High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/8622/2025allowed

Sukhraj Kaur v. State Of Punjab

2025-08-27Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel8 pages

$'( 7(61.1)+-

$'( 7(61.1)+- 3 .'

E 3 .'

!"#$% &$ # #

F0('1'1)+(# #

:(#. .

+% F0(.5)+7(+'

- - - -

#(.(+'- #(.(+'- #(.(+'- #(.(+'- = / 0 = / 0 = / 0 = / 0 / / / /

#0 "1:(+7(#9 7:)6$'( (

#0 $25#(('

1+3"9

+%$ $,0

>>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>>

/9 0

/ 0

#(.(+'

.(6)+7 + *14(7 D?

(

"$#$'12$ $ $3$#1!

#$!."$ $+"1'$9 ?

.")#'

@ = *

,($#1+3 )0E 7$'(7 00?9

#(31.'(#(7 *) )**(+6(.

5 +1."$,4( +7 7(# $#6)'16

# 3.

.26")'#)516 ,.'$+6(.

.")#'

@ 6'=

8 ) 6'

$77(7 4$'(# +9 )416( '$'1)+ 1'2 ) '"

)3$9

1.'#1 6'

)3$0

3#$:$;(+ A ( (.'1)+ +

, 5(#'$ $1+1+3 6'

1+:)4:1+3

$44(3(7 #(6):

:(#2 4)).( 1+')B16$+'

'$,4('

'.9 ($6"

C(13"1+3 ?D ;30

')'$4

0 3#$;.

'1<)4$; *#);

/($#+(7

6) +.(4 1'(#$'(7

6 .')72 .1+6( 00?0 /($#+(7

6) +.(4 * #'"(#

. ,;1''(7 ;$+7$')#2 5#):1.1)+.

"$:(

.6# 5 4) .42 6);541(7 C1'"9 '" .9 5#).(6 '1)+ . **(#.

*#);

1+"(#(+'

7(*(6'.0 /($#+(7

6) +.(4 1'(#$'(7

7(4$2(7 41$,141'2 '"(#()* *$.'(+(7

/($#+(7

6) +.(4 * #'"(# 1'(#$'(7

. **(#(7 ;)#( '"$+ 2($#0 " .9 5#$2(7 *)#0

/($#+(7

6) +.(4 )55).(7

$#3 1+3 $44(3$'1)+.

#$1.(7 $3$1+.'

$#( .(#1) .

+$' #(

$+79 '" .9 "( 7)(.

7(.(#:( 6)+6(..1)+ /($#+(7

6) +.(4 * #'"(# . ,;1''(7 1+.'$+'

54($ ,$##(7

#13)#.

'" .9 .$;( ) 3"'

71.;1..(70 /($#+(7

6) +.(4 .((!.

54$6( #(6)#7 6 .')72 6(#'1*16$'(

7$'(7 00 ')7$29 C"16"

'$!(+ #(6)#70

"$:( "($#7

6) +.(4 #1:$4 5$#'1(.

"$:( 3)+( '"#) 3"

$:$14$,4( #(6)#7.

6$.(0

C$.

$##(.'(7 00?

C"(#(1+$*'(#

1+:(.'13$'1)+ C$.

6$##1(7 ) '

6"$44$+ C$.

5#(.(+'(7 D00?0 )'$4

D 5#).(6 '1)+ C1'+(..(.

"$:( 61'(79 )+42 (B$;1+(7

D "$:( (B$;1+(7 5$#'

'144 7$'(0 #1:$4 6)+'(+'1)+.

#$1.(7

$# 31:( #1.( 7(,$'$,4( 1.. (.9 C"16"

#$'1)61+$'(7 7 #1+3

6) #.( "1.

7)(.

7((;

$55#)5#1$'( 7(4:( 7((5

'"(.( #1:$4 6)+'(+'1)+.9 .'$3(9 4(.'

;$2 5#(% 716( )'"1+3

'$+31,4( ,#) 3"'

*)#C$#7 1+716$'( 41!(41"))7

$,.6)+71+3 *#);

5#)6(..

% .'16( 1+'(#*(#1+3 5#).(6 '1)+

(:17(+6(0

+7 ,1'$,429 .(6)+7 $''(;5'

.(6 #( 4$.'

54($ 5#(*(##(7

C$.

71.;1..(7 C1'"7#$C+ 00D0 !((51+3 :1(C

* #'"(# 5(#1)7 ;)#( '"$+ 2($#

+) . ,.'$+'1$4 5#)3#(..

'#1$49 1+641+(7 *$:) #$,42 6)+.17(#

1+.'$+'

54($ 5#)*1'$,4( #(*(#(+6(9 #(3$#79 6$+ ;$7(

% 73;(+'

5$..(7 ?? ?? ?? ???

'1'4(7 $*1A &"$+

$*1A &"$+

:(#. .

$#2$+$ $+)'"(# :(#. .

$#2$+$ $+)'"(#G #(4(:$+'

C"(#()* #($7.

+7(#-

(514)3 ( $,):( 71.6 ..1)+9 *)44)C1+3

5#1+6154(.

(;(#3(-

(6)+7I. 66(..1:(

*14(7

;$1+'$1+$,4( 4$C

"(+6( . 6"

) 3"'

#(%(6'(7

.)4(42 3#) +7 ;$1+'$1+$,141'2 '"(#()*0

.(6)+7I. 66(..1:(

;$1+'$1+$,4(

C"('"(#

($#41(#

C$.

71.;1..(7

C1'"7#$C+I71.;1..(7 5#(..(7I71.;1..(7 +)+5#).(6 '1)+

($#41(# C$.

71.;1..(7 ;(#1'.0

)# .(6)+7I. 66(..1:( .

. 66((79 5('1'1)+(#I$55416$+'

(..(+'1$442I5(#'1+(+'42

#(A 1#(7 .")C . ,.'$+'1$4 6"$+3( 61#6 ;.'$+6(.

.")C1+3

;(#( . 5(#*161$4 ).'(+.1,4( 6"$+3( C) 47 . **16(0

;('$5")#16 (B5#(..1)+ .((!1+3 .(6)+7I. 66(..1:( 54($ .

) 3"'

$,.'#$6'(7 41'(#$4 1'(#$'1)+.

. ,.'$+'1$49 (**(6'1:( 6)+.(A (+'1$4 6"$+3( 61#6 ;.'$+6(.0

) (B"$ .'1:( 3 17(41+(.

6$+ 5)..1,42 4$17 7)C+

C"$'

C) 47 6)+.'1' '( . ,.'$+'1$4 6"$+3( 61#6 ;.'$+6(.

(:(#2

1'.

)C+ +1A ( *$6'.I61#6 ;.'$+6(0 $!1+3 . 6"

$''(;5'

+)'"1+3 , '

')51$+ (+7($:) #0

#3)9 1.. (

,(.'

4(*'

% 7161$4 C1.7);

71.6#('1)+ 7($41+3

. 6"

.(6)+7I. 66(..1:( .0

6")).(.

.(6)+7I. 66(..1:(

.9 6)3(+'

4 617 #($.)+.

$#( 5(#'1+(+'42 #(A 1#(7

#(6)#7(7 3#$+'1+3 . 6"

54($ 7(.51'( . 6"

54($

.(6)+7I. 66(..1:( .0 )'"(# C)#7.9 6$ .(

"$:1+3

. 66(..* 442

6) +'(+$+6(7I(+'(#'$1+(7

. 6"

.(6)+7I. 66(..1:( . ) 3"'

#($7142 64($#42

7(615"(#$,4( *#);

.$17 )#7(# 5$..(70K

5(# .$4 <1;+1 )#7(#.

5$..(7 ) #'9 ,#) 3"'

*)#'"

5('1'1)+(#9 1+716$'(.

1+7((7 5#)6#$.'1+$'1+3

*)442 '"(#()* .$774(7 .

5(# 6 .')72

6(#'1*16$'( 7$'(7 00 *14(7 4($#+(7

6) +.(49

$4#($72 . **(#(7 5(#1)7 2($# 7$2.0

:1(C ;$''(#9 #13)# 1;5).(7 6'

.'$+7.

714 '(7 413"'

#'164( )+.'1' '1)+ +71$0

0?0

"1.

% 73;(+'

'1'4(7 & 4C1+7(# :(#. .

& 4C1+7(# :(#. .

+%$, +%$, +%$, +%$, 5$..(7 DED DED DED DEDD D D D

--8 G $*'(# #(421+3

#$'1) 7(617(+71 % 73;(+'.

)+=,4( 5#(;(

..$1+$#$ &"$'))+ :.0 );( (6209

1"$#

8 G ,7 4

(";$+ +' 4$2 :.

00 $2$!

88 G $:(7 4$;

$,1

"$1!"

:.0 $"$#$."'#$ $+)'"(#9 D ?

#1;1+$4 D8DG

)"7 .41;

L ..$1+ :.0

(4"1 #(5)#'(7 ?

?G #1;1+$4 55($4 )0D I 7$'(7 E00 '1'4(7 H"1''$

1.C$.

41$.

,"$.

:.0 M(.'

(+3$4KG H1'1."

7"1!$#2 L

$5$+ :.0 M(.'

(+3$4K9 5(61$4 /($:( 55($4

#40

)0 ? 7$'(7 00 '1'4(7 H)"$;;$7 $4;$+ $+1* "$1!"

:.0 %$#$'KG #1;1+$4 55($4 )08 7$'(7

00 '1'4(7 )5$4 &#1."+$ $'#$ L )5$4# .;$ :.0 +1)+ +71$9

+! # "$ 7"$#2 :.0 $7"2$ #$7(."9 D D

#1;1+$4 EG "(479 '" .-

HE00

#13"'

.5((72 (B5(71'1) .

)+42

:1'$4 .$*(3 $#7 5#(:(+'

+7 ( )55#(..1:( 1+6$#6(#$'1)+G ;1'13$'(

$+B1('2 6)+6(#+ $66);5$+21+3 $66 .$'1)+ C(44 6 #'$14 $+2

1;5$1#;(+'

$,141'2 7(*(+7 "1;.(4*9 , '

'"(#(

):(#$#6"1+3 .)61('$4 1+'(#(.'

5$:1+3 C$2 .5((72 "1.

#13"'

#(5($'(742 $6' $'(7 #(6(+'

5$.'

#$'1) 7(617(+71

$,):(#(*(##(7 5#(;( ) #'=.

% 73;(+'.

"$:( 4$17 7)C+ .(#1(.

7(61.1)+.

)5(+1+3 +(C :1.'$.

* +7$;(+'$4 #13"'.0

6)+6(5'

.5((72 $;$43$;$'(7 #'164( (..(+'1$4 5$#'

* +7$;(+'$4 #13"'

41*( 41,(#'29 3 $#$+'((7 5#(.(#:(7 ) #

)+.'1' '1)+0

#13"'

.5((72 ,(31+.

$6' $4 #(.'#$1+'

1;5).(7 '1;( $##(.'

6)+.(A (+'

C"16"

6)+'1+ (.

$44 .'$3(.9 +$;(429 .'$3(

1+:(.'13$'1)+9 1+A 1#29 '#1$49 $55($4 #(:1.1)+ .) $+2 5)..1,4(

5#(% 716( ;$2 #(. 4'

7 ( 1;5(#;1..1,4( $:)17$,4( 7(4$2 .1+6(

'1;( 6);;1..1)+ )**(+6( '144 6#1;1+$4 5#)6((71+3.

6)+. ;;$'( *1+$41'29

6) 47 $:(#'(70

.5((72 '#1$49 ($#42

"($#1+3 A 16!

71.5).$4 $#( .1+( A $ +)+ 6#1;1+$4 % #1.5# 7(+6(0

):(#6#)C7(7 ) #'7)6!('.9 "($:2 :)4 ;( C)#!

#(. 4'$+'

5#(.. #( 5#).(6 '1)+ )416(9 1+7 ,1'$,42 !((5.

(+'1#(

6#1;1+$4 % #1.5# 7(+'1$4 ;(6"$+1.;

.'#(..

.'#$1+0

(B6 .( !((51+3 .C)#7

$;)64(.

"$+31+3

1+7(*1+1'( 5(#1)7 '1;(0

7)(.

.(#:( $+2 6#(71'

6#1;1+$4 % .'16( .2.'(;9 #$'"(# 1'

;$!(.

.$7 .'$'( $**$1#.0

3 $#$+'(( .5((72 1+'(+7(7 $:)17 )55#(..1)+ 5#(:(+'

7(4$2 1;5).1+3 5#).(6 '1)+ ),413$'1)+

5#)6((7 #($.)+$,4( 71.5$'6"0

3 $#$+'(( .(#:(.

'"#((*)47 5 #5).(0 1#.'429 1'

5#)'(6'.

$3$1+.'

)55#(..1:( 5#( 1;5#1.)+;(+'G .(6)+7429 1'

#(41(:(.

$+B1('2

5 ,416 . .5161)+ 7 ( +#(.)4:(7 6#1;1+$4 6"$#3(.

4$.'429 1'

5#)'(6'.

$3$1+.'

#1.!

(:17(+6( C144 4).'

;(;)#1(.

71;;(7

5$..$3( '1;(9 '" .9 1;5$1#1+3 $,141'2 7(*(+7

"1;.(4*0 '

3)(.

.$21+3 6)+.(A (+6(.

5#('#1$4 7('(+'1)+

$#( 3#$:(0 66 .(79 5#(. ;(7 1++)6(+'9 '144 5#):(+ )'"(#C1.(9 $#(

. ,%(6'(7 5.26")4)316$4 5"2.16$4 7(5#1:$'1)+.

%$1441*(9 . $442

)+(#) .

6)+71'1)+.0 A $442 1;5)#'$+'9 , #7(+ 7('(+'1)+

. 6"

*#(A (+'42 *$44.

"($:142 1++)6(+'

;(;,(#.

"1.

*$;1420

"(#( 2('

$+)'"(# $.5(6'

;$''(# C"16"

7(.(#:(.

6)+.17(#$'1)+ .'$3(0 $44(3$'1)+.

#(4$'(

#(4$'1+3 6);;(#61$4 A $+'1'2

6)+'#$,$+7 8 0

M"14( 6)+.17(#1+3

1+:)4:1+3 6);;(#61$4 A $+'1'29 !((5 ;1+7

#13) #.

(+ ;(#$'(7 8 C"16"

;$+7$'(.

) #'.

6$+ )+42 $*'(# "($#1+3 5 ,416

5#).(6 ')# $*'(# "$:1+3 .$'1.*1(7 1'.(4* 'C1+ 6)+71'1)+.

C"16"

$#(

#($.)+$,4( 3#) +7.

,(41(:1+3 3 14'2

)**(+6( 6"$#3(7I$44(3(7 '"$'9 "( 41!(42 6);;1'

$+2 )**(+6(

C"14(

.'#1+3(+'

#13) #.

; .'

;('16 4) .42 .6# '1+1<(7 $3$1+.'

,$6!7#)5 $66 .(7=.

* +7$;(+'$4 #13"'

.5((72

#13"'

41*( 5(#.)+$4 41,(#'2

#(+7(#(7 + 3$')#2 +C$##$+'(7 7(4$2.

% 7161$4 5#)6(..9

5$#'16 4$#42 C"(#( . 6"

7(4$2 . +(1'"(# $''#1, '$,4( +)#

% .'1*1(7 (+7 5#).(6 '1)+ 6)3(+'

#($.)+.0 + 1+71:17 $4

!(5'

,("1+7 ,$#.

1+)#71+$'( 5(#1)7 '1;( '$!1+3

#(* 3( #13) #.

4$17 7)C+ 8 0

4(31.4$' #( 1'.

C1.7);9 )#7(# (+. #( .5((72 '1;(42 71.5).$4

6$.(.

5#):17(7 6)+.'1' '1)+ .5(61$4 ) #'.

? 6'0

' #+ (4.)+=.

(2( 5#)'#$6'(7 7(4$2.

.2.'(;$'16 1+(**161(+62 *# .'#$'(

4(31.4$'1:( 5 #5).(0

4$C 7 '2,) +7 (+. #( 1'

7)(.

,(6);( 6);54161'

:1)4$'1)+ 1+71:17 $4=.

* +7$;(+'$4 #13"'.9

+)'C1'".'$+71+3 $+2'"1+3 6)+'$1+(7 .'$' '(0

M"14( 7($41+3

3):(#+(7 #13) #.

8 9 ; .'

.'#1!( % 7161) .

,$4$+6( ,('C((+ 4(31.4$'1:(

1+'(+'

6 #, ;(+$6( 7# 3.

.$6#).$+6'

#13"'

*$1# (B5(71'1) .

#)4)+3(7 1+6$#6(#$'1)+9 % .'1*1$,4(

6$ .(9 #1.!.

'#$+.*)#;1+3 5#('#1$4 7('(+'1)+ 5 +1'1:( 1;5#1.)+;(+'9

) '6);( $+'1'"('16$4 5#1+6154( % .'16( (A 1'20

#3)9 +(A 1:)6$4 1+*(#(+6( C"(#(

*$14(7 6)+64 7( C1'"1+ #($.)+$,4( '1;(9 #(. 4'1+3 5#)4)+3(7

1+6$#6(#$'1)+9 1'

;141'$'(.

$3$1+.'

5#(61) .

* +7$;(+'$4 #13"'.

41*(

41,(#'2 3#$+'(7 4$C $+79 . 6"9 6)+71'1)+$4 41,(#'2

):(##171+3 .'$' ')#2 (;,$#3) 6#($'(7

8 ) 3"'

6)+.17(#(7 5(# *$6'.

31:(+ 6$.(0

)'"(#

C)#7.9 5(#'$1+1+3 6);;(#61$4 A $+'1'29

3#) +7 +7 ( 7(4$2 '#1$49 .$17 *(''(#(7

8 0K

0D0

#'"(#9 5(# .$17 6 .')72 6(#'1*16$'(9

.'$'(7 )'"(# .0 *$6' ;

3#) +7 . **161(+'

1'.(4*9 7(641+( 6)+6(..1)+

A (.'1)+ C"(+ ;$7( ) '

A $ A (.'1)+ #$'1)61+$'1+3 *$6'.I61#6 ;.'$+6(.

.$17 0 (41$+6( #(3$#7 6$+ 54$6(7 % 73;(+'

)+=,4( 5#(;( $ 4$+$ )"70 ;1# $."$71 :0 00

$ 4$+$ )"70 ;1# $."$71 :0 00

$+)'"(#9

#1;1+$4 $+)'"(#9

#1;1+$4 G

1:1.1)+

(+6"

% 73;(+'

)+=,4( $46 ''$ 13"

#17"$#

:0 '$'(9 88

#17"$#

:0 '$'(9 88

#17"$#

:0 '$'(9 88

#17"$#

:0 '$'(9 88

#1;1+$4 DEE

% 73;(+'.

)0?

'1'4(7 !"14(."

1+3"

:0 $#2$+$ !"14(."

1+3"

:0 $#2$+$ !"14(."

1+3"

:0 $#2$+$ !"14(."

1+3"

:0 $#2$+$9 7(617(7 8009

$4#$% :0 $#2$+$9 88

#1;1+$4

$4#$% :0 $#2$+$9 88

#1;1+$4

$4#$% :0 $#2$+$9 88

#1;1+$4

$4#$% :0 $#2$+$9 88

#1;1+$4 80 80 80 80

**16( .$29 * #'"(# 7('(+'1)+

+7(#'#1$4 C$##$+'(7 *$6'.

61#6 ;.'$+6(.

6$.(0

:1(C $,):(9 $44)C(70 ('1'1)+(#

)#7(#(7 #(4($.(7 "(# * #+1."1+3 ,$14I. #('2 ,)+7.

.$'1.*$6'1)+ /70 6)+6(#+(7 ) #'I '2 $31.'#$'(0

$771'1)+ 6)+71'1)+.

;$2 1;5).(7 6)+6(#+(7

) #'I '2 $31.'#$'(9 #(;$1+ ,) +7 *)44)C1+3

6)+71'1)+.-

;1. .( 41,(#'2 3#$+'(70

'$;5(# $+2 (:17(+6(9 )#$4

7)6 ;(+'$#29 7 #1+3

111

$,.(+'

"(#.(4* $+2 7$'( ,(*)#(

6);;1'

$+2 )**(+6( C"14(

7(5).1'

"(# 5$..5)#'9 1* $+29

) #'0

31:( "(# 6(445")+( + ;,(#

+:(.'13$'1+3

**16(#I

6)+6(#+(7 )416( '$'1)+

6"$+3( "(# 6(445")+( + ;,(# 5#1)#

5(#;1..1)+ ) #'I44$A$ $31.'#$'(0

:11 $+2 ;$++(# '#2 7(4$2

:111 . ,;1'9 *1#.'

C)#!1+3 7$2

(:(#2 ;)+'"9 $**17$:1'9 ,(*)#( 6)+6(#+(7

) #'9 (**(6'

."(

6);;1..1)+ $+2 )**(+6( $*'(# #(4($.(7

*) +7 $+2

)**(+6( $*'(# "(# (+4$#3(7

9 ,$.1.

"(# $**17$:1'

)'"(#C1.(9

;$+7$'(7 ;):(9 *)#'"C1'"9 6$+6(44$'1)+ "(#

C"16"

54($9 , '

6) #.(9 #$'1)61+$'(7

;(#1'.

'"(#()*0

,#($6"

$+2 $*)#(.$17 6)+71'1)+.

'").(

C"16"

;$2 1;5).(7 6)+6(#+(7 ) #'I '2 $31.'#$'( 71#(6'(7

"(#(1+$,):(

.")C1+3

$+2

)'"(#

. **161(+'

6$ .(9

'$'(I6);54$1+$+'

41,(#'2 ;):( 6$+6(44$'1)+

#7(#(7 $66)#71+3420

)'"1+3 .$17 "(#(1+$,):( 6)+.'# (7 (B5#(..1)+

)51+1)+ ;(#1'.

6$.(0

1+6( ;$1+ 7(617(79 5(+71+3 ;1.6(44$+() .

$55416$'1)+9 1* $+29 $4.) .'$+7.

71.5).(7 )**0

/ / / /

3 .'

E 3 .'

;$"$:1#

M"('"(# .5($!1+3I#($.)+(7-

(.I)

M"('"(# #(5)#'$,4(-

(.I)