! !+&!2+2'#2''#0#&&1+& '' &2%& +/#& 6 #&&& !!+!8&2&'0 %#+!#.0/+0+2'00!&#0&#0+*) 5 & 0;++2 '% # 0 &# 0+ * 5 +! !!+ .!+0.++! !&%+!#+! /+&0&1#2

+ +##+ 1 !+#!+#!.&0!&!'+1!%##+& 1+' $%# '#6#!#+#'+0+& !'+'& &+& # &'. & +!+2. ! &!& 6:

9#% ++.1''&##%&!%#%B%++'&&

&6!'+ =#%'!%:"+&$%#. #'# &0!&&:*# ++2'.+0%!''&0!&!&

'#!!&&% #& 6'#'!

&.! #'#&'

?'!.

'0!!#6+2#&+!0&#0+ * 5!&!

#/& ?'+%2& &2%+!! 0#&+0#6 ?'#+ &2 0/+0& $%#&'+!%'#$#+!':+#0&# 0+*) 5#0# 6%&'&0!&.# +2 &%&#&1#6 ''#'&.0;+&'00!&# 0&#0+ * 5 ?'#+ #0 # 6 +###+ &+2 !. #! +2 + %+!0##+2 !+0 @#& 0! # 00!&40/+0! '& #2& ' ' &0!& 1! '#!!& & % #& 6'00!&+00+1+'&%&&1#6!

#'#&'.'##;+!+##/+2&#0+ * 5+!

%+!!+2 -'!+&':"+&$%#'&!0++0 6 !&'#'0%#%+!1!#0'& 1!'+& '# '!

& $%# & + 1! & !' '& ##& ' %#+%+ '%.'00!&'&#+!&6&%&&1#6 :+'

#2#&:*# ++2'.'0&&''2'# ++2''& !&! ' +2 !+2'

#.++!'+2' 6 +7 6''1 & '/2'%#+%+ '%!'+&!'+

1 &'/!&!'+%&#'#%#.+'+!!%&# 0+ # .''&%&6!0'0+!

1'1 !!%:"+&$%#%+ 6.+0%!'' '#!!% & % #% &0!& 1! '# ! # '# %##+21#&!&'#+!'+2!'1''#1!0'2+ ' '/+# ' 00!& # ## !' + ' %#+%+ '%&#'0%#%+! #%'!#+#' +0+& # ++2':*'&02#+0 6&!&+'#2#&. '2'.'1!0#!!B%+&&0#&1+''+!!%' +0AB .1'#'#1!##0&%&%6 + 1!!0++0 6%+&''#+ 1!1#% #+2'# :' 0 & '#!!+ %+/#'#!!%'&0!&B0 &%&&1#6.+0 +##&'!0'&%&&1#61!

0+!

@#& 0! #'00!&40/+0!'&###&

&2% 6'B#&()& *+, & - ./' !!012

0)3 42566.1'#++#,

' &2%.+1!

!#/&!&#C

# "

! -'&#'# 0&# +0 &2%#.)& *+ +), & - ./' !6)% 6"5 6'B#.

1'#++#, D.+1! !#/&!&#C F%& "

) ) $

*+,

-. + / $ %%. / . '(

)

) "

# ) )

%%. 0 / . '(

) )

%%. / "

# ) ) .'( %%. 0 / #

# ) ) / # ) ) %%

* , /

)

) "

) )

# ) )

3 "

# #

3 3 ) -'!#'##!!&+!#/+0 &2% #*+7 ) , &8) 9' !!052 0)3 425:

B#.1'#++#,!

)* .+1! !#/&!&#C F+

45 (

(

3 *,

7 *,

7 * ,

'8+ 0#

3 "

(

! ' '# '&. #& 0! # ' 0% +4#/+!++!'! ###& /#+! &2%!.+#! +2 &); , 38-3)' !!:012 0)3 425!: 6 +/+!+ 0''+!#.1'#+.+1! !#/&'1' #+& +!#&+0#!.++!'%+ 6%% #! +/+21+''#1''/ B +'0+#0%!0!+1'+0'+'&&+ 2+!0;+ .+##0+!#%+!!+ 6+#!!2+/ 6' #+ ###/#!.'1/#.'!%+%.1'#0;+ #! ! + %+!0##+2 !+0. ' # 1+ !++& +

( +##+21+''0;+ 51!#'#' &'+0!&1#6 &'.00# 6+!#/&.'#+!#!%+0++6. !! 0##6+!#/& 5'B &2%###& 6'+%. . )& *+, & - ./' !60 2 0)3 42 " 6'B#.' %+2B#!!+! #&'+0+ * 1!& 1+'

! 1!C

!"#$%&$ '

' 5 +-< ), &#+; )+' !!102 &0)2 6'B#.&+!+0+ 10+ * & 0+ 51!2+/.!+2' ''0+!#% 6 B0 !+/ 51!' &'0+ 51'#&1+'!0+ 'A/+&00'! 6 &'#+!''!

&#'+!

# +/1'!

0&1%0# 6!/+!2&+0+*) 5+!0'1%0%%+&!+0+&1+'+(6#!'#%##+23+ +!+%%#+ #0+ 51''#'0# 6#'#!!%1!

0!&F! #'#&'G'!0+ #/+!++0+ *

51 & +/0 .'#1+!#!#0 %&0+

) 5 '+! 0!. + !&! &; 6 ! +!'& ' ' &0!&1! +2'#!!&&% #&! #'#&'

&2%!###& 6 #&0! #'00!&40/+0!& 0%'+!#!0&&+#0!&0+#0%!0!.'1/#.'

&2%!# +& 6 #&0! #'0% +4#/+!++! &&/0'+!0! '#.1+&'0!&0+#0%!0!!'1 '+1!0!%#&# 0!+&#+2'0''00!&'& 0'#2&#0&#0+

5&'+0+&+!

%#' 6#! &1+''00!&82&+!''&#'/+2 B+#&.+1 & ##&##+#&##!'#+ . &+#0+2'#+ ##%0'#2#0&#0+

52+!'00!&+' #+/&1#0&&0+&' 0!!++!

-#1%6 !#/'!# 7 600!&

$%#.1'+0'+!0## #& 6!+%6:#+&#+2' 9'#+&+.+0%!' $%#&&0!&!'+ 1# #!+&+2 !# 6 + #& 00%%&+ 2+2 #+&# +2' !# #% #! $%# ?'##.

$%#+!B +!&#1'0+#0%!0!.!'+'& &+&# &'!0!+!+2 ?'+ 0+%#7!'# && &6!%+&+'#!%#%##&+' +!1!+ 0&'# 00!& $%#'!+ &B +! &#1'0+#0%!0!.'+!'&#& &6'+!1+' &0!&.'##.++! 7''+!#!!+ #'#&'

?'##.'#+!#!0;+ $%#0&# 0+*) 5.#'#.'+!0/+0++!0/#&&# 0+ * 5&'+!!0&&#25# 6#!.

1'#!.$#+!':++!0;+&'0'#2#0&# 0+*) 5.!+01&+&!+0+/+&02+!'# #'!+&0!1 !&#0+ * 5 00#&+2 6.' + & 6' +

&0#+%+ #/+!++ & 60% +"+& $%#+

# 1&# 6; $%#.1'#!.

++!&+!%+!!&1+'#2#&$#+!':+&' + & 6' 00!&40/+0!+ (

.0' 2+2'+#0/+0+ +! ! 1&# 6;$#+!':+&+!&+!%+!!&1+'#2#& 00!& $%# $%#+!!& + '+8&+0+ 2+!#.%#+!#+!&+#0&+!!'+!###!1##!!!2 '+%##!& & !& '+% # 8+ . %#+!# &#2 ' #%++2!0

, - ./ 0

1 , $ 0 1